Showing posts with label S 406 of BPMC Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label S 406 of BPMC Act. Show all posts

Saturday, 10 February 2024

Important Judgments on imposition of property tax by Municipal Corporation

1)  Whether civil suit is maintainable to challenge assessment and levy of property tax on immovable property?

 10. A Division Bench of the Delhi High Court in Sobha Singh & sons (P) Ltd. vs. New Delhi Municipal Committee [34 (1988) Delhi Law Times 91] had an occasion to consider the question of maintainability of a civil suit challenging the assessment and levy of property tax by the NDMC. Sections 84 and 86 of the Act came in for consideration. It was held that the provision of appeal contained in Section 84(1) of the Act provided a complete remedy to a party aggrieved against the assessment and levy of tax. Section 86 provides that the remedy of appeal is the only remedy to a party to challenge assessment for purposes of property tax. No other remedy was available to a party in such circumstances. It follows that the remedy of civil suit is barred.

11. In view of the aforesaid position in law, we are of the considered view that the civil suit filed by respondent challenging the assessment and demand of property tax by the appellant was clearly barred. 

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Brijesh Kumar J.Arun Kumar J.

N.D.M.C. Vs. Satish Chand(deceased by LR Ram Chand

Appeal (Civil) 2700 of 1997

11th September 2003

Citation:  2003 ALL SCR 313,2003(4) Maharashtra Law Reporter 331.

https://www.lawweb.in/2021/11/whether-civil-suit-is-maintainable-to.html

Print Page

Saturday, 27 August 2022

Whether levy of property tax can be challenged U/S 406 of Maharashtra Municipal Corporation Act?

  Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners does not dispute that against the demand for property taxes, a remedy under section 406 of the Maharashtra Municipal Corporation Act, 1949 is available. However, he submitted that the remedy is not efficacious. He submits that the towers on which the taxes have been levied are neither land nor the buildings which can be subjected to payment of the property taxes. He submits that there is a breach of principles of natural justice.

4. As far as the second submission is concerned, again the

same can be gone into by the appellate authority. Hence, we do not

agree with the submission of learned counsel for the petitioners that the remedy under section 406 of the Act is not an efficacious remedy. The issues raised by the petitioners can be gone into by the appellate authority. Hence subject to what is observed above, the petition is dismissed. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION NO.1650 OF 2014

Viom Infra Networks Maharashtra Ltd. & Anr Vs Navi Mumbai Municipal Corporation and Ors.

CORAM : A.S. OKA & A.K. MENON, JJ.

DATED : 20TH JANUARY, 2015.

Read full Judgment here: Click here

Print Page

Whether the court can permit appellant to adduce evidence in Municipal appeal?

As far as the first submission is concerned, the appellant

can always adduce the evidence before the appellate authority as

regards the nature of towers in support of the contention that no

property taxes could be levied on the towers erected by the

petitioners. It is ultimately a factual controversy which can be

decided by the appellate authority which in this case is the Court of Civil Judge, Senior Division.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION NO.1650 OF 2014

Viom Infra Networks Maharashtra Ltd. & Anr Vs Navi Mumbai Municipal Corporation and Ors.


CORAM : A.S. OKA & A.K. MENON, JJ.

DATED : 20TH JANUARY, 2015

Print Page

Whether civil suit is maintainable if municipal officials commits error in ascertaining tax amount?

