Showing posts with label propounder of will. Show all posts
Showing posts with label propounder of will. Show all posts

Friday, 19 February 2021

Whether revenue authorities have jurisdiction to decide the issue of the genuineness of will during mutation proceeding?

                   If an application under Section 110 of MPLR

       Code is filed for mutation of the name of all the legal

       heirs, then it would certainly be a proceeding under the

       MPLR Code because the question of title is not

       involved and all the legal heirs of the deceased/owner

       will be brought on record without any further

       adjudication but whether the adjudication of the title of

       the parties on the basis of a ''Will'' can be said to be a

       proceeding under the Act or not, is a moot question

       which requires consideration.

      

      (26) It is well-established principle of law that the

      burden is on the propounder of the ''Will'' to prove that

      the ''Will'' was executed in his favour by the testator.

      Even if the ''Will'' is not challenged by anybody, but

      still the propounder of the ''Will'' has to discharge his

      burden and no decree can be passed even by the Civil

      Court merely on the ground that the respondents have

      chosen not to appear before it or have failed to file their

      written statement as provided under Order 8 Rule 10

      CPC.”


9.    Further, the similar view which was taken by this Court on the


earlier occasion has also been affirmed by the Division Bench of this


Court in the Writ Appeal in the case of Murari (supra). Thus, it is


clear that the revenue authorities have no jurisdiction to decide the


correctness and genuineness of a “Will” and if the propounder of the


“Will” wants to take advantage of the “Will”, then he has to get his


title declared from the Civil Court of competent jurisdiction.

       

            THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

                    Writ Petition No.6695/2013

               Smt. Ramkali Vs. Banmali and another


Gwalior, Dated :17/02/2021


     

Print Page

Sunday, 2 December 2018

Whether propounder of will is bound to prove will even if objection to will is not taken by other side?

 In the instant case, the applicant amended her application in order to include pleadings pertaining to execution of the aforesaid Will by her son Baban Wankhade. This Will is crucial as regards the claim made by the applicant because it completely leaves out the widow of deceased Baban Wankhade from any benefits in respect of his estate. It is the case of the applicant that since the relations between deceased Baban Wankhade and his wife (contesting respondent No. 7) were strained, the desire of deceased Baban Wankhade is manifested in the contents of the aforesaid Will. It is contended on behalf of the applicant that since there was no consequential amendment made by contesting respondent Nos. 7 to 10 in their written statement/objection in respect of the pleadings pertaining to the said Will incorporated in the application filed by the applicant, the Courts below could not have "shifted the burden" on the applicant as regards the proof of the said Will.

11. In this context, it is to be examined that when the applicant herself has propounded the said Will, whether she is entitled to claim that if there is no denial in the written statement/objection on behalf of contesting respondent Nos. 7 to 10, she is discharged from her burden to prove the execution of the said Will. It is difficult to accept the said contention raised on behalf of the applicant because when she is claiming benefit under the aforesaid Will, it is for her to come to the Court and prove the fact in accordance with law that such a Will was indeed executed by her son Baban. In this context, the learned Counsel appearing on behalf of contesting respondent Nos. 7 to 10 is justified in placing reliance on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Ramesh Verma (supra), wherein it has been held as follows :

"13. A Will like any other document is to be proved in terms of the provisions of Section 68 of the Indian Succession Act and the Evidence Act. The propounder of the Will is called upon to show by satisfactory evidence that the Will was signed by the testator, that the testator at the relevant time was in a sound and disposing state of mind, that he understood the nature and effect of the disposition and put his signature to the document on his own free will and the document shall not be used as evidence until one attesting witness at least has been called for the purpose of proving its execution. This is the mandate of Section 68 of the Evidence Act and the position remains the same even in a case where the opposite party does not specifically deny the execution of the document in the written statement. "
12. It is, thus, clear that the mandate of the Act of 1925 read with the provisions of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, is that the burden is entirely upon the applicant to prove execution and contents of the said Will since she had propounded the same. Therefore, the question of law framed by this Court while admitting this application is answered in favour of contesting respondent Nos. 7 to 10 and against the applicant.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Civil Revision Application No. 68 of 2015

Decided On: 04.04.2018

 Bainabai Vs.  Divisional Manager, Life Insurance Corporation of India and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Manish Pitale, J.

Citation: 2018(6) MHLJ 91
Print Page

Tuesday, 3 July 2018

How to appreciate evidence regarding proof of execution of will?

