Showing posts with label S 509 of IPC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label S 509 of IPC. Show all posts

Sunday, 5 January 2025

Important provisions of Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013



[Act 14 of 2013 as amended up to Act 23 of 2016 and updated as of 30th April 2024]

An Act to provide protection against sexual harassment of women at workplace and for the prevention and redressal of complaints of sexual harassment and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto

Whereas sexual harassment results in violation of the fundamental rights of a woman to equality under Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution of India and her right to life and to live with dignity under Article 21 of the Constitution and right to practice any profession or to carry on any occupation, trade or business which includes a right to a safe environment free from sexual harassment;

And whereas the protection against sexual harassment and the right to work with dignity are universally recognised human rights by international conventions and instruments such as Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination against Women, which has been ratified on the 25th June, 1993 by the Government of India;

And whereas it is expedient to make provisions for giving effect to the said Convention for protection of women against sexual harassment at workplace;

Print Page

Friday, 23 August 2024

Bombay HC: Objectionable Words Written In E-Mail Or On Social Media Can Be Penalized U/S 509 of IPC For Insulting Woman's Modesty

 Later, legislature found that a woman must be protected

not only from physical aggressions made in the course of

outraging her modesty, but she should also be shielded from

various other acts which do not involve even a touch. Legislature

was quite aware that a woman’s modesty can be insulted or

outraged in various ways. A mere word, a wink, a touch or even

a look would suffice to insult the modesty of a Woman. Physical

advances may not be necessary in all cases. Everything depends

on the intention of the mischief-maker and the manner in which

he conveys his intentions. It is evident that legislature intended

that any aggression into a woman’s modesty whether by any

word, deed, touch or look need be curbed and deterred. {Para 18}

19. That is why even a verbal attack on a woman, a gesture

and other acts stated in Section 509 I.P.C. were brought under

the said Section. It is clear from a reading of Section 509 I.P.C.

that by introducing the said provision, legislature intended that

any sort of aggression into a woman’s modesty whether by any

word, deed or act should be deterred, as evident from the title to

the Section itself. Thus, the acts which are done intending to

insult the modesty of a woman which may not necessarily involve

even any physical advances are also brought within the sweep of

a separate provision viz., Section 509 I.P.C.

20. In such circumstances, can it be for a moment presumed

that the legislature intended that a person who writes a letter to

a woman with the intention to insult her modesty should go

unpunished? If such a person, instead of uttering the insulting

words, puts in writing all what he determines to utter against a

woman and sends it to her, intending to insult her modesty, will

any Court be justified in holding that the legislature expected such person to escape safely? was it the intention of the legislature that such a culprit must go unhurt only because he used his pen and not his tongue, to insult the victim? After suffering all the trauma, when a woman comes before Court with the best proof for the assault or violence made on her modesty by producing the letter, can the Court refuse to look into the same on the ground that the legislature never intended to bring cases involving writings within the purview of Section 509 I.P.C.?


21. I find it extremely difficult to reach a conclusion which

will defeat the very object of Section 509 I.P.C. There can be

little doubt that the legislature would not have intended that a

person who insults the modesty of a woman by his writings must

be kept out of the province of Section 509 I.P.C. In a country like

India, legislature would not have ever intended that a person

who expresses his attitude or intention to insult modesty of a

woman by sending a letter should be absolved from criminal

liability. I am of view that the very object of the provision will be

defeated if a contrary view is taken. Thus, while interpreting the

meaning of the relevant expression in Section 509 I.P.C. in the

light of the relevant rules of interpretation, I find that ‘writing of

letter’ to a woman, intending to insult her modesty can be

construed as ‘making a gesture’ under Section 509 I.P.C. I feel

quite confident to hold that Indian legislature’s intention will not

be contrary to what I have already concluded.”

The transmission by the Petitioner of the offensive e-mails to her and other residents in the society demonstrates clear intent of the Petitioner to insultthe Respondent No. 2. As we have already discussed hereinabove that, no matter that the offensive material was transmitted through electronic media, it would still be ensconced in the interpretation of the words ‘utter’ and ‘gesture’ and ‘exhibit’. Alternatively, it intrudes on the Respondent No. 2’s privacy.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 3480 OF 2011

WITH

INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 2355 OF 2023

IN

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 3480 OF 2011

Joseph Paul de Sousa, Vs  The State 

CORAM: A. S. GADKARI AND

DR. NEELA GOKHALE, JJ.

 PRONOUNCED ON: 21st  AUGUST 2024.

 JUDGMENT ( Per Dr. Neela Gokhale, J. ) :
Print Page

Sunday, 24 December 2017

Whether Writing of letter to woman intending to insult her modesty can be construed as making gesture U/S 509 IPC?

