Showing posts with label illiterate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label illiterate. Show all posts

Saturday, 25 January 2020

Whether illiterate lady is entitled to get benefit of Pardanashin lady in absence of pleading?

The Plaintiff-first Respondent filed a Suit No. 155 of 1996 before the Civil Judge (J.D.), Roorkee. A copy of the plaint has been placed on record (Annexure P/1). On perusal of the plaint, it reveals that it has nowhere been pleaded that the Plaintiff-first Respondent is a pardanasheen illiterate lady. In the ordinary course the burden of proof rest, on who attack. On the contrary, it was pleaded in the plaint that Defendant Nos. 1 and 3 are the sons of her uncle Mangta and Defendant No. 2 is the wife of Defendant No. 1 and they hatched a conspiracy to grab the land of the Plaintiff-first Respondent and with connivance, the power of attorney was prepared & registered on 25th April, 1995 in the registry office, in the name of the Plaintiff and pursuant thereto, suit land was sold by a registered sale deed. On the basis of pleadings on record, the above-mentioned eight issues were framed on which both the parties have adduced oral and documentary evidence and the trial Judge, after considering the evidence, dismissed the suit vide judgment and decree dated 19th January, 2001 and that came to be affirmed on dismissal of the appeal filed at the instance of the Plaintiff-first Respondent dated 27th August, 2001. It reveals from the record that without there being any factual foundation, the High Court, while admitting the appeal, framed two substantial questions of law in reference to which there was no supporting pleadings on record.

14. We still, for our satisfaction have gone through the plaint placed on record at Annexure P/1 and we are unable to find the pleadings in support that she was a pardanasheen illiterate lady and was entitled for protection of law and the burden was on the Defendant-Appellant to prove that the alleged power of attorney was the result of fraud.

15. After we have heard the parties, we are of the view that the High Court has committed a manifest apparent error in reversing the concurrent finding of the two Courts below and on this score the impugned judgment is not sustainable.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 7137 of 2010

Decided On: 17.09.2019

 Ali Hussain  Vs.  Rabiya 

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N.V. Ramana, Mohan M. Shantanagoudar and Ajay Rastogi, JJ.

Citation: AIR 2019 SC 4313
Print Page

Friday, 22 June 2018

Whether principles for proof of execution of documents taken from pardanashin lady is applicable to illiterate lady?


In Agadhei Malikani and another v. Abhimanyu Mallik and others, MANU/OR/0133/1968 : ILR 1968 Cut. 576, this Court held that the principles which govern the proof of execution of documents taken from pardanashin woman equally apply to the documents taken from an illiterate woman.

10. The gift deed, Ext. B, reveals that Chandrama had put her L.T.I. There is no endorsement in the gift deed that the contents of the gift deed had been read over and explained to Chandrama and after understanding the contents thereof, she put her L.T.I. Learned trial court held that it is highly inconceivable that Chandrama executed a gift deed in favour of defendant No. 1 in respect of her entire property. The gift deed had not been acted upon.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK

S.A. No. 249 of 1988

Decided On: 30.04.2018

 Gajraj Pasayat Vs.  Debraj Pasayat and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dr. Akshaya Kumar Rath, J.

Print Page

Wednesday, 3 January 2018

Whether a person can be held bound by recitals of deed even if he has signed said deed without reading it?

Their Lordships wish to add that in a case where the person executing the deed is neither blind nor illiterate, where no fraudulent misrepresentation is made to him, where he has ample opportunity of reading the deed and such knowledge of its purport that the plea of non est factum is not open to him, it is quite immaterial whether he reads the deed or not. He is bound by the deed because it operates as a conclusive bar against him-not because he has read it or understands it, but because he has chosen to execute it. 

BEFORE THE PRIVY COUNCIL

Privy Council Appeal No. 16 of 1937

Decided On: 13.01.1938

Martin Cashin and others  Vs. Peter J. Cashin

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Lords Atkin, Thankerton, Bussell of Killowen, Wright and Maugham

Citation:AIR 1938 Privy Council 103


Print Page

Tuesday, 22 November 2016

Whether police can insist illiterate informant to give FIR in writing written by someone else?

