Showing posts with label proof of document. Show all posts
Showing posts with label proof of document. Show all posts

Sunday, 9 August 2026

Supreme Court: Mere Marking Of Document As Exhibit Is Not Proof Of Contents

 It is also settled law that mere marking of a document as an exhibit, is not a proof of the contents thereof. A Division Bench of this Court in LIC v. Ram Pal Singh Bisen2 had observed:{Para 11}

“25. We are of the firm opinion that mere admission of a document in evidence does not amount to its proof. In other words, mere marking of exhibit on a document does not dispense with its proof, which is requiredto be done in accordance with law.

31. Under the law of evidence also, it is necessary that contents of documents are required to be proved either by primary or by secondary evidence. At the most, admission of documents may amount to admission of contents but not its truth. Documents having not been produced and marked as required under the Evidence Act cannot be relied upon by the court. Contents of the document cannot be proved by merely filing in a court.”

NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026

S. SANGEETHA & ORS Vs  TMT. P. PONNI 

Author: SANJAY KAROL, J.

Dated: August 07, 2026

Citation: 2026 INSC 813

Print Page

Sunday, 10 May 2026

Supreme Court: Whether the court can permit Accused to Exhibit Documents as per S.294 CrPC, Already Part Of Chargesheet Without Formal Proof Of Signature?

 In order to duly appreciate the provisions of

Section 294 Cr.P.C., it is necessary to refer to the

provision which is reproduced as under:

“294. No formal proof of certain

documents.—(1) Where any document is

filed before any Court by the

prosecution or the accused, the

particulars of every such document

shall be included in a list and the

prosecution or the accused, as the case

may be, or the pleader for the

prosecution or the accused, if any,

shall be called upon to admit or deny

the genuineness of each such document.

(2) The list of documents shall be in

such form as be prescribed by the State

Government.

(3) Where the genuineness of any

document is not disputed, such document

may be read in evidence in inquiry,

trial or other proceeding under this

Code without proof of the signature of

the person to whom it purports to be

signed:

Provided that the Court may, in its

discretion, require such signature to

be proved.”{Para 4}

5) After perusal thereof, it cannot be doubted

that in case any document has been filed by the

prosecution or the accused in any Court, such

document is required to be included in a list. The

genuineness of the documents included in the list

can be ascertained by the Court by calling upon the

prosecution or the accused, as the case may be. If

such document is not disputed, it can be read in

inquiry, trial or other proceedings under Cr.P.C.

without proving the signature of the person to whom

it purports to be. As per proviso thereto, if

necessary, it is on the discretion of the Court to

require such signature to be proved, while applying

the provision of Section 294 (3) Cr.P.C.

6) In the facts of the present case, it is clear

that the documents as sought to be marked as

exhibits by the appellant are part of the

chargesheet and of documents produced by the

prosecution. The appellant, through averments made

in the application, contends that these documents

were included in the list of documents of

prosecution. Learned Additional Solicitor General,

appearing for the CBI, disputes this fact, but on

prima facie examination of the record, it suggests

that the documents sought by accused formed part of

the list of documents produced by CBI. Nevertheless,

we reserve the CBI’s liberty to raise this objection

at the appropriate stage before court.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. OF 2026

(Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 1383 of 2026)

R. GANESH Vs THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU 

Dated: April 27, 2026.

Print Page

Monday, 10 November 2025

Telangana HC: What is the appropriate method of proving medical certificate or post mortem report in Session trial if doctor who has issued that certificate or report is not available?

 The core contention of the learned counsel for the appellant/accused is that the doctor who examined the victim and allegedly issued Ex. P8-Medical report of the victim was not examined before the Court below to prove the contents of the same. Without formally proving Ex. P8-Medical report of the victim, which is tendered in evidence by PW. 11-investigation officer, the Court below erroneously took the same into consideration to come to a conclusion that PW. 2-victim was sexually assaulted by the appellant/accused. {Para 3}

4. We find force in the submission of the learned counsel for the appellant/accused. It is evident from the record that Ex. P8-Medical report of the victim was tendered in evidence by PW. 11-Investigation Officer in this case. It is settled law that mere marking of a document in evidence does not amount to its proof. Nor, mere marking of exhibit does not dispense with its proof, which is otherwise required to be done, in accordance with law. In medical jurisprudence, proof of writings and reports by any other person, than the real author of a document, should be by a 'competent person'. Such document should not be brought in evidence mechanically, only for the sake of empty formality, but, if taken in evidence, it should be meaningful and purposeful. In case of Injury Certificate/Wound Certificate/PME Certificate etc., the execution of such a document has to be proved by evidence of those technical/expert persons who can certify the contents of such document. It should be proved firstly by examining the doctor himself who issued the same; and if the said doctor is not found, the course available to the prosecution is to examine some other doctor from the same hospital, who knew the handwritings and signature of the doctor who issued the certificate in question. When the other doctor is examined who knew the handwritings and signature of the doctor who issued Ex. P8-medical report of the victim, he would have spoken about the contents of the medical report and the conclusions reached therein. In such an event, there would have been an opportunity to the appellant/accused to cross-examine the said doctor to answer the questions raised in relation to the commission of rape etc., and it would have been helpful to the Court to arrive at a just conclusion. Non-examination of the doctor who issued Ex. P.8-Medical report of the victim or any doctor working in the same hospital capable of identifying the handwritings and signature of the author of Ex. P8-medical report of the victim certainly causes prejudice to the appellant/accused. In the absence of such evidence, it is unsafe to act on Ex. P8-medical report of the victim.


