Showing posts with label Gunthewari Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gunthewari Act. Show all posts

Thursday, 26 October 2023

Whether the Civil court has jurisdiction to try suit relating to Maharashtra Gunthewari Development (Regulation, Upgradation and Control) Act, 2001?

The requirement of producing documentary proof of ownership or lawful possession of the land contained in clause (a) below sub-section (2) of section 4, is merely for the purposes of recording subjective satisfaction of the authority competent to grant regularization under section 3 of the said Act. There is no finality attached, as contemplated by section 18 of the said Act, to the question of title or of the possession gone into by the competent authority under section 3 or 4 of the said Act. The plenary jurisdiction of the Civil Court to decide the question of title and possession therefore, remains intact, and it is open for the Civil Court to find out whether, before granting of regularization, the property was owned and/or possessed by a person other than one at whose instance the regularization was granted under section 3 of the said Act. Such a suit cannot, therefore, be held to be barred under section 18 of the said Act. In the result, the petition is dismissed, holding that the jurisdiction of the Civil Court to entertain, try and decide a suit based on title and possession is not barred under section 18 of the Maharashtra Gunthewari Development (Regulation, Upgradation and Control) Act, 2001. {Para 9}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

S.A. No. 30 of 2016

Decided On: 26.08.2016

Sunderlal Vs. Nagpur Improvement Trust and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

R.K. Deshpande, J.

Citation:  MANU/MH/3000/2016,2017(4) ALLMR 378.

Print Page

Wednesday, 29 December 2021

Whether a party can claim protection from demolition if he has not complied with requirements of Gunthewari Act?

  As far as Second Appeal Nos. 48 of 2018,35 of 2018, 37 of 2018 & Second Appeal (ST) no.2243 of 2019 are concerned, learned counsel for the appellant would urge that Gunthewari Act prescribes a procedure for regularisation of unauthorised properties at the behest of holder of such unauthorised plots/structures.According to him, amongst other, concerned plot holder is required to place on record documentary proof of ownership or lawful possession of plot, existing lay out plan, plan of existing construction of such plot,rectification plan, an undertaking by the applicant to rectify uncompoundable infringements and demand draft of scheduled bank to cover the amount due as compounding fee and development charges. According to him, as far as appellants in the aforesaid four appeals are concerned, appellant has submitted an application for compounding alongwith location plan of the proposed site and also deposited the amount of compounding fees as is acknowledged by receipt no.1896 issued on 21/01/2010. {Para 10}


12. Learned counsel for the respondent-Corporation, Mr. Patil and other respondents would support the judgment of the Courts below, as according to them, both the Courts below have rightly held that the suit was not maintainable in view of bar under Section 433(A) of the Act.

13. By inviting attention of this Court on the various documents in the backdrop of pleadings, the submissions are, the appellant is trying to take disadvantage of certain procedural steps taken by erstwhile owner. According to him, even if presuming certain steps taken by erstwhile owner under the Gunthewari Act, for regularisation of the structure, the corresponding responsibility and the compliances are not reported. As such, the appellants are trying to take disadvantage of their own fault. As such, it is prayed in the given set of facts and documentary evidence on record, the suit is rightly held to be not maintainable. 

15. The appellant has placed on record acknowledgment depicting payment of Rs. 5275/- on 21/01/2010 under the head of Gunthewari for regularisation. However, this Court is required to take note of the fact that predecessor of the appellant on 16/05/2002 was served with a notice to comply with requirement under the Gunthewari Act and subsequent thereto, certain compliance not stricto sense in accordance with under Section 4 of the Act were sought to be relied. It appears that appellant after payment in 2010, has not complied with other terms of Gunthewari Act. Rather the appellant is trying to shift burden on respondent-Corporation to carve out the case of nullity in law for the issuance of impugned notice by the Corporation.

16. This Court has already observed that appellant cannot take undue advantage of its own wrong as appellant was not diligent in pursuing its case of regularisation under the Gunthewari Act.

18. Admittedly, there is no sanction from the Planning Authority i.e. respondent-Corporation to the structure in question and that being so, the appellant has come out with a case that regularisation proceedings were taken recourse to under Gunthewari Act.


20. Rather the documents produced on record demonstrates that except moving an application, no further steps are taken by the  appellant. Rather the plans which were called by the respondent- Corporation were not submitted. On one hand, the appellant is not pursuing the claim under the Gunthewari Act and on other hand are trying to take disadvantage of their own shortfall.

21. In the aforesaid background, considering the conduct of the appellant, the claim as is sought to be put-forth, based on the judgment in the matter of Akola Municipal Corporation and Yogesh Gada cited supra cannot be termed to be of no assistance. 

26. In view of the aforesaid observations that the predecessor- in-title of the appellant namely Shelke or the appellant himself has not complied with further requirement under the Gunthewari Act, the said ground of seeking protection under the Provisions of Gunthewari Act is not available to the appellant.