That is why even a verbal attack on a woman, a gesture and other acts stated in Section 509 I.P.C. were brought under the said Section. It is clear from a reading of Section 509 I.P.C. that by introducing the said provision, legislature intended that any sort of aggression into a woman's modesty whether by any word, deed or act should be deterred, as evident from the title to the Section itself. Thus, the acts which are done intending to insult the modesty of a woman which may not necessarily involve even any physical advances are also brought within the sweep of a separate provision viz., Section 509 I.P.C.

20. In such circumstances, can it be for a moment presumed that the legislature intended that a person who writes a letter to a woman with the intention to insult her modesty should go unpunished? If such a person, instead of uttering the insulting words, puts in writing all what he determines to utter against a woman and sends it to her, intending to insult her modesty, will any court be justified in holding that the legislature expected such person to escape safely? was it the intention of the legislature that such a culprit must go unhurt only because he used his pen and not his tongue, to insult the victim? After suffering all the trauma, when a woman comes before court with the best proof for the assault or violence made on her modesty by producing the letter, can the court refuse to look into the same on the ground that the legislature never intended to bring cases involving writings within the purview of Section 509 I.P.C.?

21. I find it extremely difficult to reach a conclusion which will defeat the very object of Section 509 I.P.C. There can be little doubt that the legislature would not have intended that a person who insults the modesty of a woman by his writings must be kept out of the province of Section 509 I.P.C. In a country like India, legislature would not have ever intended that a person who expresses his attitude or intention to insult modesty of a woman by sending a letter should be absolved from criminal liability. I am of view that the very object of the provision will be defeated if a contrary view is taken. Thus, while interpreting the meaning of the relevant expression in Section 509 I.P.C. in the light of the relevant rules of interpretation, I find that 'writing of letter' to a woman, intending to insult her modesty can be construed as 'making a gesture' under Section 509 I.P.C. I feel quite confident to hold that Indian legislature's intention will not be contrary to what I have already concluded.

22. So, if the court finds that a person writes a letter to woman and that the offender intends that such letter is seen or read by such woman and he also intends thereby to insult her modesty, an offence under Section 509 I.P.C. will be clearly attracted. Charge-sheet in this case itself reveals that the Petitioner allegedly wrote insulting and obscene letters to the victim-woman. It is also clear from the records that such letters were sent to her in the name-address so that the letters will be seen and read by the victim. It further appears from the contents of those letters that prima facie, intention of the author of the letters was to insult the modesty of the woman who receives the letter. Such intention can be discerned from the nature of the language, tone and tenor of the writing.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA

Crl. M.C. No. 9717 of 2002

Decided On: 16.02.2005

M.M. Haries Vs. State of Kerala

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
K. Hema, J.


Print Page

Thursday, 6 April 2017

Whether offence U/S 509 of IPC is made out against accused even if obscene words are not heard by victim?

Learned   counsel   for   the   appellant   was   at   pains   to
argue that, as PW2 Priyanka Raorane had not heard the obscene
remark hurled at her by the accused, the accused is not liable for
conviction for the offence punishable under Section 509 of the
IPC,   and   at   the   most,   he   can   be   convicted   for   the   offence

punishable under Section 294 of the IPC.  Section 509 of the IPC
reads thus :
509. Word, gesture or act intended to insult
the   modesty   of   a   woman  —   Whoever,
intending to insult the modesty of any woman,
utters any word, makes any sound or gesture,
or   exhibits   any   object,   intending   that   such
word  or sound  shall  be  heard,  or that  such
gesture or object shall be seen, by such woman,
or intrudes upon the privacy of such woman,
shall   be   punished   with   simple   imprisonment
for a term which may extend to one year, or
with fine, or with both.
Evidence of PW1 Akshay establishes what were utterances of the
accused addressed to PW2 Priyanka Raorane, though she might
not have heard the same.  At the cost of repetition, it needs to be
put   on   record   that,   the   accused,   upon   seeing   PW2   Priyanka
Raorane, uttered  “kya ball hai.”   These utterances are obscene
remarks on breast of PW2 Priyanka Raorane.   Therefore, such
utterances are undoubtedly intending to insulting the modesty of
PW2 Priyanka Raorane.   Section 509 of the IPC provides that

utterances intending to insult the modesty of woman should be
with   an   intention   that   such   words   or   sound   shall   be   heard.
Section  509  of the IPC  does not  provide that such  utterances
should   be   heard   by   the   subject.     Hearing   such   utterances   by
anybody would amount to the offence punishable under Section
509 of the IPC.  Hence, no infirmity can be found in the order of
conviction of the accused for the offence punishable under Section
509 of the IPC.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.791 OF 2012

DIVAKAR BHAIRAVNATH YADAV @ ROCKY  V/s. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA 

CORAM : A. M. BADAR
DATE : 17th NOVEMBER 2016 &
18th NOVEMBER 2016.
Citation: 2017 ALLMR(CRI)941
Print Page