Showing posts with label wakf tribunal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label wakf tribunal. Show all posts

Saturday, 23 April 2022

Can Wakf tribunal decide suit relating to encroachment and tenancy over wakf property?

 It is clear that the Legislature has

added the underlined portion in the earlier

Section 83. If the amended Section 83(1) is

perused, it is quite apparent that any dispute,

question or other matter relating to Waqf

property, eviction of a tenant or determination of

rights and obligation of the lessor and the lessee

of such property i.e. Waqf property is to be

decided by the Waqf Tribunal. The amended

provision came into effect on 1st November 2013 and

naturally when the Waqf Tribunal decided the

Application on 5th May 2014, it was within its

jurisdiction to consider the dispute of tenancy

also, which was raised. This is apart from the

fact that the basic dispute the Tribunal was

dealing with, was whether or not the Applicant was

a trespasser as found under Section 54 of the Waqf

Act. To decide that dispute, it was required to

deal with the defence of the claim of tenancy.

10. Tribunal considered the admitted facts,

the law and opportunity given to applicant by

C.E.O. and rejected the application. The Applicant

is unable to show that the impugned order is not

correct, legal or proper. Consequently, there is

no substance in the Revision application.{Para 9}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

CIVIL REVISION APPLICATION NO.127 OF 2014

Ishtaque Ali Sayyad Ali, Vs  Maharashtra State Wakf Board,

CORAM: A.I.S. CHEEMA, J.

DATED : 17TH FEBRUARY, 2015.

Print Page

How to ascertain jurisdiction of wakf tribunal to entertain a proceeding?

  No doubt, while deciding the jurisdiction of the forum

to try and entertain the proceedings, the same requires to be

decided on the basis of facts pleaded in the plaint, application or

memo. Admittedly, there is no reference in the plaint that the

property is a wakf property. However, in para 10 of the plaint there is specific reference that as during the city survey, the property was recorded in the name of Wakf Board, taking disadvantage of this fact, respondent No.1 tried to induct respondent No.3 as tenant in the said property. In reply to this contention, in para 5 of the written statement filed on behalf of respondent No.1, a categorical statement is made that the plaintiff has no concern with the suit property and on the contrary the suit land belongs to Wakf Board and it reveals from the property extract that CTS No. 8796 belongs to defendant No.1 and defendant No.3 is the tenant.

Thus, the averments in plaint para 10 are supported by the

contents of para 5 of the written statement field by defendant No.1. If it is so, the issue comes under the ambit of wordings of section 85 i.e. any dispute or question or other matters relating to any wakf, and hence there is bar of jurisdiction of the Civil Court to take cognizance of the dispute. {Para 7}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

CIVIL REVISION APPLICATION NO.19 OF 2010

Hajra Bee w/o Sk.Ismail Vs  Maharashtra State Board of Wakfs

[CORAM : A.V.POTDAR, J.]

DATE: 31st March 2010

Citation: 2010(4) LJSOFT(URC) 1

Print Page

Whether Wakf tribunal has jurisdiction to entertain a suit for grant of perpetual injunction U/S 38 of Specific relief Act?

  The very scheme under the Wakf Act, 1995, in terms of Sections

83 and 85 in particular needs to be considered. The legislature desire to confer the jurisdiction of all the disputes relating to Wakf property are to be decided or adjudicated upon by the legally established Tribunal created in terms of Section 83 of the Act. Taking survey of the statute, even a suit simplicitor for injunction in terms of  Section 38 of Specific Relief Act will lie within Domain of the Wakf Tribunal. The proviso is for the aggrieved plaintiff, branding himself as Mutawali, it will, squarely fall within role of Wakf established under the Wakf Act,

1995. Hence, recourse taken by present respondent by a suit before learned Civil Judge (J.D.) at Paranda was not warranted.

 {Para 9}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

APPELLATE SIDE, BENCH AT AURANGABAD

CIVIL REVISION APPLICATION NO. 71/2009

 Dastagir s/o Ahmed Jagirdar, Vs Ashar Sharif Dargah,Paranda


CORAM : K.U. CHANDIWAL, J

Date : 17th February, 2010.

Print Page

Whether Wakf tribunal can entertain a suit regarding a dispute about the area of wakf property?

 When that is the position, it will have to be noted that in the instant case, though the legal remedy had not been availed by the Respondent within the time frame as provided Under Section 6 of the Act, the issue had fallen for consideration before the Wakf tribunal in view of the defence put forth by the Respondent and the Wakf tribunal had rendered its finding on that aspect based on the evidence placed before it. Since the gazette notification had been questioned to indicate that the property which is in the occupation of the Respondent was not a part of the notified Wakf property, the same applied both to the suit Schedule 'A' as well as Schedule 'B' properties. In such circumstance, the Wakf tribunal had the jurisdiction to determine that question which had been framed as an issue in this suit. Further as already noted, on the facts evolving in the instant case, the tribunal had relied upon the evidence available and had arrived at the conclusion that the property in question is Wakf property and had accordingly decreed the suit. {Para 23}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 4522 of 2021 

Decided On: 03.08.2021

 Telangana State Wakf Board and Ors. Vs. Mohamed Muzafar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Hemant Gupta and A.S. Bopanna, JJ.

