Showing posts with label non user of premises. Show all posts
Showing posts with label non user of premises. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 November 2019

Whether landlord can get eviction decree on ground of bonafide need if there is non user of tenanted premises?

Dr. Bhal­Chandra Balwant Marathe and ors. Vs.
Narayan Vaman Sumant [1986(1) RCI 302 (Bom.)],
wherein the Hon'ble Bombay High Court observed that,
premises in occupation of the tenant almost in a state of

non ­user by him. No hardship will cause to tenant. Even a
minor requirement of the landlord will be sufficient to give
landlord decree for eviction sought by him.
Print Page

Tuesday, 30 July 2019

How to appreciate evidence in eviction suit on ground of non user of tenanted premises?

 This apart, the fact that under the Shops and Establishments Act, it is undoubtedly true that a person having a shop must get it registered. In other words, carrying on a shop or establishment, as defined in the Act, without registration, would make it illegal. The fact that there is a registration, however, would not be sufficient to establish that there is use of the premises. In other words, even if a person has registration, that by itself would not mean that the tenant is actually using the premises for the purpose for which it is rented out to him. Actual use of the premises can be established by various other circumstances like electricity bills, payment of wages to employees if there are employees, evidence relating to transactions of the business which is carried on etc. No doubt, the burden actually is on the landlord to establish the non-user. But since, in this case, it would appear that there is no registration for the period, it shows that the Appellants could not have lawfully conducted any business in the suit premises. There is, no doubt, the evidence of PW1 also.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 4268 of 2019

Decided On: 08.05.2019

Nilesh Laxmichand  Vs.  Shantaben Purushottam Kakad (Since Deceased) by L.Rs.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Ashok Bhushan and K.M. Joseph, JJ.
Citation: (2019) 6 SCC 542
Print Page

Monday, 5 November 2018

How to ascertain relevant period for seeking eviction decree on ground of non user of premises?

 In the context of this provision, it is desirable to retain focus on two aspects of the matter viz., (i) that such period of non-user must be a continuous period of six months and (ii) that this period of six months must be immediately prior to the date of the suit. It is, therefore, necessary to identify this specific period from the facts of the case. The suit notice at Exh. 44 is dated 10th December, 1985. The suit was filed on 25th April, 1986. Therefore, the landlord is required to prove by appropriate evidence that the period of non-user on the part of the tenant was a period beginning from 25th October, 1985 to 25th April, 1986. This period shall hereinafter be referred to as "the relevant period".

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT

Civil Revision Application No. 1118 of 1992

Decided On: 09.03.2001

 Ashwinbhai C. Sheth Vs.  Bank of Baroda

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Y.B. Bhatt, J.

Citation: Laws(GJH 2001-3-31)
Print Page

What is reasonable cause for non user of tenanted premises?

 The above circumstances make it clear that the respondent could not operate the Atta Chakki earlier for want of an electric power connection. This was undoubtedly a reasonable cause for not carrying on business in the shop in dispute. In spite of the fact that there is no averments in the application that the respondent ceased to occupy the shop without reasonable cause, the respondent has fully established on the record that he could not operate the Atta Chakki because of a reasonable cause i.e. non-provision of electric power connection to him. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

Civil Revision No. 2617 of 1979

Decided On: 25.08.1987

 Jagdish Parshad  Vs.  Madan Lal

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dharam Vir Sehgal, J.

Citation: 1988(1) RCR 583
Print Page

Whether court can pass eviction decree on ground of non user even if tenant has no intention to shift his residence?

The contention of Learned Counsel for the Petitioner is that the burden of proof has been wrongly placed on the Petitioner/Landlord. It has, however been recognised in the impugned judgment itself that in cases of the present genere, it is the tenant who can best discharge the burden of proving that he/she had not resided in the demised premises for a period of over six months immediately preceding the filing of the Petition. However, residency inherently implies permanency. Before a finding can be returned to the effect that a tenant has not resided in the demised premises for the said period of six months, the Court must be fully satisfied that there was an intention to shift the residence to an alternative place. For instance, a tenant may be transferred to another city and as a consequence it may become necessary for him to be away from the demised premises for even six months. The grounds of eviction would be made out. Could the tenant defeat the purpose of the legislation by making a short stay, in between this period, I would think that it would be a futile exercise, and he would not succeed in sewing himself from eviction. For the same reason, if there is no intention to reside at another place for this period, if this incidentally transpires for circumstances beyond the control of the Tenant, in my view he would not be liable to eviction. In the present instance, it appears to be the common case that the Respondent had left India with the purpose of visiting her children. There is no evidence that she had the intention of shifting residence for a period of over six months. As it happened, she appears to have returned to within three months. The Court must be alive fact that it is conceivable that the tenant leaves the residence with the intention of staying out for a couple of months, and for reasons beyond their control, staying out for a period of over six months. The burden of giving an acceptable Explanation would rest with the Tenant. In such case, there is no intention not to reside in the said premises within this period. In my view, Therefore, the initial burden would be on the Petitioner not only to state that there has been an absence of the tenant from the demised premises for a period of six month but also that this absence was fully intended. Only once the initial burden of proof is discharged by the Landlord does it shift to the Tenant. Learned Counsel has relied on the decision of Sushil Chander Gupta Vs. Radha Krishan Bathisa, 1981 (1) All IRCJ 711. I am in respectful agreement with the extracted view expressed therein which reads as follows

