Showing posts with label additional issues. Show all posts
Showing posts with label additional issues. Show all posts

Wednesday, 21 December 2022

Whether the court can frame issues placing burden of proof on Municipal Corporation to prove that it has levied property taxes by following due procedure of law?

  The application filed by the petitioner/ plaintiff to

frame the additional issue, so as to cast burden upon the

defendant to prove that the defendant levied the taxes by

following due procedure of law came to be rejected. It is the

contention of the plaintiff that the defendant has not adhered to

the procedure. In para 7 of the plaint, the plaintiff has averred

that the defendant has not followed the procedure laid down in

Chapter VIII of Schedule of the Bombay Provincial Municipal

Corporations Act. It is for the plaintiff to aver and prove as to

how the procedure has not been followed. Vide the issue sought

to be framed, the plaintiff wants to cast burden upon the

defendant. It is for the plaintiff first to aver and then to lead

evidence to the effect that the defendant has not followed the

procedure as laid down in Chapter VIII and thereafter the burden

would shift on the defendant to show that the procedure has

been followed. It is the plaintiff who is seeking the relief from

the Court and against the defendant.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

WRIT PETITION NO.1740 OF 2015

Marathwada Shikshan Prasarak Mandal Vs  The Municipal Corporation, Aurangabad


CORAM: S.V. GANGAPURWALA, J.

DATED: 23rd March, 2016.

Print Page

Wednesday, 15 April 2020

Whether the court must frame additional issues?

It would be evident from perusal of Order 14, Rule 5 of the CPC that amendment of issues is in the discretion of the trial court. While framing issues no right or obligation of a party is determined. It is only a procedural matter. It is for the trial court to determine the controversy between the parties. It is well settled principle in law that it is not necessary to frame all issues. The issues are framed on question of law and fact and in order to determine whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief claimed or the suit is liable to be dismissed. It would further be evident that if the court considers it necessary for determining the matter in controversy, it can raise an additional issue even at the stage of final arguments and allow parties to lead evidence on such issue.

9. However, in the present case, since the court is of the considered view that the issues intended to be added as additional issues are not necessary for determining the suit, the petitioner cannot compel the court for addition of those issues.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PATNA

Civil Miscellaneous Jurisdiction No. 429 of 2019

Decided On: 25.07.2019

Yatindra Narayan Choudhary Vs.  Ram Kumar Choudhary and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Ashwani Kumar Singh, J.

Citation: AIR 2020(NOC) 45 Patna
Print Page

Saturday, 28 September 2019

Whether court should frame additional issues if those issues are included in already framed issues?

Trial court has observed that present suit is a simple suit for injunction filed by the plaintiff against defendant/petitioner wherein relevant issues have already been framed, which are Issues No. 1 and 2. Additional issues, which are required to be framed as per submissions of defendant, have already been included in Issues No. 1 and 2. Trial court has further observed that no specific issue has been suggested by the defendant in the application under Order 14 Rule 5 CPC.
7. Reasons assigned by the trial court for rejecting the application of the petitioner under Order 14 Rule 5 CPC appears to be absolutely legal and justified and no interference in the same is called for.

RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
(Before Narendra Kumar Jain, J.)

Sheikhul Mashsaeikh Dewan Syed Zainul Abedin Ali Khan
v.
The Dargah Committee Ajmer & Another.

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 15676/2009
Decided on December 16, 2010
Citation: 2010 SCC OnLine Raj 4476
Print Page

Thursday, 27 December 2018

Whether court can frame issue at the time of final argument?

Mr. Das, learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the impugned order of the learned trial Judge is not only illegal, but it is vitiated on account of material irregularity in exercise of jurisdiction. After the evidence had been closed and the parties were proceeding with the argument, the learned trial Judge had no jurisdiction to direct an additional issue to be raised and further evidence to be taken.

Order 14, Rule 1 C. P. C. provides--

"(1) Issues arise when a material proposition of fact or law is affirmed by the one party and denied by the other.

(2) Material propositions are those propositions of law or fact which a plaintiff must allege in order to show a right to sue or a defendant must allege in order to constitute his defence.

