Showing posts with label voice recording. Show all posts
Showing posts with label voice recording. Show all posts

Wednesday, 9 September 2026

Bombay HC: Conviction of accused for offence under Prevention of Corruption Act is not permissible if voice recording of trap was not played in the court at the time of evidence

 Now, turning towards the electronic evidence, it is to be noted that the said panchanama including the transcript of the dialogues exchanged is stated to have been prepared on the basis of what was heard from the voice recorder. No doubt, it appears that by taking out hash value the said voice recorder was sent to the forensic lab for analysis with the sample of the voice, but no efforts appears to have been taken by the prosecution to play that voice recorder or the CD prepared therefrom during the course of the testimony of P.W. 1, P.W. 3 and P.W. 5. Mere submission of the certificate will not absolve the prosecution from identifying the voice before the Court. The report of the forensic lab would be in the form of opinion of an expert and the concerned authority may come to a conclusion that the voice, which has been heard in both the devices, are of the same person. But it has to be concluded that, the said voice is of the accused and that can be done only before the trial Court. Therefore, taking into consideration all the abovesaid evidence, scanning thereof and the reasons aforesaid, it cannot be said that the offence was proved by the prosecution against the appellant beyond reasonable doubt, and therefore, the point is answered in the negative. {Para 18}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Criminal Appeal No. 103 of 2017

Decided On: 05.08.2022

Shobha Sonba Raut Vs. The State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vibha Kankanwadi, J.

Citation: 2022 ALLMR (Cri) 3199,MANU/MH/2655/2022.
Print Page

Saturday, 1 November 2025

J & K HC: CDRs Without Voice Evidence Insufficient To Connect Co-Accused in NDPS Case

  The only material that connects the petitioner to the

alleged crime that is left is the CDR which has been collected by

the investigating agency during the investigation of the case. As

per analysis of the CDR, it appears that the petitioner was in

touch with the co-accused during the relevant period. The

question arises as to whether the same would be sufficient to

prima facie hold that the petitioner guilty of having committed the offence for which he has been booked. In the opinion of this

Court, CDR details showing contact between the petitioner and

co-accused, without there being any voice recording relating to

conversation between them, may not be sufficient to convict the

petitioner for the offence for which he has been booked. {Para 15}

HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH

AT JAMMU

Case No. Bail App No. 21/2025

Sareed Ahmed Ganie  Vs UOI and anr.

Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, 

Pronounced on: 18.10.2025.
Print Page

Monday, 4 May 2015

When voice recording can be discarded in criminal prosecution?


It is to be noted that in the first complaint filed by the second respondent - the de facto complainant, there is no allegation for any demand for bribe by the appellant. The allegation of demand is specifically against accused no.2 only. That allegation against the appellant is raised only subsequently. Be that as it may, the only basis for supporting the allegation is the conversation that is said to be recorded by the voice recorder. The Directorate of Forensic Science Laboratories, State of Maharashtra vide Annexure-B report has stated that the conversation is not in audible condition and, hence, the same is not considered for spectrographic analysis. Learned Counsel for the respondents submit that the conversation has been translated and the same has been verified by the panch witnesses. Admittedly, the panch witnesses have not heard the conversation, since they were not present in the room. As the voice recorder is itself not subjected to analysis, there is no point in placing reliance on the translated version. Without source, there is no authenticity for the translation. Source and authenticity are the two key factors for an electronic evidence, as held by this Court in Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer and others[4].
The Magistrate, having seen the records and having heard the parties, has come to the conclusion that no offence is made out against the appellant under the provisions of the PC Act so as to prosecute him. Even according to the High Court, "the crux of the matter is the conversation between the complainant and the accused no.1 of 22.11.2010". That conversation is inaudible and the same is not to be taken in evidence. Therefore, once the 'crux' goes, the superstructure also falls, lacking in legs. Hence, prosecution becomes a futile exercise as the materials available do not show that an offence is made out as against the appellant. This part, unfortunately, the High Court missed. "Summoning of an accused in a criminal case is a serious matter. Criminal law cannot be set into motion as a matter of course. ..."(Pepsi Foods Limited and another v. Special Judicial Magistrate and others[5], Paragraph-28). The process of the criminal court shall not be permitted to be used as a weapon of harassment. "Once it is found that there is no material on record to connect an accused with the crime, there is no meaning in prosecuting him. It would be a sheer waste of public time and money to permit such proceedings to continue against such a person"
Supreme Court of India
Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan vs Dattatray Gulabrao Phalke & Anr on 16 January, 2015
Bench: Kurian Joseph, Abhay Manohar Sapre
Citation;2015(1)BomCR(Cri)593, 2015CriLJ1259, 2015(1)Crimes90(SC),  (2015)3SCC123,2015 ALLSCR851
Print Page

Wednesday, 10 October 2012

WHAT IS SOUND SPECTROGRAPH AND VOICE PRINTS ??

SOUND SPECTROGRAPH AND VOICE PRINTS – A NEW PARADIGM IN THE CRIMINAL JUDICIAL ADMINISTRATION
The idea that someone could be identified by the sound of his voice had its origins in the work of Alexander Melville Bell (father to Alexander Graham Bell).  Over one hundred years ago, he developed a visual representation of what the spoken word would look like.  It was based on pronunciation and he showed that there were subtle differences among different people who said the same things. Then in 1941, the laboratories of Bell Telephone inNew Jersey produced a machine—the sound spectrograph—for mapping a voice onto a graph.  It analyzed sound waves and produced a visual record of voice patterns that were based on frequency, intensity, and time.  Acoustic scientists used it during World War II to identify enemy voices on telephones and radios.  However, with the war's end, the urgency for this technology diminished and little came of it until later.
Print Page