5. Similar question came up for determination before the Hon'ble Jharkhand High Court in Sowam Kisku and others Vs. The State of Bihar MANU/JH/0542/2006 : 2006 Crl.L.J. 2526 wherein, the post mortem report of the deceased therein was sought to be proved by a Compounder attached to the hospital. Declining such practice, the Hon'ble Jharkhand High Court observed as follows:-


"8. We are unable to understand as to why the prosecution did not choose to examine the doctor. It is no doubt true that in spite of the steps taken, the prosecution could not procure the attendance of the doctor who conducted autopsy over the dead body, but that could not have precluded the prosecution from examining some other doctor from the same hospital who knew the handwriting and signature of the doctor who conducted autopsy. If any other doctor had been examined who knew the signature of the doctor who conducted the autopsy and if he had given evidence as to the nature of post mortem done and the injuries found by the doctor on the dead body, then the appellants could have had an opportunity of cross-examining the said doctor to say that the injuries suffered by the deceased are not fatal in nature and even if the deceased died on account of such injuries, the accused - appellants could have taken a defence to say that the said injuries are not sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause the death of the deceased or that the said injuries are only likely to cause the death. The prosecution by not examining the doctor denied the opportunity to the accused-appellants as they were prevented from cross-examining the doctor. Therefore, in absence of any evidence that Dugu Ram Kisku died due to homicidal violence, we cannot find the appellants guilty of murder."

IN THE HIGH COURT OF STATE OF TELANGANA

Criminal Appeal No. 244 of 2022 and IA No. 2 of 2022

Decided On: 22.08.2022

Manoj Kumar Mahanand Vs. State of Telangana

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Dr. Shameem Akther and E.V. Venugopal, JJ.

Author: Dr. Shameem Akther, J.

Citation: MANU/TL/2666/2022.

Print Page

Sunday, 30 March 2025

Supreme Court: Whether a party can say that a document is not proved if he has shown that document in cross- examination of other side witness?

His evidence was that the books were, systematically kept on 'mahajani' system in connection with the business. The witness proved the Khata, the raznamcha and the nakalbahi entries. In cross-examination of Gopi Kishan Saraugi it was suggested that the entry under the date 30 September, 1942 in the roznamcha was not written at the same time. The suggestion was that there was interpolation of the words "deposit karaya" in the roznamcha entry. In cross-examination of Padampat Singhania questions were asked about the rokar, khata, nakalbahi and roznamcha entries. Padampat Singhania said that the entry of Rs. 4,00,000 was not recorded in the daily cash book but was recorded in the roznamcha. He said that credit and debit entries were made in the roznamcha. Padampat Singhania said that the entries were made by Gopi Kishan Jaipuria who was in a dying condition at the time the witness gave evidence.

16. It was suggested to Padampat Singhania that the words "deposit karaya" in the roznamcha entry were not written at the same sitting. Padampat Singhania denied that, Counsel for the appellant contended that in the absence of Gopi Kishan Jaipuria the account books were not proved. This is unacceptable for two reasons. First, the account books were shown in cross-examination of Padampat Singhania and question were asked on the same. It is not open to the appellant to complain of lack of proof of account books when the documents are shown to the witness in cross-examination. 

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 2151 of 1966

Decided On: 21.01.1971

Ram Janki Devi and Ors. Vs. Juggilal Kamlapat

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

A.N. Ray and G.K. Mitter, JJ.

Author: A.N. Ray, J.

Citation: 1971:INSC:35 : 1971 (1) SCC 477, MANU/MH/1001/2025.

Print Page

Sunday, 5 January 2025

Supreme Court: Xerox copy of Income tax return is not admissible in Evidence in Motor accident claim petition

The fact is that, the Appellant had produced only the xerox copies of the Income Tax Returns of her parents, pertaining to the financial years 2003 to 2007. Indisputably, the Tribunal as also the High Court did not take them as admissible evidence and make assessment on their basis. At the same time without placing reliance on the xerox copies of the Income Tax Returns, the Tribunal fixed the monthly income of her father as Rs. 12,000/- and that of her mother as Rs. 8,000/-.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 24 of 2025.

Decided On: 02.01.2025

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Sonigra Juhi Uttamchand

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

C.T. Ravikumar and Sanjay Karol, JJ.

Author: C.T. Ravikumar, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0014/2025.

