Counsel for the Respondent sought to urge that there was no electricity connection because the premises have been used only as a godown since the Respondent had certain adjoining premises in which the factory is situated. No such case has been established by the Respondent in the course of his evidence. On the contrary, the case of the Respondent in the course of Examination-in-Chief is that he was using the premises for painting, woodwork and paper manufacturing. That being so, the Learned Trial Judge was clearly justified in coming to the conclusion that there was a complete failure on the part of the Respondent to produce any material which would even prima facie indicate that the premises had been used for the purpose for which they were let. The absence of electricity/the absence of a telephone which was, in fact, removed after 12 years in 1977, the absence of a business licence and the failure of the Respondent to produce Accounts Books and a wage register would only go to establish that a ground for eviction has been clearly established with reference to Section 13(1)(k). An adverse inference would have to be drawn against the Respondent for a complete failure to produce any evidence whatsoever to show the user of the premises for the purposes for which they were let. I am conscious of the limitations on the exercise of the jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution. This Court would not in that jurisdiction reappreciate the evidence, substitute its own conclusions for those of the Court below of adopt a particular view only because it commends itself better than that of the primary fact finding Court. However, this is a case where the First Appellate Court has failed to consider and has completely ignored material evidence on the record, including clear admissions of the Respondent. Hence, the interference of the Court is warranted in order to ensure that a failure of justice does not ensue.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Writ Petition No. 278 of 1990
Decided On: 14.08.2003
Ravinbhushan Anant Datar Vs. Waman Dattatray Purohit
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, J.
Citation: 2004 Bom RC 463

