Showing posts with label Pardanashin lady. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pardanashin lady. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 March 2024

Under which circumstances the Appellate court can permit defendant to Add Facts Omitted Earlier In Written Statement?

The matter in hand would go to show that the petitioner/ defendant being illiterate and pardanashin lady was in fact unable to understand the pleadings in the written statement and therefore, in order to do justice effectively, the proposed amendment which is in the nature of clarification, ought to have been considered by the learned First Appellate Court. However, while taking hyper technical aspect and without considering the status of the defendant, such amendment was rejected. {Para 30}

31. To my mind, the impugned order suffers from improper exercise of jurisdiction. No doubt, the proposed amendment/facts were to the knowledge of the defendant when she filed the written statement, that ground could have been considered qua the status of the defendant being illiterate and pardanashin lady. At the most,costs could have been imposed since the proposed amendment is not in a mala fide manner and certainly it is not causing any prejudice to the plaintiff.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.

WRIT PETITION NO. 1608 OF 2021

 Hasinabi w/o Abdul Latif Vs  Mohammad Sharif S/o Abdul Rajjak, 

CORAM : B.P. DESHPANDE, J.

PRONOUNCED ON : 7TH MARCH, 2024

Print Page

Saturday, 25 January 2020

Whether illiterate lady is entitled to get benefit of Pardanashin lady in absence of pleading?

The Plaintiff-first Respondent filed a Suit No. 155 of 1996 before the Civil Judge (J.D.), Roorkee. A copy of the plaint has been placed on record (Annexure P/1). On perusal of the plaint, it reveals that it has nowhere been pleaded that the Plaintiff-first Respondent is a pardanasheen illiterate lady. In the ordinary course the burden of proof rest, on who attack. On the contrary, it was pleaded in the plaint that Defendant Nos. 1 and 3 are the sons of her uncle Mangta and Defendant No. 2 is the wife of Defendant No. 1 and they hatched a conspiracy to grab the land of the Plaintiff-first Respondent and with connivance, the power of attorney was prepared & registered on 25th April, 1995 in the registry office, in the name of the Plaintiff and pursuant thereto, suit land was sold by a registered sale deed. On the basis of pleadings on record, the above-mentioned eight issues were framed on which both the parties have adduced oral and documentary evidence and the trial Judge, after considering the evidence, dismissed the suit vide judgment and decree dated 19th January, 2001 and that came to be affirmed on dismissal of the appeal filed at the instance of the Plaintiff-first Respondent dated 27th August, 2001. It reveals from the record that without there being any factual foundation, the High Court, while admitting the appeal, framed two substantial questions of law in reference to which there was no supporting pleadings on record.

14. We still, for our satisfaction have gone through the plaint placed on record at Annexure P/1 and we are unable to find the pleadings in support that she was a pardanasheen illiterate lady and was entitled for protection of law and the burden was on the Defendant-Appellant to prove that the alleged power of attorney was the result of fraud.

15. After we have heard the parties, we are of the view that the High Court has committed a manifest apparent error in reversing the concurrent finding of the two Courts below and on this score the impugned judgment is not sustainable.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 7137 of 2010

Decided On: 17.09.2019

 Ali Hussain  Vs.  Rabiya 

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N.V. Ramana, Mohan M. Shantanagoudar and Ajay Rastogi, JJ.

Citation: AIR 2019 SC 4313
Print Page

Friday, 20 September 2019

Whether court can put burden of proof on other side if plaintiff has failed to plead that she was pardanashin lady?

The plaintifffirst
respondent filed a Suit No. 155 of 1996
before the Civil Judge (J.D.), Roorkee. A copy of the plaint has
been placed on record (Annexure P/1). On perusal of the plaint,
it reveals that it has nowhere been pleaded that the plaintifffirst
respondent is a pardanasheen illiterate lady. In the ordinary
course the burden of proof rest, on who attack. On the contrary,
it was pleaded in the plaint that defendant nos.1 and 3 are the
sons of her uncle Mangta and defendant no. 2 is the wife of
defendant no. 1 and they hatched a conspiracy to grab the land
of the plaintifffirst
respondent and with connivance, the power of
attorney was prepared & registered on 25th April, 1995 in the
registry office, in the name of the plaintiff and pursuant thereto,
suit land was sold by a registered sale deed. On the basis of
pleadings on record, the abovementioned
eight issues were
framed on which both the parties have adduced oral and
documentary evidence and the trial Judge, after considering the
evidence, dismissed the suit vide judgment and decree dated 19th
January, 2001 and that came to be affirmed on dismissal of the
appeal filed at the instance of the plaintifffirst
respondent dated
27th August, 2001. It reveals from the record that without there
being any factual foundation, the High Court, while admitting the

appeal, framed two substantial questions of law in reference to
which there was no supporting pleadings on record.
14. We still, for our satisfaction have gone through the plaint
placed on record at Annexure P/1 and we are unable to find the
pleadings in support that she was a pardanasheen illiterate lady
and was entitled for protection of law and the burden was on the
defendantappellant
to prove that the alleged power of attorney
was the result of fraud.

NONREPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO(S). 7137 OF 2010

ALI HUSSAIN  Vs  RABIYA 

Dated:SEPTEMBER 17, 2019
Rastogi, J.
Print Page

Sunday, 9 September 2018

Whether court can direct defendant to lead evidence first?

 In Bhagirath Shankar Somani v. Rameshchandra Daulal Soni, MANU/MH/0306/2007 : 2007 (5) Mh.L.J. 508 : 2007(4) ALL MR 514, this Court concluded that if the Defendant decides to lead evidence first and is so permitted by the Court, the Plaintiff can always lead evidence in rebuttal. The Trial Court does not have the power to issue a direction to the Defendant compelling him to lead his evidence before the Plaintiff adduces his evidence under Order 18 Rule 1. Only when the Defendant claims a right to begin under Rule 1 and the Plaintiff disputes existence of such right, the Court will have to decide the question whether, the Defendant has acquired a right to begin.

21. This Court, in Dattatray Namdeo Patil v. Ram Namdeo Patil and others, MANU/MH/0403/2010 : 2010(3) Mh.L.J. 801, dealt with a similar issue and concluded in paragraphs 3 and 4 that Rules 1 and 2 of Order 18 of the Code of Civil Procedure would entitle the Defendant, who admits the fact, to begin the recording of his evidence first. It is an enabling provision. If the Defendant applies and makes a request or claims such a right, the Court may pass an order permitting the Defendant to step into the witness box first.

22. In Metafield Coil Private Limited v. Nikivik Tube Industries Private Limited, MANU/MH/1909/2011 : 2012 (1) Mh.L.J. 289, while considering such an issue under Order 18 Rule 1, this Court concluded that a consistent view taken by the courts is that a direction against the Defendant to lead evidence before the Plaintiff leads his evidence, cannot be issued under Order 18 Rule 1. The scheme of law appears to be that of a normal rule and it would be a privilege of the Plaintiff to lead his evidence first. However, it enables the Defendant to exercise the right in the contingency mentioned in the rule. After the Plaintiff exercises his option to lead evidence first, it is for the Defendant to decide whether, he would like to lead evidence and make such a formal request to the Court. If the Court permits the Defendant to lead evidence first, the Plaintiff can always lead evidence in rebuttal. The Court does not have the power to issue a direction to the Defendant so as to compel him to step into the witness box first and lead evidence.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 781 of 2003 and Civil Application No. 7105/2014 in WP/781/2003

Decided On: 15.09.2017

 Zainabee Vs. Shivkumar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.V. Ghuge, J.

Citation: AIR 2018(NOC) 709 Bom
Print Page

Friday, 22 June 2018

Whether principles for proof of execution of documents taken from pardanashin lady is applicable to illiterate lady?


In Agadhei Malikani and another v. Abhimanyu Mallik and others, MANU/OR/0133/1968 : ILR 1968 Cut. 576, this Court held that the principles which govern the proof of execution of documents taken from pardanashin woman equally apply to the documents taken from an illiterate woman.

10. The gift deed, Ext. B, reveals that Chandrama had put her L.T.I. There is no endorsement in the gift deed that the contents of the gift deed had been read over and explained to Chandrama and after understanding the contents thereof, she put her L.T.I. Learned trial court held that it is highly inconceivable that Chandrama executed a gift deed in favour of defendant No. 1 in respect of her entire property. The gift deed had not been acted upon.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK

S.A. No. 249 of 1988

Decided On: 30.04.2018

 Gajraj Pasayat Vs.  Debraj Pasayat and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dr. Akshaya Kumar Rath, J.

Print Page

Sunday, 23 October 2016

How to appreciate evidence in case of execution of document by pardanashin lady?

