Showing posts with label conduct of accused. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conduct of accused. Show all posts

Sunday, 29 December 2024

Under which circumstances the conduct of accused becomes additional link in the chain of circumstances for convicting him?

Circumstance No. 4 : Conduct under Section 8 of the Evidence Act:

24. Irrespective of the admissibility of the discovery, panchnama (Exh.18) and the recovery panchnama Exh. 21 and irrespective of the admissibility of the recovery of the clothes of the deceased on the statement of the accused, we find that the conduct of the appellant in leading the investigation team and the panchas and pointing out where the apparel of the deceased was hidden would be admissible. In this case PW-17, the Investigating Officer has clearly deposed that the accused showed willingness to show the place where he had thrown the clothes. PW-17, his team and the panchas reached by walking to the place as indicated by the accused. This Court in A.N. Venkatesh v. State of Karnataka (2005) 7 SCC 714 relying on Prakash Chand v. State (Delhi Admn.), (1979) 3 SCC 90 held as under:

“9. By virtue of Section 8 of the Evidence Act, the conduct of the accused person is relevant, if such conduct influences or is influenced by any fact in issue or relevant fact. The evidence of the circumstance, simpliciter, that the accused pointed out to the police officer, the place where the dead body of the kidnapped boy was found and on their pointing out the body was exhumed, would be admissible as conduct under Section 8 irrespective of the fact whether the statement made by the accused contemporaneously with or antecedent to such conduct falls within the purview of Section 27 or not as held by this Court in Prakash Chand v. State (Delhi Admn.) [(1979) 3 SCC 90 : 1979 SCC (Cri) 656 : AIR 1979 SC 400]. Even if we hold that the disclosure statement made by the accused-appellants (Exts. P-15 and P-16) is not admissible under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, still it is relevant under Section 8. The evidence of the investigating officer and PWs 1, 2, 7 and PW 4 the spot mahazar witness that the accused had taken them to the spot and pointed out the place where the dead body was buried, is an admissible piece of evidence under Section 8 as the conduct of the accused. Presence of A-1 and A-2 at a place where ransom demand was to be fulfilled and their action of fleeing on spotting the police party is a relevant circumstance and are admissible under Section 8 of the Evidence Act.”

We take this as an additional link in the chain of circumstances.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

(Before B.R. Gavai, Aravind Kumar and K.V. Viswanathan, JJ.)

Criminal Appeal Nos. _________ of 2024

(@ Special Leave Petition (Crl.) Nos. 9015-9016 of 2019)

Sambhubhai Raisangbhai Padhiyar Vs State of Gujarat 

Decided on December 17, 2024

Citation: 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3769,2024 INSC 987.

Print Page

Saturday, 25 May 2024

Supreme Court: Even if disclosure statement made by Accused is not admissible U/S 27 of Evidence Act but it is relevant U/S 8 of evidence Act as his conduct

 e) The conduct of the Appellant in leading the Investigating Officer and others to a drain nearby his house and the discovery of the knife from the drain is a relevant fact Under Section 8 of the Evidence Act. In other words, the evidence of the circumstance simpliciter that the Appellant pointed out to the Investigating Officer the place where he threw away the weapon of offence i.e., knife would be admissible as 'conduct' Under Section 8 irrespective of the fact whether the statement made by the Accused contemporaneously with or antecedent to such conduct falls within the purview of Section 27 of the Evidence Act.


59. Even while discarding the evidence in the form of discovery panchnama, the conduct of the Appellant herein would be relevant Under Section 8 of the Evidence Act. The evidence of discovery would be admissible as conduct Under Section 8 of the Evidence Act quite apart from the admissibility of the disclosure statement Under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, as this Court observed in A.N. Venkatesh and Anr. v. State of Karnataka,   MANU/SC/0468/2005 : (2005) 7 SCC 714:


9. By virtue of Section 8 of the Evidence Act, the conduct of the Accused person is relevant, if such conduct influences or is influenced by any fact in issue or relevant fact. The evidence of the circumstance, simpliciter, that the Accused pointed out to the police officer, the place where the dead body of the kidnapped boy was found and on their pointing out the body was exhumed, would be admissible as conduct Under Section 8 irrespective of the fact whether the statement made by the Accused contemporaneously with or antecedent to such conduct falls within the purview of Section 27 or not as held by this Court in Prakash Chand v. State (Delhi Admn.) [  MANU/SC/0147/1978 : 1978:INSC:234 : (1979) 3 SCC 90: 1979 SCC (Cri) 656: AIR 1979 SC 400]. Even if we hold that the disclosure statement made by the Accused-Appellants (Ex. P-15 and P-16) is not admissible Under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, still it is relevant Under Section 8. ...

