Showing posts with label dismissal of proceeding. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dismissal of proceeding. Show all posts

Saturday, 23 April 2022

Whether interim order ends if the proceeding in which stay is granted is dismissed?

  From the above discussion, it is clear that imposition of a stay on the operation of an order means that the order which has been stayed would not be operative from the date of passing of the stay order. However, it does not mean that the stayed order is wiped out from the existence, unless it is quashed. Once the proceedings, wherein a stay was granted, are dismissed, any interim order granted earlier merges with the final order. In other words, the interim order comes to an end with the dismissal of the proceedings. In such a situation, it is the duty of the Court to put the parties in the same position they would have been but for the interim order of the court, unless the order granting interim stay or final order dismissing the proceedings specifies otherwise. On the dismissal of the proceedings or vacation of the interim order, the beneficiary of the interim order shall have to pay interest on the amount withheld or not paid by virtue of the interim order. {Para 24}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION 

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 2417 OF 2022 

 STATE OF U.P. THR. SECRETARY AND ORS. Vs PREM CHOPRA

Print Page

Whether a party should pay interest on the amount payable by him which he has not paid due to stay order after the dismissal of that proceeding?

When the interim order was in force, the recovery of license fee was temporarily suspended. The restraint was only against the Department not to recover the license fee. There was no prohibition for the respondent to deposit the balance of license fee. {Para 18}

24. From the above discussion, it is clear that imposition of a stay on the operation of an order means that the order which has been stayed would not be operative from the date of passing of the stay order. However, it does not mean that the stayed order is wiped out from the existence, unless it is quashed. Once the proceedings, wherein a stay was granted, are dismissed, any interim order granted earlier merges with the final order. In other words, the interim order comes to an end with the dismissal of the proceedings. In such a situation, it is the duty of the Court to put the parties in the same position they would have been but for the interim order of the court, unless the order granting interim stay or final order dismissing the proceedings specifies otherwise. On the dismissal of the proceedings or vacation of the interim order, the beneficiary of the interim order shall have to pay interest on the amount withheld or not paid by virtue of the interim order. 


25. Coming to the facts of the present case, the respondent was not successful in his challenge to the notice dated 06.01.2003 demanding the balance of license fee before the Authorities under the Act. Therefore, he filed the writ petition bearing Misc. Single No.2582 of 2003 before the High Court wherein the High Court, by an interim order, stayed the recovery of the monthly instalment of license fee for the months January 2003 to March 2003, subject to deposit of Rs.2,75,000/within a period of six weeks before the District Excise Officer. It is not disputed that this amount of Rs.2,75,000/was deposited by the respondent. The said writ petition was dismissed by the High Court for nonprosecution vide Order dated 21.12.2015. On 23.12.2017, the respondent deposited the remaining amount of Rs.3,68,562/towards license fee. However, the respondent did not make payment of interest to the Department. The writ petition was restored on 19.01.2018. In the meantime, the appellants issued a notice calling upon the respondent to pay Rs.10,08,210.51/towards interest due. The High Court held that the respondent was not liable to pay interest as he was under the protection of the interim order. Given the settled position of law, in our view the High Court has erred in holding that the respondent was not liable to pay interest due to the protection given under the interim order.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION 

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 2417 OF 2022 

 STATE OF U.P. THR. SECRETARY AND ORS. Vs PREM CHOPRA

Coram: S. ABDUL NAZEER; VIKRAM NATH; JJ. 

Author: S. ABDUL NAZEER, J.

Dated: March 25, 2022 

Print Page

Friday, 3 April 2015

When court can dismiss proceeding on ground that fair trial is not possible due to delay?


The question of dismissing proceedings on the ground of inordinate delay or non-prosecution has been considered by English Courts. In The 'Mollymawk'. (1974) 1 Lloyd's Law Rep 32, Justic Brand on held that in order to succeed in an application for striking out the proceedings on the ground of delay, the defendants should show (a) that there had been an inordinate delay by the plaintiffs in prosecuting the claim: (b) that such a delay was inexcusable : and (c) that the defendants would, or were likely to be seriously prejudiced by the delay. Though the learned Judge in that case found that the delay of over four years was inordinate, he held on the facts that it was not proved that the defendants were prejudiced by the delay so as to make a fair trial impossible. On that ground, he refused to strike off the proceedings.
Madras High Court
Union Of India vs M/S. Cavalier Shipping Company, ... on 2 June, 1989
Equivalent citations: AIR 1990 Mad 312
Bench: Srinivasan

Print Page