We may hasten to observe that it is now well settled that
the Designated Court, besides trying the case under TADA,
can also try any other offence with which the accused may be
charged at the same trial if the offences are connected with
offences under TADA. For, implicit power has been bestowed
upon the Designated Court to convict the accused for offences
under other enactments if there is legally admissible evidence
to establish those charges. We may usefully refer to the
dictum in paragraph 37 of the Constitution Bench judgment in
Prakash Kumar alias Prakash Bhutto (supra), which reads
thus:
“37. The legislative intendment underlying Sections 12(1)
and (2) is clearly discernible, to empower the Designated
Court to try and convict the accused for offences committed
under any other law along with offences committed under
the Act, if the offence is connected with such other offence.
The language “if the offence is connected with such other
offence” employed in Section 12(1) of the Act has great
significance. The necessary corollary is that once the
other offence is connected with the offence under TADA
and if the accused is charged under the Code and tried
together in the same trial, the Designated Court is
empowered to convict the accused for the offence under
any other law, notwithstanding the fact that no offence
under TADA is made out. This could be the only
intendment of the legislature. To hold otherwise, would
amount to rewrite or recast legislation and read something
into it which is not there.”
(emphasis supplied)
This exposition has been applied by a Two Judge Bench in a
recent decision in Ashrafkhan alias Babu Munnekhan
Pathan & Anr. Vs. State of Gujarat 10 (2012) 11 SCC 606, as is evident from
paragraph 41, which reads thus:
“41. We have held the conviction of the accused to have
been vitiated on account of noncompliance
with Section
20A( 1) of TADA and thus, it may be permissible in law to
maintain the conviction under the Arms Act and the
Explosive Substances Act but that shall only be possible
when there are legally admissible evidence to establish
those charges. The Designated Court has only relied on the
confessions recorded under TADA to convict the accused for
offences under the Arms Act and the Explosive Substances
Act. In view of our finding that their conviction is
vitiated on account of noncompliance
of the mandatory
requirement of prior approval under Section 20A(
1) of
TADA, the confessions recorded cannot be looked into to
establish the guilt under the aforesaid Acts. Hence, the
conviction of the accused under Sections 7 and 25(1A)
of
the Arms Act and Sections 4, 5 and 6 of the Explosive
Substances Act cannot also be allowed to stand.”
(emphasis supplied)
24. Even in the present case, it is noticed that the
prosecution has essentially relied upon the confessional
statement of the accused recorded under the provisions of
TADA. That will be of no avail and certainly not admissible
against the accused in the trial for offences under other
enactments, especially when the Designated Court could not
have taken cognizance of the offence under TADA for lack of a
valid sanction.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. 13591361
OF 2007
The State of Gujarat Vs Anwar Osman Sumbhaniya
A.M. Khanwilkar, J.
Dated:February 27, 2019.
Print Page