Showing posts with label condition precedent. Show all posts
Showing posts with label condition precedent. Show all posts

Tuesday, 9 May 2017

Whether application for removal of executor of will can be moved prior to grant of probate?

 I return now to the question of when an application under Section 301 can be brought and, specifically, whether the grant of probate is a condition precedent to the maintainability of the application for removal. Here, Ms. Iyer is correct in saying that such an application can be brought at any time. The findings and observations in FSC Amalnathan4 are apposite:
"5. The learned Counsel for the respondent, during arguments, contended that as the will is still not probated this petition is not a maintainable under Section 213 of the Act. According to him the petitioners want to rely on the terms of the Will to contend that the respondent has acted against the wishes of the testatrix and that as such he is liable to be removed and that the petitioners cannot rely on the terms of the Will without the same having been probated. The sum and substance of the argument was that the contents of the Will cannot be looked into without the Will being probated and that as admittedly the Will is till not probated this petition itself is not maintainable. The learned counsel for the petitioners, however, contended that (sic) the Will cannot be made use of for the purpose to establish rights under the Will without the same being probated, there is no bar for the Will being relied upon for a collateral purpose. He relied upon the decision reported in John Guruprakasam v. Yovel Nesal (MANU/KE/0015/1979 : AIR 1979 Ker 96 : ILR (1978) 2 Kar 335. Relying the decision in Bali Ram Dhote v. Bhupendra Nath Banerjee, (MANU/WB/0130/1978 : AIR 1978 Cal 559) he contended that the property vests in the executor immediately on the death of the deceased and the probate is not necessary to make an executor act and that the executor can even effect a sale. He therefore contended that for removal of a private executor under Section 301 probate of the Will is not a condition precedent.
6. Under Section 211 of the Act an executor of a Will of the deceased is a legal representative of the deceased for all purposes and the property of the deceased vests in the executor immediately after the death. The law is fairly well settled that the executor can exercise his powers as executor and act in accordance with the terms of the Will even though probate of the Will is not granted. In fact one of the points of distinction between an executor and administrator is that the executor may act even before he obtains probate but an administrator cannot act unless letters of administration are granted to him. The interest of an executor in the estate of the deceased vests in him immediately on the death of the testator.
7. Section 222 of the Act stipulates that probate shall be granted only to the executor appointed under the Will. Under Section 229 when a person appointed as executor has not renounced the executorship, letters of administration cannot be granted to any other person until citation has been issued calling upon the executor to accept or renounce his executorship. Under Section 231, if an executor renounces or fails to accept an executorship within the time limits for the acceptance or refusing thereof then the Will may be proved and the letters of administration with a copy of the Will annexed may be granted to the person entitled to administration in case of intestacy. Thus, where an executor accepts executorship no one else can seek letters of administration. When such is the case, if an executor who starts functioning as an executor without obtaining probate and his actions are in derogation of the terms of the Will and prejudicial to the interest of the estate, the beneficiaries cannot remain helpless. They cannotassert their rights under the Will as legatees without probate of the Will by filing a suit. In such a case the remedy available is to apply to the court for removal of the executor under Section 301. Such proceedings cannot be considered to be a proceeding to establish the right of an executor or legatee.
8. Section 213(1) reads as hereunder:
"No right as executor or legatee can be established in any Court of Justice, unless a Court of competent jurisdiction in India has granted probate of the will under which the right is claimed, or has granted letters of administration with the will or with a copy of an authenticated copy of the will annexed."
9. The Supreme Court in Mrs. Hem Nolini Judah v. Mrs. Isolyne Sarojbashini Bose (MANU/SC/0399/1962 : AIR 1962 SC 1471) : 1962 All LJ 695 : ILR (1962) 2 All 683 has held that Section 213 acts as a bar to the establishment of rights under a Will by an executor or a legatee, unless probate or letters of administration of the Will have been obtained and that it is immaterial whether the right is claimed as the plaintiff or as a defendant. Thus the bar comes into play only when a right as an executor or a legatee under a Will is sought to be established. However an unprobated will can be admitted in evidence for collateral purposes in any proceeding other than a probate proceeding. This position is made clear in several decisions and also in the decision reported in John Guruprakasham's case (see also Mr. Sen's Indian Succession Act, 1955, second edition p. 425). As under law an executor is competent to administer the estate even without grant of probate, it has to be held that to maintain an application for his removal probate of the Will is not a condition precedent. The proceeding to remove an executor cannot be considered to be proceeding for establishment of right of an executor or a legatee. In the present case it is undisputed that the petitioners and respondent have been appointed as executors under the Will and that they have accepted executorship. As such it cannot be said that the petition is not maintainable under Section 301 only on the ground that probate of the Will has till not been granted.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Miscellaneous Petition No. 38 of 2011 in Testamentary Suit No. 9 of 2007 in Testamentary Petition No. 223 of 2006
Decided On: 14.12.2016

 Radhika Bhargava  Vs.  Arjun Sahgal and Ors.


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
G.S. Patel, J.


Citation: 2017 (1) ALLMR 652
Print Page

Tuesday, 3 April 2012

The Word "Terms" as used in section 91 and 92 of evidence act

The expression "terms" in sec 91 and 92 of evidence act must relate to statements assertions or representations contained in written contract which relates to subject matter of contract and something to be done or not to be done under the contract and has no application to a provision in the nature of condition precedent to a very existence or formation of a contract.
Bombay High Court

P.B. Bhatt And Ors. vs V.R. Thakkar And Ors. on 27 July, 1971

Equivalent citations: AIR 1972 Bom 365, (1972) 74 BOMLR 509
Bench: Vimadalal

Print Page