Showing posts with label banking law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label banking law. Show all posts

Saturday, 25 October 2025

Revolutionary Changes in Bank Nomination Rules: What November 1, 2025 Brings for Indian Depositors


 The Indian banking sector is witnessing a transformative shift in depositor rights and nomination facilities with the enforcement of key provisions of the Banking Laws (Amendment) Act, 2025 from November 1, 2025. Through a notification issued by the Ministry of Finance on October 23, 2025, the Central Government has brought into force four critical sections—Sections 10, 11, 12, and 13—that fundamentally reshape how depositors can nominate beneficiaries for their bank accounts, lockers, and safe custody articles.

Read Said notification here: Click here.

Print Page

Sunday, 26 December 2021

Is the relationship between the customer and Bank a creditor and a debtor?

 The money that a customer deposits in a bank is not held by the latter on trust for him. It becomes a part of the banker’s funds who is under a contractual obligation to pay the sum deposited by a customer to him on demand with the agreed rate of interest. Such a relationship between the customer and the Bank is one of a creditor and a debtor. The Bank is liable to pay money back to the customers when called upon, but until it’s called upon to pay it, the Bank is entitled to utilize the money in any manner for earning profit.

Supreme Court

CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA N.V. RAMANA JUSTICE SURYA KANT JUSTICE HIMA KOHLI

N. Raghavender Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh, CBI

Print Page

Thursday, 13 May 2021

Can a court permit a close relative of an incapacitated individual to withdraw money from the latter’s bank account to cover his necessary medical expenses?

  For ready reference, the guidelines as laid down in Vandana Tyagi, read as follows:

“76. Guidelines (i) A person(s) who seek(s) to be appointed as guardians vis-à-vis an individual, who is lying in comatose state, shall in their petition to the court disclose the details of all tangible and intangible assets of such an individual. The details as to their location and approximate market value shall also be disclosed. In case of bank accounts, stocks, shares, and debentures and other investments are concerned, material particulars will be provided. (ii) The court will have the person lying in comatose examined by a duly constituted medical board which would include, inter alia, a neurologist. (iii) The court will also direct the concerned SDM/Tehsildar in whose jurisdiction the person lying in comatose is said to be located to carry out an enquiry to establish the veracity of the assertion and to gather material particulars concerning the person(s) who approach the court for being appointed as guardians. The enquiry will, inter alia, gather information as regards the relationship that the person(s) who wish to be appointed as guardians has/have with the person lying in comatose state. Information with regard to the financial condition of persons wanting to be appointed as guardians shall also be collected apart from other aspects which may have a material bearing in their discharging the duties of a guardian. Any conflict of interest concerning the affairs of the person lying in comatose state will be brought to fore in the report generated during the course of the enquiry.

(iv) Ordinarily only that person will be appointed as guardian who is a spouse or a progeny of the person lying in comatose. The person seeking appointment as a guardian in his petition to the court will, however,disclose the particulars of all legal heirs of the person lying in comatose. In the event, the person lying in comatose has neither a spouse nor any children or even any legal heirs or if he/she has such persons in his life but stands abandoned by them subject to the permission of the court his next friend who wishes to be appointed as a guardian can approach the court with such a request. In the alternative, the Court could direct the Department of Social Welfare, GNCTD to appoint a public official such as a Social Welfare Officer or a person holding equivalent rank to act as the guardian of the person lying in comatose state. (v) Only that person shall be appointed as a guardian who is otherwise in law competent to act as a guardian. (vi) The order directing appointment of a guardian shall specify the assets qua which the guardianship order is passed. The court will be empowered to modify the order and bring within its sweep other assets, if required, in the interest of the person lying in comatose state. In case liquid funds are not available and there is a requirement to sell the assets of the person lying in comatose state, upon the guardian approaching the court, necessary directions could be passed in that behalf. (vii) The person appointed as a guardian will file every six (6) months (or within such period as the court may indicate in its order) a report with the Registrar General of this court. The report shall advert to the transactions undertaken by the guardian in respect of the assets of the person lying in comatose state. Besides this, the report shall also indicate the funds, if any, received by the guardian and their utilization for the purposes of maintaining the person lying in comatose state.

(viii) The Registrar General of this court will cause a separate register to be maintained which will set out inter alia the details of the proceedings, the particulars of the person appointed as a guardian and orders, if any,passed after the appointment of the guardian. Measures will also be taken by the Registrar General to preserve the reports filed by the guardian from time to time. (ix) It will be open to the court to appoint a guardian either temporarily or for a limited period, as may be deemed fit. (x) In the event, the guardian appointed by the court misuses his/her power or misappropriates, siphons or misutilizes the assets of the person lying in comatose state or fails to utilize the assets in the best interest of the person lying in comatose state, the court would have the power to remove the guardian and appoint another person in his/her place. The substituted person could also be a public officer such as a Social Welfare Officer or an officer holding an equivalent rank. (xi) The guardian appointed by the court shall intimate his appointment to the public official/Social Welfare Officer or officer of an equivalent rank designated by GNCTD. Both the guardian as well as the Registrar General of this court will cause a copy of the order of guardianship being served upon such officer. Such officer shall visit the person lying in comatose at least once in every quarter. The Social Welfare Officer will generate a report of his visit. In case the Social Welfare Officer finds that the guardian appointed by the court is not acting in the best interest of the person lying in comatose state, he will move the court, at the earliest, for seeking appropriate directions. (xii) The guardian appointed by the court will ensure that the transactions entered into by him or her comport with the relevant provisions of the law.