Section 154 of CrPC contemplates that if the information is given orally to the officer in-charge of a police station it shall be reduced to writing by him or under his direction. The informant was an illiterate person. He stated that when the police officers arrived there he told the police officers that accused Nani Kanta and Tukan murdered Gopi Mohan and so it was the duty of the police officers to record the FIR themselves as per the statement of Bidhu but they insisted for an FIR in writing and one can just imagine under that circumstances where a brutal murder occurred in the house of Bidhu he might not be in a position to narrate the occurrence arithmetically. It was obvious that hearing cries many people would gather since the cry was raised saying 'thief thief" whereas the accused persons only chased behind the deceased Gopi Mohan and searched for him and they have only killed the deceased.
In the given facts and circumstances of this case while an information was already received by police at P.S. and Exbt. 10 G.D. entry was made which was definite about a cognizable offence the subsequent collection of writing ejahar from Bidhu which is proved as Exbt. 1/1 by PW. 9 is clearly hit by Section 162 of CrPC and cannot be regarded as FIR.
This Court on several earlier occasions insisted that the law requires the FIR should be recorded by the police officer himself or by any person under his direction and a police officer should not insist upon an illiterate person to give an FIR in writing written by somebody else.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA AT AGARTALA
Crl. A (J) Nos. 4 and 11 of 2014
Decided On: 05.04.2016
Tukan Sharma and Ors.
Vs.
The State of Tripura
Coram:Deepak Gupta, C.J. and S.C. Das, J.
Citation: 2016 CRLJ4019
Print Page

Friday, 25 December 2015

Precaution to be taken by court when defendant is an illiterate farmer of rural area

Whenever a dispute regarding execution of a document is raised and defendant is an illiterate farmer of rural area, Court(s) has/have to consider the matter with great caution and care so that an innocent illiterate person may not suffer for something he was not able to understand. 
Equivalent Citation: 2013(8)ADJ617, 2013 (100) ALR 621, 2013 121 RD228
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
Second Appeal No. 772 of 1979
Decided On: 04.04.2013

Tika Ram and Another

Vs.
Daulat Ram and Others
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:Sudhir Agarwal, J.


Print Page

Whether principles applicable to Pardanashin lady can be applied to illiterate widow/lady from rural area?


Evidence - Burden of proof - Sections 101, 102, 103 and 104 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 - Present appeal filed for challenging order of execution of sale-deed - Whether Rules regarding Pardanashi lady would apply equally to ignorant and illiterate Appellant - Held, burden of proof and heavy onus lie upon Respondent who seeks to enforce agreement for sale - By seeking decree of specific performance when such document had been denied by Appellant who was illiterate widow lady of rural area - Principles applicable to Pardanashi lady had to be applied to case where Appellant was illiterate widow/lady from rural area - Not much difference in two types of ladies - Appeal allowed.
Equivalent Citation: 2013(8)ADJ617, 2013 (100) ALR 621, 2013 121 RD228
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
Second Appeal No. 772 of 1979
Decided On: 04.04.2013
Tika Ram and Another Vs.Daulat Ram and Others
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:Sudhir Agarwal, J.


Print Page

Thursday, 3 January 2013

Whether it is necessary to explain contents of document if thumb mark is affixed by illiterate person?

 Coming to the agreement to sell (Ext. 1) both the courts below have held that the document is not genuine and is a forged one, and this finding being based on appreciation of evidence is a finding of fact. But. as much argument was advanced, I have to look to the evidence in relation to the execution of the document and its genuineness. Under Section 67 of the Evidence Act execution of document has to be proved, which denotes a conscious act of subscribing to a document. In order to prove the execution of a document it must be shown that the person executing it consciously subscribed to it in the sense that he put his mark or signature on it after having known and understood its contents. Mere proof that the person's signature appears on the document cannot, by itself, amount to execution of the document. It is also settled that if an illiterate person affixes his thumb mark to a document, the onus to prove that the document was properly explained to the person affixing his thumb mark so as to make him understand its true import is on the person relying on the document.

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Ramjan Khan And Ors. vs Baba Raghunath Dass And Ors. on 5 December, 1990
Bench: S Dubey
Print Page