Print Page

Sunday, 28 July 2024

Bombay HC: Motor accident claim tribunal can take into consideration medical bills in absence of specific defence that those documents are fabricated

As far as claim of expenditure on medical treatment is concerned, it is brought on record that the appellant was admitted in three different hospitals in Pune and in hospitals at Karad and Satara. The appellant was also admitted to the institution at Coimbatore for a period of more than two months. Lot of expenditure must have been incurred on travelling and residence of the relatives and friends of the appellant. The bills evidencing expenditure on medicines, medical treatment, special diet, travelling expenses and residence of the relatives and friends of the appellant have been produced on record. There are four lists of documents marked as 85/1 to 85/4. Along with the said four lists, voluminous original documents such as bills, vouchers etc. have been produced on record. As expected, none of the documents were admitted by the respondent No. 3. Perhaps the respondent No. 3 wanted that large number of witnesses should be examined to prove the documents. In the examination-in-chief, the appellant has made a reference to all the bills and vouchers. The Tribunal constituted under the said Act is not bound by strict rules of evidence. Therefore, the said bills and vouchers ought to have been taken into consideration by the Tribunal in absence of the specific case made out that the documents were fabricated. {Para 24}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

F.A. No. 717 of 1999

Decided On: 08.08.2011

Dattatraya Laxman Shinde Vs. Nana Raghunath Hire and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Shreeniwas Oka, J.

Citation:  MANU/MH/1265/2011.

Print Page

Under which circumstances, Motor accident claim tribunal can rely on medicine bills even though pharmacist is not examined?

The High Court has gravely erred both on facts and in law in interfering with the impugned judgment and award of the Tribunal in reducing the pecuniary damages awarded towards medical expenses incurred by the Appellant herein from Rs. 17,51,726/- to Rs. 7,77,000/- solely on the ground that there is no documentary evidence in relation to the amount spent towards medical expenses which is awarded by the Tribunal. This assumption by the learned Judge of High Court is factually not correct. As could be seen from the record, there are large number of medical bills and vouchers produced by the Appellant for having spent the money towards the surgeries conducted upon her and payment made to the various Hospitals and Nursing Homes namely, V.S.S. Medical Hospital, Burla, Kalinga Hospital, Bhubaneshwar, Nursing Home, Cuttack along with purchase of medicines for the aforesaid period which run to Rs. 17,51,726/-. The above said factual aspects are stated in unequivocal terms in her statement of evidence, and she has also referred to the documents such as bills, receipts and vouchers obtained by her from various medical stores on the basis of the prescriptions of the doctors who have treated her. Some of the documents were marked in the evidence of PW-3 - the Appellant herein and she had spoken about the expenses incurred towards her treatment and purchase of medicines. In relation to some other documents, the learned Counsel for the Insurance Company has objected for making them exhibits without raising tenable objections. The learned member of the Tribunal neither upheld nor rejected the objection raised by the counsel on behalf of the Respondent Insurance Company at the time of marking documents through the Appellant in her evidence. Nonetheless, the learned member of the Tribunal has taken those documents into consideration and has awarded compensation under pecuniary damages having regard to the clinching evidence on record that the surgeries were conducted and treatment was taken by her in various hospitals and Nursing Homes for a period of four years. The correctness of the said claim is examined by us with reference to the documents in Ann. P-7 produced in this case, in which date-wise particulars with regard to the name of the Institutions and Medical Stores, the expenses incurred and bill numbers, payment made for the purpose of conducting blood tests, purchase of medicines, purchase of blood from the blood bank and cost of surgeries spent by the Appellant are given. The Tribunal, in the absence of rebuttal evidence and the nature of cross examination of the Appellant-PW 3 made by the learned Counsel on behalf of the Insurance Company and the evidence adduced by the Appellant herein and the claim made by her under the pecuniary damages towards the medical expenses, tests, surgeries etc. and other incidental purposes, has accepted and has rightly awarded a sum of Rs. 17,51,726/- under the heading of medical expenses. The same has been arbitrarily and unreasonably, without assigning any cogent and valid reason, interfered with by the High Court and it has erroneously modified the judgment by reducing the amount from Rs. 17,51,726/- to Rs. 7,77,000/-. This has been very lightly interfered with by the learned Judge of the High Court without application of mind and consideration of legal evidence on record particularly in the absence of rebuttal evidence and further, the Insurance Company was unable to show that the documents referred to supra produced by the Appellant in her evidence are fabricated documents, which have been produced with deliberate intention to prefer a false claim in this regard as contended by the learned Counsel on behalf of the Insurance Company. We have carefully examined the evidence on record and the findings of the Tribunal to examine as to whether the findings recorded by the High Court in the impugned judgment for reduction of pecuniary damages from Rs. 17,51,726/- to Rs. 7,77,000/- is correct. On careful perusal of the evidence and documents produced by the Appellant we have to hold that the finding and reason recorded by the High Court is wholly erroneous in law as the same is contrary to the facts pleaded and proved by producing evidence on record. Therefore, the same requires to be interfered with by this Court in these appeals. Accordingly, point Nos. (i) and (ii) are answered in the affirmative in favour of the Appellant. The finding and reason recorded by the High Court in not awarding just and reasonable compensation under the various heads of non pecuniary damages for which she is legally entitled to on the basis of proven facts, legal evidence on record and law laid down by this Court, is not only erroneous but also suffers from error in law. On this aspect, separate reasons are assigned while answering point Nos. (iii) & (iv).

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 5370-5372 of 2013 

Decided On: 01.08.2013

Rekha Jain Vs. National Insurance Company Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

G.S. Singhvi and V. Gopala Gowda, JJ.

Author: V. Gopala Gowda, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0773/2013.

