Showing posts with label construction permission. Show all posts
Showing posts with label construction permission. Show all posts

Wednesday, 24 May 2023

Can a trespasser claim that their construction is authorized if they have performed construction after obtaining permission?

Further this Court in the case of Mr. G.S.J. Shapoorjee v. Allahabad Development Authority & Ors., 2016 11 ADJ 524 has held in paragraph 45, 46, 56, 57 and 58 as under:-


45. ........Mere fact that map was sanctioned and thereafter constructions were raised, would make no difference for the reason that all transactions were void ab initio. The petitioners had no right over land, they were unauthorised occupants, hence question of making construction by getting a map sanctioned by ADA does not arise at all. Any act of ADA would not create any legal right in favour of petitioners which otherwise they also do not possess.
46....... A trespasser is not entitled to get sanction and raise constructions on a land over which it has no right,so as to create right over land. The entire things are illegal and void ab initio. {Para 41}

 ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT

Case :- WRIT - C No. - 6183 of 2016

 D.B. Kauser Vs  State Of U.P. And 4 Others

Coram: Hon'ble Kshitij Shailendra,J.
Delivered on 10.05.2023.
Neutral Citation No.-2023:AHC:102783.
Read full Judgment here: Click here
Print Page

Wednesday, 31 August 2022

Can Municipality refuse to issue an occupancy certificate if the building was constructed after obtaining construction permission?

 In the circumstances, this Court is of the firm view

that when a citizen makes an application for Occupancy

Certificate in respect of a building which was constructed as

per a valid Building Permit issued prior to 30.12.2017, the

respondents cannot take umbrage under Section 14 to deny

Occupancy Certificate to the building on the ground that the

land where the construction is made is a paddy land or

wetland. {Para 14}

15. In view of the above, the petitioners are entitled to

relief. The respondent-Municipality is therefore directed to

issue Occupancy Certificate to the building constructed by the

petitioner in WP(C) No.25545/2020, if the petitioner is

otherwise eligible, within a period of one month.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

WP(C) NO. 25545 OF 2020

USHA RAJAN Vs  TRIPUNITHURA MUNICIPALITY

PRESENT

 MR.JUSTICE N.NAGARESH

Dated this the 11th day of August, 2022

Print Page

Tuesday, 28 December 2021

Whether plaintiff can claim that he has deemed permission for construction if he intends to carry out construction in the flood line?

 However, so far as the present matter is concerned, it has to be held that the construction of theatre by Respondent No. 3 in CTS No. 417 is within the prohibited area. He had no authority to construct such theatre. He has faulted the provisions of the M.R.T.P.Act and the M.M.Act. There was no valid permission for construction of the theatre. No permission could have been granted for construction of the theatre by the Municipal Council, Rahuri. Furthermore, even taking into consideration the provisions of section 5(b) of the Cinema Regulation Act, no licence can be issued for having a cinema theatre in that building, because it is not safe place to have cinema theatre. In such circumstance, the licence has to be revoked. So also, the building has to be demolished.{Para 67}

68. The learned Counsel for Respondent No. 3 has argued that this floodline is only imaginary line. No proper survey was made before drawing the floodline. There were no floods since 1947 in the area, where the floodline is provided for; and in such circumstances, merely on technicalities, the reliefs sought in the writ petition should not be allowed. However, we do not agree with this argument. It is amply brought on record that the concerned authorities had taken the survey, especially by the Engineers of the Irrigation Department. The Government also considered the matter on every aspect; and though at one stage, the Government was thinking of removing the floodlines, after reconsideration of the entire matter, decided to retain the floodlines and then the Notification of 1981 was issued. It is a precautionary measure taken by the Government for the safety of the residents of Rahuri town. There were no floods in the past, that does not mean that the precautionary measures be thrown to winds. The construction is unauthorised construction and it has to be treated like that.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY(AURANGABAD BENCH)

V.K. BARDE AND D.S. ZOTING, JJ.

Vithal Ramchandra Devkhar & Anr. Vs. The State Of Maharashtra & Ors.

Writ Petition No. 187 of 1989

18th January, 2001

Citation: 2001(3) ALL MR 872

Print Page

Sunday, 26 December 2021

Whether municipal Corporation must hear applicant before deciding application for grant of construction permission?

