Showing posts with label accomplice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label accomplice. Show all posts

Monday, 20 January 2025

Supreme Court: When Accused Acted With Common Intention, Punishment Can't Be Reduced Merely Because Injury Inflicted Individually Wasn't Severe

 Merely for the reason that

the injuries inflicted by Accused no.2 (K.B.Vijayakumar)

were less than what was inflicted by Accused no.3

(K.B.Jayakumar @ Suresh) and the injuries were not a

grievous. Conviction under Section 326 cannot be converted

to Section 324. Irrespective of the facts whether the

injuries caused to the injured persons (PW1 & PW7) were

only on the hand, the fact remained that the presence of

Accused no.2 on the spot is as an accomplice of Accused

no.3 and hence, Section 34 of the IPC is clearly made out.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

 CRIMINAL APPEAL NO(S). 1694/2014

THE STATE OF KARNATAKA Vs  BATTEGOWDA & ORS.

Dated: January 09, 2025.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Supreme Court: Common intention U/S 34 of IPC and the pre-meeting of minds can take place at the spur of the moment itself during the course of the incident.

Accused no.2 on the spot is as an accomplice of Accused

no.3 and hence, Section 34 of the IPC is clearly made out.

The case of the defence is that when the Accused Nos.2 & 3

had arrived at the spot, they had no intention to inflict

the nature of injuries on the injured persons. Even if it

is assumed it is true, it cannot be denied that common

intention and the pre-meeting of minds can take place at

the spur of the moment itself during the course of the

incident.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

 CRIMINAL APPEAL NO(S). 1694/2014

THE STATE OF KARNATAKA Vs  BATTEGOWDA & ORS.

Dated: January 09, 2025.

Print Page

Sunday, 24 February 2019

Whether accused can be cited as witness without following procedure of S 306 of CRPC?

The submission made on behalf of the Appellants that the prosecution was entitled to cite the three original Accused as witnesses, in the given fact situation, having regard to larger interest of justice to strengthen the prosecution case against more serious Accused cannot be held to be without substance. This could be done even without recourse to Section 306 Code of Criminal Procedure It is certainly open to the Court to finally decide whether cognizance ought to be taken or not after balancing all the relevant considerations. The decision of the prosecutor to cite them as witnesses does not bind the Court and such decision can be interfered with if interest of justice so requires.

7. In the present case, decision of the High Court has not been arrived at by weighing the interest of justice in having the Appellants as Accused instead of their utility as witnesses. The decision is based on the sole consideration of there being material against them. It was erroneously assumed that without following the procedure of Section 306 Code of Criminal Procedure, an accomplice could not be cited as a witness. Further question, whether rejecting the proposal of prosecution to cite the Appellants as witnesses will jeopardise prosecution case against more serious accused, has not been gone into. Thus, the matter needs fresh consideration on this touchstone.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal Nos. 939-940, 941-942/2017,

Decided On: 23.08.2017

 Girish Sharma  Vs.  The State of Chhattisgarh and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.K. Goel and U.U. Lalit, JJ.

Citation:(2018) 15 SCC192
Print Page

Sunday, 27 May 2018

Notes on tender of pardon to accomplice


S 306 of CRPC:- Tender of pardon to accomplice:-
1) With a view to obtain the evidence of any person who is supposed to have been directly or indirectly concerned in or privy to an offence to which this section applies, the chief judicial magistrate or metropolitan magistrate or first class magistrate may at any stage of investigation or inquiry tender a pardon to such person, on the condition that he will make a full and true disclosure of the whole of the circumstances within his knowledge relating to the offence and to every other person concerned in the commission thereof as principal or as an abettor.

The offences in respect of which such tender can be made are following:
a) Any offence which can be tried exclusively by session court,or by the court of special Judge appointed under criminal law amendment Act 1952.
Print Page

Sunday, 4 December 2016

Whether accused can be permitted to cross examine approver at pre-committal stage?

The examination which is contemplated under Section 306(4)
of the Code, cannot be equated with the 'examination' of a witness under
Section 138 of the Evidence Act. If what is contended by the learned

counsel for the respondent is to be accepted, and the accused is given a
right to cross examine an approver at the pre-committal stage, the same
would not only be contrary to law, but would lead to hazardous
consequences, as a Magistrate would be required to deal with and decide
the admissibility of any question raised in the examination/cross
examination by the accused, in a case exclusively triable by the Court of
Sessions. Under Section 306 of Code of Criminal Procedure, what cannot
be lost sight of is, that when an approver is being examined by a
Magistrate, he is merely recording his statement, after grant of pardon and
as such, he merely acts as a post office by recording the statement under
Section 306(4) and thereafter, forwards it to the Court of Sessions, which
is the Court competent to try the case. Thus, the term ‘examination’ used
in Section 306(4) of the Code, cannot be construed to mean an examination,
contemplated under Section 138 of the Evidence Act. The accused will get
an opportunity to cross examine the approver, only after the case is
committed to the Court of Sessions, when the approver is examined as a
prosecution witness, after which the accused will have a right to cross
examine the approver and bring out the contradictions or improvements
made by him during his evidence at the trial.

