Later, legislature found that a woman must be protected
not only from physical aggressions made in the course of
outraging her modesty, but she should also be shielded from
various other acts which do not involve even a touch. Legislature
was quite aware that a woman’s modesty can be insulted or
outraged in various ways. A mere word, a wink, a touch or even
a look would suffice to insult the modesty of a Woman. Physical
advances may not be necessary in all cases. Everything depends
on the intention of the mischief-maker and the manner in which
he conveys his intentions. It is evident that legislature intended
that any aggression into a woman’s modesty whether by any
word, deed, touch or look need be curbed and deterred. {Para 18}
19. That is why even a verbal attack on a woman, a gesture
and other acts stated in Section 509 I.P.C. were brought under
the said Section. It is clear from a reading of Section 509 I.P.C.
that by introducing the said provision, legislature intended that
any sort of aggression into a woman’s modesty whether by any
word, deed or act should be deterred, as evident from the title to
the Section itself. Thus, the acts which are done intending to
insult the modesty of a woman which may not necessarily involve
even any physical advances are also brought within the sweep of
a separate provision viz., Section 509 I.P.C.
20. In such circumstances, can it be for a moment presumed
that the legislature intended that a person who writes a letter to
a woman with the intention to insult her modesty should go
unpunished? If such a person, instead of uttering the insulting
words, puts in writing all what he determines to utter against a
woman and sends it to her, intending to insult her modesty, will
any Court be justified in holding that the legislature expected such person to escape safely? was it the intention of the legislature that such a culprit must go unhurt only because he used his pen and not his tongue, to insult the victim? After suffering all the trauma, when a woman comes before Court with the best proof for the assault or violence made on her modesty by producing the letter, can the Court refuse to look into the same on the ground that the legislature never intended to bring cases involving writings within the purview of Section 509 I.P.C.?
21. I find it extremely difficult to reach a conclusion which
will defeat the very object of Section 509 I.P.C. There can be
little doubt that the legislature would not have intended that a
person who insults the modesty of a woman by his writings must
be kept out of the province of Section 509 I.P.C. In a country like
India, legislature would not have ever intended that a person
who expresses his attitude or intention to insult modesty of a
woman by sending a letter should be absolved from criminal
liability. I am of view that the very object of the provision will be
defeated if a contrary view is taken. Thus, while interpreting the
meaning of the relevant expression in Section 509 I.P.C. in the
light of the relevant rules of interpretation, I find that ‘writing of
letter’ to a woman, intending to insult her modesty can be
construed as ‘making a gesture’ under Section 509 I.P.C. I feel
quite confident to hold that Indian legislature’s intention will not
be contrary to what I have already concluded.”
The transmission by the Petitioner of the offensive e-mails to her and other residents in the society demonstrates clear intent of the Petitioner to insultthe Respondent No. 2. As we have already discussed hereinabove that, no matter that the offensive material was transmitted through electronic media, it would still be ensconced in the interpretation of the words ‘utter’ and ‘gesture’ and ‘exhibit’. Alternatively, it intrudes on the Respondent No. 2’s privacy.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 3480 OF 2011
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 2355 OF 2023
IN
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 3480 OF 2011
Joseph Paul de Sousa, Vs The State
CORAM: A. S. GADKARI AND
DR. NEELA GOKHALE, JJ.
PRONOUNCED ON: 21st AUGUST 2024.
JUDGMENT ( Per Dr. Neela Gokhale, J. ) :
Print Page