The conduct, in order to be admissible, must be such that it has close nexus with a fact in issue or relevant fact. Explanation 1 makes it clear that the mere statements as distinguished from acts do not constitute "conduct" unless those statements "accompany and explain acts other than statements". Such statements accompanying the acts are considered to be evidence of res gestae. 

206. We have already noticed the distinction highlighted in Prakash Chand case (supra) between the conduct of an Accused which is admissible Under Section 8 and the statement made to a police officer in the course of an investigation which is hit by Section 162 Code of Criminal Procedure The evidence of the circumstance, simpliciter, that the Accused pointed out to the police officer, the place where stolen articles or weapons used in the commission of the offence were hidden, would be admissible as "conduct" Under Section 8 irrespective of the fact whether the statement made by the Accused contemporaneously with or antecedent to such conduct, falls within the purview of Section 27, as pointed out in Prakash Chand case. In Om Prakash case (supra) this Court held that: (SCC p.262, para 14)


Even apart from the admissibility of the information Under Section 27, the evidence of the investigating officer and the panchas that the Accused had taken them to PW 11 (from whom he purchased the weapon) and pointed him out and as corroborated by PW 11 himself would be admissible Under Section 8 of the Evidence Act as conduct of the Accused.

(Emphasis supplied)


61. However, in the aforesaid context, we would like to sound a note of caution. Although the conduct of an Accused may be a relevant fact Under Section 8 of the Evidence Act, yet the same, by itself, cannot be a ground to convict him or hold him guilty and that too, for a serious offence like murder. Like any other piece of evidence, the conduct of an Accused is also one of the circumstances which the court may take into consideration along with the other evidence on record, direct or indirect. What we are trying to convey is that the conduct of the Accused alone, though may be relevant Under Section 8 of the Evidence Act, cannot form the basis of conviction.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 437 of 2015

Decided On: 03.05.2024

Anees Vs. The State Govt. of NCT

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, C.J.I., J.B. Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, JJ.

Author: J.B. Pardiwala, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0379/2024,2024 INSC 368.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.Click here.

Print Page

Sunday, 27 August 2023

To what extent conduct of accused in relevant even if prosecution has failed to prove his discovery statement U/S 27 of Evidence Act?

 Even if we have to discard the evidence of discovery

on the ground that no independent witnesses were present

at the time of discovery, still the fact that the appellant

herein led the police party to his house and handed over the

ice pick used at the time of the assault, would be reflective

of his conduct. By virtue of Section 8 of the Evidence Act,

the conduct of an accused is relevant, if such conduct

influences or influenced by any fact in issue or relevant fact.

The evidence of the circumstance, simpliciter, that the

accused pointed out to the police officer, the place where he

had concealed the weapon of offence i.e. ice pick, would be

admissible as conduct under Section 8 irrespective of the

fact whether the statement made by the appellant convict

contemporaneously with or antecedent to such conduct

falls within the purview of Section 27 of the Evidence Act or

not. Even if we hold that the discovery statement made by

the appellant convict referred to above is not admissible

under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, still it is relevant

under Section 8 of the Evidence Act. {Para 78}

2023INSC765

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1554 OF 2015

MUKESH SINGH Vs THE STATE (NCT OF DELHI) 

Author: J.B. PARDIWALA, J. :

Dated: AUGUST 24, 2023.

Read full Judgment here: Click here

Print Page

Thursday, 27 December 2018

Whether conduct of accused is admissible in evidence?

 It is a settled legal position that the facts need not be self-probatory and the word "fact" as contemplated in Section 27 of the Evidence Act is not limited to "actual physical material object". The discovery of fact arises by reason of the fact that the information given by the Accused exhibited the knowledge or the mental awareness of the informant as to its existence at a particular place. It includes a discovery of an object, the place from which it is produced and the knowledge of the Accused as to its existence. It will be useful to advert to the exposition in the case of Vasanta Sampat Dupare v. State of Maharashtra MANU/SC/1098/2014 : (2015) 1 SCC 253, in particular, paragraphs 23 to 29 thereof. The same read thus:

23. While accepting or rejecting the factors of discovery, certain principles are to be kept in mind. The Privy Council in Pulukuri Kotayya v. King Emperor MANU/PR/0049/1946 : AIR 1947 PC 67 has held thus: (IA p. 77)

...it is fallacious to treat the 'fact discovered' within the Section as equivalent to the object produced; the fact discovered embraces the place from which the object is produced and the knowledge of the Accused as to this, and the information given must relate distinctly to this fact. Information as to past user, or the past history, of the object produced is not related to its discovery in the setting in which it is discovered. Information supplied by a person in custody that 'I will produce a knife concealed in the roof of my house' does not lead to the discovery of a knife; knives were discovered many years ago. It leads to the discovery of the fact that a knife is concealed in the house of the informant to his knowledge, and if the knife is proved to have been used in the commission of the offence, the fact discovered is very relevant. But if to the statement the words be added 'with which I stabbed A', these words are inadmissible since they do not relate to the discovery of the knife in the house of the informant.


