Showing posts with label alternative pleas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label alternative pleas. Show all posts

Wednesday, 2 August 2023

Whether the plaintiff can make two or more inconsistent sets of allegations and claim relief thereunder in the alternative?

 A plaintiff may rely upon different rights alternatively and there is nothing in the Civil Procedure Code to prevent a party from making two or more inconsistent sets of allegations and claiming relief thereunder in the alternative. Ordinarily, the Court cannot grant relief to the plaintiff on a case for which there was no foundation in the pleadings which the other side was not called upon or had an opportunity to meet. But when the alternative case, which the plaintiff could have made, was not only admitted by the defendant, in his written statement, but was expressly put forward as an answer to the claim which the plaintiff made in the suit, there would be nothing improper in giving the plaintiff a decree upon the case which the defendant himself makes, A demand of the plaintiff based on the defendant's own plea cannot possibly be regarded with surprise by the latter and no question of adducing evidence on these facts would arise when they were expressly admitted by the defendant in his pleadings. In such circumstances, when no injustice can possibly result to the defendant it may not be proper to drive the plaintiff to file a separate suit.


Thus, where in a suit for specific performance of a contract, in part performance of which the plaintiff alleges to have paid the deft/ some money, the defendant denies the contract and pleads that the money was taken by him, as a loan, the Court can pass a decree for recovery of the loan in favour of the plaintiff on his failure to prove the contract even though the plaintiff had failed to plead, and claim relief on, this alternative case.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

W.P. No. 1594 of 2006

Decided On: 29.03.2006

GTL Ltd.  Vs. Maharashtra Rajya Rashtriya Kamgar Sangh and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V.C. Daga, J.

Citation:  MANU/MH/0254/2006,2006(3) MHLJ 646, 2006(4) ALLMR 690.

Read full Judgment here: Click here

Print Page

Saturday, 4 April 2020

Whether a person can take an alternative plea of adverse possession and tenancy?

Once a person takes the stand that he/she has become the owner of a property on the ground of adverse possession, then he/she could not subsequently take the alternative plea that a suit for eviction was not maintainable and that the provisions of the  Rent Control Act, would apply. The Court held that a plea of adverse possession would be destructive of the rights under the Rent Act.

 Now though the appellant in his communications of June 2008 to the Monitoring Committee has alleged himself to be a tenant of this were premises but in para 15 and 22 of his written statement has denied such relationship and alleged himself to be an owner by adverse possession. Thus once the appellant claims to be in adverse possession of the premises, he cannot alleged himself to be a tenant as both these pleas cannot exist together. The principle once a tenant always a tenant ends on taking plea of adverse possession and asserting one's own right.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

RFA 633/2014

Decided On: 09.01.2020

 Hans Raj Vs.  Raghuvir Singh and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Yogesh Khanna, J.

Print Page

Sunday, 17 November 2019

Whether tenant can take alternative plea that additions and alteration are not of permanent nature and if it is so,it is for beneficial use?

 It was next urged by Shri Vashi that after the issue was remitted back to the Appellate Court by this Court by its judgment dated 28.9.1990, the tenant has submitted an application for permission to amend his written statement, taking a pleas that as the alterations and additions that were made, were for the better enjoyment of the suit premises, the landlord is not entitled to a decree for possession under Section 13(1)(b) of the Act. The application for amendment in the writing statement sought by the tenant was rejected by the Appellate Court. However, this Court allowed the amendment on the condition that no additional evidence would be led. Shri Vashi. urged that though this Court allowed the tenant to amend their written statement, it is clear from the observations in paragraph 19 of the order of the Appellate Court dated 1st November, 1993 that this plea was not considered by the Appellate Court on the ground that the plea taken by the tenant was an inconsistent plea. In the submission of Shri Vashi the plea taken by the tenant was not an inconsistent plea, but was an alternate plea whereby the tenant urged that if the Court holds that the additions and alterations carried out by the tenant in the suit premises are of permanent nature then they were necessary for better enjoyment of the properly. He further urged that basically it was the contention of the tenant that the additions and alterations carried out in the suit premises were not of permanent nature. In my opinion, these two submission of Shri Vashi that additions and alterations made in the suit premises by the tenant were not of permanent nature and that even if they were assumed to be so they were necessary for beneficial enjoyment of the property, can be conveniently considered together with reference to each of the additions and alterations made in the premises. Before proceeding to do so, I may observe here that the Appellate Court, was not right in refusing to consider the plea of the tenant that additions and alterations were for the beneficial enjoyment of the property. 
Bombay High Court
Ramrao Balaji Kothare And Ors. vs Lila, Widow Of Dr. Yeshwant ... on 28 January, 1997
Equivalent citations: (1997) 99 BOMLR 400

Bench: D Deshmukh
Print Page

Saturday, 17 August 2019

Tests laid down by Supreme Court for determining whether alternative plea raised by plaintiff was permissible