Undoubtedly, the Respondent municipal corporation would be required to determine the assessable value/price on which the octroi can be levied in accordance with the Octroi Rules. The power to determine this value undoubtedly rests with the Respondent and its officers. It cannot be said that any decision taken by the Respondents/its officers competent to decide the value for the purpose of levy of octroi is without power or in excess of their jurisdiction. The error, if any, in determination of the assessable value for the purpose of levy of octroi would be an error within the powers or within the jurisdiction of the Respondent and its officers. Such an error can be corrected in an appeal under Section 406 of the BPMC Act. A civil suit would not be an appropriate remedy and the civil court would not have jurisdiction to decide the issue. The jurisdiction of the civil court is excluded by necessary implication by reason of a provision of an appeal against determination of an octroi (which is a tax) contained in Section 406 of the BPMC Act.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Appeal From Order NO. 1379 of 2010

Decided On: 12.07.2011

Titan Industries Limited  Vs. Thane Municipal Corporation and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

D.G. Karnik, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/0889/2011

Print Page

Whether the civil court has jurisdiction to entertain a challenge to property tax imposed on charitable trust?

This contention of the respondent/Public Trust can be certainly raised in an appeal under Section 406 of the said Act. The exemption claimed by it, is under Section 132(1)(b) of the said Act, which is a ground that can be agitated in the appeal. It is not as if the respondent/Public Trust is prohibited from raising such a ground in the appeal or that the "Judge" does not have the authority to deal with such a ground of challenge while exercising appellate power under Section 406 of the said Act. The said contention of the respondent/Public Trust is covered under the expression "appeals against rateable value or the capital value as the case may be or tax fixed or charged under this Act" used in Section 406 of the said Act. {Para 15}


16. A perusal of the other relevant provisions of the said Act show that under Section 410 thereof, if on hearing of an appeal a question of law or construction of a document arises, the Judge may draw a statement of the facts of the case and refer such questions with his own opinion on the point for a decision of the District Court. Under Section 411 of the said Act, an appeal shall lie to the District Court from any decision of the Judge in an appeal under Section 406 thereof, by which a rateable value or capital value as the case may be is fixed or upon a question of law or usage or the construction of a document. The question whether tax is to be fixed at the rate at which the Municipal Corporation claims or it has to be nil as claimed by the respondent based on Section 132(1)(b) of the Act, can also be a subject matter of such appeal under Section 411 of the Act. Further Section 413 of the said Act provides that the decision of the District Court in an appeal under Section 411 of the Act shall be final.


17. Thus, the provisions of the aforesaid Act provide a scheme wherein the grievance of the respondent/Public Trust can be fully taken care of and, therefore, the jurisdiction of the Civil Court is impliedly ousted. Applying the propositions culled out by the Constitution Bench judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Dhulabhai (supra), it becomes evident that the aforesaid Act, with which we are concerned in the present case, is covered under proposition Nos. 2 and 6. In the present case, there is no question of a challenge to the vires of any provision of the aforesaid Act and the claim of the respondent/Public Trust that the notice and bills issued by the appellant/Municipal Corporation are illegal because the respondent is entitled for exemption from payment of property tax, is a question that can very well be decided in the mechanism provided as per the aforesaid provisions of the said Act.


18. In this context, the contents of the plaint of the respondent/Public Trust need to be appreciated. The entire grievance of the respondent is that it is undertaking educational activities in the building in question and that, therefore, under Section 132(1)(b) of the said Act, it is exempt from levy of tax. It is also claimed that tax is being claimed retrospectively by the appellant/Municipal Corporation, which cannot be done. In my opinion, all these are facets of "tax fixed or charged" or the rateable value applied by the appellant/Municipal Corporation, while raising bills against the respondent/Public Trust. If the contents of the plaint are appreciated in the proper perspective, it becomes evident that there is force in the contention raised on behalf of the appellant/Municipal Corporation that the respondent/Public Trust has filed the civil suit, instead of appeal under Section 406 of the said Act, only to avoid the mandatory deposit of disputed tax claimed by the appellant/Municipal Corporation, under Section 406(2)(e) of the Act, before the appeal can be heard or decided by the Judge. Although, this aspect may not be relevant to decide as to whether the jurisdiction of the Civil Court is ousted, it does demonstrate that in such cases, by clever drafting assessees may claim that civil suit is maintainable by contending that the very levy of the tax by the Municipal Corporation is "illegal" and that there is no remedy other than filing of suit before the Civil Court. It is for the assessees like the respondent/Public Trust to demonstrate as to why the grievance sought to be raised by them cannot be addressed under the scheme manifested by the above quoted provisions of the said Act.


