Showing posts with label caveater. Show all posts
Showing posts with label caveater. Show all posts

Tuesday, 21 January 2025

Karnataka HC: Whether Stay order by Revenue Appellate court is bad if it has passed stay order without hearing caveater?

Thus, a reading of Section 148-A of the C.P.C. makes it absolutely clear that it applies only to a suit or proceeding instituted, or about to be instituted, in a Court. Section 148-A create a sustentative right in the party. It is not a matter of procedure only. It gives a substantive right in relation to the proceedings that are instituted, or that may bo instituted in a Court. The word "Court" has been defined in Section 2(9a) of the Land Reforms Act as "Court means the Court of Munsiff within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the land is situate." The Appellate Authority constituted under the Amendment Act 1986 is not a Court of original jurisdiction or a Court of Appeal within the meaning of the C.P.C. The Appellate Authority has been created by the Land Reforms Act under Section 116A. Therefore, it becomes clear that the Appellate Authority does not amount to a Court within the meaning of the definition of the Court given by the Land Reforms Act or within the meaning of the word 'Court' as defined by the C.P.C. Therefore, Section 148-A of the C.P.C. does not apply to the proceedings instituted or to be instituted before the Appellate Authority. {Para 2}

Therefore, the Appellate Authority, by virtue of Section 107 C.P.C. read with Section 113 of the Land Reforms Act, cannot entertain a caveat as defined by Section 148-A of the C.P.C. Section 148-A doesn't give a right to the Court to receive the caveat, but it gives a right to the party to file a caveat. There is nothing in the Land Reforms Act, even as amended by Act No. 19/86 to show that the party has got a right to file caveat. This is a special right given to the party by the C.P.C. in relation to the proceedings instituted or to be instituted in a Court. This is an exceptional right given to the party in relation to the proceedings filed or to be filed in a Court. Such an exceptional right given to a party by Section 148-A of the C.P.C. in relation to suits or appeals or proceedings instituted or to be instituted in a Court, is not available to a litigant in respect of the proceedings under the Land Reforms Act.

6. As already stated above, Sub-section (3) speaks about the State Government making Rules for conferment of such other powers on the Appellate Authority as may be considered necessary or to regulate the practice and procedure of the Appellate Authority and the conduct of its business. It does not contemplate anything like giving an additional right to the litigant file a caveat. As already indicated above, it is only a special right given to the litigant to file a caveat. Such a right does not amount to conferment of the powers on the Appellate Authority. Therefore, the said argument also stands rejected. Under these circumstances, his argument that the stay order is bad as it has been passed by the Appellate Authority without hearing him even though he had filed a caveat, stands rejected.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

C.R.P. No. 3088 of 1986

Decided On: 25.08.1986

Panchakshari Vs. Chairman, Land Tribunal

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

P.A. Kulkarni, J.

Citation: MANU/KA/0318/1986.

Print Page

Friday, 31 August 2018

Whether it is permissible to file caveat in proceeding for execution of decree?

Under S. 148A(1) therefore. Any person who claims a right to appear before the Court on the hearing of an application can file a caveat under that section in anticipation of such application being made. The result of filing such a caveat is that once such a caveat is filed a notice of any application such a suit or proceeding must be given to the caveator. The filing of a caveat prevents separate orders being made in proceedings where the caveator has ordinaries as right to be heard. The provisions of Section 148A are therefore attracted in cases of such proceedings where the caveator is entitled to be heard in the ordinary course. Section 148A may also apply to those proceedings where the court in its discretion. Hears the party who has filed the caveat. Before passing orders. Application for execution under O. 21. R. 43 or R. 54 are not proceedings where the judgment-debtor has a right to be heard. In fact there is no provision in law for issue of a notice to the judgment-debtor in applications for execution except in specific cases enumerated in O. 21. R. 22 and O.21. R. 37. Since the judgment-debtor is not a party who has a right to be heard or is ordinarily heard in applications under O. 21, R. 43 or O.21, R.54. the provisions of S. 148A are not attracted to such execution applications. The defendants are therefore not entitled to file a caveat in such an application for execution of a decree passed against them.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Execution Appln. No. 139 of 1983 in Suit no. 1832 of 1979

Decided On: 07.10.1983

Nav Digvijaya Co-operative Housing Society Limited Vs. Sadhana Builders and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.V. Manohar, J.
Citation: AIR 1984 Bombay 114
Print Page

Saturday, 14 January 2017

How to ascertain limitation for filing of cross objection if caveater was present before court at the time of hearing?