 Reference may also be made to the decision of this
Court in J.J. Lal Pvt. Ltd. and Ors. v. M.R. Murali and
Anr. (2002) 3 SCC 98 where this Court formulated the
following tests for determining whether the alternative plea
raised by the plaintiff was permissible:
“To sum up the gist of holding in Firm Sriniwas
Ram Kumar's case: If the facts stated and
pleading raised in the written statement, though by
way of defence to the case of the plaintiff, are
such which could have entitled the plaintiff to a
relief in the alternative, the plaintiff may rely on
such pleading of the defendant and claim an

alternate decree based thereon subject to four
conditions being satisfied, viz., (i) the statement of
case by defendant in his written statement amounts
to an express admission of the facts entitling the
plaintiff to an alternative relief, (ii) in granting such
relief the defendant is not taken by surprise, (iii) no
injustice can possibly result to the defendant, and
(iv) though the plaintiff would have been entitled to
the same relief in a separate suit the interest of
justice demand the plaintiff not being driven to the
need of filing another suit.”
18. The plaintiff-appellant in the case at hand had set up a
specific case that the defendant as also his legal
representative after his demise were occupying the suit
premises as licensees which licence had been validly
terminated. In the reply to the notice the case of the
defendants was that were in occupation of the suit premises
not as licensees but as tenants. The plaintiff was, therefore,
entitled on that basis alone to ask for an alternative relief of
a decree for eviction on the grounds permissible under the
Rent Control Act. Such an alternative plea did not fall foul if
any of the requirements/tests set out in the decision of this
Court in J.J. Lal’s case (supra). We say so because the
written statement filed by the defendant contained an
express admission of the fact that the property belonged to
the plaintiff and that the defendants were in occupation

thereof as tenants. At the trial Court also the question
whether the defendants were in occupation as licencee or as
tenants had been specifically put in issue thereby giving the
fullest opportunity to the parties to prove their respective
cases. There was no question of the defendants being taken
by surprise by the alternative case pleaded by the plaintiff
nor could any injustice result from the alternative plea being
allowed and tried by the Court. As a matter of fact the trial
Court had without any demurrer gone into the merits of the
alternative plea and dismissed the suit on the ground that
the plaintiff had not been able to prove a case for eviction of
the defendants. There was thus not only a proper trial on all
those grounds urged by the plaintiff but also a judgment in
favour of the defendant respondents. Last but not the least
even if the alternative plea had not been allowed to be raised
in the suit filed by the appellant he would have been certainly
entitled to raise that plea and seek eviction in a separate suit
filed on the very same grounds. The only difference may
have been that the suit may have then been filed before the
Court of Small Causes but no error of jurisdiction was
committed in the instant case as the finding recorded by the

Civil Court was that the defendants were licensees and not
tenants. Superadded to all these factors is the fact that the
appellate Court had granted relief to the appellant not in
relation to the alternative plea raised by him but on the
principal case set up by the plaintiff. If the plaintiff
succeeded on the principal case set up by him whether or not
the alternative plea was contradictory or inconsistent or even
destructive of the original plea paled into insignificance.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 50 OF 2014

Praful Manohar Rele Vs Smt. Krishnabai Narayan Ghosalkar 

T.S. THAKUR, J.
Dated:January 3, 2014
Print Page

Saturday, 10 March 2018

Whether plaintiff can raise alternate pleas in eviction suit?

To my mind, the plea raised by the defendant is a meaningless plea for more than one reasons. Firstly, it is futile contention now to contend that the suit will have to be filed in two different courts. A licensee is equally entitled to protection under the Rent Act as a tenant. The fact that the defendant would be a licensee governed by the amended definition of the word "tenant" and especially a "deemed tenant" or a 'protected licensee" within the meaning of the Rent Act has not been disputed and cannot be disputed. If this is the position, then a suit against such deemed tenant or protected licensee has got to be filed in the same Court in which the suit against tenant can be filed. As a matter of fact the alternative contention based on the plea of license raised by the plaintiff's is of no consequence whatsoever; because even assuming that the defendant was inducted on the premises only as a licensee, still the protection that he gets from the Court is the same. The Court in which suit against a protected licensee can be filed is the same Court in which the suit against a tenant can be filed. The learned Judge who will be hearing the suit will be the same one, irrespective of the question whether the suit is filed against a licensee or against a tenant. The plea that there is some jurisdictional defect as regards the entertainment of the suit is, therefore, meaningless on the face of it. The revision application is, therefore, liable to be dismissed on this short ground itself.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Civil Revision Application No. 755 of 1982

Decided On: 21.03.1984

 Kamruddin Shabuddin Tamboli Vs.  Allauddin Fattemohamed Malik and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.G. Manohar, J.

Citation: 1984 MHLJ750,1985(1) BOMCR,1985 BomRC108
Print Page

Sunday, 24 September 2017

What is distinction between contradictory pleas and alternative pleas?

Significantly, the decision rendered by the High Court
rests entirely on the fourth question extracted above. The
High Court has taken the view that while the plaintiff could
indeed seek relief in the alternative, the contentions raised
by him were not in the alternative but contradictory, hence,
could not be allowed to be urged. The High Court found that
the plaintiff’s case that the defendant was a gratuitous
licensee was incompatible with the plea that he was a tenant
and, therefore, could be evicted under the Rent Act. The
High Court observed:
“It is now well settled that a plaintiff may seek
reliefs in the alternative but in fact the pleadings are
mutually opposite, such pleas cannot be raised by

the plaintiff. There is an essential difference
between contradictory pleas and alternative pleas.
When the plaintiff claims relief in the alternative,
the cause of action for the reliefs claimed is the
same. However, when contradictory pleas are
raised, such as in the present case, the foundation
for these contradictory pleas is not the same. When
the plaintiff proceeds on the footing that the
defendant is a gratuitous licensee, he would have to
establish that no rent or consideration was paid for
the premises. Whereas, if he seeks to evict the
defendant under the Rent Act, the plaintiff accepts
that the defendant is in possession of the premises
as a tenant and liable to pay rent. Thus, the issue
whether rent is being paid becomes fundamental to
the decision. Therefore, in my opinion, the pleas
that the defendant is occupying the suit premises
gratuitously is not compatible with the plea that the
defendant is a tenant and therefore can be evicted
under the Rent Act.”
 REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 50 OF 2014

Praful Manohar Rele V Smt. Krishnabai Narayan
Ghosalkar & Ors.
Dated:January 3, 2014.

Print Page