  Mr. Aney the learned counsel for the respondent no.7 countered this argument by saying that action under section 45 is to sanction and what is required by Planning Authority is to see that the development plan as put in with the application under section 44 conforms to the requirements of law, rules, instructions, byelaws etc, framed in that behalf by the Planning authority. That being a pure administrative action there is no question of principles of natural justice being attracted in the consideration of the application under section 45. We are unable to accept the submission of Mr. Tulzapurkar that section 45 postulates grant of hearing of the objectors. Firstly because the process of granting application under that section is purely a mechanical and administrative process. The authority has to process the application for development and on finding it to be in conformity with the requirements of law grant it, and if they are not in conformity, it will be rejected. There is therefore no room for granting any hearing to any person. The provisions of section 45 if read in whole, do not contemplate hearing even to the person applying under section 44 and the only remedy available to such person after the order is made is that, without hearing as contemplated by section 45, it will have to be held that both the applicant and the objectors if any, are entitled to hearing. The very fact that no such hearing as contemplated by provisions of section 45 is evident from the fact that the appeal is made available to persons aggrieved by grant of or refusal of permission under that section. In our opinion putting such prayer under section 45 is also hazard or to put in objections in various multi crore development plan the claim demand and delaying the execution of the development scheme. Such is not the intention of section 45 and therefore we reject the submission that it postulates the hearing. {Para 16}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

V.G. PALSHIKAR AND P.V. KAKADE, JJ.

The Raja Bahadur Motilal Poona Mills Ltd. & Anr. Vs. State Of Maharashtra & Ors.

Print Page

Friday, 12 November 2021

Whether civil court has jurisdiction to try suit for cancellation of construction permission granted by Municipal Corporation?

 Looking to the Court Fee clause of the suit as well as the prayers of the suit reproduced above, it is quite clear that the only relief sought is to cancel the construction permission given to Defendant No.3 and "in consequences of cancellation/suspension" of permission the mandatory injunction to remove structure and further perpetual injunction is claimed that Defendant No.3 should not do any construction at the suit property.

20. I have gone through the impugned order passed by the trial Court. Trial Court referred to the Rulings and in Para 22 of its order, in a cryptic manner observed that the plaintiff was seeking relief in respect of construction permission raising objections in respect of title and not considering the same by Corporation while granting construction permission. Trial Court then went on to observe that the question raised could be decided only by the Civil Court and observed that the Plaintiff is claiming the relief about the title which affects on the construction permission of the suit property. Thus only because plaintiff refers to his title, the trial Court has presumed that the suit was maintainable without seeing the substance of the Suit and prayer clauses and the fact that the suit did not at all claim declaration of title nor Court Fee was paid by the plaintiff. Thus, I find that the order passed by the trial Court is not maintainable.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

A. I. S. CHEEMA, J.

M/s. Arihant Construction Vs. Shri Subhash Kesharmal Barlota & Ors.

Civil Revision Application No.132 of 2014

20th March, 2015.

Citation: 2015(5) ALL MR 23

Print Page

Friday, 24 May 2013

Construction permission can not be cancelled on basis of inspection extracts of Municipal Corporation.


 The Repair Board was moved by a complainant. The grievance of the Petitioners is that the complainant was motivated by an animus of a personal nature against the Petitioners. Once circumstances were drawn to the notice of the Repair Board warranting further enquiry, it was justified in verifying the basis on which the no objection certificate was issued in the first instance. For the reasons that we have indicated, the Repair Board would not be correct in revoking the list certified earlier purely on the basis of the inspection extracts of 
the Municipal Corporation. That is one aspect which can be borne in mind by the Repair Board but it would have to be considered together with all the documentary material that may be available. The Petitioners have relied upon other documentary evidence including the records of the Registrar of Companies, Licenses under the Shops and Establishments Act, Sales Tax and Service Tax documents, Registration papers, Bank statements and Income Tax returns and PAN cards. The Petitioners would be at liberty to produce them before the Chief Officer of the Repair Board. The impugned communication dated 10 November 2008 has been issued purely on the basis of inspection extract of the Municipal Corporation.

Bombay High Court
Dahyabhai Papers & Boards Pvt.Ltd vs Maharashtra Housing And Area ... on 21 August, 2012
Bench: Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, A.A. Sayed

Print Page