Once it is found that the plaintiffs and especially the
plaintiff no.2 – Ramesh who was the propounder of the Will had
not discharged the burden of proving the due execution of the will


and   had   failed   in   removing   the   suspicious   circumstances

surrounding the same, the burden to disprove the said will did not
shift   on   the   defendants.   On   that   count   merely   because   the
defendant examined the power of attorney holder – Vitthal who
was not fully aware about the facts of the case would not affect the
case of the defendant.  It was only if the valid execution and due
attestation of the will at Exhibit­41 would have been proved as
required by Section 63 of the Indian Execution Act, that burden
would have shifted on the defendant. At that stage, the aspect of
the defendant not examining herself and instead examining her
power   of   attorney   holder   would   have   been   a   relevant   factor.

However, as it has been found that the will propounded by the
plaintiffs has not been duly proved the aspect of the defendant
examining   her   power   of   attorney   holder   is   not   of   much
consequence.  In that view of the matter, the decisions relied upon
by   the   learned   Counsel   for   the   appellants   in  Janki   Vashdeo
Bhojwani and another  as well  Man Kaur through her legal heirs
(supra)  does   not   take   the   case   of   the   plaintiffs   any   further.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR.
SECOND APPEAL NO. 167 OF 2004

 Ramesh Tanbaji Satpute Vs  Smt.   Tulsabai   Wd/o   Laxmanrao Bhanose 
CORAM: A.S. CHANDURKAR, J.

DATED:  22­-06-­2018   

Print Page

Sunday, 31 December 2017

What is doctrine of dependant relative revocation relating to proof of will?

 This Court had occasion to consider the doctrine of dependant relative revocation in Vadakkayil Gopalan v. Vadakkayil Paru and others [MANU/KE/0669/2013 : 2013 (3) KLT 69], wherein it has been held as follows:-

"The doctrine of dependent relative revocation is explained by Jarman on Wills, as follows:

"Where the act of destruction is connected with the making of another will, so as fairly to raise the inference that the testator meant the revocation of the old to depend upon the efficacy of the new disposition intended to be substituted, such will be the legal effect of the transaction and therefore, if the will intended to be substituted is inoperative from defect of attestation or any other cause, the revocation fails also, and the original will remains in force. The doctrine, which has been described as somewhat overloaded with unnecessary polysyllables, applies whenever the intention to revoke a will is conditional only and the condition is not fulfilled, and the doctrine may apply although the later will is partially effective."
Of course, this Court has held that even in cases wherein the doctrine of dependent relative revocation can be applied, it does not mean that the genuineness of the contents of the earlier will have to be swallowed and taken as granted without proof of the contents of the Will as contemplated under Section 63 of the Indian Succession Act read with Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

RSA No. 779 of 2011 (A)

Decided On: 07.03.2017

K.C. Bindu and Ors. Vs.Leela Kollandi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B. Kemal Pasha, J.

Citation: AIR 2017(NOC)1119 Kerala
Print Page

Sunday, 12 November 2017

Whether execution of will is validly proved if testator was on death bed at time of execution of will deed?