Print Page

Sunday, 26 February 2023

Whether certified copy of sale deed is deemed to be proved if it is exhibited without objection from other side?

 But, here, the question is, whether the plaintiffs have been able to prove the contents and execution of the sale deed they adduced as evidence. The scribe of the sale deed was produced by the plaintiffs who deposed as PW.3. During his cross-examination, PW.3 admitted that he did not know Asrab Ali, the vendor of the sale deed in question or his hand writing or signature and he also could not say whether original Asrab Ali executed the sale deed before the Sub-Registrar. Furthermore, the case of the defendant/respondents is total denial of the facts and circumstances of execution of the sale deed.  {Para 13}

14. Clause (b) of Section 65 of the Evidence Act contemplates that secondary evidence may be given of the existence, condition or contents of a document when the existence, conditions or contents of the original have been proved to be admitted in writing by the person against whom it is proved or by his representative.

15. In the instant case, the existence, conditions or contents of the original sale deed have not been admitted in writing by the defendants against whom the plaintiffs wanted to prove it. However, considering the law that certified copy of a registered deed may be the proof of the contents of the original deed, the contents of the sale deed (Ext.3 series) may be admissible in evidence since objection to the contents was not raised by the defendants. Applying the principle as laid down in Dayamathi Bai (supra), in the opinion of this Court, there cannot be any disagreement in the said proposition of law that admissibility of a document in the form of secondary evidence cannot be questioned if objection is not raised by the opposite party when the document is introduced and taken into evidence and marked as exhibit. 16. Here, however, the principal question hinges upon whether the execution of the sale deed (Ext.3 series) is proved or not, keeping in view the findings of the Courts below as regards admissibility of sale deed in evidence.

17. According to this Court, a certified copy is secondary evidence under Section 63 of the Evidence Act which acknowledges/recognizes the existence, conditions and contents of the deed, but not of its execution. This Court does not find any mention that secondary evidence itself is the proof of the execution of the deed. Added to it, execution of document means the last act or series of acts which complete the document. It does not mean merely signing it. In other words, execution means all acts necessary to make the parties to the contract bound thereby. In furtherance thereof, it should be accompanied by the intention to give effect to the document in question. 

18. In the context of the present case, it is re-iterated at the cost of repetition that execution of the sale deed by Asrab Ali i.e. vendor of the sale deed (Ext.3 series) has not been proved since PW.3 admitted that he did not know Asrab Ali or his handwriting or signature and he also could not say whether original Asrab Ali executed the sale deed before the Sub-Registrar.

19. In this situation, according to this Court, in the present case, it is apparent that execution of the sale deed (Ext.3 series) has not been proved being not accompanied by the intention of the executant (Asrab Ali, the vendor) to give effect to the said sale deed, Ext.3 series in question, when it is the specific pleaded case of the defendants/respondents that Late Asrab Ali had never intended to sell the suit land and the alleged sale deed (Ext.3 series) was simultaneously accompanied by a deed of re-conveyance, which, in reality was a deed of mortgage. Therefore, in the context of the case, the attending circumstances of the execution of sale deed (Ext.3 series) ought to have been necessarily proved by the plaintiffs, which they failed to discharge by leading other evidence recognized by law of evidence.

HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA AGARTALA

 RSA No.52 of 2022

Smti. Rubia Bibi  W/o Alfat Ali, Vs Md. Mati Miah

 Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH 

Dated : 08.02.2023 

Print Page

Saturday, 30 May 2020

Leading Supreme Court Judgment on proof of document by internal evidence where the disputed document purports to be a link in a chain of correspondence

Most of the letters from the appellant relied upon bear what purport to be his signatures. A few of them are admitted by the appellant. There are also a few letters without signatures. Both the complainant and Jasawalla speak to the signatures on the other letters. The objection of the learned counsel for the appellant is that neither of them has actually seen the appellant write any of the letters nor are they shown to have such intimate acquaintance with his correspondence, as to enable them to speak to the genuineness of these signatures.

Learned trial Judge as well as the learned Judges of the High Court have found that there were sufficient number of admitted or proved letters which might well enable Jasawalla and the complainant to identify the signatures of the appellant in the disputed letters. They also laid stress substantially on the contents of the various letters, in the context of the other letters and telegrams to which they purport to be replies and which form the chain of correspondence as indicating the genuineness of the disputed letters.

Learned counsel objected to this approach on a question of proof. We are, however, unable to see any objection.

The proof of the genuineness of a document is proof of the authorship of the document and is proof of a fact like that of any other fact. The evidence relating thereto may be direct or circumstantial. It may consist of direct evidence of a person who saw the document being written or the signature being affixed.
It may be proof of the handwriting of the contents, or of the signature, by one of the modes provided in Sections 45 and 47 of the Indian Evidence Act.
It may also be proved by internal evidence afforded by the contents of the document. This last mode of proof by the contents may be of considerable value where the disputed document purports to be a link in a chain of correspondence, some links in which are proved to the satisfaction of the court. In such a situation the person who is the recipient of the document, be it either a letter or a telegram, would be in a reasonably good position both with reference to his prior knowledge of the writing or the signature of the alleged sender, limited though it may be, as also his knowledge of the subject matter of the chain of correspondence, to speak to its authorship.

