At the time of submissions, learned Advocate Mr. S.S. Bora appearing for the appellants submitted that the first appellate court has not framed the points for determination as required under Order XLI Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. Whatever points are stated to have been framed in the judgment cannot be said to be the compliance of the law and, therefore, he prayed that the matter is required to be remanded for proper framing of points and deciding according to the issues in dispute. He relied on the decision in Khatunbi & others Vs. Aminabai 2006(6) Mh.L.J. 759, wherein it has been observed thus:
"5. Order 41, Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure clearly provides that the judgment of the appellate Court shall be in writing and shall state the points for determination, the decision thereon, the reasons for the decision, and where the decree appealed from is reversed or varied, the relief to which the appellant is entitled, and shall at the time that it is pronounced be signed and dated by the Judge or by the Judges concurring therein.
6. Plain reading of the said provision would disclose that the appellate Court before proceeding to deliver the judgment on merits of the case has to formulate the points for determination and with reference to such points for determination, analyse the materials on record and thereupon arrive at the conclusion to be delivered as its decision. Obviously the decision should disclose the reasons for the decision. However, the reasons for decision by themselves cannot constitute the points for determination. The points for determination have to be formulated in order to enable the Court to identify the exact points in controversy in the matter and with reference to those points, the Court has to appreciate the evidence led by the parties. In fact, the law on this aspect has been well settled by the decision of the learned Single Judge of this Court in Vishwas Balu v. Ghasiram Ramratan Jajum MANU/MH/0168/1975 : AIR 1975 Bom. 278 wherein it has been held that the compliance of Order 41, Rule 31 is mandatory and the expression used therein "shall state" clearly discloses that the failure to comply with the said provision of law would not be a mere irregularity. Indeed, the phraseology used in Rule 31 apparently discloses that compliance of the said provision is not a mere formality and therefore failure thereof cannot be said to be a mere irregularity. This is also clear from Rule 30 of Order 41 and in particular Sub-rule (2) thereof. Rule 30(2) of Order 41 provides that "where a written judgment is to be pronounced, it shall be sufficient if the points for determination, the decision thereon and the final order passed in the appeal are read out and it shall not be necessary for the Court to read out the whole judgment, but a copy of the whole judgment shall be made available for the perusal of the parties or their pleaders immediately after the judgment is pronounced," Obviously, in cases where on conclusion of the arguments in appeal, the judgment is reserved to be delivered and thereafter it is sought to be pronounced, it is not sufficient merely to declare as to whether the appeal is allowed or not, but ultimate decision has to be made known to the parties along with the points for determination which have been considered in the appeal. This provision of law clearly discloses the necessity for formulation of the point for determination before the appellate Court proceeds to deliver the judgment in the appeal.
7. The learned Single Judge of this Court in Smt. Anita M. Barretto v. Abdul Wahid Sanaullah MANU/MH/0711/1984 : 1984 Mh.L.J. 931 : AIR 1985 Bom. 98, while dealing with the necessity of compliance of provisions of Order 41, Rule 31, held that when a requirement such as this is insisted upon by the procedural law of the land, one must try to understand the object and scope of such provision. Merely asking the question as to whether the judgment of the Court below is correct, legal or valid is hopelessly an inadequate method of meeting the requirement of this legal provision. Further, while referring to the earlier decision in Mhasu v. Davalat (1905) 7 Bom. L.R. 174, it was also reminded that there was similar provision in the earlier Civil Procedure Code and it was pointed out that the object of the Legislature in making it incumbent on an appellate Court to raise points for determination is to clear up the pleadings and focus the attention of the Court and of the parties on the specific and rival contentions in the matter. It was further held that the points which must arise for determination by a Court of first appeal must cover all important questions involved in the case and they should not be general and vague. It was further held that it is a matter of almost textbook knowledge that the exact questions which arise in the appeal for determination must be stated in the judgment.
8. It is thus clear that right from the beginning of 20th century consistent view taken by this Court is that the provision regarding the requirement of formulation of points for determination by the appellate Court while proceeding to deliver the judgment in appeal has been held to be mandatory in nature and not a mere irregularity."
7. On behalf of the appellants, further reliance has been placed on the decision in Abdul Kadar s/o. Mohammad Ibrahim, Second Appeal No. 68 of 1991, decided by this Court on 14-10-2008. In this case also, reliance was placed on the above said decision of Khatunbi & others Vs. Aminabai and further reliance was placed on Smt. Anita M. Barretto Vs. Abdul Wahid Sanaullah (MANU/MH/0270/1985 : AIR 1985 Bom. 98). In both these above said cases, it was, therefore, held that when there is no proper framing of points in compliance of Order XLI Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, the matter deserves to be remanded.
9. At present, a limited question is arising as to whether the judgment of the first appellate court is in pursuance to the compliance of Order XLI Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The Division Bench of this Court in Khatunbi & others (supra) had considered the pronouncement of the judgments of this Court as well as by Apex Court in Santosh Hazari Vs. Purushottam Tiwari deceased by L.Rs. (MANU/SC/0091/2001 : 2001(2) Mh.L.J. 786) and it was clearly observed that, compliance of Order XLI Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure is not an empty formality. The necessity of formulation of points for determination by the appellate Court cannot be considered lightly and brushed aside as benefit of technical plea cannot be granted. In fact, formulation of points for determination has to be such that it should cover all important issues in dispute. Therefore, such formulation of points for determination cannot be vague.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)
Second Appeal No. 0282 of 2015
Decided On: 09.01.2019
Subabai Shivram Patil Vs. Dharamsing Julalsing Patil
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Vibha Kankanwadi, J.
Citation: 2019(3) MHLJ 400
Print Page