Ex. P/4 discloses that Srimati Mooli Swarnkar attended the school as a teacher up to 1.10.2001, and thereafter she remained on medical leave. It is also not in dispute, that the deceased was suffering from liver cancer and Hepatitis 'B' disease. Admittedly, the will was executed between 7 to 8 a.m. on 18.11.2001, and after few hours she expired on the very same date. The attesting witness of Ex. D/6, namely, Shri Dhannalal Mahavar (NAW/02) has admitted in the cross-examination that he is a government hospital compounder. The deceased was being treated in a hospital at Bhopal. At about 5.30 a.m. on 18.11.2001, a telephone call was received by Shri Brijmohan Soniji, who is the father of respondent no.1, and immediately thereafter he arrived at the site, i.e. in the hospital at Bhopal.
It is admitted by the attesting witness and other witnesses who were allegedly present at the time of the execution of the will that the hands of Srimati Mooli Swarnkar were shivering while signing Ex. D/6. At that point of time, Srimati Mooli Swarnkar was very weak and she was administered drip. The health condition of Srimati Mooli Swarnkar had deteriorated when the drip was being administered. Therefore, in our considered opinion, the first appellate Court was justified in concluding that the propounder of the will was not successful in proving that the will was executed in a healthy state of mind as well as body of the deceased and without any pressure.
The will is surrounded by suspicious circumstances mentioned supra. Similar observation needs to be made in respect of nomination forms also, which were allegedly executed by the deceased just prior to her death on 18.11.2001, i.e., on 16.11.2001. Admittedly, the deceased was on medical leave. The nomination forms allegedly signed by the deceased were placed before the concerned department by the relatives and other family members of the respondents. Upon comparison of the disputed and other signatures of the deceased Srimati Mooli Swarnkar on Ex. P/4, D/7, D/8 and the alleged will Ex. D/6, the first appellate Court on facts has concluded that the signatures found on Ex. D/6 were totally different.
9. We find from the records that the condition of the testator's mind and body was very feeble and debilitated. The signature of the testator was allegedly taken on the death bed while she was administered drip. The dispositions made in the will may not be the result of the testator's free will and mind. In such cases, the Court would naturally expect that all legitimate suspicions should be completely removed before the document is accepted as the last will of the testator.
The presence of such suspicious circumstances naturally tends to make the initial onus very heavy and unless it is satisfactorily discharged, Courts would be reluctant to treat the document as the last will of the testator. Since there are many suspicious circumstances narrated above, and as we are satisfied that the dispositions made in the alleged will may not be as a result of testator's free will and mind, the Civil Court as well as the High Court are not justified in coming to the conclusion that the will Ex.D/6 is duly executed by the deceased.
The respondents being the propounders of the will have failed to satisfy the judicial conscience of this Court regarding due execution of the will. Since the suspicious circumstances relate to the genuineness of the signatures of the testator, as well as the condition of the testator's mind and the dispositions made in the will being unfair, the judgment of the High Court restoring the judgment of the Civil Court is liable to be set aside.
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Dr. Prakash Soni Vs. Deepak Kumar and Another
[Civil Appeal No. 6388 of 2009]
Dated:SEPTEMBER 15, 2017.
MOHAN M. SHANTANAGOUDAR
Print Page

Tuesday, 11 April 2017

Whether active participation by beneficiary of will in execution of will amounts to suspicious circumstance?

 It is settled by a catena of decisions that any and every circumstance is not a suspicious circumstance. Even in a case where active participation and execution of the Will by the profounder/beneficiaries was there, it has been held that that by itself is not sufficient to create any doubt either about the testamentary capacity or the genuineness of the Will. It has been held that the mere presence of the beneficiary at the time of execution would not prove that the beneficiary had taken prominent part in the execution of the Will. This is the view taken by this Court in Sridevi and Ors. v. Jayaraja Shetty and Ors., MANU/SC/0065/2005 : AIR2005SC780 . In the said case, it has been held that the onus to prove the will is on the propounder and in the absence of suspicious circumstances surrounding the execution of the will proof of testamentary capacity and the proof of signature of the testator as required by law not be sufficient to discharge the onus. In case, the person attesting the Will alleges undue influence, fraud or coercion, the onus will be on him to prove the same and that as to what suspicious circumstances which have to be judged in the facts and circumstances of each particular case.
Citation : AIR 2005 SC 4362
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Civil Appeal Nos. 5941-5942 of 2005 
Decided On: 29.09.2005
 Pentakota Satyanarayana 
Vs.
 Pentakota Seetharatnam and Ors.
Print Page

Sunday, 26 February 2017

What will not be suspicious circumstance surrounding execution of will?

This Court has held that the mode of proving a will does not ordinarily differ from that of proving any other document except to the special requirement of attestation prescribed in the case of a will by Section 63 of the Successions Act. The onus of proving the will is on the propounder and in the absence of suspicious circumstances surrounding the execution of the will, proof of testamentary capacity and the signature of the testator as required by law is sufficient to discharge the onus. Where however there are suspicious circumstances, the onus is on the propounder to explain them to the satisfaction of the court before the court accepts the will as genuine. Even where circumstances give rise to doubts, it is for the propounder to satisfy the conscience of the court. The suspicious circumstances may be as to the genuineness of the signatures of the testator, the condition of the testator's mind, the disposition made in the will being unnatural, improbable or unfair in the light of relevant circumstances, or there might be other indications in the will to show that the testator's mind was not free. In such a case the court would naturally expect that all legitimate suspicions should be completely removed before the document is accepted as the last will of the testator. If the propounder himself takes a prominent part in the execution of the will which confers a substantial benefit on him, that is also a circumstance to be taken into account, and the propounder is required to remove the doubts by clear and satisfactory evidence. If the propounder succeeds in removing the suspicious circumstances the court would grant probate, even if the will might be unnatural and might cut off wholly or in part near relations. MANU/SC/0278/1963 : AIR1964SC529
8. Needless to say that any and every circumstance is not a `suspicious' circumstance. A circumstance would be `suspicious' when it is not normal or is not normally expected in a normal situation or is not expected of a normal person.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Civil Appeal No. 1872 of 1970
Decided On: 18.11.1981
 Smt. Indu Bala Bose and Ors.
Vs.
 Manindra Chandra Bose and Anr.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.N. Sen and Baharul Islam, JJ.
Citation:A.I.R. 1982, Supreme Court, 133
Print Page