In an appropriate case the court may also be in a position to judge whether the document constitutes a genuine link in the chain of correspondence and thus to determine its authorship.

We are unable, therefore, to say that the approach adopted by the courts below in arriving at the conclusion that the letters are genuine is open to any serious legal objection. 

 It is true that under s. 88 of the Evidence Act there is a presumption only that the message received by the addressee corresponds with the message delivered for transmission at the office of origin.

There is no presumption as to the person who delivered such a message for transmission. But here again proof of authorship of the message need not be direct and may be circumstantial as has been explained above in the case of letters. The contents of the messages received, in the context of the chain of correspondence may well furnish proof of the authorship of the messages at the dispatching end. 

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 200 of 1956

Decided On: 06.09.1957

Mobarik Ali Ahmed  Vs. The State of Bombay

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B. Jagannadhadas, P. Govinda Menon and Syed Jaffer Imam, JJ.

Citation: AIR 1957 SC 857 
Print Page

Monday, 17 February 2020

How to prove private documents?

How to Mark a Private Document:

47. In Smt. Rekha Rana v. Smt. Ratnashree Jain [MANU/MP/0544/2005 : AIR 2006 MP 107], a Division Bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court, per R.V. Raveendra C.J., as his Lordship then was, has answered this question. A private document cannot be used in evidence unless its execution is admitted by the party against whom it is intended to be used, or it is established by proof that it is duly executed. In this context, Rekha Rana has held that a private document must be proved

i. by examining the executants of the document; or

ii. by examining a person in whose presence the signature/mark was affixed to the document; or

iii. by referring the document to a handwriting expert and examining such expert; or

iv. by examining a person acquainted with handwriting/signature of the person who is supposed to have written/signed the document; or

v. by requesting the Court to compare the signature of the executant in the document with some admitted signature of the person shown as executants; or

vi. by proving admission by the person who is said to have signed the document, that he signed it.

48. Therefore, the lessors' effort to mark the documents through the officer summoned under Order 16, Rule 15 of CPC cannot be sustained. The documents summoned may be public documents, or private documents, or a combination of both. They have come on record, but they have not yet become part of the record. So the party that summoned them must first determine which are public documents and which are private ones. As I have noted, the marking of public documents presents no problem. If the summoned documents is private, then, as held in Rekha Rana, the party must take steps to get the private document or documents marked through a proper person.

The Answers:

49. A private document cannot be marked through a person who has merely produced that document in answer to the court's summons.



50. If the objection is about the mode of proof, the party that summoned the document must ensure that it is marked through a proper person. Thus marked, the document becomes a part of the court record. But its proof is altogether a different matter. Pithily put, document marking is procedural; document proving is adjudicatory--judicial. The proof of the document-- that is, the veracity of its contents--depends, say, on the document's nature, source, the statutory presumptions it may carry with it. Even if all these aspects are satisfactory, still its relevance is yet another matter. A document emerging to be genuine still may be irrelevant for the court to adjudicate an issue before it. Thus, the proof and relevance may be tested on the touchstone of cross-examination.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition Nos. 5016 and 5017 of 2018

Decided On: 28.06.2019

 J.M. Constructions Vs.  Shamrock Impex Pvt. Ltd. 
Print Page

Saturday, 28 September 2019

Whether defendant can compel plaintiff to enter into witness box to give evidence?

Order XII, Rule 2 of the Code enables the party to call upon other party to admit, within seven days from the date of service of notice, any document and it further provides that in case the other party refuses or neglects to admit the documents after service of such notice, the party giving notice to produce documents can take further steps and in such situation party which refuses or neglects to produce the documents will have to pay the costs of proving those documents. This provision does not enable the defendant to compel the plaintiff to enter the witness box to give evidence. It only entitles the party giving notice to admit documents to recover the costs incurred by it for proving the documents, irrespective of the result of the civil suit.

6. Order XVI, Rule 1 of sub-rule (2) of the Code provides for the procedure which is required to be followed by a party who desires to obtain any summons from the Court for the attendance of any person. Again this provision does not deal with right of the defendant to compel the plaintiff to enter the witness box to give evidence.

7. Though the submission made on behalf of the petitioner/defendant that examination of Madhusudan is necessary to prove the document which the defendant has produced on record appears to be correct at the first blush, in the absence of any such provision and considering the fact that the defendant and plaintiff No. 1 (Madhusudan) are contesting parties, the prayer made on behalf of the defendant cannot be accepted. The defendant has other options available as per law to prove the documents.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

W.P. No. 1772 of 2016

Decided On: 27.11.2018

Ramchandra Krushnaji Dhale Vs.  Madhusudan Jhunjhunwala and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Z.A. Haq, J.

Citation: 2019(3) MHLJ 532
Print Page

Monday, 1 July 2019

When certified copy of public document is presumed to be authentic?

Section 114 of the Evidence Act enables the Court to presume the existence of any fact which it thinks likely to have happened, regard being had to the common course of natural events, human conduct an public and private business, in their relation to the fact of the particular case. The illustrations to the section state that the Court may presume, inter alia, that judicial and official acts have been regularly performed. In respect of public documents which form the acts or records of the acts of the sovereign authority, official bodies and Tribunals, and of public officers, legislative, judicial and executive, the presumption can be and is, in fact, invariably drawn. It is necessary, however, to appreciate that the source of the presumption is S. 114.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Suit No. 1108 of 1981

Decided On: 28.06.1982

Om Prakash Berlia  Vs. Unit Trust of India and Ors

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.P. Bharucha, J.