The question of residence or non-residence is not a question of presumption. It is question of fact. It is not a question of inference but of positive proof. The landlord cannot prove the negative except by his statement. The tenant is required to prove the positive. The burden at once shift to him to show that he was residing during the period in question.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

C.M.(M) No. 576 of 1998

Decided On: 13.12.2000

Ranjit Singh Vs. Inez Richards

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Vikramajit Sen, J.

Citation: 2001(2) RCR 716
Print Page

When tenant can not be evicted from tenanted premises on ground of non user of premises?

Thus it becomes clear from the observations of the Supreme Court quoted above, that the liability of the tenant to pay rent is linked to his enjoyment of the demised premises. In the present case the tenant-petitioner has been deprived of the enjoyment of the entire premises only due to the conduct and attitude of the landlord and therefore, in my opinion, the tenant's liability to pay the entire rent would stand suspended from the date from which he became unable to use and enjoy the tenanted premises. Bare perusal of Section 13(1)(k) of the Act makes it clear that if there is reasonable cause for not using the tenanted premises then a decree of eviction cannot be passed. In the present case there was definitely a reasonable cause for the tenant not to use the tenanted premises in the circumstances referred to above. So far as a decree under Clause (1) of Section 13(1) is concerned it contemplates the tenant to secure suitable residence. Section 13(1)(1) contemplates a voluntary act on the part of the tenant. When the tenant is forced to shift his residence and especially when the conduct of the landlord himself is responsible for forcing the tenant to shift his residence in my opinion, the landlord would not be entitled to seek decree of eviction against the tenant under Clause 13(1)(1) of the Act. In my opinion, the Courts below have neither appreciated the evidence on record properly nor they have applied law properly. So far as the judgment of the Calcutta High Court in the case of Jatindra Kumar Dass relied on by the learned Counsel for the respondents is concerned, in my opinion, the judgement does not consider the Judgement of the Supreme Court in Surendra Nath Bibra 's case referred to above. In any case the perusal of paragraph IS of that Judgement shows that ultimately the Court in that case found that there is no liability on the landlord to repair the tenanted premises and therefore, the tenant was not justified in suspending the payment of rent.

6. The learned Counsel for the respondents by relying on the provisions of Section 10(D) of the Act, contended that the tenant had a remedy of getting the premises repaired. But in my opinion, it is not the question of tenant's having a remedy to get the premises repaired. The question is. the landlord entitled to a decree of eviction against the tenant. The tenant is deprived of the enjoyment of the property by a conduct which is attributable directly to the landlord and therefore there occurs suspension of the liability of the tenant to pay the rent. In my opinion, the tenant had done all within his powers, namely, issuing notice to the landlord to carry out repairs, offering to carry out repairs himself and moving the authorities of the Pune Municipal Corporation. But it is only because of the adamant attitude adopted by the landlord, that repairs could not be carried out. At this stage, now the landlord cannot turn around and say that despite his refusal and his attitude, the tenant could have on his own done the repairs. In my opinions the Courts below were not justified in passing the decree of eviction against the petitioner-tenant. It is to be seen that Section 23(1) casts a duty on the landlord to keep the premises in good and tenantable repair. The landlord committed breach of this statutory duty imposed on him. Sub-section 2 of Section 23. enables the tenant to carry out the repairs, after giving notice to the landlord, The tenant in this case, issued necessary notice to the landlord and then wanted to carry out the repairs, but the landlord did not permit him to do so. This attitude was adopted by the landlord, obviously, to force the tenant to leave the suit premises. Now, in my opinion, to pass a decree in favour of the landlord, on the ground that the tenant has not paid rent for the period during which he could not have occupied the suit premises and also on the ground that he did not continue In occupy the premises and sought shelter elsewhere, would amount to allowing the landlord to take advantage of his own wrong.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 67 of 1983

Decided On: 27.02.1997

 Gopal Dattaraya Chapahlkar  Vs. Govind Yeshwant Borkar and Ors.
Print Page

When liability of tenant to pay rent gets suspended?

