Showing posts with label dismissal in default. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dismissal in default. Show all posts

Thursday, 20 November 2025

Kerala HC: Whether Motor accident claim tribunal can dismiss claim petition for default/non prosecution?

 Where the Tribunal is genuinely satisfied that there are contumacious laches on the part of the claimants in prosecuting their claims and where the claimants are not interested in prosecuting their cases, the Tribunal can dismiss the application for default using Order IX Rule 8 in appropriate cases. To the above extent the decisions in Lukose v. Govindan Nair (MANU/KE/0070/1990 : 1990 (1) KLT 378) and Saramma Scaria and others v. Mathai and another (MANU/KE/0165/2002 : 2002 (2) ILR 191), are overruled.

5. When the claim is dismissed for default, parties will be free to approach the Tribunal to set aside such orders by filing application under Order IX Rule 9. But, if the Tribunal decides the matter on merit suo motu collecting evidence, the only remedy open to the claimant will be to file an appeal before the High Court as provided under Section 173 of the Act. After the judgment in Saramma's case (supra) we have seen that many Claims Tribunals are dismissing the cases on merits holding that no evidence is adduced on the side of the claimant and claimant is absent. In such circumstances, the claimant will be compelled to approach the High Court which may incur heavy expenses and inconveniences. If the Tribunal dismisses the case for default, he can approach the Tribunal itself of the place which he has selected in view of section 166(2) of the Act, to file the claim petition for setting aside the order of dismissal of the case for default and the Tribunal should be liberal in its approach when such applications are filed.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA

M.A.C.A. No. 327 of 2004

Decided On: 01.09.2005

Jacob Thomas Vs. C. Pandian and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

J.B. Koshy, K.M. Joseph & K.R. Udayabhanu

Author: J.B. Koshy, J.

Citation: I(2006)ACC204, 2006ACJ464, AIR2006Ker77, AIR2006Ker77, ILR2005(4)Kerala419, [2006(2) JCR250(Kerala)], 2005(3)KLJ331, 2005(4)KLT545, 2006(1)RCR(Civil)193,MANU/KE/0396/2005.

Print Page

Thursday, 19 November 2020

Whether the court can restore insolvency petition dismissed in default on the application of one of the creditors?

 The learned Assistant Judge considered that the petitioning creditor sues on behalf of the general body of creditors and, therefore, in a sense every creditor is a party to the proceedings and that under Order IX, Rule 9, any party to the proceeding can ask for a petition dismissed for default being restored to file. But Order IX, Rule 9, refers specifically to the plaintiff who has to satisfy the Court that he has sufficient cause for non-appearance, and it is doubtful whether it was competent to the shop of Laxminarayan Sitaram to apply under Order IX, Rule 9, for a revival of the petition.


7. But the question still remains whether the Court did not have inherent jurisdiction to restore the application to file at the instance of one of the creditors. Under Section 151 of the Civil Procedure Code the Court has inherent powers to make such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice and to prevent abuse of the process of the Court. In my opinion the ends of justice do require in the peculiar circumstances of this case that the application should be restored to file, and that, therefore, the two lower Courts were right in passing the order that they did.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Civil Revision Application No. 87 of 1944

Decided On: 17.11.1944


 Keshav Appa Bhagat  Vs.  Sitaram Hanumandas


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

G.S. Rajadhyaksha, J.

Citation:1944 SCCONLINE 79: AIR 1946 Bom 20:MANU/MH/0133/1944


Print Page