Citation:AIR 1983 Bom 1
Print Page

Tuesday, 18 June 2019

Whether certified copy of plaint is public document?

 The certified copy of the plaint is not a public document. Hence, it requires proof. For proving such document, the original plaint should have been called in the court. That is not done, hence the certified copy of the plaint could not be said to be proved at all.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Second Appeal No. 67 of 1996

Decided On: 29.01.2008

 Shamlata  Vs. Vishweshwar Tukaram Giripunje and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges: 
C.L. Pangarkar, J.

Citation: AIR 2008 Bom 155
Print Page

Sunday, 17 March 2019

Whether document can be treated as proved if it is produced in consequence of notice to produce document?

Section 163, Evidence Act reads as under : --

"163. When a party calls for a document which he has given the other party notice to produce, and such document is produced and inspected by the party calling for its production, he is bound to give it as evidence if the party producing it requires him to do so."
The ingredients of the provision are :

(i) One party having given the other a notice to produce must call for that document;

(ii) Such document should be produced by such other party;

(iii) the party calling for the document must have inspected it.

When the abovesaid three steps have been followed the party calling for the document would be bound to give it a evidence on the party producing the document insisting on doing so.Section 163 of the Evidence Act has to be read along with Section 164. The two read together project the object underlying. If a party called upon to produce a document in his custody fails to produce the same, he would be debarred from producing that document as evidence unless the other party waives the right accrued to him or the Court still permits the production. On the contrary, if the party in possession of the document yields to the call of his opponent not only by producing the document but also by offering its inspection, the party calling for the document, cannot be permitted to turn around object to the production of that document in evidence. This appears to be a simple rule of fair trial between the two adversaries before a Court and nothing more. Be it noted that the two provisions enact a rule of evidence and not a principle of proof.

Distinction between evidence and proof is well defined and perceptible. It will be useful to read the definition of the term 'evidence' with reference to documents and the definitions of the terms 'proved', 'disproved' and 'not proved' in Section 3 of the Evidence Act.

'Evidence' means and includes

xxx xx

(2) all documents produced for the inspection of the Court;

Such documents are called documentary evidence.

'Proved'

A fact is said to be proved when, after considering the matters before it, the Court either believes it to exist, or considers its existence so probable that a prudent man ought, under the circumstances of the particular case, to act upon the supposition that it exists.

'Disproved'

A fact is said to be disproved when after considering the matters before it, the Court either believes that it does not exist, or considers its non-existence so probable that a prudent man ought, under the circumstances of the particular case, to act upon the supposition that it does not exist.

'Not proved'

A fact is said not to be proved when it is neither proved nor disproved.

Section 163 of the Evidence Act read in the light of the definition of the term 'evidence' leads to certain inferences. A party man call for production of a document in the custody of his opponent and may also inspect the same. Till that stage, the document remains a 'document' and does not become an 'evidence'. It is only when a document is produced for inspection of the Court that the 'document' becomes 'evidence'. The party calling for the document may have several weapons in his armoury utilising which it can prevent the other party's document from becoming evidence. All those weapons can be utilised at all times until all the three steps contemplated by Section 163 of the Evidence Act have been put in. A party may call for a document but the opponent may not produce. The opponent having produced the document, the party making the call may still be advised not to inspect. Till this stage the party is not debarred from objecting to other party's documents becoming evidence, if it can. But having inspected the document, the party would be debarred from objecting to the attempt of other party in tendering that document in evidence or in other words from producing that document for the inspection of the Court. However, that does not mean that if the law bars admissibility of a document than merely on account of production and inspection of the document between the parties, it would become admissible. For example, if a document is required by law to be registered to be scribed on stamp paper of a particular denomination, which it is not, a mere product ion for and inspection by adversary of the document would not make it admissible in evidence. Similarly, Section 163 of the Evidence Act does not speak of relevancy of the document. A document may be admissible in evidence and yet be not relevant. Then, a document may be required by law to be proved in a particular mode, such as a will is required to be proved in accordance with Section 68 of the Evidence Act. In a disputed case of will, if the party disputing the will propounded by his opponent, has called for and inspected the will, it would not mean that the opponent would be absolved of his responsibility of proving the will in the manner required by Section 68 of the Evidence Act.

Evidence in relation to law includes all the legal means exclusive of mere argument which tend to prove or disprove any fact the truth of which is submitted to judicial investigation. This term and the word proof are often used as synonyms, but the latter is applied by accurate logicians, rather to the effect of evidence, than to evidence itself (Taylor 11th Ed., p. 1). The definitions of the words 'proved' 'disproved' and 'not proved', embodiment of sound rule of common sense, would be described the degree of certainty to be arrived at before the fact can be said to be proved, disproved and not proved by evidence. In short, proof is the effect of evidence. It is this background which assumes significance as to why the draftsman of the Evidence Act deliberately abstained from using the term 'proof' in any of its variations in the language of Section 163 of the Evidence Act.