 If we examine the provisions of Order XLI Rule 22 of the Code in its correct perspective and in light of the above stated principles then the period of limitation of one month stated therein would commence from the service of notice of the day of hearing of appeal on the respondent in that appeal. The hearing contemplated under Order XLI Rule 22 of the Code normally is the final hearing of the appeal but this rule is not without any exception. The exception could be where a party respondent appears at the time of admission of the appeal, as a caveator or otherwise and argues the appeal on merits as well as while passing of interim orders and the Court has admitted the appeal in the presence of that party and directs the appeal to be heard finally on a future date actual or otherwise, then it has to be taken as complete compliance of the provisions of Order XLI Rule 22 of the Code and thereafter, the appellant  who has appeared himself or through his pleader cannot claim that period mentioned under the said provision of the Code would commence only when the respondent is served with a fresh notice of hearing of the appeal in the required format. If this argument is accepted it would amount to travesty of justice and inevitably result in delay while causing serious prejudice to the interest of the parties and administration of justice. Such interpretation would run contra to the legislative intent behind the provisions of Order XLI Rule 11 of the Code which explicitly contemplate that an appeal shall be heard expeditiously and disposed of as far as possible within 60 days at the admission stage. All the provisions of Order XLI of the Code have to be read conjunctively to give Order XLI Rule 22 its true and purposive meaning. Having analytically examined the provisions of Order XLI Rule 22, we may now state the principles for its applications as follow:
(a) Respondent in an appeal is entitled to receive a notice of hearing of the appeal as contemplated under Order XLI Rule 22 of the Code;
(b) The limitation of one month for filing the cross-objection as provided under Order XLI Rule 22 of the Code shall commence from the date of service of notice on him or his pleader of the day fixed for hearing the appeal.
(c) Where a respondent in the appeal is a caveator or otherwise puts in appearance himself and argues the appeal on merits including for the purposes of interim order and the appeal is ordered to be heard finally on a date fixed subsequently or otherwise, in presence of the said respondent/caveator, it shall be deemed to be service of notice within the meaning of Order XLI Rule 22. In other words the limitation of one month shall start from that date.
Reportable

Supreme Court of India
Mahadev Govind Gharge & Ors vs Spl.Land Acq Officer ... on 10 May, 2011
Bench: Ashok Kumar Ganguly, Swatanter Kumar
Print Page

Sunday, 1 September 2013

Supreme Court: Burden of proof on propounder of a will v Burden of proof on caveator

 The propounder of a will has to show that the will was signed by the testator, that he was at the relevant time in a sound disposing state of mind, that he understood the nature and effect of the dispositions, that he put his signature to the testament of his free will and that he had signed it in the presence of two witnesses who attested it in his presence and in the presence of each other. once these elements are established the onus resting on the propounder is discharged. If the caveator alleges undue influence, fraud and coercion the onus is on him to prove the same. If the caveator does not discharge this burden probate of the will must necessarily be granted if it is established that the testator had full testamentary capacity and had, in fact, executed it validly with a free will and mind. A man may act foolishly and even heartlessly but if he acts with full comprehension of what he is doing the Court will not interfere with the exercise of his volition. There may however be cases in which the execution of the will is surrounded by suspicious circumstances such as where the signature is doubtful, the testator is of feeble mind or is overawed by powerful minds interested in getting his property or where, in the light of the relevant circumstances, the dispositions appear to be unnatural, improbable t and unfair; or; where there are other reasons for doubting that the dispositions in the will were not the result of the testator's free will and mind. In all such cases the suspicious circumstances must be reviewed and satisfactorily explained by the propounder before the will is accepted as genuine. Again, in cases where the pro- pounder has himself taken a prominent part in the execution of the will which confers on him a substantial benefit, that is itself a suspicious circumstance which he must remove by clear and satisfactory evidence.

Supreme Court of India
Surendra Pal & Ors vs Saraswati Arora & Anr on 9 August, 1974
Equivalent citations: 1974 AIR 1999, 1975 SCR (1) 687
Print Page