(xiii) In case a relative or a next friend of the person lying in comatose state finds that the guardian is not acting in the best interest of the person lying in comatose state, such person will also have the locus to approach the court for issuance of appropriate directions and/or for removal of the guardian. (xiv) In case, the guardian wishes to move the person lying in comatose state to another state or even to another country for the purposes of securing better medical treatment for the person lying in comatose state, he/she would approach the court for necessary permission before undertaking such an exercise.”

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

 Date of Decision: 08th April, 2021 

W.P.(C) 354/2021 & CM APPL. 915/2021

 BHIM SINGH Vs AGM STATE BANK OF INDIA & ANR

CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRATEEK JALAN 

Print Page

Sunday, 21 February 2021

Supreme Court directions to the bank for the avoidance of mismanagement of bank locker of customer


 It appears to us that the present state of regulations on the

subject of locker management is inadequate and muddled. Each

bank is following its own set of procedures and there is no

uniformity in the rules. Further, going by their stand before the

consumer fora, it seems that the banks are under the mistaken

impression that not having knowledge of the contents of the

locker exempts them from liability for failing to secure the lockers

in themselves as well. In as much as we are the highest Court of

the country, we cannot allow the litigation between the bank and

locker holders to continue in this vein. This will lead to a state of

anarchy wherein the banks will routinely commit lapses in proper

management of the lockers, leaving it to the hapless customers to

bear the costs. Hence, we find it imperative that this Court lays

down certain principles which will ensure that the banks follow

due diligence in operating their locker facilities, until the

issuance of comprehensive guidelines in this regard.

12. Thus, we emphasize that irrespective of the value of the

articles placed inside the locker, the bank is under a separate

obligation to ensure that proper procedures are followed while

allotting and operating the lockers:

(a) This includes maintenance of a locker register and

locker key register.

(b) The locker register shall be consistently updated in

case of any change in allotment.

(c) The bank shall notify the original locker holder

prior to any changes in the allotment of the locker,

and give them reasonable opportunity to withdraw the

articles deposited by them if they so wish.

(d) Banks may consider utilizing appropriate

technologies, such as blockchain technology which is

meant for creating digital ledger for this purpose.

(e) The custodian of the bank shall additionally

maintain a record of access to the lockers, containing

details of all the parties who have accessed the lockers

and the date and time on which they were opened and

closed.

(f) The bank employees are also obligated to check

whether the lockers are properly closed on a regular

basis. If the same is not done, the locker must be


immediately closed and the locker holder shall be

promptly intimated so that they may verify any

resulting discrepancy in the contents of the locker.

(g) The concerned staff shall also check that the keys

to the locker are in proper condition.

(h) In case the lockers are being operated through an

electronic system, the bank shall take reasonable

steps to ensure that the system is protected against

hacking or any breach of security.

(i) The customers’ personal data, including their

biometric data, cannot be shared with third parties

without their consent. The relevant rules under the

Information Technology Act, 2000 will be applicable in

this regard.

(j) The bank has the power to break open the locker

only in accordance with the relevant laws and RBI

regulations, if any. Breaking open of the locker in a

manner other than that prescribed under law is an

illegal act which amounts to gross deficiency of service

on the part of the bank as a service provider.

(k) Due notice in writing shall be given to the locker

holder at a reasonable time prior to the breaking open

of the locker. Moreover, the locker shall be broken

open only in the presence of authorized officials and

an independent witness after giving due notice to the

locker holder. The bank must prepare a detailed

inventory of any articles found inside the locker, after

the locker is opened, and make a separate entry in the

locker register, before returning them to the locker

holder. The locker holder’s signature should be

obtained upon the receipt of such inventory so as to

avoid any dispute in the future.

(l) The bank must undertake proper verification

procedures to ensure that no unauthorized party gains

access to the locker. In case the locker remains

inoperative for a long period of time, and the locker

holder cannot be located, the banks shall transfer the

contents of the locker to their nominees/legal heirs or

dispose of the articles in a transparent manner, in

accordance with the directions issued by the RBI in

this regard.


(m) The banks shall also take necessary steps to

ensure that the space in which the locker facility is

located is adequately guarded at all times.

(n) A copy of the locker hiring agreement, containing

the relevant terms and conditions, shall be given to the

customer at the time of allotment of the locker so that

they are intimated of their rights and responsibilities.

(o) The bank cannot contract out of the minimum

standard of care with respect to maintaining the safety

of the lockers as outlined supra.

 REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3966 OF 2010

Amitabha Dasgupta  Vs United Bank of India


Author: MOHAN M. SHANTANAGOUDAR, J.