A few decided cases may now be noticed.

In Rajagopala Ayyangar v. Ramanuja Ayyangar 72 Ind Cas 459 : (AIR 1923 Mad 607), a Division Bench of Madras High Court observed :

"Section 163 of the Evidence Act does hot render proof of the documents to be exhibited unnecessary or alter the normal incidents of that burden.....it includes nothing relating to the burden of proof or the necessity for the proof prescribed in the other Sections of the Act."
In Ramadhin v. Ram Dayal 57 Ind Cas 973 : (AIR 1919 Oudh 8), it was held :--

"Where documentary evidence is admitted under the special provisions of Section 163 of the Evidence Act, such evidence is merely evidence in the case for what it may be worth, and is not conclusive against the party who has inspected the documents."

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH (GWALIOR BENCH)

C.R. No. 86 of 1989

Decided On: 26.09.1989

 Phoolchand Garg Vs. Gopaldas Agarwal and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.C. Lahoti, J.

Citations: AIR 1990 MP 135
Print Page

Sunday, 10 February 2019

Whether it is necessary to prove documents obtained under right to information Act?

 Even otherwise,
mere marking of documents as exhibits does not amount to
proving the contents thereof. The plaintiffs will have to prove the
contents of the documents. Understood thus, I do not find that
the learned trial Judge has committed any error in passing the
impugned order. Hence, Petition fails and the same is dismissed.
It is, however, expressly made clear that where a decree is
appealed from by the petitioner, any error, defect or irregularity
in the impugned order, affecting the decision of the case, may be
set forth as a ground of objection in the memorandum of appeal
as contemplated by Section 105(1) of C.P.C.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 4651 OF 2016

Dr. M.K.Prakash Vs Smt. Snehmala Sapale.

CORAM : R.G.KETKAR,J.
DATE : 24/06/2016

Print Page

Tuesday, 18 December 2018

How to prove statements contained in power of attorney?

 It was then argued that the statement made by the notary public in the power of attorney regarding the articles of plaintiff-bank being contents of documents could be proved only by producing memorandum of articles. Reliance was placed on a decision of the Judicial Commissioner in Nar Bahadur Gurung v. Anil Krishna Bhattacharya, AIR 1970 Man 57. In this case, it was held that the statements contained in the powers of attorney have to be proved like any other statements. There is no quarrel so far as the principle of law is concerned. But, I have referred to these statements not for the purpose of using them as evidence to prove those facts but only to show the act of notarisation. Those statements do show that the notary public had satisfied himself about the authority of the executants of the power of attorney.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Suit No. 1290 of 1979

Decided On: 17.05.1982

Citibank N.A. Vs.  Juggilal Kamlapat Jute Mills Co. Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Gian Chand Jain, J.

Print Page

Wednesday, 14 November 2018

How to prove documents obtained under right to information Act?

 In view of the above analysis, the xerox copy certified by the designated Public Information Officer under Right to Information Act of the private documents are not certified copies within the meaning of the provisions of Section 65 of the Evidence Act. They are merely true copies of the private documents available in the records of the particular Department. The production and marking of such copies is permissible only after laying a foundation for acceptance of secondary evidence under clauses (a) (b) or (c) of Section 65 of the Act. The condition prescribed under the above cases (a), (b) or (c) of Section 65 of the Act have to be fulfilled before marking the true copies obtained under the Right to Information Act. However, the true copies of public documents certified by the designated Information Officer can be taken as certified copies of the public documents.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT HYDERABAD 
Civil Revision Petition Nos. 3031 and 3048 of 2015

Decided On: 11.12.2015

 Datti Kameswari  Vs. Singam Rao Sarath Chandra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A. Ramalingeswara Rao, J.

Print Page

Tuesday, 2 October 2018

Whether court should permit recalling of witness for proof of document?

Admittedly, these two letters were relevant for the purpose
of deciding the dispute involved between the parties and hence this
Court has, vide its order dated 15th April 2011, allowed and permitted

the Petitioner to adduce additional evidence in respect of these two
letters. It is a matter of record that thereafter the Petitioner has filed
affidavit of evidence and along with it these two letter were also
produced under the bonafide impression that they were the originals.
However, when it was pointed out in cross-examination that these two
letters are not the originals but the photocopies thereof, the Petitioner
got the original letters produced, which were in the office of his
Advocate and for that purpose witness Ms.Bhairavi Pathak is also
examined and she has explained the reason, under which the originals
remained in the office and the photocopies came to be produced. Her
evidence was led only for the purpose of producing the original letters,
from the proper custody. She was not examined to prove those letters.
Now only to prove those letters, the Petitioner wants that witness
Mr.Rakesh Agarwal may be recalled.
10] If one considers the earlier order passed by this Court
holding that these letters are relevant and therefore granted
permission to the Petitioner to lead additional evidence in respect of
these letters and if one considers the above said sequence of facts,
then interest of justice requires that merely on account of the
negligence or inadvertence on the part of the Petitioner, the Petitioner
should not be deprived of the opportunity to prove these letters and

for that purpose his recall of PW-1 Mr.Rakesh Agarwal become
necessary. The interest of justice always requires that the dispute
between the parties should come to an end completely, finally and
effectively and no one should suffer on account of any negligence or
inadvertence which might have occurred in the course of the
proceeding. In this case, if one considers that the cross-examination of
the witness Mr.Rakesh Agarwal was concluded with an endorsement
that if the original letters are produced, the right of Respondent to
cross-examine him is reserved, then it follows that at that time also
there was understanding that such original letters will be produced
and then the Respondent will further cross-examine the witness.
Therefore, there is no question of any prejudice being caused to the
Respondent. In the interest of justice, it is always desirable that one
last opportunity may be given to the Petitioner to prove these two
letters and for that purpose to recall the witness.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 6721 OF 2016
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1682 OF 2016

Styrolution ABS (India) Ltd. V National Education & Information Films Ltd.


