Showing posts with label direct evidence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label direct evidence. Show all posts

Saturday, 26 May 2012

Whether execution or authorship of a document can be proved by circumstantial evidence?

Documents can be proved like any other fact by direct as well as circumstantial evidence although the circumstantial evidence must be of sufficient strength to carry conviction.
30. In - 'S. H. Jhabawala v. Emperor' AIR 1933 All 690 (D), Sulaiman C.J. at p. 704 says as follows:
...the execution or authorship of a 'document' is a question of fact and may be proved like 'any other fact. In such a case:
(a) A document may be 'proved' as defined in Section 3 when the Court considers its existence so probable that a prudent man ought, under the circumstances, to act upon the supposition that it was written by the person alleged to be its author even though no direct proof of his handwriting is given,
(b) thus a document may be proved both: (i) by the direct evidence, and (ii) by circumstantial evidence.
31. This question was considered earlier in - 'Barindra Kumar v. Emperor' 37 Cal 467 (E) where Carnduff J. held that execution and authorship of a document is a question of fact and can be proved like any other fact and that handwriting, in addition of usual methods of proof can be proved by circumstantial evidence under Section 67, Evidence Act which prescribes no particular kind of proof. Recently the aforesaid Calcutta case appears to have been followed in - 'Gover-dhan Das y. Ahmadi Begam' AIR 1953 Hyd 181 (F) by PalnitKar and Deshpande JJ. although the report mentions - 'Ashutosh v, Nalinakshya' AIR 1937 Cal 467 (G).
32. Section 3, Evidence Act gives the definition of the term 'proved' as follows:
A fact is said to be proved when, after considering the matters before it the Court either believes it to exist, or considers its existence so probable that a prudent man ought, under the circumstances of the particular case, to act upon the supposition that it exists." Section 67, Evidence Act lays down:
If a document is alleged to be signed or to have been written wholly or in part by any person, the signature or the handwriting of so much of the document as is alleged to be in that person's handwriting must be proved to be in his handwriting.
33. Reading the two sections together it is clear that Section 67 does not lay down any specific mode of proof and circumstantial evidence, as a mode of proof of authorship or execution of documents, is not excluded.

Madhya Pradesh High Court

Krishnabiharilal vs State on 8 December, 1954
Equivalent citations: 1956 CriLJ 233

Bench: Nevaskar, Chaturvedi, A Khan
Print Page