Dated: FEBRUARY 19, 2021

Print Page

Friday, 2 October 2020

Basic concept of cross-liability or cross-collateralisation in Commercial contract


The very concept of cross-liability or cross-collateralisation, as applicable to commercial contracts, predicates reciprocity of security and commonality of the parties to the contract. This is, even etymologically, apparent, as "cross-collateralisation" necessarily requires the same collateral being available, as security against more than one loan. "Cross-collateralisation", as a concept known to commercial contracts, necessarily predicates the usage of the collateral, available as security against one loan, as collateral against a second loan. If, however, the two loans are governed by independent loan agreements, the inclusion of a cross collateralisation clause, in one of them, cannot, proprio vigore, justify proceeding against the collateral, provided in the said loan agreement, for satisfaction of the loan in the other agreements, unless the said security is also collateral under such other agreements. It is open, to contractual parties, to provide for such a dispensation in the loan agreements. Absent such dispensation, however, the mere existence of a cross collateralisation, or cross liability, clause in one of the agreements, would be insufficient.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

O.M.P. (I) (COMM.) 142/2020, I.A. 4600/2020, I.A. 4942/2020 and I.A. 4943/2020

Decided On: 31.08.2020

Sunil Goel  Vs.   Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

C. Hari Shankar, J.

Citation: MANU/DE/1654/2020

Print Page

Monday, 21 October 2019

Important judgment on liability of bank in case of online fraud through SIM swapping and identity theft

 Thus, it is clear that the bank cannot claim any amount
from the customer when a transaction is shown to be a 'disputed
transaction'. The bank can recover from the customers only when it can
unequivocally prove that the customer was responsible for such

transaction, independently through the civil court. The RBI guidelines
is a clear mandate to exonerate a customer in such 'disputed
transaction'. RBI circular presumes the innocence of the customer in
such given circumstances. However, this innocence can be
controverted. The onus falls on the bank to prove otherwise.
21. In the present case, the police investigation prima facie
established that fraud has been committed. The beneficiaries hail from
West Bengal. There is nothing on record to establish any connivance
on the part of the petitioners. The police investigation also would
reveal that the accused obtained duplicate SIM cards by using fake
identity cards. It was also brought out that the beneficiaries
immediately withdrew the money from their bank accounts at West
Bengal. In such circumstances, the transactions can be treated as
'disputed transactions'. These transactions would fall within the sweep
of zero liability as referred to in RBI Circular. The remedy of the bank
in such circumstances is to approach the civil court and recover the
amount from the persons who were responsible for such transactions.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
 MR. JUSTICE A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE

WP(C).No.28823 OF 2017(C)

 TONY ENTERPRISES  Vs RESERVE BANK OF INDIA


Dated this the 11th day of October, 2019
Print Page

Sunday, 17 March 2019

Whether bank will be liable if money is unauthorizedly withdrawn from bank account of customer?


 Question (ii): Various services are being provided by banks to their customers. In fact, banks are soliciting business by advertising the various services provided by them to their customers in connection with different accounts. SMS alerts is one of the facility extended by most of the banks to their customers in connection with the savings bank accounts having electronic banking facilities including ATM-cum-Debit Card facilities. Such facilities are provided not only to those who specifically request for the same, but also to those who do not ask for such facilities. Could such a facility voluntarily given by banks to their customers determine the rights of parties, is the question. According to me, only if there exists a specific term in the contract between a bank and its customer to the effect that the bank would be exonerated from the liability in connection with the unauthorised transactions if the customer does not respond to the SMS alerts, SMS alerts cannot be the basis for determining the liability of the customer, for, there would be account holders who may not be in the habit of checking SMS alerts at regular intervals and account holders like the plaintiff in the instant case who is working in an offshore oil rig, who may not be able to access their mobile phones for several days having regard to the peculiarity of their avocation. The defendant has no case that there is a contract between them and the plaintiff to the effect that if the plaintiff does not respond to the SMS alerts given by them regarding the withdrawals from his accounts, they would not be liable for the loss, if any, caused to the plaintiff. In the circumstances, question (ii) is also answered against the appellant.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

R.S.A. No. 1087 of 2018

Decided On: 09.01.2019

State Bank of India  Vs.  P.V. George

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
P.B. Suresh Kumar, J.

Print Page

Monday, 4 February 2019

Whether bank can avoid its liability for unauthorised withdrawal if Customer does not respond to SMS alert?

 It is clarified in the said circular that
the customer shall have no liability at all in the case of third-party breach
where the deficiency lies neither with the bank nor with the customer but
lies elsewhere in the system. The only obligation which casts on the
customers of the bank in terms of the circular is that the unauthorised
transactions shall be brought to the notice of the bank forthwith so as to
enable the bank to block the account. The circular aforesaid only
reminds the banks, their obligations and responsibilities and it does not
create any new rights or obligations. In short, there is also no difficulty in
holding that if a customer suffers loss in connection with the transactions
made without his junction by fraudsters, it has to be presumed that it is
on account of the failure on the part of the bank to put in place a system
which prevents such withdrawals, and the banks are, therefore, liable for
the loss caused to their customers. All over the world, the courts are

