The first appellate Court has heavily relied on the case holding
of Bhanu Kumar Jain v Archana Kumar. (2005) 1 SCC 787 Then, it has held that the judicial dictum of Bhanu Kumar Jain is unmistakable and that an appeal under Section 96 of CPC cannot accommodate the grounds available for the appellants under Order 9 Rule 13 of CPC. Therefore, it has concluded
that instead of filing the cross-objections, the contesting defendants could have invoked Order 9 Rule 13 CPC.
12. In this context, we may straight away refer to para 24 of Bhanu Kumar Jain. It declares that an appeal under Section 96(2) of CPC against an ex parte decree could be filed on two grounds: (i) that the materials brought on record [the merits] in the ex parte suit proceedings by the plaintiff would not entail a decree in his favour, and (ii) that the suit could not have been posted for ex parte hearing. Thus, the procedural lapse that
has led to the ex parte decree can be very much a ground of appeal under Section 96. It is under the rubric “that the suit could not have been posted for ex parte hearing.”
21. Though the Appellate Court has acknowledged the contesting
defendants’ right to file cross-objections, it has concluded that under Section 96 of the Code, no plea about procedural lapses such as nonservice of suit summons can be taken; it ought to be purely on the merits.
22. We have already examined Bhanu Kumar Jain but have found no such judicial dictum as suggested by the First Appellate Court. Even Section 96 of the Code imposes no such restriction. Section 96, in fact, allows the first appeal against “every decree passed by any Court exercising original jurisdiction.” Under sub-section (2), it explicitly mentions that “an appeal may lie from an original decree passed ex parte.”
25. The First Appellate Court has rejected those cross-objections on the premise Section 96 of the Code allows a challenge only on the merits, but not on procedural lapses. As we have already discussed, Bhanu Kumar Jain’s dictum does not endorse this interpretation of Section 96, as the First Appellate Court has erroneously believed.
26. So, I am constrained to hold that the First Appellate Court has
misread the case holding of Bhanu Kumar Jain and misapplied its judicial dictum. Pithily put, an appeal under Section 96 can contain pleas not only on the merits but also on questions like non-service of suit summons and the illegality of the order setting the defendant ex parte – procedural lapses.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA
SECOND APPEAL NO.61 OF 2019
Mr. Carlton Gilbert Fortes V/s Smt. Sonhia Lobo,
Coram: - DAMA SESHADRI NAIDU, J.
Date: - 3rd March 2020
Citation: 2020(6) MHLJ 703
Print Page