 There is no quarrel that the plaintiff is a Paradanasin
lady. Thus, onus is on the defendants, who derived the benefits out
of the deed executed by the plaintiff, i.e., Ext.A, to prove and
establish that the document was read over and explained to the
plaintiff and thereafter, she put her signature after fully
understanding the contents thereof. Law is no more res integra on
this point. (See Nitei Sahu Vs. Chanda Bewa, reported in 30 (1964)
CLT 463 (para-6) and Brundaban Misra Vs. Iswar Swain and others,
reported in AIR 1983 Orissa 172). Mr. Pradhan, learned counsel for
the respondents submitted that the contents of Ext.A was read over
and explained to the plaintiff in Odia by the scribe and she put her
signature after being fully satisfied with the said terms and recitals.
Ext.A was admitted into evidence without any objection. Moreover,
P.W.1, the plaintiff at paragraph-6 of her deposition, has admitted
execution of Ext.A and registration thereof. She categorically
admitted in her evidence that on the date of execution and
registration of Ext.A, she had gone to the Sub-Registrar Office with
her husband, namely, Purna Chandra Paikray. However, she
deposed in her evidence at paragraph-10 that on enquiry, she found
that in order to grab the entire property, the defendant No.3 has
attempted to become the absolute owner by practising fraud and no
consideration money as indicated in the alleged deed of sale has been
paid to her. Though at paragraph-6 of her evidence, she admitted
about execution of Ext.A, but in paragraph-7, she deposed that she
does not know English and the entire fact of Power of Attorney
having not been apprised to her, she signed the same on good faith
and she was not aware of the details of said Power of Attorney. The
execution of Ext.A is not disputed by the plaintiff. She only took
exception to Clause-6 of the said Ext.A. The scribe, namely, Sri Kirti
Chandra Swain, an Advocate of Bhubaneswar, had given his 12
endorsement (as stated above), which makes it abundantly clear that
Ext.A was read over and explained to the plaintiff in Odia and she
had put her signature in the said deed being satisfied with its terms
and conditions. The plaintiff does not challenge the endorsement
given by the Scribe, Sri Kirti Chandra Swain. Further, defendant
No.3 against whom allegations have been made that he had obtained
Ext.A fraudulently, though filed his written statement did not come
to the witness box to testify his statement on oath. Thus, the stand
taken by defendant No.3 in his written statement cannot be taken
into consideration. P.W.1 (plaintiff) in her evidence has categorically
admitted that she was accompanied by her husband to the SubRegistrar
Office. Her husband is also an attesting witness to the
Power of Attorney. Thus, she had an opportunity of independent
advice in the matter. In that view of the matter, initial onus on
defendant Nos.1 and 2 to the effect that Ext. A was read over and
explained to the plaintiff and on being satisfied, she put her
signature, is duly discharged. Accordingly, the onus shifts on to the
plaintiff to prove that the contents of the deed was not read over and
explained to her. At paragraph-6 of Nitei Sahu’s case (supra), this
Court has held as under:-
“6. It must, however, be made clear that if the
plaintiff satisfies the Court, after evidence has been
gone into, that she is either a puradanashin or an
illiterate lady, then the onus would shift to the
defendants to establish that the document was read
over and fully explained to her and it was thereafter
that she put her signature after fully understanding 
the contents thereof. In many cases the burden is a
shifting one.”
14. Once the initial burden of proof is discharged by the
defendants, onus shifts and heavily lies on the plaintiff to prove her
contention as she challenges the solemnly executed registered
document as fraudulent transaction. She has to prove the
circumstances, which would establish that it was a fraudulent one.
[See Parasnath Thakur Vs. Mohini Dasi (dead) and another, reported
in AIR 1959 SC 1204] HIGH COURT OF ORISSA: CUTTACK
 RFA NO.231 OF 2009

Smt. Haramani Paikray 

V
Hadibandhu Senapati and others 
 Dated: 24.06.2016

P R E S E N T:
 SHRI JUSTICE K.R. MOHAPATRA
Citation: AIR 2016 (NOC) 633 Orissa
Print Page

Friday, 25 December 2015

Whether principles applicable to Pardanashin lady can be applied to illiterate widow/lady from rural area?


Evidence - Burden of proof - Sections 101, 102, 103 and 104 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 - Present appeal filed for challenging order of execution of sale-deed - Whether Rules regarding Pardanashi lady would apply equally to ignorant and illiterate Appellant - Held, burden of proof and heavy onus lie upon Respondent who seeks to enforce agreement for sale - By seeking decree of specific performance when such document had been denied by Appellant who was illiterate widow lady of rural area - Principles applicable to Pardanashi lady had to be applied to case where Appellant was illiterate widow/lady from rural area - Not much difference in two types of ladies - Appeal allowed.
Equivalent Citation: 2013(8)ADJ617, 2013 (100) ALR 621, 2013 121 RD228
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
Second Appeal No. 772 of 1979
Decided On: 04.04.2013
Tika Ram and Another Vs.Daulat Ram and Others
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:Sudhir Agarwal, J.


Print Page

Sunday, 22 June 2014

How to appreciate evidence of pardanashin lady?

The trial court wrongly held that being a pardanashin lady she might not have seen the appellant and hence her alleged identification cannot be relied upon. The face of a pardanashin lady cannot be seen by others, but she can see everybody.No infirmity in her identifying  the accused persons.

Supreme Court of India
Ashok Rai vs State Of U.P. & Ors on 15 April, 2014
Bench: Ranjana Prakash Desai, Madan B. Lokur
NON-REPORTABLE
Citation;2014(2)crimes 155 SC,2014 (85) ALLCC 625, 2014(2)RCR(Criminal)536, 2014(5)SCALE73
Print Page