adopting the aforesaid approach to protect the interests of the customers
of electronic banking. Reverting to the facts of the case on hand, though
it was contended by the defendant in the written statement filed in the
suit that the disputed withdrawals cannot be said to be withdrawals
without the junction of the plaintiff, in the light of the facts established by
evidence, such a contention was not pressed into service by the
defendant in the second appeal. Instead, as noted, the main contention
pressed into service by the defendant in the second appeal is that the
defendant is not liable for the unauthorised withdrawals made from the
account of the plaintiff by fraudsters abroad. As the second contention
was found against, the question is answered against the appellant.
11. Question (ii): Various services are being provided by
banks to their customers. In fact, banks are soliciting business by
advertising the various services provided by them to their customers in
connection with different accounts. SMS alerts is one of the facility
extended by most of the banks to their customers in connection with the
savings bank accounts having electronic banking facilities including ATMcum-
Debit Card facilities. Such facilities are provided not only to those
who specifically request for the same, but also to those who do not ask
for such facilities. Could such a facility voluntarily given by banks to their
customers determine the rights of parties, is the question. According to
me, only if there exists a specific term in the contract between a bank
and its customer to the effect that the bank would be exonerated from

the liability in connection with the unauthorised transactions if the
customer does not respond to the SMS alerts, SMS alerts cannot be the
basis for determining the liability of the customer, for, there would be
account holders who may not be in the habit of checking SMS alerts at
regular intervals and account holders like the plaintiff in the instant case
who is working in an offshore oil rig, who may not be able to access their
mobile phones for several days having regard to the peculiarity of their
avocation. The defendant has no case that there is a contract between
them and the plaintiff to the effect that if the plaintiff does not respond
to the SMS alerts given by them regarding the withdrawals from his
accounts, they would not be liable for the loss, if any, caused to the
plaintiff.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
MR. JUSTICE P.B.SURESH KUMAR
 09TH DAY OF JANUARY 2019.
RSA.No. 1087 of 2018

STATE BANK OF INDIA, Vs  P.V.GEORGE


Print Page

Saturday, 8 December 2018

When land should not be treated as agricultural land even if revenue record shows that it is agricultural land?

 In the present case, security interest was created in respect of several parcels of land, which were meant to be a part of single unit i.e. the five star hotel in Goa. Some parcels of land now claimed as agricultural land were apparently purchased by the debtor from agriculturists and are entered as agricultural lands in the revenue records. The debtor applied to the revenue authorities for the conversion of these lands to non-agricultural lands which is pending till date due to policy decision.

40. It is undisputed that these lands were mortgaged in favour of the creditor under a deed dated 26.02.2010. Obviously, since no security interest can be created in respect of agricultural lands and yet it was so created, goes to show that the parties did not treat the land as agricultural land and that the debtor offered the land as security on this basis. The undisputed position is that the total land on which the Goa Hotel was located admeasures 182225 sq. mtrs. Of these, 2335 sq. mtrs. are used for growing vegetables, fruits, shrubs and trees for captive consumption of the hotel. There is no substantial evidence about the growing of vegetables but what seems to be on the land are some trees bearing curry leaves and coconut. This amounts to about 12.8 % of the total area.

The mortgage is thus intended to cover the entire property of the Goa Hotel. Prima facie, apart from the fact that the parties themselves understood that the lands in question are not agricultural, it also appears that having regard to the use to which they are put and the purpose of such use, they are indeed not agricultural.

44. In 'Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Andhra Pradesh v. Officer-in-Charge (Court of Wards) Paigah MANU/SC/0232/1976 : (1976) 3 SCC 864, this Court interpreted the definition of the term 'Agricultural Land' with respect to Section 2(e) of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957 that excluded the said term from the definition of assets. This Court observed:

We agree that the determination of the character of land, according to the purpose for which it is meant or set apart and can be used, is a matter which ought to be determined on the facts of each particular case. What is really required to be shown is the connection with an agricultural purpose and user and not the mere possibility of user of land, by some possible future owner or possessor, for an agricultural purpose. It is not the mere potentiality, which will only affect its valuation as part of "assets", but its actual condition and intended user which has to be seen for purposes of exemption from wealth-tax. One of the objects of the exemption seemed to be to encourage cultivation or actual utilisation of land for agricultural purposes. If there is neither anything in its condition, nor anything in evidence to indicate the intention of its owners or possessors, so as to connect it with an agricultural purpose, the land could not be "agricultural land" for the purposes of earning an exemption under the Act. Entries in revenue records are, however, good prima facie evidence.

Similarly, in the case of Kunjukutty Saheb v. State of Kerala MANU/SC/0634/1972 : (1972) 2 SCC 364, this Court held as follows:

We suppose that something or other can be, and often is, grown on any vacant land, but that would not necessarily make it agricultural land for our purposes. To give an example the possibility of cultivating, or even the actual cultivation of, what is essentially a building site in the heart of a town would not make it agricultural land. It is the purpose for which it is held that determines its character and the existence of a few coconut trees or a vegetable patch on the land cannot alter the fact that it is held for purposes of building and not for purposes of agriculture.

In any event, having regard to the character of the land and the purpose for which it is set apart, we are of the view that the land in question is not an agricultural land. The High Court mis-directed itself in holding that the land was an agricultural land merely because it stood as such in the revenue entries, even though the application made for such conversation lies pending till date.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 2928-2930 of 2018 

Decided On: 19.03.2018

 ITC Limited Vs.  Blue Coast Hotels Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.A. Bobde and L. Nageswara Rao, JJ.

Citation: 2018(6) MHLJ 42
Print Page

Thursday, 18 October 2018

Whether bank is required to subject the cheque to minute and microscopic examination?