Thus it becomes clear from the observations of the Supreme Court quoted above, that the liability of the tenant to pay rent is linked to his enjoyment of the demised premises. In the present case the tenant-petitioner has been deprived of the enjoyment of the entire premises only due to the conduct and attitude of the landlord and therefore, in my opinion, the tenant's liability to pay the entire rent would stand suspended from the date from which he became unable to use and enjoy the tenanted premises. Bare perusal of Section 13(1)(k) of the Act makes it clear that if there is reasonable cause for not using the tenanted premises then a decree of eviction cannot be passed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 67 of 1983

Decided On: 27.02.1997

 Gopal Dattaraya Chapahlkar  Vs. Govind Yeshwant Borkar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
D.K. Deshmukh, J.

Citation: 1997 BomLR 52
Print Page

Saturday, 11 August 2018

Whether burden of proof is on landlord to prove that non user of tenanted premises was without reasonable cause?

The initial burden to show that the tenant has ceased to occupy the building continuously for 6 months is always on the landlord. He has to adduce tangible evidence to prove the fact that as on the date of filing the petition, the tenant was not occupying the building continuously for 6 months. Once such evidence is adduced, the burden shifts on the tenant to prove that there was reasonable cause for his having ceased to occupy the tenanted premises for a continuous period of 6 months.

23. No straitjacket formula can be evolved for determining as to what is the reasonable cause and each case is required to be decided keeping in view the nature of the lease, the purpose for which the premises are let out and the evidence of the parties. If the building, as defined in Section 2(1), is let out for industrial or commercial/business purpose and the same is not used for the said purpose continuously for a period of six months, the tenant cannot plead financial crunch as a ground to justify non-occupation of the building unless cogent evidence is produced by him to prove that he could not carry on the industrial or commercial/business activity due to fiscal reasons which were beyond his control. If the tenant does not use the building for the purpose for which it is let out, he cannot be said to be occupying the building merely because he has put some furniture or articles or machinery under his lock and key.

19. As observed above by the Supreme Court it shows that reasonable cause depends on facts of each case. The reasonable cause must be for the relevant period of non-user. In this case, the Respondent- Defendant neither pleaded with sufficient particulars as to why he was not using the suit premises during the relevant period from May, 2004 to November, 2004 nor he led any oral or documentary evidence in support of that period. In my opinion, therefore, this was a case where Respondent-Defendant has failed to discharge burden cast on him.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Civil Revision Application No. 753 of 2009

Decided On: 27.04.2012

 Gopaldas Khushaldas Parmar Vs. Sanmukhlal P. Shah

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
G.S. Godbole

Citation: 2012(1) RCJ 305 Bom
Print Page

When non user of tenanted premises is proved?

Counsel for the Respondent sought to urge that there was no electricity connection because the premises have been used only as a godown since the Respondent had certain adjoining premises in which the factory is situated. No such case has been established by the Respondent in the course of his evidence. On the contrary, the case of the Respondent in the course of Examination-in-Chief is that he was using the premises for painting, woodwork and paper manufacturing. That being so, the Learned Trial Judge was clearly justified in coming to the conclusion that there was a complete failure on the part of the Respondent to produce any material which would even prima facie indicate that the premises had been used for the purpose for which they were let. The absence of electricity/the absence of a telephone which was, in fact, removed after 12 years in 1977, the absence of a business licence and the failure of the Respondent to produce Accounts Books and a wage register would only go to establish that a ground for eviction has been clearly established with reference to Section 13(1)(k). An adverse inference would have to be drawn against the Respondent for a complete failure to produce any evidence whatsoever to show the user of the premises for the purposes for which they were let. I am conscious of the limitations on the exercise of the jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution. This Court would not in that jurisdiction reappreciate the evidence, substitute its own conclusions for those of the Court below of adopt a particular view only because it commends itself better than that of the primary fact finding Court. However, this is a case where the First Appellate Court has failed to consider and has completely ignored material evidence on the record, including clear admissions of the Respondent. Hence, the interference of the Court is warranted in order to ensure that a failure of justice does not ensue.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 278 of 1990

Decided On: 14.08.2003

Ravinbhushan Anant Datar Vs. Waman Dattatray Purohit

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, J.

