Showing posts with label Article 311 of constitution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Article 311 of constitution. Show all posts

Sunday, 25 May 2025

LLM Notes: Impact of Article 16 and Article 311 of the Constitution of India on Public Utilities

 Article 16 and Article 311 of the Indian Constitution play a significant role in shaping the employment landscape and service conditions within public utilities and other government-run or controlled organizations.


Article 16: Equality of Opportunity in Public Employment

  • Article 16 guarantees equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters relating to employment or appointment to any office under the State, which includes public utilities run by the government or statutory bodies.

  • It prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place of birth, or residence, except as expressly provided for reservations.

  • The Supreme Court, in the landmark Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992, Mandal case), upheld the constitutional validity of reservations for backward classes in public employment, provided the "creamy layer" is excluded and the total reservation does not exceed 50%, except in extraordinary circumstances.

  • The Court clarified that reservations should be confined to initial appointments and not promotions, directly impacting recruitment and promotion policies in public utilities.


Article 311: Safeguards to Civil Servants

  • Article 311 provides procedural safeguards to civil servants (including those in public utilities) against arbitrary dismissal, removal, or reduction in rank by the government.

  • It mandates that no government employee shall be dismissed or removed by an authority subordinate to the one who appointed them, and no civil servant shall be dismissed or removed without a reasonable opportunity to be heard and a proper inquiry.

  • These protections ensure job security and fair treatment for employees of public utilities, who are often classified as government servants or hold civil posts under the State.

  • The Supreme Court in Parshotam Lal Dhingra v. Union of India (1958) laid down tests to determine whether a termination is punitive and thus attracts Article 311 protections.

  • In State of Uttar Pradesh v. Audh Narain Singh (1964), the Supreme Court held that even temporary employees in public utilities are entitled to Article 311 protections if they hold a civil post and are dismissed without due process.

  • State of Punjab v. Kishan Dass (1971) clarified that not every reduction in salary constitutes a reduction in rank under Article 311, which helps prevent frivolous litigation over minor administrative actions.


Summary of Impact

  • Article 16 ensures that recruitment and promotion in public utilities are conducted fairly, with constitutionally valid reservations for underprivileged sections, thus promoting inclusivity and diversity in public employment.

  • Article 311 offers robust procedural safeguards against arbitrary action by the State, ensuring security of tenure and fair treatment for employees in public utilities, which is crucial for maintaining an efficient and motivated workforce.

  • Landmark Supreme Court judgments have clarified and reinforced these protections, directly influencing the operational and human resource policies of public utilities across India.

These constitutional provisions collectively ensure that public utilities function in a manner that is equitable, transparent, and just, both in hiring practices and in the treatment of their employees.

Article 16 & Article 311: Impact on Public Utilities – Key Points

1. Equality of Opportunity in Public Employment (Article 16)

  • Article 16 ensures equal opportunity for all citizens in public employment, prohibiting discrimination based on religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place of birth, or residence.

2. Reservations and Social Justice

  • Article 16 allows for reservations in public employment for backward classes, ensuring inclusivity and social justice in public utilities.

3. Landmark Judgment: Indra Sawhney Case

  • The Supreme Court in Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992) upheld the validity of reservations in public employment, setting limits and guidelines that directly affect recruitment in public utilities.

4. Safeguards Against Arbitrary Dismissal (Article 311)

  • Article 311 protects civil servants (including those in public utilities) from arbitrary dismissal, removal, or reduction in rank, requiring due process and inquiry.

5. Security of Tenure

  • Article 311 grants civil servants job security, ensuring they cannot be dismissed by an authority lower than the appointing authority and only after due inquiry.

6. Exceptions to Procedural Safeguards

  • Inquiry under Article 311(2) is not required if the civil servant is convicted on a criminal charge, if an inquiry is not practicable (with reasons recorded), or if state security is at risk.

7. Scope of Protection

  • Article 311 applies only to civil servants (government employees in public utilities), not to employees of statutory corporations, government companies, or universities.

8. Judicial Review and Remedies

  • Dismissals or removals not following Article 311 can be challenged in courts or administrative tribunals, providing effective remedies for aggrieved employees.

9. Landmark Judgment: Parshotam Lal Dhingra Case

  • The Supreme Court clarified that the right to hold office and the consequences of termination determine whether Article 311 protections apply, impacting disciplinary actions in public utilities.

10. Impact on Public Utilities

  • Together, Articles 16 and 311 ensure fair recruitment, job security, and protection from arbitrary action in public utilities, promoting efficiency, transparency, and accountability.