(3) x x x

(4) x x x

(5) At the first hearing of the suit the court shall, after reading the plaint and the written statements, if any, and after such examination of the parties as may appear necessary, ascertain upon what material propositions of fact or of law the parties are at variance, and shall thereupon proceed to frame and record the issues on which the right decision of the case appears to depend.

(6) x x x "

Rule 5 provides:--

"The court may, at any time before passing a decree, amend the issues or frame additional issues on such terms as it thinks fit, and all such amendments or additional issues as may be necessary for determining the matters in controversy between the parties shall be so made or framed."
5. Thus it is clear that the duty to frame issues is put on the court and power inheres in the court to amend existing issues or frame additional issues on such terms as the court thinks fit. In exercise of this power, the court while the arguments had begun, framed an additional issue and thought it fit to allow parties to lead evidence on the additional issue as it was necessary for determining the matter in controversy. The jurisdiction exercised by the court is in terms of Rule 5 (1) of Order 14 of the Code.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA

Civil Revn. No. 377 of 1969

Decided On: 21.09.1970

Kishorelal Gupta Vs. Devilal Kalwar alias Gowalla

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Ranganath Misra, J.

Citation: AIR 1971 Orissa 191
Print Page

When court should amend issues to decide controversy between in the parties?

 I have considered the rival contentions. Law for amending issues, or framing of additional issues is well settled. During the course of the trial in the suit, the court is bound to take cognizance of the question going to the root of the subject matter in controversy between the parties. Perusal of the issues noted above, shows that no issue has been framed on the case set up by the plaintiff that R.L. Sharma (father of defendant Nos. 1 and 2) was licensee in the premises. In my considered view, the interest of justice would be met, if issue No. 3 is amended, so as to include the plea of the licensee, set up by the plaintiff. It is necessary for determining the matter in controversy between parties. Accordingly, issue No. 3 is amended as follows:

3. Whether Shri R.L. Sharma (father of defendant Nos. 1 and 2), was a licensee or tenant in the premises in dispute? (Onus on both the parties)

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

IA 6726-02 in S. 1256-82

Decided On: 05.09.2002

Yatendra Nath Gupta  Vs. Jagdish Chander Sharma and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Surinder Kumar Aggarwal, J.

Citation: AIR 2003 Delhi 267
Print Page

When it is mandatory for court to frame additional issue?

 Therefore, in the present case, when the defendant has taken an objection in the written statement that Surender Kumar had no authority to sign the plaint and verification and in the cross-examination the said Surender Kumar has admitted that on the date of signing the plaint and verifying the same, he had no special power of attorney, the trial Court should have framed an issue with regard to the maintainability of the suit, which has to be decided in the first instance. Even though the trial Court has failed to frame an issue in the first instance, on the basis of the evidence adduced by DW1 that he had no power of attorney at the time of signing the plaint and verification and subsequent to the filing of the suit, the power of attorney was executed in his favour, in accordance with Rule 5 of Order 14, before passing a final decree, the trial Court has got the power to frame issues. When the defendant took an objection that Surender Kumar has no power of attorney to sign the plaint and on the other hand, though he has got letter of authority and that he is entitled to sign the plaint and verification, the trial Court should have framed an issue where one proposition of fact is affirmed by one party and denied by the other. Therefore, keeping this in mind, the trial Court should have exercised the power contemplated under Rule 5 by framing an issue with regard to authority of Surender Kumar to sign the plaint, inasmuch as this issue goes to the root of the matter. Without framing issue with regard to the maintainability of the suit and the authority of the deponent to sign the plaint and verification, trial Court should have not given a finding that deponent has got letter of authority to sign the plaint.

20. Viewed from any angle, the trial Court has committed an error in not framing an issue with regard to the maintainability of the suit under Order 14, Rules 1 and 5 CPC and also giving a finding without there being any issue to that effect. Therefore, the trial Court has committed an error of law in delivering the judgment.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT HYDERABAD

CCCA No. 153 of 1987

Decided On: 30.10.2000

Unitech Industrial Corporation  Vs.  Arvind Engineering Co., Hyd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
E. Dharma Rao, J.

Citation:AIR 2001 AP 177
Print Page