 In the present case, we do not find any circumstance or reason which could have caused any doubt in the mind of a prudent bank to initiate inquiries, rather the facts of the case demonstrate that the respondent-bank and the petitioners were in the same position. The mere fact that the collecting bank has made a payment to its customer who deposited the tampered cheque does not raise an estoppel against the paying bank if later on it is found that the cheque is forged. The respondent-bank was not called upon to be overtly suspicious. The standard of care expected from a banker in collecting the cheque did not require him to subject the cheque to a minute and microscopic examination. The collecting bank has its remedies against its clients for indemnification by asking them to return the money. In turn the clients, i.e., the petitioners have remedies against the drawer of the cheque or her customer to recover the amount from them as per law. 
 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI 
Date of Decision: 16th October, 2018 
 W.P. (C) No. 6778/2016 & C.M. No.27868/2016 

M/S ADYA GLOBAL EXPORT INC.  Vs CANARA BANK 

  CORAM:  MR. JUSTICE SANJIV KHANNA 
                 MR. JUSTICE CHANDER SHEKHAR 
Print Page

Saturday, 2 December 2017

Whether bank can fix liability upon guarantor on basis of account statement?

 In addressing the above rival submission at the cost of
repeatation for better appreciation, it may be stated that the so called
cash credit facility holder, Madhusudan being dead, his liability towards
the so called cash credit facility as is said to have been availed by him
from the plaintiff-Bank is now sought to be fastened upon the defendant
assigning him in the position as that of a guarantor. 
Undeniably, the plaintiff-Bank neither proved any loan
document i.e. promissory note, nor any such agreement for said cash
credit facility said to have been availed of by Madhusudan from the
plaintiff-Bank nor the agreement of the hypothecation being executed by
Madhusudan Pansari. The document which the bank has proved is the
statement of account certified under Banker’s Book of Evidence Act.
Thus the factum that Madhusudan had availed of any such cash credit
facility from the plaintiff-Bank has not been established. So when the
plaintiff-Bank has not proved the factum of lending of money by way of
cash credit facility to said Madhusudan, there arises no question of any
person coming to be saddled with the liability on that score merely
basing upon the statement of the account that too on being said as a
guarantor. There being no relationship of creditor and debtor between
the plaintiff-Bank and Madhusudan, the creation of relationship putting
a person in the position of a guarantor / surety does not arise. This
assignment of position of a guarantor to the defendant is based upon the
relationship between the person who has taken the cash credit facility
standing as the debtor which stands as the basic precondition so as to be
satisfied. Then only the question of the defendant standing as guarantor
as the surety in securing the payment of dues of the plaintiff- Bank
remaining unpaid by Madhusudan for its recovery on account of default
of Madhusudan would arise.
The law is quite well settled that mere statement of
account is not sufficient to charge the person of the liability unless of
course with the relationship first, the liability if on that score is accepted
by giving a nod to the correctness of the entry of account. This is not the
case here. In every such monetary transaction, the relationship between
the parties must be established first with the availment of the facility and
thereafter the accounts relating to the said transaction as between the
parties as maintained in due course of business when is proved would go
to determine the rights and liability of the parties to the transaction. The
statement of the account has been filed with the plaint. The correctness
of the same has been challenged with the denial of relationship between
the plaintiff-bank and Madhusudan and thereafter the position of this
defendant as assigned by the Bank as a guarantor. When it is stated in
the plaint that Madhusudan has executed a promissory note, no such
pro note has been proved in the case. P.W.1 on behalf of the Bank has
merely gone to depose that the bank record reveals about the advance of
cash credit facility to the extent of Rs.50,000/- to Madhusudan on
21.3.1971 according to his request. Evidence of P.W.1 being read with
the relevant pleading in the plaint, it is seen that the agreement of
hypothecation also is said to have been executed in the year 1976
whereas facility is said to have been so advanced on 21.3.78 which is one
year and four months after the execution of the so called agreement of 
hypothecation. Those documents are not going to establish the
advancement of the cash credit facility to Madhusudan and about such
other documents, it has neither been spoken by P.W.1 nor those have
even been produced and proved in accordance with law. Said documents
have not seen the light of the day. The statement of account filed by the
bank containing the certificate as required under section 3 of the
Banker’s Book of Evidence Act undoubtedly raises a presumption with
regard to correctness of the statement of account until so rebutted by the
adversary. But the same itself is not taken as the document from which
the court can got to hold that the plaintiff-Bank’s case as regards the
advancement of cash credit facility to Madhusudan and the factum as
stated that the defendant stood as guarantor / surety for the same by
tendering the title deeds with the plaintiff-Bank in creating with
equitable mortgage for the purpose of repayment of loan in case of
default by mortgaged has been so established. Mere entry in the books of
account even though maintained therein the Bank in course of official
transaction and by those in due discharge of official duty cannot be
taken as enough and sufficient or the basis so as to fasten the liability
upon the (so called debtor) or a person sought to be proceeded with in
connection with said transactions and dues recoverable by the creditor
being arraigned as a guarantor as to have been given his property as
equitable mortgage through deposit of title deeds for recovery of said 
outstanding dues due to default by the so called debtor and in the
absence of proof of any documents laying the foundations in creating the
relationship between parties.