19. In the present case, the learned Counsel for the respondent/Public Trust has heavily relied upon the judgment of this Court in the case of Balkrishna Vora v. Poona Municipal Corporation (cited supra). In the aforesaid case, the Court was concerned with the question that the tax levied or sought to be recovered was ultra vires the powers of the Corporation. In such a situation, it was held by this Court that the machinery provided under the aforesaid Act would not be sufficient for the assessee to air his grievance and thereupon, the Court held that the jurisdiction of the Civil Court could not be said to have been ousted and that the suit was maintainable. But, in the instant case, the nature of the grievance of the respondent/Public Trust is not such that it cannot be redressed under the machinery of the aforesaid Act. Therefore, the reliance placed on the said judgment of this Court is misplaced.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Appeal Against Order (AO) No. 34 of 2017

Decided On: 14.02.2018

Akola Municipal Corporation Vs. Shri Akola Gujrati Samaj

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Manish Pitale, J.

Citation:  MANU/MH/0239/2018

Print Page

Tuesday, 31 August 2021

Whether civil suit by Charitable trust challenging levy of property tax imposed by Municipal Corporation is maintainable?

Once it is found that the true nature of the grievance is such that it can certainly be raised in an appeal under section 406 of the said Act, it becomes clear that the jurisdiction of the civil Court is impliedly ousted and that the respondent/Public Trust is required to exhaust the remedy provided under the above quoted provisions of the said Act.

 21. If litigants like the respondent/Public Trust are permitted to raise grievance, that can certainly be addressed in the remedies provided under the aforesaid Act, by filing civil suits, on the basis of clever drafting, all such litigants would avoid mandatory requirements of the said Act and approach the civil Court, although a proper mechanism of grievance redressal is provided under the said Act. This aspect was not appreciated in the correct perspective by the Appellate Court while passing the impugned judgment and order.

(a) Maharashtra Municipal Corporations Act (59 of 1949), SS. 406 and 132(1)(b) — Municipal Tax — Levy of tax on Public Trust — Validity — Jurisdiction of Civil Court — Claim by Public Trust that it is undertaking educational activities in building in question and is exempt from levy of tax under section 132(1)(b) — Can be agitated in an appeal under section 406 — Jurisdiction of Civil Court is impliedly ousted.

The exemption claimed by respondent-Public Trust is under section 132(1)(b) of the Maharashtra Municipal Corporations Act, which is a ground that can be agitated in the appeal. It is not as if the respondent/Public Trust is prohibited from raising such a ground in the appeal or that the “Judge” does not have the authority to deal with such a ground of challenge while exercising appellate power under section 406 of the said Act. The said contention of the respondent/Public Trust is covered under the expression “appeals against rateable value or the capital value as the case may be or tax fixed or charged under this Act” used in section 406 of the said Act. The provisions of the Act provide a scheme wherein the grievance of the respondent/Public Trust can be fully taken care of and, therefore, the jurisdiction of the Civil Court is impliedly ousted. 1968 (3) SCR 662.

(Paras 15, 17, 20 and 22)

(b) Maharashtra Municipal Corporations Act (59 of 1949), SS. 406 and 132(1)(b) — Ouster of jurisdiction of Civil Court — Ouster of jurisdiction can take place by an express provision in statute or impliedly — Must be decided on examination of scheme of statute in question and its analysis.

 In the High Court of Bombay


(Nagpur)

(Before Manish Pitale, J.)

Akola Municipal Corporation Vs Akola Gujratisamaj and Others

Appeal against Order (AO) No. 34 of 2017

Decided on February 14, 2018

Citation: 2018 SCC OnLine Bom 201 : (2018) 5 Mah LJ 267 : (2018) 2 AIR Bom R 578 : (2018) 2 Bom CR 841

Print Page

Friday, 30 September 2016

Whether plaint can returned to avail remedy of Municipal Appeal U/S 406 of Maharashtra municipal corporation Act?