Author: A.S. Bopanna, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/0500/2021

Print Page

Friday, 22 April 2022

Whether the wakf tribunal can entertain suit for declaration in respect of wakf property?

 Aforesaid provisions show that the powers of Civil Court are vested with the Wakf Tribunal. The provisions also show that the suit of the present nature, the suit filed for declaration of rights by Shikmidars and for enforcement of their rights can be entertained by Wakf Tribunal and the decision of Wakf Tribunal needs to be treated as the decision of civil Court. {Para 26}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

CRA No. 10 of 2013

Decided On: 20.07.2015

Syed Muzafaruddin and Ors. Vs.  Syed Zeenat Bee and Ors.


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

T.V. Nalawade, J.

Citation: 2015(6) MHLJ 378,MANU/MH/1744/2015

Print Page

Whether the Civil court can entertain dispute relating to wakf property?

 In our opinion, all matters pertaining to Wakfs should be filed in the first instance before the Wakf Tribunal constituted under Section 83 of the Wakf Act, 1995 and should not be entertained by the Civil Court or by the High Court straightaway under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. {Para 10}

14. Thus, the Wakf Tribunal can decide all disputes, questions or other matters relating to a Wakf or Wakf property.

The words "any dispute, question or other matters relating to a Wakf or Wakf property" are, in our opinion, words of very wide connotation. Any dispute, question or other matters whatsoever and in whatever manner which arises relating to a Wakf or Wakf property can be decided by the Wakf Tribunal.

The word 'Wakf' has been defined in Section 3(r) of the Wakf Act, 1995 and hence once the property is found to be a Wakf property as defined in Section 3(r), then any dispute, question or other matter relating to it should be agitated before the Wakf Tribunal.

15. Under Section 83(5) of the Wakf Act, 1995 the Tribunal has all powers of the Civil Court under the Code of Civil Procedure, and hence it has also powers under Order 39 Rules 1, 2 and 2A of the Code of Civil Procedure to grant temporary injunctions and enforce such injunctions. Hence, a full-fledged remedy is available to any party if there is any dispute, question or other matter relating to a Wakf or Wakf property.

16. We may further clarify that the party can approach the Wakf Tribunal, even if no order has been passed under the Act, against which he/she is aggrieved. It may be mentioned that Sections 83(1) and 84 of the Act do not confine the jurisdiction of the Wakf Tribunal to the determination of the correctness or otherwise of an order passed under the Act. No doubt Section 83(2) refers to the orders passed under the Act, but, in our opinion, Sections 83(1) and 84 of the Act are independent provisions, and they do not require an order to be passed under the Act before invoking the jurisdiction of the Wakf Tribunal. Hence, it cannot be said that a party can approach the Wakf Tribunal only against an order passed under the Act. In our opinion, even if no order has been passed under the Act, the party can approach the Wakf Tribunal for the determination of any dispute, question or other matters relating to a Wakf or Wakf property, as the plain language of Sections 83(1) and 84 indicates.

18. It is well-settled that when there is a special law providing for a special forum, then recourse cannot be taken to the general law vide Justice G.P. Singh's Principles of Statutory Interpretation (9th Edn. 2004, pp 133-134).

20. In view of the above, we are of the opinion that since the matter fell under the purview of the Wakf Act, only the Wakf Tribunal has jurisdiction in the matter, and not the Civil Court.


 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 5297 of 2004

Decided On: 23.11.2010

Board of Wakf, West Bengal Vs. Anis Fatma Begum and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Markandey Katju and Gyan Sudha Misra, JJ.

Author: Markandey Katju, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/0970/2010,2010 ALLSCR 2690,(2010) 14 SCC 588
Print Page

Sunday, 17 March 2019

Whether wakf tribunal can decide issue of title even if non muslim parties are involved?

