Showing posts with label terms. Show all posts
Showing posts with label terms. Show all posts

Sunday, 7 October 2018

Whether new tenancy is created by attornment of tenancy?

 I shall first deal with the legal effect of attornment on the rights of the parties. What is attornment? The dictionary meaning of the word is "Transfer; legal acknowledgment of new landlord" (Oxford Dictionary). It is an overt act by which the tenant acknowledges and accepts the new person as the Landlord in the place of the old Landlord. It has no impact on the lease except for the substitution of one landlord for another and the terms and incidents thereof continue and operate. It does not bring about a new tenancy or lease; nor does it destroy the existing one, or alter the rights and obligations of the lessor and the lessee prevailing at the moment of the attornment.

12. In a very early English decision Cornish v. Searell, (1828) 8 B & C 471, Holroyd, J. observed:

"The attornment is the act of the tenant's putting one person in the place of another as his landlord."
Halsbury in his Laws of England Vol. 23, 3rd Edn. page 408, observed as follows:

"Where the occupier is a tenant and agrees to hold of a new landlord during the currency of the agreement without any change in the terms of the tenancy, this is a mere attornment."

In Words and Phrases, Permanent Edn. Vol. IV page 798, attomment is defined as follows:

"Attornment is the act of recognising a new landlord.... An attornment is a continuation of an existing lease on the same conditions in all respects, putting another in the place of the original landlord. Any act done by a tenant whereby he recognises a change of the person to whom rent is due is an attomment, and an agreement to pay rent to an assignee of the lease is such an act."
In Corpus Juris Secundum, Vol. 51, p. 527 it is observed:

"An attornment in effect is a continuation of an existing lease, and the tenant holds on the same conditions as under the former landlord; the tenant's possession is that of the new owner.... An attornment is not the creation or initiation of a new lease, beginning on the day of attornment, since a new tenancy arises only on departure from the time and conditions in the original lease."
13. Whatever shows the assent of the tenant to the alienation of the reversion and his recognition of the alienee as landlord is a valid attornment. A promise to pay rent to the alienee and a tenant's continued occupancy under the tenancy with notice of alienation amounts to a recognition of the purchaser as his landlord. There is no difficulty in this case to hold that there has been a valid attornment by the tenant to the purchasers. But having regard to the legal concept of attornment as elucidated by the references cited above, it does not create by itself a new tenancy between the parties to the attornment but continues the existing lease with the substitution of a new landlord in the place of the old landlord.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS

Civil Revn. Petn. No. 870 of 1959

Decided On: 31.05.1960

Munavar Basha Vs. V. Narayanan and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Jagadisan, J.

Citation : AIR 1961 Mad 200

Print Page

Thursday, 28 April 2016

When oral evidence shall not prevail over terms and conditions mentioned in contract?

The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that
the Courts below have not considered circumstances that there
is only oral evidence of plaintiff and there is nothing in rebuttal
in respect of the oral evidence. He submitted that when
evidence is given that plaintiff had approached Smt. Mathurabai
and Mathurabai had given assurance to execute the sale deed,
this unrebutted evidence ought to have been considered by the
Courts below and it ought to have been held that the remedy
was still in existence. This submission is not at all acceptable.
When the terms and conditions of the contract were embodied in
the document and there was condition like fixing of time of
performance, not much importance can be given to the oral
evidence of plaintiff though it is unrebutted.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT BOMBAY
APPELLATE SIDE, BENCH AT AURANGABAD
SECOND APPEAL NO. 183 OF 2015
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 4815 OF 2015
Dr. Miss Kunda d/o. Khemraj Choudhary ..
V
Smt. Mathurabai w/o. Mahadu Jadhav
(Deceased) and others 

CORAM : T.V. NALAWADE, J.
DATED : 1st September, 2015.
Citation;2016(2) ALLMR203,2016(3) MHLJ602
Print Page

Friday, 10 October 2014

Whether any term or condition by implication can be imported into contract?

It is well established that where a contract is in writing no unexpressed condition should, however, be considered as implied in the contract except such term as was necessary in order to give the transaction such efficacy as both parties must have in all reason Intended it to have.
The general rule is that if the contract can be fulfilled as it stands and is effective no term or condition by implication should be imported-into it simply because it may seem reasonable that there should have been such a term in the contract.
In case of the contracts before me I am unable to see anything which permits of any such implied condition being read in the contracts as having been in the contemplation of the parties. The obligation to perform the contracts appears to me to be unconditional and absolute. To put a different construction on these words and to permit them to control the obligation created by the two contracts would be virtually to make out a new contract for the parties.
Bombay High Court
Navnital & Co. And Ors. vs Kishanchand & Co. on 11 July, 1955
Equivalent citations: AIR 1956 Bom 151
Bench: Desai
Print Page

Tuesday, 3 April 2012

The Word "Terms" as used in section 91 and 92 of evidence act

The expression "terms" in sec 91 and 92 of evidence act must relate to statements assertions or representations contained in written contract which relates to subject matter of contract and something to be done or not to be done under the contract and has no application to a provision in the nature of condition precedent to a very existence or formation of a contract.
Bombay High Court

P.B. Bhatt And Ors. vs V.R. Thakkar And Ors. on 27 July, 1971

Equivalent citations: AIR 1972 Bom 365, (1972) 74 BOMLR 509
Bench: Vimadalal

Print Page