27. In the aforesaid background, in my opinion, the view expressed by both the Courts below of non-maintainability of suit, in view of statutory embargo under Section 433 (a) of the Maharashtra Municipal Corporations Act appears to be just and proper.

Bombay High Court
Sau.Sulochana Kantilal Shelke ... vs Shri.Prashant Pannalaji ... on 18 February, 2020
Print Page

Can the court permit an amendment of plaint to add a prayer for specific performance of the contract if that relief is time-barred?

 Apart from this, a perusal of the original plaint and the proposed amendment filed on behalf of the  petitioner would show that the cause of action for the proposed prayer for grant of decree of specific performance and declaration was very much available to the petitioner when he filed the suit for permanent injunction on 11.09.2013. Having failed to incorporate prayers for aforesaid reliefs and restricting the suit only for the relief of permanent injunction, clearly shows that the attempt subsequently made by the petitioner by filing application for amendment on 24.01.2017 was barred by operation of Order 2 Rule 2 of the C.P.C. It is clear that the petitioner was now seeking to change the very nature of the suit, which was impermissible. {Para 12}

16. In the case of K. Raheja Constructions Ltd. .vs. Alliance Ministries (supra) referred to in the above quoted judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, it was held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as follows:-

"4. It is seen that the permission for alienation is not a condition precedent to file the suit for specific performance. The decree of specific performance will always be subject to the condition to the grant of the permission by the competent authority. The petitioners having expressly admitted that the respondents have refused to abide by the terms of the contract, they should have asked for the relief for specific performance in the original suit itself. Having allowed the period of seven years elapsed from the date of filing fo the suit, and the period of limitation being three years under Article 54 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963, any amendment on the grounds  set out, would defeat the valuable right of limitation accrued to the respondent."

17. The position of law as elucidated in the aforesaid judgments relied upon by the learned counsel for the respondents shows that in the present case also prayers sought to be added by the petitioner by way of amendment were not only barred by limitation under Article 54 of the Limitation Act, 1963, but also by operation of Order 2 Rule 2 of the C.P.C.

18. Insofar as the contention raised on behalf of the petitioner that relief of specific performance could have been sought by the petitioner only after the competent authority had granted regularisation under the provisions of the Gunthewari Act, as noted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Van Vibhag Karamchari Griha Nirman Sahakari Sanstha Maryadit .vs. Ramesh Chander (supra), nothing prevented the petitioner to make a prayer for decree of specific performance when the suit for permanent injunction was filed on 11.09.2013. The Court would certainly have the power to pass a decree of specific performance in favour of the petitioner, which would be a conditional decree, subject to the competent authority in the present case granting order of regularisation under the provisions of the Gunthewari Act. Therefore, the said submission raised on behalf of the petitioner is also untenable.

Bombay High Court
Mangesh S/O Madhukar Giri vs Lata D/O Ganpatrao Korde And ... on 23 January, 2019
Bench: Manish Pitale
Print Page

Tuesday, 28 December 2021

Whether Municipal Corporation can reject application for regularization of Gunthewari without following proper procedure?

 It is seen from the impugned order that application of the petitioners for regularization of their plot bearing Nos.89 to 94 falling in Khasra No.254/4, Mouza Zingabai Takali, Nagpur located in Progressive Co-operative Housing Society having refused to be regularized under the Maharashtra Gunthewari (Regularization, Upgradation and Control) Act, 2001 by the impugned order dated 01.01.2020. The only ground taken in the impugned order is that the plots in question have been shown as lying within the open space in the approved layout plan and that these plots are not forming part of any approved layout plans. Section 3 of the Maharashtra Gunthewari (Regularization, Upgradation and Control) Act lists out the grounds on which Gunthewari Development can be disallowed. According to the learned counsel for the respondents, the contingencies envisaged in second proviso (e) to section 3(1) of the said Act are applicable to the case of the petitioners. These contingencies, relate to the circumstances when in the opinion of the Planning Authority, such regularization is not in the public interest or because of the matter being sub-judice or same being barred by some Court’s decision or order. These grounds do not form any part of the impugned order dated 01.01.2020. Therefore, even though these grounds have been stated in the reply filed on behalf of the respondents cannot be looked into to support the impugned order, as held in the case of Mohinder Singh Gill and another Vs. The Chief Election Commissioner, New Delhi and ors. Reported in (1978) I SCC, 405. Besides, it appears that no opportunity of hearing has been granted to the petitioners which ought to have been granted in such cases.

Bombay High Court

JUSTICE SUNIL B. SHUKRE JUSTICE AVINASH G. GHAROTE

Smt. Samsunnissa Wd/o Mohd Ismail Pathan & Ors. Vs. Nagpur Municipal Corporation & Anr.

WRIT PETITION NO. 1386 OF 2021

4th May 2021

Author: Sunil B.Shukre, J.

Citation: 2021 NearLaw (BombayHC Nagpur) Online 453

Print Page