Showing posts with label dependency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dependency. Show all posts

Thursday, 1 August 2024

Bombay HC: Motor accident claim tribunal should not grant compensation as per apportionment provided by personal law of the parties but must grant compensation as per their dependency

Shri Kazi, the learned Counsel appearing for the appellants, submitted that as per the principles of Mohammedan law, appellant No. 1 father Abdul Raheman being the heir of deceased Mohammed Shafi is entitled to half of the total compensation and mother and widow to the extent of 1/4th each. We gave anxious consideration on this aspect. However, the compensation is being paid taking into consideration the dependency of the claimants. We are of the opinion that we are not guided by the apportionment as provided under the Mohammedan law. 

{Para 5}

6. Appellant No. I father Abdul Raheman is aged 61 whereas mother of deceased is aged about 43. At the time of incident, appellant No. 3 Shahnazbanu was hardly aged about 28. Her dependency is comparatively more than appellants Nos. 1 and 2, taking into consideration her age. We, therefore, feel that it would be just and reasonable to pay half of the amount of compensation to appellant No. 3 and rest of the amount in equal share i.e. 1/4th to each appellant No. 1 and 2.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Decided On: 30.11.1988

Abdul Rahman and Ors. Vs. Dayaram and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

M.M. Qazi and Ashok A. Desai, JJ.

Author: Ashok A. Desai, J.

Citation: 1989 (2) T.A.C. 423, 1(1989)ACC226,  MANU/MH/0742/1988.

Print Page

Thursday, 23 May 2024

Kerala HC: Legal representatives of deceased are not entitled to claim compensation u/s163­A of the Motor vehicles Act.

  Under Section 163A, the persons who are entitled to apply for compensation are the legal heirs, in the case of death of a person and in the case of injury, the victim. Once a claim is made under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, then application for compensation can be filed by the persons enumerated in the section, namely the person who sustained injury, by the owner of the property, where the death has resulted from the accident, by all or any of the legal representatives of the deceased, or by any agent duly authorised by the person injured or all or any of the legal representatives of the deceased, as the case may be. There is wide difference in the words used in both the sections regarding the persons entitled to apply for compensation in the case of death of a person, who died in a motor vehicle accident. Under Section 166, in the case of death, the persons entitled to claim compensation are the legal representatives of the deceased. But in the case of a claim under Section 163A, the persons entitled to claim compensation are the legal heirs. Further, in the case of 166, even if, a person is not a legal heir, if he is able to prove that, he/she is a dependant of the deceased, then irrespective of the fact, whether he/she is a legal heir or not, is entitled to claim compensation, in proportion to the extent of dependency claimed by him/her. In such cases, the dependency will have some relevance for the purpose of assessing compensation. But for a claim under Section 163A, the dependency has no relevancy, because the persons who are entitled to file an application for compensation for the death of the deceased are the legal heirs and not the legal representatives. Once it is proved by the appellants that, they are legal heirs of the deceased then, in a claim under Section 163A, they are entitled to claim compensation for the death of the deceased. Legal representatives include legal heirs as well and not vice versa.{Para 6}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA

M.A.C.A. No. 896 of 2008

Decided On: 18.10.2013

Kadeeja and Ors. Vs. Managing Director, KSRTC, Tvm and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S. Siri Jagan and K. Ramakrishnan, JJ.

Author: K. Ramakrishnan, J.

Citation: 2014 ACJ 1492 (Ker)­, MANU/KE/1078/2013.

Print Page

Saturday, 23 July 2016

Whether claimants can seek compensation under motor accident claim petition without proving their dependency over deceased?

 Thus from the aforesaid, it is clear that the aspect of dependency
has to be pleaded and proved by the claimants before any compensation is
granted to them.   As noted above, only the original  claimant No.2 had
examined himself.   There was no other evidence on record.   The original
claimant No.2 had opposed the addition of Farzana and Shoeb as claimants.
After   being   added   as   claimants,     these   two   claimants   did   not   lead   any
evidence to indicate their dependency on Haroon.   Moreover, the rejection
of the claim for compensation has been challenged only by the subsequently

added claimants and not by the original claimant No.2.  Thus in absence of
any evidence whatsoever that the appellants were dependent upon Haroon,
the prayer for grant of compensation to them cannot be granted.   There is in
fact no legal basis whatsoever to grant such compensation.  By applying the
ratio of the judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court in  Gujarat State
Transport   Corporation  (supra),   it   is   held   that   there   is   no   justification
whatsoever which would be in consonance with principles of justice, equity
and good conscience to grant compensation to the appellants.  
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
 FIRST APPEAL NO.199 OF 2007
 Farzana d/o Abbas Bhai 
     
­vs
Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation, 

CORAM  : A.S.CHANDURKAR, J. 
Citation:2016(3) ALLMR870                    

Date on which judgment is pronounced    :  29th April, 2016 

Print Page