HIGH COURT OF ORISSA: CUTTACK.
S.A. NO.240 of 1998

U.Co.Bank, Bolangir  V Bipin Bihari Pansari 

PRESENT:
  SHRI JUSTICE D.DASH
Citation: AIR 2017 (NOC)776 Orissa
Print Page

Saturday, 21 October 2017

Whether bank can evict tenant using provisions of SARFAESI Act?

That issue has been considered in the various Judgments of this Court and the latest one is in "Vishal N. Kalsaria v. Bank of India and Ors." in Crl. Appeal No. 52 of 2016 decided on 20.01.2016, reported in MANU/SC/0061/2016 : (2016) 1 SCALE 172 and at paragraph 30, this Court has observed as under:

It is a settled position of law that once tenancy is created, a tenant can be evicted only after following the due process of law, as prescribed under the provisions of the Rent Control Act. A tenant cannot be arbitrarily evicted by using the provisions of the SARFAESI Act as that would amount to stultifying the statutory rights of protection given to the tenant.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 5610-5611 of 2011

Decided On: 17.02.2016

 Indian Bank Vs. Nippon Enterprises South and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Kurian Joseph and Rohinton Fali Nariman, JJ.
Citation:(2016) 15 SCC 79
Print Page

Saturday, 14 October 2017

Whether bank can refuse to encash FDR issued without consideration?

Be that as it may, we do not see nor is there any discussion in the orders before us giving the basis on which the second FDR was issued. Assuming the FDR dated 8th March, 1996 was issued to the Appellant fraudulently, it was all the more obligatory on the Respondent-Bank to have taken action against its employees. As far as the Appellant is concerned, the only document that he had in his possession and rightly so was the FDR issued to him by the Respondent-Bank. The Appellant cannot be expected to produce anything more than what is given to him by the Bank which is the FDR receipt itself.

9. Under the circumstances, we are of the view that the State Commission as well as the National Commission were in error in dismissing the complaint filed by the Appellant. Accordingly, we set aside the orders passed by the State Commission as well as the National Commission and restore the order passed by the District Consumer Forum.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 6850 of 2005

Decided On: 18.01.2017

 Pishora Singh Vs.  Bank of Punjab and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Madan B. Lokur and Prafulla C. Pant, JJ.

Citation: AIR 2017 SC 2696
Print Page

Tuesday, 5 September 2017

Whether Advocate can be prosecuted for giving wrong search report to bank?

After hearing learned counsel for the parties
and perusing the record of the case alongwith the factual
report submitted by the learned Public Prosecutor as well
as the precedent law cited at the Bar, this Court is of the
opinion that in totality, the only allegation against the
petitioners is that they were panel lawyers of the Bank
and were supposed to furnish their professional advice
regarding the documents submitted by the loanee.
13. The advice rendered by the petitioners has
apparently gone wrong, but such a wrong would not
entitle the respondent to prosecute a lawyer, as it does
not amount to any criminal culpability. The petitioners at
the most may be liable for gross negligence or
professional misconduct, if it is established by the
evidence, but they cannot be charged for the offences, as
alleged, alongwith the other conspirators.
14. It is not the case of the prosecution that the
petitioners were conspirators alongwith the loanee or had
direct link with them, so as to enter into the conspiracy to
cause loss to the Bank. If any such material was on
record, then of course, the prosecution could have
proceeded against the petitioners. But since there is no
such fact available on record, therefore, the prosecution
of the lawyers, merely on the basis of their professional
advice, cannot be sustained in the eye of law.
15. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Central
Bureau of Investigation, Hyderabad (supra) also
observed that rendition of legal opinion cannot be
construed as an offence.
16. This Court also takes note of the fact that it is
not possible for the panel advocate to investigate the
genuineness of the documents and he can only peruse the
contents and conclude whether the title was conveyed
through a document or not, which has been done in this
case. It shall not be possible for a lawyer to render
professional advice, in case a wrong advice results into a
case for criminal prosecution against him, and in such
circumstances, the system of justice delivery shall suffer,
as lawyer being an important component of the justice
delivery system would not be able to give his professional
advice without fear and favour.
17. It is also not the case of the prosecution that
the petitioners were themselves involved in forgery or in
creation of illegal documents for committing fraud with
the Banking institution.
18. In light of the aforesaid discussions, this
Court deems it appropriate to allow the present
misc.petitions and the same are accordingly allowed. FIR
No.54/2009 registered at Police Station, Shastri Nagar,
Jodhpur for offences under Sections 420, 467, 468 and
471 IPC is quashed qua the present petitioners only. 
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT
JODHPUR
S.B. Criminal Misc(Pet.) No. 2786 / 2017
Rajendra Singh V  State of Rajasthan 
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE PUSHPENDRA SINGH BHATI
 Order
29/08/2017
Print Page

Saturday, 24 June 2017

Whether bank is liable for payment of compensation for wrongful attachment of property?

