Showing posts with label bank locker. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bank locker. Show all posts

Tuesday, 22 June 2021

Can the court refuse to issue a letter of administration regarding demonetized currency notes laying in the bank locker?

  Merely because the Government has issued a

demonetization policy, it does not mean that the claim as to

the requisite currency notes is extinguished. If we go by the

report of Assistant Superintendent, we may find that apart

from banned currency notes of Rs.500/- and Rs. 1000/- notes

of Rs. 50/- and Rs. 100/- denomination were also found in

the locker. Trial Court has wrongly rejected the claim in toto.

Even in respect of banned currency notes, the appellants can

approach the concerned authorities and may do the needful.

It is very well true that as the claim is pending for

adjudication before the trial Court, it was not possible for the

appellants to approach the competent authority under the

Specified Bank Notes (Cessation of Liabilities) Act, 2017. This

Court hope that when approached, the competent authority

will consider the claim of the appellants in respect of banned

currency notes. {Para 20}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR

FIRST APPEAL NO. 1602 OF 2019

Sushilkumar  Motilal Sharma Vs Umeshkumar s/o Motilal Sharma,

CORAM : S.M. MODAK, J .

PRONOUNCED ON : 11.06.2021

Print Page

Sunday, 21 February 2021

Supreme Court directions to the bank for the avoidance of mismanagement of bank locker of customer


 It appears to us that the present state of regulations on the

subject of locker management is inadequate and muddled. Each

bank is following its own set of procedures and there is no

uniformity in the rules. Further, going by their stand before the

consumer fora, it seems that the banks are under the mistaken

impression that not having knowledge of the contents of the

locker exempts them from liability for failing to secure the lockers

in themselves as well. In as much as we are the highest Court of

the country, we cannot allow the litigation between the bank and

locker holders to continue in this vein. This will lead to a state of

anarchy wherein the banks will routinely commit lapses in proper

management of the lockers, leaving it to the hapless customers to

bear the costs. Hence, we find it imperative that this Court lays

down certain principles which will ensure that the banks follow

due diligence in operating their locker facilities, until the

issuance of comprehensive guidelines in this regard.

12. Thus, we emphasize that irrespective of the value of the

articles placed inside the locker, the bank is under a separate

obligation to ensure that proper procedures are followed while

allotting and operating the lockers:

(a) This includes maintenance of a locker register and

locker key register.

(b) The locker register shall be consistently updated in

case of any change in allotment.

(c) The bank shall notify the original locker holder

prior to any changes in the allotment of the locker,

and give them reasonable opportunity to withdraw the

articles deposited by them if they so wish.

(d) Banks may consider utilizing appropriate

technologies, such as blockchain technology which is

meant for creating digital ledger for this purpose.

(e) The custodian of the bank shall additionally

maintain a record of access to the lockers, containing

details of all the parties who have accessed the lockers

and the date and time on which they were opened and

closed.

(f) The bank employees are also obligated to check

whether the lockers are properly closed on a regular

basis. If the same is not done, the locker must be


immediately closed and the locker holder shall be

promptly intimated so that they may verify any

resulting discrepancy in the contents of the locker.

(g) The concerned staff shall also check that the keys

to the locker are in proper condition.

(h) In case the lockers are being operated through an

electronic system, the bank shall take reasonable

steps to ensure that the system is protected against

hacking or any breach of security.

(i) The customers’ personal data, including their

biometric data, cannot be shared with third parties

without their consent. The relevant rules under the

Information Technology Act, 2000 will be applicable in

this regard.

(j) The bank has the power to break open the locker

only in accordance with the relevant laws and RBI

regulations, if any. Breaking open of the locker in a

manner other than that prescribed under law is an

illegal act which amounts to gross deficiency of service

on the part of the bank as a service provider.

(k) Due notice in writing shall be given to the locker

holder at a reasonable time prior to the breaking open

of the locker. Moreover, the locker shall be broken

open only in the presence of authorized officials and

an independent witness after giving due notice to the

locker holder. The bank must prepare a detailed

inventory of any articles found inside the locker, after

the locker is opened, and make a separate entry in the

locker register, before returning them to the locker

holder. The locker holder’s signature should be

obtained upon the receipt of such inventory so as to

avoid any dispute in the future.

(l) The bank must undertake proper verification

procedures to ensure that no unauthorized party gains

access to the locker. In case the locker remains

inoperative for a long period of time, and the locker

holder cannot be located, the banks shall transfer the

contents of the locker to their nominees/legal heirs or

dispose of the articles in a transparent manner, in

accordance with the directions issued by the RBI in

this regard.


(m) The banks shall also take necessary steps to

ensure that the space in which the locker facility is

located is adequately guarded at all times.

(n) A copy of the locker hiring agreement, containing

the relevant terms and conditions, shall be given to the

customer at the time of allotment of the locker so that

they are intimated of their rights and responsibilities.

(o) The bank cannot contract out of the minimum

standard of care with respect to maintaining the safety

of the lockers as outlined supra.

 REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3966 OF 2010

Amitabha Dasgupta  Vs United Bank of India


Author: MOHAN M. SHANTANAGOUDAR, J.

Dated: FEBRUARY 19, 2021

Print Page

Sunday, 26 February 2017

Whether court should grant succession certificate for operating bank locker after death of holder of locker?

Generally, banks are insisting on obtaining a succession certificate by the legal heirs in the case of lockers on the death of the holder of the locker. But succession certificate cannot be granted as the locker held by the deceased cannot be treated as a debt. The bank also is not expected to put the legal heirs in a difficult situation to spend more money in obtaining the succession certificate or some other certificate to safeguard their liability. Therefore, it is always desirable that the bank should adopt a procedure in obtaining a nomination at the time of opening of a locker by any person. In case of death of the person holding the locker, the bank may allow the nominee to operate the locker provided an inventory of the articles kept in the bank's safe custody and also obtain a guarantee from the said nominee to produce the articles in the event of any claim by any other person. If this simple procedure is implemented, it will save the parties from spending huge amounts by approaching the courts as courts have consistently held that no sucession certificate can be granted under section 370 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, to operate a locker as the locker cannot be treated as a debt.
Andhra High Court
Venugopal Loya And Ors. vs Vijayalakshmi Bung And Anr. on 16 March, 1990
Equivalent citations: 1991 71 CompCas 393 AP,.1991 (I)vol.15.All India Banking Law 

Bench: G R Rao
Print Page