Sunday, 6 November 2016

How to ascertain suspicious circumstances while proving execution of will?


It is true that it is for the propounder of a Will to
remove all suspicious circumstances, but these circumstances must
either appear from the document itself or must be shown to exist by 
cogent evidence. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
TESTAMENTARY & INTESTATE JURISDICTION
TESTAMENTARY SUIT NO. 20 OF 2005
IN
TESTAMENTARY PETITION NO. 753 OF 2004
SHIRISH POPATLAL SHAH,

v
ARUN POPATLAL SHAH,

CORAM : G.S.Patel, J.
Dated : 8th July 2016
Citation: 2016(6) MHLJ 257

Print Page

Supreme Court: Golden rules for appreciation of evidence in case of will

There is a long line of decisions bearing on the nature and standard of evidence required to prove a will. Those decisions have been reviewed in an elaborate judgment of this Court in R. Venkatachala Iyengar v.B.N. Thirnmajamma & Others. [1959] Supp. I S.C.R. 426. The Court, speaking through Gajendragadkar J., laid down in that case the following positions :--

1. Stated generally, a will has to be proved like any other document, the test to be applied being the usual test of the satisfaction of the prudent mind in such matters. As in the ease of proof of other documents, so in the case of proof of wills, one cannot insist on proof with mathematical certainty.

2. Since section 63 of the Succession Act requires a will to be attested, it cannot be used as evidence until, as required by section 63 of the Evidence Act, one attesting witness at least has .been called for the purpose of proving its execution, if there be an attesting witness alive and subject to the process of the court and capable of giving evidence.

3. Unlike other documents, the will speaks from the death o[ the testator and therefore the maker of the will is never available for deposing as to the circumstances in which the will came to be executed.

This aspect introduces an element of solemnity in the deci- sion of the question whether the document propounded is proved to be the last will and testament of the testator. Normally, the onus which lies on the propounder can be taken to be discharged on proof of the essential facts which go into the making of the will.

4. Cases in which the execution of the will is surround- ed by suspicious circumstances stand on a different footing. A shaky signature, a feeble mind, an unfair and unjust disposition of property, the propounder himself taking a leading part in the making of the will under which he re- ceives a substantial benefit and such other circumstances raise suspicion about the execution of the will. That suspicion cannot be removed by the mere assertion of the propounder that the will bears the signature of the testator or that the testator was in a sound and disposing state of mind and memory at the time when the will was made, or that those like the wife and children of the testator who would normally receive their due share in his estate were disin- herited because the testator might have had his own reasons for excluding them. The presence of suspicious circumstances makes the initial onus heavier and therefore, in cases where the circumstances attendant upon the execution of the will excite the suspicion of the court, the propounder must remove all legitimate suspicions before the document can be accepted as the last will of the testator.

5. It is in connection with wills, the execution of which is surrounded by suspicious circumstance that the test of satisfaction of the judicial conscience has been evolved. That test emphasises that in determining the question as to whether an instrument produced before the court is the last will of the testator, the court is called upon to decide a solemn question and by reason of suspicious circumstances the court has to be satisfied fully that the will has been validly executed by the testator.

6. If a caveator alleges fraud, undue influence, coer- cion etc. in regard to the execution of the will, such pleas have to be proved by him, but even in the absence of such pleas, the very circumstances surrounding the execu- tion' of the will may raise a doubt as to whether the testa- tor was acting of his own free will. And then it is a part of the initial onus of the propounder to remove all reasona- ble doubts in the matter.

Supreme Court of India
Jaswant Kaur vs Amrit Kaur & Ors on 25 October, 1976
Equivalent citations: 1977 AIR 74, 1977 SCR (1) 925, 1977 SCC (1) 369

BENCH:
CHANDRACHUD, Y.V.
GOSWAMI, P.K.
GUPTA, A.C.
Print Page

Sunday, 23 October 2016

What is duty of propounder of will if natural legal heirs are excluded in will?