 Given the above narration of facts, we are satisfied that the
action of the Bank touted as a “mistake”, was not a genuine
mistake but was a deliberate act which they have stood by even
after they were put to notice that they had illegally attached the
petitioner’s property. The respondents did not withdraw the
attachment even when the petitioner filed objection on 14th
September, 2015 against the order of attachment before the Debt
Recovery Tribunal, Lucknow. The petitioner attempted follow-up
with the detailed reminder dated 29th September, 2015 to the
Canara Bank as well as the Recovery Officer, Debt Recovery
Tribunal which was of no avail. Even the filing of this writ
petition on the 25th of October 2016 did not persuade the
respondent bank to seek cancellation of the attachment which was
informed by the petitioner as being completely wrongful. The
attachment was withdrawn only on 7th of March 2017 by the
Recovery Officer. 
31. It is evident that if the petitioner had not agitated before the
Recovery Officer, the respondents may have very well proceeded
with the attachment and may have even sold the property pursuant
to the recovery certificate.
32. The act of attachment of the property is a serious matter.
This attachment was effected without taking the basic care and
effecting a title search. The attachment remained in force from 14th
September, 2015 to 7th March, 2017. Undoubtedly, the present
case is a fit case where the petitioner deserves to be compensated
for the wrongful act of the respondents and the harassment,
insecurity and the trauma which has been faced by 68 year old
petitioner for over one and a half years.
33. It would appear that the compensation amount at the rate of
Rs.15,000/- per month of the attachment i.e., from 14th September,
2015 to 7th March, 2017 (seventeen and half months) being a total
of Rs.2,62,500/- would be a reasonable compensation for the
petitioner.
34. We may note that the petitioner has been compelled to
contest the attachment in Lucknow and by filing the present writ
petition in this court. The petitioner is entitled to litigation costs as
well which are quantified at Rs.1,00,000/-.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
 W.P.(C) 10210/2016 & CM No.40335/2016
 Date of decision : 20th June, 2017
V.K. BHATNAGAR 
v
CANARA BANK & ANR
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR CHAWLA
Dated:JUNE 20, 2017
Print Page

Thursday, 22 June 2017

When it is not permissible for bank to forfeit amount deposited by successful bidder in Auction sale?

 Another issue which was debated during the course of
hearing of the instant Letters Patent Appeal, is whether forfeiture of the
amount deposited by the appellant would amount to unjust enrichment
of the respondent-Bank. The learned Senior counsel for the appellant
contended that in the subsequent auction vide E-auction notice
published in the Newspaper on 07.05.2016 the borrower himself has
paid all dues to the Bank, which issued “No Dues Certificate” to the
borrower vide letter dated 23.06.2016 and therefore, appropriation of
Rs.31,25,000/- deposited by the appellant would be unjust retention of
the said amount by the Bank amounting to unjust enrichment.
Mr. P.A.S. Pati, the learned counsel for the respondent-Bank, however,
contended that on account of failure of the appellant to deposit the
balance bid amount, the auction failed and the Bank was constrained
to re-auction the property. The amount deposited by the appellant has
to be forfeited in terms of the conditions attached to E-auction notice
dated 01.03.2016, and if, the Courts interfere with the matters like the
present one, no auction would ever be concluded.
18. The Contract Act, 1872 recognizes the principle of
unjust enrichment in Section 72. This principle is infact foundation
for the law governing restitution. The retention of money or property of
another against the principle of justice, equity and good conscience
has been held by the Courts “unjust enrichment”. On admitted facts,
forfeiture of the amount deposited by the successful bidder, for sale of
a property which the respondent-Bank could not have sold in auction
sale without prior approval of the Housing Board and after realizing its
dues from the borrower, would certainly amount to unjust enrichment.
The respondent-Bank cannot legally retain EMD and 25% of the bid
amount deposited by the appellant.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
 L.P.A. No. 220 of 2016

Kumar Rohit, 
 V
Allahabad Bank, 
CORAM:  MR. JUSTICE VIRENDER SINGH, CHIEF JUSTICE
  MR. JUSTICE SHREE CHANDRASHEKHAR

 Dated:26th July, 2016.
Citation: AIR 2017 Jharkh 65
Print Page

Friday, 16 June 2017

How to prove execution of revival letter for extending limitation for filing of suit?

 On the contrary, Indra Mal (DW-1) has stated in
examination in chief that the signatures at “A to B” on
Ex.2 to Ex.7 are not of his. These signatures are forged.
Though at one place, he has stated that on Ex.6 and Ex.7
also “A to B” part contains his signatures but it appears
that due to typographical error, the word “not” has been
left out. If we read the examination in chief in whole, it
reveals that at other places, he has not only refused his
signatures on revival letters but also stated that the
signatures are fabricated and forged. In cross examination,
he has further stated that on the revival / acknowledgment
letters Ex.2 to Ex.7, “A to B” signatures are not of his,
rather they are forged one.
9. Documents themselves cannot be taken to be of
any value unless their execution is proved by the legal,
relevant and material evidence of the person who has seen
the person signing the documents or who may be conversant
with the signatures of the person executing the documents.
In absence of any such evidence, Ex.2 to Ex.7 cannot be
said to have been established as valid acknowledgment by
the defendant. In the instant matter, the Manager of the
Bank, examined to prove the acknowledgments has admitted
that he was not posted in that Bank branch at the time of
their execution. Moreover, he has specifically said that
he cannot identify the signatures of the defendant.
Therefore, acknowledgments cannot be taken to be validly
proved. The learned courts below have not noticed this
aspect of the matter. The case N.T. Vijayakumar & Ors. vs
The Allahabad Bank, reported in 1999(2) Civil Court Cases,
571 (Karnataka) cited by the appellant is squarely
applicable in the instant case. In absence of valid proof of
execution of debt acknowledgments, the benefit of
protection of section 18 or 19 of the Limitation Act is not
available to the plaintiff Bank and as such, the suit filed
in the year 2003 for recovery of loan disbursed in the
year 1985, stands time barred.
Reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B.Civil Second Appeal No. 242 / 2013