Compact Mind Map: Article 16 & 311 – Impact on Public Utilities

Key Branches Explained

  • Article 16

    • Equality of Opportunity

    • Reservations & Social Justice

    • Recruitment & Promotion

    • Indra Sawhney Case

  • Article 311

    • Safeguards Against Dismissal

    • Security of Tenure

    • Fair Process & Inquiry

    • Judicial Remedies

  • Landmark Cases

    • Indra Sawhney (Reservations)

    • Dhingra Case (Scope of Safeguards)

    • Application in Public Utilities


Print Page

Saturday, 9 November 2019

Who is competent authority to dismiss judicial officer from service without disciplinary enquiry?

 Learned counsel appearing for Komal Ram and Jitendra Nath
Singh had raised another contention relating to the power of the
High Court to dispense with the inquiry under clause (b) of the
second proviso to Article 311 of the Constitution. The contention is
that this power exclusively vests with the Governor alone who has
to satisfy himself and record in writing the reasons why it is not
reasonably practical to hold an inquiry. Reliance was placed on
the following observations in the Constitutional Bench judgment of
this Court in State of West Bengal v. Nripendra Nath Bagchi,11:
“...within the exercise of the control vested in the High
Court, the High Court can hold enquiries, impose
punishments other than dismissal or removal, subject
however to the conditions of service, to a right of
appeal if granted by the conditions of service, and to
the giving of an opportunity of showing cause as
required by clause (2) of Article 311 unless such
opportunity is dispensed with by the Governor acting
under the provisos (b) and (c) to that clause.”
17. The contention misreads the ratio in Nripendra Nath Bagchi
(supra), which rather holds to the contrary. Interpreting Articles
233 and 235 of the Constitution, and on the aspect of ‘control’ of
the High Court in matters relating to the subordinate judiciary in
Nripendra Nath Bagchi (supra), it was held:
“13. […] the history which lies behind the enactment of
these Articles indicate that “control” was vested in the
11 AIR 1966 SC 447

High Court to effectuate a purpose, namely, the
securing of the independence of the subordinate
judiciary and unless it included disciplinary control as
well the very object would be frustrated. This aid to
construction is admissible because to find out the
meaning of a law, recourse may legitimately be had to
the prior state of the law, the evil sought to be removed
and the process by which the law was evolved. The
word “control”, as we have seen, was used for the first
time in the Constitution and it is accompanied by the
word “vest” which is a strong word. It shows that the
High Court is made the sole custodian of the control
over the judiciary. Control, therefore, is not merely the
power to arrange the day to day working of the court
but contemplates disciplinary jurisdiction over the
presiding Judge. Article 227 gives to the High Court
superintendence over these courts and enables the
High Court to call for returns etc. The word “control” in
Article 235 must have a different content. It includes
something in addition to mere superintendence. It is
control over the conduct and discipline of the judges.
This conclusion is further strengthened by two other
indications pointing clearly in the same direction. The
first is that the order of the High Court is made subject
to an appeal if so provided in the law regulating the
conditions of service and this necessarily indicates an
order passed in disciplinary jurisdiction. Secondly, the
words are that the High Court shall “deal” with the
judge in accordance with his rules of service and the
word “deal” also points to disciplinary and not mere
administrative jurisdiction.
14. Articles 233 and 235 make a mention of two distinct
powers. The first is power of appointments of persons,
their postings and promotion and the other is power of
control. In the case of the District Judges,
appointments of persons to be and posting and
promotion are to be made by the Governor but the
control over the District Judge is of the High Court. We
are not impressed by the argument that the term used
is “District Court” because the rest of the Article clearly
indicates that the word “court” is used compendiously
to denote not only the court proper but also the
presiding Judge. The latter part of Article 235 talks of
the man who holds the office. In the case of the judicial

service subordinate to the District judge the
appointment has to be made by the Governor in
accordance with the rules to be framed after
consultation with the State Public Service Commission
and the High Court but the power of posting, promotion
and grant of leave and the control of the courts are
vested in the High Court. What is vested includes
disciplinary jurisdiction. Control is useless if it is not
accompanied by disciplinary powers. It is not to be
expected that the High Court would run to the
Government or the Governor in every case of
indiscipline however small and which may not even
require the punishment of dismissal or removal. These
Articles go to show that by vesting “control” in the High
Court the independence of the subordinate judiciary
was in view. This was partly achieved in the
Government of India Act, 1935 but it was given effect
to fully by the drafters of the present Constitution. This
construction is also in accord with the Directive
Principles in Article 50 of the Constitution which reads:
“50. The State shall take steps to separate
the judiciary from the executive in the public
services of the State”.
xx xx xx
17. […] That the Governor appoints District Judges and
the Governor alone can dismiss or remove them goes
without saying. That does not impinge upon the control
of the High Court. It only means that the High Court
cannot appoint or dismiss or remove District Judges. In
the same way the High Court cannot use the special
jurisdiction conferred by the two provisos. The High
Court cannot decide that it is not reasonably
practicable to give a District Judge an opportunity of
showing cause or that in the interest of the security of
the State it is not expedient to give such an
opportunity. This the Governor alone can decide. That
certain powers are to be exercised by the Governor
and not by the High Court does not necessarily take
away other powers from the High Courts. The provisos
can be given their full effect without giving rise to other
implications. It is obvious that if a case arose for the
exercise of the special powers under the two provisos,