12. The expression 'provided that' together with the phrase 'whether it amounts to a confession or not' show that the Section is in the nature of an exception to the preceding provisions particularly Sections 25 and 26. It is not necessary in this case to consider if this Section qualifies, to any extent, Section 24, also. It will be seen that the first condition necessary for bringing this Section into operation is the discovery of a fact, albeit a relevant fact, in consequence of the information received from a person Accused of an offence. The second is that the discovery of such fact must be deposed to. The third is that at the time of the receipt of the information the Accused must be in police custody. The last but the most important condition is that only 'so much of the information' as relates distinctly to the fact thereby discovered is admissible. The rest of the information has to be excluded. The word 'distinctly' means 'directly', 'indubitably', 'strictly', 'unmistakably'. The word has been advisedly used to limit and define the scope of the provable information. The phrase 'distinctly relates to the fact thereby discovered' is the linchpin of the provision. This phrase refers to that part of the information supplied by the Accused which is the direct and immediate cause of the discovery. The reason behind this partial lifting of the ban against confessions and statements made to the police, is that if a fact is actually discovered in consequence of information given by the Accused, it affords some guarantee of truth of that part, and that part only, of the information which was the clear, immediate and proximate cause of the discovery. No such guarantee or assurance attaches to the rest of the statement which may be indirectly or remotely related to the fact discovered.

13. At one time it was held that the expression 'fact discovered' in the Section is restricted to a physical or material fact which can be perceived by the senses, and that it does not include a mental fact (see Sukhan v. Emperor MANU/LA/0128/1929 : AIR 1929 Lah 344; Ganu Chandra Kashid v. Emperor MANU/MH/0264/1931 : AIR 1932 Bom 286). Now it is fairly settled that the expression 'fact discovered' includes not only the physical object produced, but also the place from which it is produced and the knowledge of the Accused as to this (see Pulukuri Kotayya v. King Emperor4; Udai Bhan v. State of U.P. MANU/SC/0144/1962 : AIR 1962 SC 1116 : (1962) 2 Cri. LJ 251 : 1962 Supp (2) SCR 830).

(Emphasis in original)

27. In the case at hand, as is perceptible, the recovery had taken place when the Appellant was Accused of an offence, he was in custody of a police officer, the recovery had taken place in consequence of information furnished by him and the panch witnesses have supported the seizure and nothing has been brought on record to discredit their testimony.

28. Additionally, another aspect can also be taken note of. The fact that the Appellant had led the police officer to find out the spot where the crime was committed, and the tap where he washed the clothes eloquently speak of his conduct as the same is admissible in evidence to establish his conduct. In this context we may refer with profit to the authority in Prakash Chand v. State (Delhi Admn.) MANU/SC/0147/1978 : (1979) 3 SCC 90 wherein the Court after referring to the decision in H.P. Admn. v. Om Prakash MANU/SC/0118/1971 : (1972) 1 SCC 249 held thus: (Prakash Chand case, SCC p. 95, para 8)

8. ... There is a clear distinction between the conduct of a person against whom an offence is alleged, which is admissible Under Section 8 of the Evidence Act, if such conduct is influenced by any fact in issue or relevant fact and the statement made to a police officer in the course of an investigation which is hit by Section 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. What is excluded by Section 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is the statement made to a police officer in the course of investigation and not the evidence relating to the conduct of an Accused person (not amounting to a statement) when confronted or questioned by a police officer during the course of an investigation. For example, the evidence of the circumstance, simpliciter, that an Accused person led a police officer and pointed out the place where stolen articles or weapons which might have been used in the commission of the offence were found hidden, would be admissible as conduct, Under Section 8 of the Evidence Act, irrespective of whether any statement by the Accused contemporaneously with or antecedent to such conduct falls within the purview of Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1617 of 2011

Decided On: 24.10.2018

Asar Mohammad  Vs.  The State of U.P.
Print Page

Sunday, 26 June 2016

Whether conduct of accused taking press conference is relevant in his prosecution?

PW-41, the investigating officer of the case has
categorically stated in the trial that:
“In course of my investigation I tried my level best to
examine the accused Sushil Choudhury. But he was
not willing to give statement about the incident
which took place in his complex.”
 On the other hand, the appellant held a press
conference for declaring some ex-gratia payment to the bereaved
family and reward for the person who would trace out the
assailants. The purpose was to dispel the cloud of suspicion
around him. Such post conduct of the appellant is relevant and
admissible under Section 8 of the Evidence Act.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A G A R T A L A
CRL.A (J) No.28 of 2014
Sri Sushil Choudhury  V The State of Tripura


BEFORE
 CHIEF JUSTICE MR. DEEPAK GUPTA
 MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA

Dated: 10.12.2015

Citation: 2016 CRLJ(NOC)157 TRI
Print Page