Thus, the view of the High Court that right, title and interest of a non-Muslim to the Wakf in a property cannot be put in jeopardy is contrary to the statutory scheme as contained in Section 6 of the Act, 1995. Thus, the reason of the High Court to allow the revision petition is wholly unfounded. The defendant in written statement has pleaded that the suit property is not Wakf property. When issue in the suit is as to whether suit property is Wakf property or not it is covered by specific provision of Sections 6 and 7 of the Wakf Act, 1995, hence, it is required to be decided by the Tribunal under Section 83 and bar under Section 85 shall come into existence with regard to jurisdiction of Civil Court. In this context, in the judgment in Haryana Wakf Board v. Mahesh Kumar, (2014) 16 SCC 45, this Court has laid down that the question as to whether the suit property is a Wakf property is a question which has to be decided by the Tribunal.
In the Supreme Court of India
(Before Ashok Bhushan and K.M. Joseph, JJ.)
Civil Appeal No. 92 of 2019

Punjab Wakf Board  v. Sham Singh Harike

Civil Appeal No. 92 of 2019 and Civil Appeal No. 93 of 2019
Decided on February 7, 2019
Citation: 2019 SCC OnLine SC 142
Print Page

Saturday, 2 December 2017

Whether dispute relating to mutation entries of wakf property can be referred to wakf tribunal?

 No doubt, Section 83 of Wakf Act, 1995 says about the constitution of Tribunal for determination of any disputed question or other matter relating to a wakf or wakf property and the aforesaid Act bars the jurisdiction of courts to entertain the dispute relating to wakf or wakf property but the dispute in the present matter does not relate to the right and title as well as nature of wakf property rather it relates to mutation proceeding and admittedly, the wakf Tribunal has got no power to pass an order of mutation because the aforesaid power lies with revenue officials. Therefore, in my view, learned counsel appearing for the private respondents rightly submitted that learned Additional Collector was right in passing the impugned order.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PATNA

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 5953 of 2009

Decided On: 03.07.2017

Masjid and Madarasa Committee Vs. The State of Bihar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Hemant Kumar Srivastava, J.
Citation: AIR 2017 PATNA 137
Print Page

Tuesday, 16 August 2016

When wakf will be wakf-alal-aulad that is private wakf?

Wakf may be created by Muslim generally falls into two
categories. One is public Wakf in the sense that the beneficiaries
are members of the public and the other is private Wakf in the
sense that public as such are not the beneficiaries and certain
specified individual happens to be the beneficiaries. Even with
regard to a private Wakf there may be two kinds. One is a Wakf-alal-aulad
simpliciter and the other is Wakf in which there is a
dedication or gift in praesenti in the sense that a portion of the
income from the Wakf property is preserved for being spent for
strangers and other objects of piety or charity and the other portion
being spent for the benefit for the Wakif’s relations and members of
the family.
 In the given facts of this case the Wakf was created for
performing specific religious and charitable purpose as well as for
maintenance of the legal heirs/descendents of the testator and the
testator has specified that in the event the legal heirs/descendents
failed to maintain the Mosque and light candles in the Mosque, they
will be deprived of enjoying the usufruct of the Wakf property. 
Therefore, in my considered opinion it was a private Wakf created
for some religious purpose as well as for the interest of the family
members of the Wakif.

19. Learned senior counsel, Mr. Bhowmik has referred the
case of Tamil Nadu Wakf Board v. Larabsha Darga Panruti
reported in (2007) 13 SCC 416 and submitted that the apex Court
clearly held in the judgment that the suit property was belonged to
a private Wakf and Wakf-alal-aulad. Though the fact of that case
and the fact of the present case are not exactly similar but the
principles enunciated in that judgment may fairly be applied in the
facts of this case and I am of the considered opinion that the Wakf
created by Nachir Mohammed in the facts of the present case is a
private Wakf, Wakf-alal-aulad and it is not a public Wakf.
THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
 AGARTALA
RSA NO.67 OF 2008


Smt. Rahima Begam Choudhury,

 -Vs –
The State of Tripura,

BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.C. DAS


Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order : 06.05.2015
Citation:AIR 2016(NOC) 549 Tri

Print Page

Whether jurisdiction of civil court is barred in respect of dispute relating to wakf property?

In view of the provisions laid down in the Wakf Act and
the law explained by the apex Court in Anis Fatma Begum(supra)
the civil Court is barred in exercising jurisdiction in respect of a
dispute of Wakf. Since in the present case, it is an admitted position
that a Wakf was created by the deceased Nachir Mohammed, any
dispute regarding the Wakf or Wakf property should be decided by
the Tribunal and the plaintiff or the defendants may approach the 
Tribunal for deciding the dispute which is brought in the civil suit.
The apex Court has held that against the decision of the Tribunal an
aggrieved party can approach the High Court which can call for the
records for satisfying itself as to the correctness, legality or
propriety of the decision of the Tribunal. The plaintiff-appellant, if
so advised may approach the appropriate Tribunal for deciding the
dispute and in case the plaintiff-appellant is aggrieved by the
decision of the Tribunal it may approach the High Court as per the
law explained by the apex Court.
THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
 AGARTALA
RSA NO.67 OF 2008


Smt. Rahima Begam Choudhury,

 -Vs –
The State of Tripura,

BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.C. DAS


Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order : 06.05.2015
Citation:AIR 2016(NOC) 549 Tri
Print Page