 On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent
submitted   with   reference   to   Section   106   of   the   Maharashtra
Municipalities Act that specific remedy of appeal against any rateable
value or the capital value, as the case may be, or tax fixed or charged
under  the  Act shall  be  heard and determined by the  Judge before

whom the appeal is provided against such levy of tax or rateable value
or charges.   Thus, according to learned counsel for the respondent,
specific statutory remedy of appeal is provided which is statutory right
of plaintiff / appellant, and therefore, learned Judge was right to arrive
at a conclusion that Civil court had no jurisdiction to entertain and try
the suit.  Reference is made to a ruling in Dai Ichi Karkaria Ltd. vs.
Pimpri Chinchwad Municipal Corporation & Ors. decided by Single
Judge of this court in Appeal from Order No.714 of 2013 decided on
29.7.2013.  Learned counsel for the respondent invited my attention to
the fact that Section 406 of the BPMC Act was considered as also
earlier ruling by this court in  Titan Industries Limited, Mumbai vs.
Thane   Municipal   Corporation   and   Ors.  reported   in  2011   (6)
Mah.L.J. 228 on the point that Civil court has no jurisdiction to decide
the issue regarding levy of octroi in view of statutory remedy of appeal
under Section 406 of the BPMC Act.  The contention regarding issue of
limitation also appears to have been dealt with by this court in   Dai
Ichi Karkaria's case, in paragraph 9, as in that case tax was levied
after   23   years,   and   there   was   an   argument   that   it   is   barred   by
limitation.  This court specifically observed that “the court which has
jurisdiction   would   decide   the   issue   and   not   the   court   not   having
jurisdiction.”  In other words, consensus of ruling in Titan Industries

Limited, Mumbai, case   as also in Dai Ichi Karkaria's case, appears
that the plaintiff has to be relegated to the specific statutory remedy of
appeal available under Section 406 of the BPMC Act on the ground that
Civil court would have no jurisdiction to entertain and try the suit.  My
attention is also invited to the fact that in  Dai Ichi Karkaria's case,
Special Leave Petition was preferred and it was dismissed by Hon'ble
Supreme Court of India by observation that if the petitioner pursues the
remedy under Section 406 of the BPMC Act, 1949, within 30 days from
today,  the  time   granted   in  the   order   dated   31.10.2012   shall  stand
extended to that date.   Even otherwise, delay occurred due to time
spent   bonafide   to   pursue   the   litigation   has   to   be   condoned   when
remedy prescribed by the statute is availed of, which was not availed
of,   on   account   of   bonafide   –   but   wrong   impression   that   ordinary
remedy is available by way of civil suit.
5 Having   considered   the   submissions   at   the   bar   and   the
rulings referred to before this court, I am of the opinion that impugned
order is legal and correct. Learned counsel for the appellant prayed that
plaint may be returned to the appellant so that it's contents can be
relied upon along with memorandum of appeal before the appellate
authority concerned because the plaintiff relegated to avail of statutory
remedy of appeal under Section 406 of BPMC Act.  

6 Hence, instead of dismissal of the suit, the order passed by
the court below is modified to the effect that plaint in the suit shall be
returned to the plaintiff to enable him to avail of statutory remedy of
appeal by filing the  plaint along with appropriate memorandum of
appeal before the appellate authority concerned, in view of Section 406
of the BPMC Act, 1949.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
FIRST APPEAL NO.1169 OF 2013
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.2960 OF 2013
IN
FIRST APPEAL NO.1169 OF 2013
GREAVE COTTON LIMITED  V/s. PIMPRI CHINCHWAD MUNICIPAL CORPORATION 
CORAM: A. P. BHANGALE, J.
DATE    : 23rd SEPTEMBER, 2013.
Citation:2014(1) MHLJ655
Print Page

Sunday, 28 August 2016

What amount is to be deposited while filing municipal appeal under S 406 of BPMC Act?