Whenever the execution of a will is denied, burden is always on the propounder to ward off all suspicious circumstances surrounding the will. Principles to this effect have been succinctly enunciated by the Hon'ble apex court in the case of H. Venkatachala Iyengar v. B.N. Thimmajamma (MANU/SC/0115/1958 : AIR 1959 SC 443). In the said case, it is held that the propounder is not only expected to prove due execution of the will, but also to prove that the executant, i.e. testator was in a sound disposing state of mind at that time.
13. Whenever a legatee intends to exclude his natural heir, who would otherwise inherit the property, is expected to indicate strong reasons for such exclusion. The recitals in Ex. P1 disclose that Chandramma- wife of Chandrappa was not leading a good life and that her character was suspicious. Nobody is examined to prove such a serious allegation. Whenever the genuineness of a will is disputed, one of the attesting witnesses must be examined to support the same in terms of Section 68, Evidence Act and Section 63, Indian Succession Act.
In the case of Ram Piary v. Bhagwat (MANU/SC/0306/1990 : AIR 1990 SC 1742), the Hon'ble apex court has held that there must be some strong reason to exclude the natural heirs. 
The legal principles that could be drawn from the decisions referred to above is that the propounder of a will is expected to prove its due execution and if there are suspicious circumstances, the propounder must before remove the suspicious circumstances by adducing cogent and acceptable evidence, though every circumstance may not be suspicious circumstance.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
R.S.A. Nos. 1952/2005 and 220/2006
Decided On: 18.03.2016
 Chennappa Gowda and Ors.
Vs.
 N.C. Rajashekara and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:A.V. Chandrashekara, J.

Citation:AIR 2016 (NOC)622 Kar
Print Page

Monday, 9 November 2015

Father excluding his sons from getting estate in will, whether doubtful circumstance?

Let us now test the genuineness of the Will and testator's mind set in execution of such Will for disposition of his estate in the manner it was done by sitting in the arm chair of the testator in the light of the guidelines given by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as mentioned above. We find from the evidence on record that Nilkrishna Paul had strained relationship with his sons namely Sankar and Bimal Paul. It is apparent from the evidence of the contesting defendant/respondent that Sankar Paul had love marriage and since the time of his marriage he had been living in separate mess. They did not take any information with regard to their mother and the testator. DW1 further admitted that his brothers (the appellants) used to look after the business of his father on and from 1979.
Since these two sons separated themselves from the testator's family and they did not maintain any relationship with the testator during his lifetime and further they withdrew themselves from assisting their father in carrying on the father's business, the testator(father) did not give any part of his property to these two sons by mentioning the reasons for their exclusion in his disposition, which appears to us very reasonable for a father, who was deprived and/or neglected by his own sons. On reading the evidence of the DW.1, we find that the contesting parties failed to prove that the reasons which were mentioned by the testator in Will for their exclusion from inheritance by testamentary succession were not correct. They could not prove that they did not separate themselves from the family of the testator since the time of their marriage and they took all necessary care for their father and the other members of his family in the manner as ordinarily a father expects from his son. In the absence of such proof, we have no hesitation to hold that the testator was not unreasonable in his disposition of his estate in the manner as it was done by him in his Will.
Secondly, it is apparent from the evidence of DW1 that he used to reside in separate mess since 1979. It is also apparent from his evidence that the business of his father had been managing by the appellants since 1979. It has been elicited in the cross examination of PW1 that Bimal got married out of his own and without the consent of the testator. That goes to show that the testator was definitely not happy because of such marriage of Bimal. Thus, sufficient reasons were given for exclusion of other sons by the testator. Accordingly, such dispositions in the Will cannot be said to be suspicious circumstances to reject the testamentary application.
Kolkata High Court (Appellete Side)
Sri Birendranath Paul @ Barendra ... vs Sri Sankar Paul @ Kali Krishna Paul on 26 June, 2015
Print Page

Thursday, 6 August 2015

When propounder of will is not permitted to adduce evidence as per S 71 of Evidence Act?