CORAM : DR.SHALINI PHANSALKAR-JOSHI, J.
DATE : 6th FEBRUARY, 2018.

Print Page

Saturday, 24 February 2018

Whether it is necessary to issue notice to produce document if document to be proved is notice?

Besides that by the said affidavit, the complainant had given a notice to the accused persons to produce the original notices, in view of Clause (1) to proviso to Se.66 such notice was in fact not essential. Section 66 provides for the rules to issue notice to produce the original documents as per provisions of Section 65 Clause (a). However, the proviso to Section 66 provides that such notice shall not be required in order to render secondary evidence admissible when the document to be produced is itself a notice. The learned Counsel for the Petitioner contended that his provision will not be applicable to the facts of the present case. In the Law of Evidence by Rattanlal & Dhirajlal (22nd Enlarged Edn. revised by Mr. Justice Y.V. Chandrachud, Former Chief Justice of India), the following observation is made:

Notice shall not be required to be given (under this section) when the document to be proved is itself a notice. When a party sends a notice to the opposite party and it is received by him, a copy of the notice is admissible, and it is not obligatory to issue notice calling upon the opposite party to produce the original notice.

PHIPSON on Evidence (15th Edn. (2000), para 41-31, page 1120) observes: "Notice to produce the original is not necessary:

(a)....

(b) When the document to be proved is itself a notice which has been served on the adversary; though not on a third, e.g. a notice to produce or to quit, or of action, or of the dishonour of a bill, when the action is brought upon the bill, or of intention to remove a building, pursuant to a by-law under the Public Health act, 1875 (now the Highways Act, 1980).



In the same commentary, reference is made to Lockchand v. Union of India, MANU/RH/0079/1959 : AIR 1959 Raj.231where in a suit against Union of India, a copy of notice under Section 80 of Code of Civil Procedure was sought to be produced by the Plaintiff, but it was objected on behalf of the Defendant on the ground that copy was not admissible. It was held that Section 65 read with Section 66 of the Evidence Act permits the Plaintiff to produce the copy of the notice without summoning the original. It was also held that it was for the Defendant to show by production of the original that the document did not amount to a notice as per Section 80 of Code of Civil Procedure.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Writ Petition No. 40 of 2011

Decided On: 16.03.2011

Ashish C. Shah Vs. Sheth Developers Pvt. Ltd., 
Print Page

Whether certified copy of resolution or extract of minutes book is admissible without proof of original?

Next comes the document No. 1 -the certified true copy of the resolution dated 16.2.2009, whereby the complainant company had allegedly resolved to give consent of the Board of Directors to execute power of attorney in favour of Ashwin Sheth, Managing Director and/or Sharad Doshi, Executive Assistant to the Managing Director to institute or defend any suit or criminal proceedings. The learned trial Court observed in the impugned order that there is no clear-cut provision about issuance of certified copy of extract of minutes book but if Sub-section (2) of Section 196 of the Companies Act is read, it may be stated that certified copy of the minutes can be given. The learned trial Court observed that the witness Sharad Doshi in his affidavit had deposed about the said document and thereby he has proved the genuineness of the document. Under Section 195 of the Companies Act, where minutes of the proceedings of any general meeting of the company have been kept in accordance with the provisions of Section 193, then, until the contrary is proved, the meeting shall be deemed to have been duly called and held, and all proceedings thereat to have duly taken place. Section 194 of the Companies Act provides that the minutes of meetings kept in accordance with the provisions of Section 193 shall be evidence of the proceedings recorded therein. However, no provision in the Companies Act is brought to my notice which provides that the certified copy or extract of the minutes would be admissible in evidence without proof of the original. Section 65(f) of the Evidence Act provides that secondary evidence may be given of the existence, condition and contents of the document when the original is the document of which a certified copy is permitted by the Evidence Act or by any other law in force in India to be given in evidence. As no provision from the Companies Act is brought to my notice under which the certified copy of the minutes of the meetings of the board of directors is admissible in evidence without proof of the original, it must be said that the copy of the minutes cannot be admitted in evidence directly unless the original is proved or the copy is admitted by opposite party. Therefore, even though that document is given exhibit number, it cannot be treated to have been proved, unless the complainant leads appropriate evidence to prove the minutes.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Writ Petition No. 40 of 2011

Decided On: 16.03.2011

Ashish C. Shah Vs. Sheth Developers Pvt. Ltd., 

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
J.H. Bhatia, J.
Citation: 2011(4) MHLJ 288
Print Page