the High Court must leave the matter to the Governor.
In this connection we may incidentally add that we
have no doubt that in exercising these special powers
in relation to inquiries against District Judges, the
Governor will always have regard to the opinion of the
High Court in the matter. This will be so whoever be
the inquiring authority in the State. But this does not
lead to the further conclusion that the High Court must
not hold the enquiry any more than that the Governor
should personally hold the enquiry.”
18. The expression/words “within the exercise of the control vested in
the High Court, the High Court can hold enquiries, impose
punishments other than dismissal or removal, subject however to
the conditions of service, to a right of appeal if granted by the
conditions of service, and to the giving of an opportunity of
showing cause as required by clause (2) of Article 311 unless
such opportunity is dispensed with by the Governor acting under
the provisos (b) and (c) to that clause” is not to deny the High
Court the authority to decide whether conditions for invoking
clause (b) of the second proviso to Article 311(2) are satisfied, but
recognises that the resolution and recommendation of dismissal,
removal or reduction in rank or for dispensing with the inquiry in
terms of clause (b) [also clause (c)] of the second proviso to
Article 311(2) would require an order of the Governor. The
observations do not hold that the Governor, and not the High
Court, is vested with the jurisdiction and is the competent authority

to decide whether the inquiry should be dispensed with upon
recording of satisfaction in terms of clause (b) of the second
proviso to Article 311(2) of the Constitution. The decision refers to
Article 235 of the Constitution and states that the control vests
with the High Court, albeit order of appointment, dismissal or
removal is passed and made in the name of the Governor who
passes the formal order be it a case of appointment, dismissal or
removal. This is clear from the last portion of paragraph 17 in
Nirpendra Nath Bagchi (supra) which records “that the Governor
will always have regard to the opinion of the High Court in the
matter. This will be the inquiring authority in the State. But this
does not lead to the further conclusion that the High Court must
not hold the enquiry any more than that the Governor should
personally hold the enquiry.”
This legal position with reference to Articles 233 to 236 and
‘control’ of the High Court is beyond doubt as was explained in
Ajit Kumar v. State of Jharkhand12 in the following words:
“15. The next contention raised by the appellant was
that the aforesaid power under Article 311(2)(b) of the
Constitution could not have been invoked by the High
Court. The aforesaid submission also cannot be
accepted in view of the fact that a Subordinate Judge is
also a Judge within the meaning of the provision of
Article 233 of the Constitution of India read with the
provisions of Articles 235 and 236 of the Constitution of
India.
12 (2011) 11 SCC 458

16. Article 233 clearly lays down that appointments and
promotions of District Judges in any State are to be
made by the Governor of the State in consultation with
the High Court exercising jurisdiction in relation to such
State. The aforesaid provision, like Articles 234 to 236,
has been incorporated in the Constitution of India inter
alia to secure the independence of the judiciary from
the executive and the same deals with the scope of
separation of power of the three wings of the State.
17. It cannot be disputed that the power under the
aforesaid articles [Articles 233-236] is to be exercised
by the Governor in consultation with the High Court.
Under the scheme of the Indian Constitution the High
Court is vested with the power to take decision for
appointment of the subordinate judiciary under Articles
234 to 236 of the Constitution. The High Court is also
vested with the power to see that the high traditions
and standards of the judiciary are maintained by the
selection of proper persons to run the District Judiciary.
If a person is found not worthy to be a member of the
judicial service or it is found that he has committed a
misconduct he could be removed from the service by
following the procedure laid down. Power could also be
exercised for such dismissal or removal by following
the preconditions as laid down under Article 311(2)(b)
of the Constitution of India. Even for imposing a
punishment of dismissal or removal or reduction in
rank, the High Court can hold disciplinary proceedings
and recommend such punishments. The Governor
alone is competent to impose such punishment upon
persons coming under Articles 233-235 read with
Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India. Similarly,
such a power could be exercised by the High Court to
dispense with an enquiry for a reason to be recorded in
writing and such dispensation of an enquiry for valid
reasons when recommended to the Governor, it is
within the competence of the Governor to issue such
orders in terms of the recommendation of the High
Court in exercise of power under Article 311(2)(b) of
the Constitution of India.” (emphasis supplied)

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3105 OF 2017

HARI NIWAS GUPTA Vs  STATE OF BIHAR 

SANJIV KHANNA, J.

Dated:NOVEMBER 08, 2019.
Print Page