Indra Mal v State Bank of Bikaner & Jaipur,

MR. JUSTICE VIJAY KUMAR VYAS
Dated: 04/01/2017.
Citation: AIR 2017 Raj 66
Print Page

Thursday, 15 June 2017

Whether pawnee has right to file suit for recovery of debt even though he is in possession of pledged Goods?

The Supreme Court in the case of Infrastructure Leasing and Financial Services Ltd. Vs. B.P.L. Ltd., MANU/SC/0018/2015 : (2015) 3 SCC 363, has held that as per Section 176 of the Act when the pawnor makes default in making the payment, the pawnee may bring a suit upon the debt or promise and retain the good(s) pledged as a collateral security. A pawnee has both collateral and concurrent rights and can institute a suit for the purpose of realization of the said debt or promise while retaining the goods as a collateral security. Section 176 also makes it clear that it is the discretion of the pawnee and it gives an option to him and merely because pawnee has filed a suit for recovery, that would not affect or destroy the charge or the right of the pawnee in respect of the pledged goods or the collateral security. Thus, it is within the domain of discretion of pawneee to file a suit for recovery of a debt and yet retain the collateral security or pledged goods.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH (GWALIOR BENCH)
First Appeal Nos. 144/2007, 444, 166 and 167/2006
Decided On: 21.04.2016
 Vijay & Sons and Ors.
Vs.
Shivpuri Guna Kshetriya Gramin Bank and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Alok Aradhe and Vivek Agarwal, JJ.

Citation: AIR 2017(NOC)56 MP
Print Page

Monday, 12 June 2017

How difference between sale and agreement of sale will affect contractual obligation?

The undisputed factual position is that the appellantbank
has not released the mortgage. The possession of the
mortgaged property has not been delivered to the first
respondent so far. The three year lock in period expired on
01.03.2015. The creation of third party interest or
arrangement by way of agreement for sale within the three year
period is different from sale. Admittedly, sale has not been
made within the period of three years of settlement. The
scheme has not provided for any other restriction of
involvement of third party interest for settlement of the

dues. The only restriction is on sale of the property within
three years of the settlement. That admittedly having not been
done, the appellant cannot rest any claim under law for the
share of the increase in fair market value by way of
recompense. There is nothing to be recompensed since the bank
has not suffered or lost anything.
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3197 OF 2016

PUNJAB & SIND BANK
V
PUNJAB BREEDERS LTD. & ANOTHER.
Citation:(2016) 13 SCC 283
Print Page

Monday, 5 September 2016

Whether debts recovery Triunal can permit cross examination of witnesses?

 Mr. Sahu, who appears for respondent no. 2 in the present
matter, candidly admitted that on the basis of the impugned order,
leave to cross-examine will have to be applied in practically all the
pending cases and such leave, will have to be granted as, the facts
and circumstances in each of these cases are the same. Therefore, if
the impugned order is allowed to stand, leave to cross-examine will
have to be granted, as a matter of course, in several matters
concerning the same transaction, thereby, rendering such proceedings
virtually interminable. All this, will only contribute to the very frustration
of the objective behind enactment of the Recovery of Debts Due to
Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 and the said Rules. The
said Act came to be enacted to facilitate expeditious resolution of
disputes concerning payment of dues to banks and financial
institutions. In order that the tribunals constituted under the said Act
are not fettered by technicalities, having regard to larger public
interest, the tribunals have been freed from shackles of procedural law
and are to be only guided by the principles of natural justice and fair
play. The tribunals constituted under the said Act are required to
bestow attention and give priority to the real controversy arising before
them out of the special legislations. Tribunals therefore, cannot permit
themselves to be derailed at the behest of parties resisting recovery,
particularly where such parties fail to take any prompt steps for the
assertion or enforcement of their alleged rights or privileges.

10] In the present case, there is no explanation whatsoever as to
why the respondents did not apply for leave to cross-examine, no
sooner, affidavit was filed for and on behalf of MSFC. The plea of
delay was rightly upheld by DRT and DRAT was obviously not right in
ignoring the same, merely on the ground that the proceedings, in any
case, had protracted for over 20 years. Besides, the DRAT has failed
to notice the impact of its order on several other cases arising out of
the very same transaction. This was certainly a very relevant
consideration, which has been totally ignored by DRAT in making the
impugned order.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
 ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 2066 OF 2014
Maharashtra State Financial Corporation .. Petitioner
versus
Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal,
Mumbai & Ors. .. Respondents

CORAM: D. H. WAGHELA, C. J. AND
M. S. SONAK, J.

 Dated : 02 April 2016
Citation: 2016(4) MHLJ 458
Print Page