With the aforesaid factual backdrop, in the teeth of the above statutory provisions, one cannot dispute that tax, interest and penalty are three different concepts. Tax becomes payable by an assessee by virtue of the charging provision in a taxing statute. Penalty ordinarily become payable when it is found that an assessee  has willfully violated any of the provisions of the taxing statute. Interest is ordinarily claimed from an assessee who has withheld payment of any tax payable by him and it is always calculated at the prescribed rate on the basis of the actual amount of tax withheld and the extent of delay caused in paying it. It is, therefore, clear that interest is compensatory in character and not penal. [ACC Cement Co.Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer (supra) Para-23]
18. Having found three different concepts referred to above, if one turns to clause (e) of sub-section (2) of section 406 of the Act, what is required to be deposited is the amount of disputed tax or the amount of tax chargeable on the basis of the disputed ratable value upto the date of filing of appeal. If that be so, the submission advanced by the petitioners that the said sub-section does not require the appellant to pre- deposit interest and penalty amount needs to be accepted.
Bombay High Court
M/S.C.G.International Pvt.Ltd vs The State Of Maharashtra And ... on 22 January, 2010
Bench: V.C. Daga
                                       
      WRIT PETITION NO. 4176 OF 2008
Print Page

Whether court can decide municipal appeal without calling assessment Records from Municipal Corporation?

Appeal under section 406 of the BPMC Act being a statutory Appeal,
without calling for the Records of assessment from the Municipal Corporation
neither the Small Causes Court nor the Court of 7th Additional District Judge
could have decided the same. Provisions of the Rules particularly Rule 7 of
Property Rules framed under the BPMC Act show that the Annual letting value is
to be determined after ascertaining the reasonable rent on which the premises are
expected to be let out. How the reasonable rent is to be determined is not very
clear and none of the Courts have looked into it .Whether any such reasonable
rent has been worked out and thereafter Annual letting value was reached is also
not clear.

The Small Causes Court ought to have called for
Assessment Records from the Municipal Corporation. Perusing the same in the
light of Relevant Rules dealing with determination of reasonable rent and Annual
letting value and then determined whether the assessment order dated 20.6.1986
was in accordance in law or not ? The statutory Appeal could not have been
determined without such application of mind and without going through the basic
record.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
APPELLATE CIVIL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 133 OF 1996


Trilok Baburao Deshpande. Vs. Municipal Corpn of Gr.City of Pune 

CORAM : B.P.DHARMADHIKARI, J
DATED : 23.11.2012
Citation:2013(1) MHLJ 794

Print Page

Thursday, 26 March 2015

Whether jurisdiction of civil court is barred in respect of assessment of tax by municipal corporation?

 Dispute in this appeal was in substance relating to the
assessment of the tax for the period from the year 1999 to 2001 which was challenged in the suit. Learned Judge considered the remedy of
appeal statutorily available under Section 406 of the BPMC Act and
held that plaintiff has to move to avail of the statutory remedy of
appeal on the ground that the civil court had no jurisdiction to grant
relief to the plaintiff for want of jurisdiction under Section 9 of Code of
Civil Procedure. The civil suit was held not maintainable and the issue
of jurisdiction was decided against the plaintiff. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
FIRST APPEAL NO.1169 OF 2013

WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.2960 OF 2013
IN
FIRST APPEAL NO.1169 OF 2013
GREAVE COTTON LIMITED  V/s. PIMPRI CHINCHWAD MUNICIPAL CORPORATION )
AND OTHERS 


CORAM: A. P. BHANGALE, J.
DATE : 23rd SEPTEMBER, 2013.
Citation;2014(1) MHLJ 655

Print Page