 Viewed in premise, Section 71 of the 1872 Act has
to be necessarily accorded a strict interpretation. The
two contingencies permitting the play of this provision,
namely, denial or failure to recollect the execution by the
attesting witness produced, thus a fortiori has to be
extended a meaning to ensure that the limited liberty
granted by Section 71 of 1872 Act does not in any
manner efface or emasculate the essence and efficacy of
Section 63 of the Act and Section 68 of 1872 Act. The
distinction between failure on the part of a attesting
witness to prove the execution and attestation of a Will
and his or her denial of the said event or failure to
recollect the same, has to be essentially maintained. Any
unwarranted indulgence, permitting extra liberal
flexibility to these two stipulations, would render the
predication of Section 63 of the Act and Section 68 of the
1872 Act, otiose. The propounder can be initiated to the
benefit of Section 71 of the 1872 Act only if the attesting
witness/witnesses, who is/are alive and is/are produced
and in clear terms either denies /deny the execution of
the document or cannot recollect the said incident. Not
only, this witness/witnesses has/have to be credible and
impartial, the evidence adduced ought to demonstrate
unhesitant denial of the execution of the document or
authenticate real forgetfulness of such fact. If the
testimony evinces a casual account of the execution and
attestation of the document disregardful of truth, and
thereby fails to prove these two essentials as per law, the
propounder cannot be permitted to adduce other
evidence under cover of Section 71 of the 1872 Act. Such
a sanction would not only be incompatible with the
scheme of Section 63 of the Act read with Section 68 of
the 1872 Act but also would be extinctive of the
paramountcy and sacrosanctity thereof, a consequence,
not legislatively intended. If the evidence of the witnesses
produced by the propounder is inherently worthless and
lacking in credibility, Section 71 of Act 1872 cannot be
invoked to bail him (propounder) out of the situation to
facilitate a roving pursuit. In absence of any touch of
truthfulness and genuineness in the overall approach,
this provision, which is not a substitute of Section 63 (c )
of the Act and Section 68 of the 1872 Act, cannot be
invoked to supplement such failed speculative endeavour
45.2 Section 71 of the 1872 Act, even if assumed to be
akin to a proviso to the mandate contained in Section 63
of the Act and Section 68 of the 1872 Act, it has to be
assuredly construed harmoniously therewith and not
divorced therefrom with a mutilative bearing. This
underlying principle is inter alia embedded in the
decision of this Court in the Commission of Income Tax,
Madras Appellant Versus Ajax Products Limited
Respondent AIR 1965, Supreme Court 1358.
[REPORTABLE]
 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
 CIVIL APPEAL Nos.4181-4182 OF 2015
(ARISING OUT OF SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION(C)NOs. 36311-12/2014
JAGDISH CHAND SHARMA .
 Vs.
NARAIN SINGH SAINI (DEAD) 
THROUGH HIS LRs & Ors.

Citation;AIR 2015 SC2149
AMITAVA ROY, J.
Print Page

Sunday, 1 September 2013

Supreme Court: Burden of proof on propounder of a will v Burden of proof on caveator

 The propounder of a will has to show that the will was signed by the testator, that he was at the relevant time in a sound disposing state of mind, that he understood the nature and effect of the dispositions, that he put his signature to the testament of his free will and that he had signed it in the presence of two witnesses who attested it in his presence and in the presence of each other. once these elements are established the onus resting on the propounder is discharged. If the caveator alleges undue influence, fraud and coercion the onus is on him to prove the same. If the caveator does not discharge this burden probate of the will must necessarily be granted if it is established that the testator had full testamentary capacity and had, in fact, executed it validly with a free will and mind. A man may act foolishly and even heartlessly but if he acts with full comprehension of what he is doing the Court will not interfere with the exercise of his volition. There may however be cases in which the execution of the will is surrounded by suspicious circumstances such as where the signature is doubtful, the testator is of feeble mind or is overawed by powerful minds interested in getting his property or where, in the light of the relevant circumstances, the dispositions appear to be unnatural, improbable t and unfair; or; where there are other reasons for doubting that the dispositions in the will were not the result of the testator's free will and mind. In all such cases the suspicious circumstances must be reviewed and satisfactorily explained by the propounder before the will is accepted as genuine. Again, in cases where the pro- pounder has himself taken a prominent part in the execution of the will which confers on him a substantial benefit, that is itself a suspicious circumstance which he must remove by clear and satisfactory evidence.

Supreme Court of India
Surendra Pal & Ors vs Saraswati Arora & Anr on 9 August, 1974
Equivalent citations: 1974 AIR 1999, 1975 SCR (1) 687
Print Page