14. In conclusion, we may note that under Section 306 of the
Cr.P.C, the Magistrate is only empowered to examine the approver, as at this
stage, the proceeding before the concerned Magistrate is neither an inquiry
nor a trial, and therefore the accused has no right to cross-examine the
approver. The Magistrate does not have the jurisdiction and discretion to
“appreciate the evidence” which will be adduced before the Sessions Court
and give any findings on the merits of the case. His duty is only to record
the examination under Section 306(4)(a) and forward it to the Court of
Sessions, whilst committing the case. The examination of the approver as
contemplated under Section 306(4)(a) cannot in any circumstance, be
equated with the examination contemplated under Section 138 of the
Evidence Act. Infact, the examination is more or less akin to an examination
contemplated under Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Hence,
an accused has no right to cross examine an approver at the pre-committal
stage.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.237 OF 2015

The State of Maharashtra V  Narendra G. Goel

CORAM : V. M. KANADE &
 REVATI MOHITE DERE, JJ.

PRONOUNCED ON : 18th APRIL, 2016
Citation:2016 CRLJ 4227 Bom
Print Page

Tuesday, 8 April 2014

Whether Magistrate can grant pardon to accomplice during investigation?


Bangaru Laxman (supra), therefore, emphasizes the concurrent jurisdiction of the Special Judge as well as the Chief Judicial Magistrate or Metropolitan Magistrate to grant pardon during investigation, but does not say that the Metropolitan Magistrate has no power Under Section 306 Code of Criminal Procedure to grant pardon during the investigation i.e. before filing of charge-sheet before the Special Judge. During investigation, in our view, both the Special Judge as well as the Magistrate acting Under Section 306 Code of Criminal Procedure have concurrent jurisdiction to entertain application of pardon, which facilitates proper investigation of the crime. But, as already indicated, after the committal of the case, the pardon granted by the Magistrate is not a curable irregularity.
15. We may, in this regard, refer to Section 460 Code of Criminal Procedure which refers to nine kinds of curable irregularities, provided they are caused erroneously and in good faith. Irregularity caused while granting pardon is dealt with in Section 460(g) Code of Criminal Procedure. The relevant part of that Section reads as follows:
460. Irregularities which do not vitiate proceedings.
If any Magistrate not empowered by law to do any of the following things, namely:
(g) to tender a pardon Under Section 306;
erroneously in good faith does that thing, his proceedings shall not be set aside merely on the ground of his not being so empowered.
Section 461 Code of Criminal Procedure speaks of irregularities which vitiate proceedings.
16. We have already held, both the Magistrate as well as the Special Judge has concurrent jurisdiction in granting pardon Under Section 306 Code of Criminal Procedure while the investigation is going on. But, in a case, where the Magistrate has exercised his jurisdiction Under Section 306 Code of Criminal Procedure even after the appointment of a Special Judge under the PC Act and has passed an order granting pardon, the same is only a curable irregularity, which will not vitiate the proceedings, provided the order is passed in good faith. In fact, in the instant case, the Special Judge himself has referred the application to Chief Metropolitan Magistrate/Metropolitan Magistrate to deal with the same since the case was under investigation. In such circumstances, we find no error in Special Judge directing the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate or the Metropolitan Magistrate to pass appropriate orders on the application of CBI in granting pardon to second Respondent so as to facilitate the investigation.
REPORTABLE
Supreme Court of India
P.C.Mishra vs State(C.B.I) & Anr. on 27 March, 2014
Author: K Radhakrishnan


Print Page

Sunday, 5 January 2014

Whether extent of culpability of accomplice in an offence is material for Granting him pardon?


The first question that we have to decide is whether the High Court is right in coming to the conclusion that for being an approver within the meaning of Section 306, Cr.P.C., a person has to inculpate himself in the offence and has to be privy to the crime, otherwise he removes himself from the category of an accomplice and places himself as an eyewitness. Section 306, Cr.P.C. provides that with a view to obtaining the evidence of any person supposed to have been directly or indirectly concerned in or privy to an offence, the Magistrate may tender a pardon to such person on condition of his making a full and true disclosure of the whole circumstances within his knowledge relative to the offence and to every other person concerned, whether as principal or abettor, in the commission thereof. This Court in the case of Suresh Chandra Bahri v. State of Bihar [1995 Supp.(1) SCC 80] explained the object of Section 306 Cr.P.C. in the following words:
“The object of Section 306 therefore is to allow pardon in cases where heinous offence is alleged to have been committed by several persons so that with the aid of the evidence of the person granted pardon the offence may be brought home to the rest. The basis of the tender of pardon is not the extent of the culpability of the person to whom pardon is granted, but the principle is to prevent the escape of the offenders from punishment in heinous offences for lack of evidence. There can therefore be no objection against tender of pardon to an accomplice simply because in his confession, he does not implicate himself to the same extent as the other accused because all that Section 306 requires is that pardon may be tendered to any person believed to be involved directly or indirectly in or privy to an offence.”
Thus, the High Court failed to appreciate that the extent of culpability of the accomplice in an offence is not material so long as the magistrate tendering pardon believes that the accomplice was involved directly or indirectly in or was privy to the offence. 
Reportable
Supreme Court of India

State Of Rajasthan vs Balveer @ Balli & Anr. on 31 October, 2013
Author: A K Patnaik

Citation;2013(4) crimes 464 SC
Print Page

Sunday, 11 March 2012

Whether special Judge has power to grant pardon to accomplice under prevention of Corruption Act?

Special Judge has power to grant pardon to accomplice under prevention of corruption act at any stage of proceeding. As per sec. 306 of CRPC CJM, MM Or JMPC inquiring into or trying the offence at any stage of inquiry or trial may tender pardon to accomplice.
Supreme Court of India
Bangaru Laxman vs State Tr.C.B.I & Anr. on 22 November, 2011

Print Page