Citation: 2004 Bom RC 463
Print Page

When suit for eviction of tenant on ground of non user of premises will not be barred by limitation?

In view of the aforesaid pleadings and the wording of section 16(1)(n) of the Act the Courts below have observed that the suit is within limitation. Provision of section 16(1)(n) runs as under :-

"16. When landlord may recover possession (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act but subject to the provisions of section 25, a landlord shall be entitled to recover possession of any premises if the court is satisfied --

(n) that the premises have not been used without reasonable cause for the purpose for which they were let for a continuous period of six months immediately preceding the date of the suit. "

17. The aforesaid provision shows that the landlord can file suit only if he is sure that the tenant has not used the premises for the period of six months immediately preceding the date of suit. The question of limitation is mixed question of law and fact and further the knowledge of the landlord in that regard needs to be considered. Thus in a case like the present one it cannot be said with certainty that on a particular day the tenant practically stopped using the premises for the purpose for which it was given and on particular day the landlord came to know about such non user. Though it is true that initial burden is on the plaintiff to show that the suit is within limitation and for deciding the point of limitation, pleading is required to be first considered, at the time of decision, evidence is also to be considered. As there is no specific case as required by the provision of Limitation Act on the point involved, this Court holds that it is not possible to infer that the suit came to be filed after the period prescribed by Article 66 of the Limitation Act, from the date of cause of action. 


IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Civil Revision Application No. 199 of 2013

Decided On: 04.08.2015

Shankarlal Ramsay Sharma  Vs.  Sushilabai Govindlal Wani

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
T.V. Nalawade, J.

Citation: 2015(5) ALLMR 346
Print Page

Whether eviction decree can be passed against tenant on ground of non user of premises if he has subletted it?

Hence for a claim under Section 13(1)(k) it is not necessary for a landlord to establish that the premises are left to a total non-user. It is enough if he proves that his tenant has not used the premises for the purpose for which they were let for a continuous period of six months immediately preceding the date of the suit and the same was without reasonable cause. Though the premises are shown to be in use say by a third person or for a purpose other than the one for which they were let, the same cannot detract from the concept of 'non-user' contemplated under Section 13(1)(k). In this view of the matter, though the premises had been occupied by a third party, the ground of non-user is still open to the plaintiff for claiming possession.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

W.P. No. 4598 of 2005

Decided On: 20.10.2005

 Bhaskar Wamanrao Rithe  Vs. Indira Iyer

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B.P. Dharmadhikari, J.

Citation: 2006 (1) MHLJ 155
Print Page

Whether burden of proof is on tenant to prove that non user of tenanted premises was due to reasonable cause?

Recently, again, the same view has been reiterated by this Court in Smt. Aleamma v. Seth Meghraj MANU/MP/0041/1993 : 1993 (1) MPJR 378. Therefore, the absence of pleading "without reasonable cause" by the plaintiff for seeking eviction under Section 12(1)(d) of the Act, is misconceived as the law is settled that a landlord seeking eviction under Clause (d) of Section 12(1) of the Act, has only to satisfy the Court that he has pleaded and proved the non-user of the accommodation for a continuous period of six months immediately preceding the date of filing of the suit. If the plaintiff establishes his claim, the onus shifts to the tenant to establish that his default which rendered him liable to eviction was condonable by the Court because of a "reasonable cause".

9. This Court, in an unreported decision in the case of Kashibai v. Shardabai 1987 MPRCJ (N) 74 has also considered the effect of the absence of the pleading of "without reasonable cause" by the landlord and has observed that if the plaintiff pleads and proves the non-user of the accommodation for the purpose for which it was let out for a period of six months preceding the filing of the suit, absence of the pleading "without reasonable cause" will not non-suit the plaintiff.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH (GWALIOR BENCH)

Second Appeal No. 94 of 1986

Decided On: 26.08.1993

Godharam Vs. Vasudev Prasad Sharma

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.K. Dubey, J.

Citation: AIR 1994 MP 20
Print Page

Whether non user of tenanted premises is inferred if electricity bill is Nil?



On the other hand, there is record of receipts issued to the present petitioners, and in particular the son, which clearly show that after May 1978 there was no electricity consumption by the present petitioners in the suit premises. The receipts are exhibited documents and are proved. The receipts which are produced are the counter-foils and the original receipts have been issued to the present petitioners and the counter-foils are also bearing the signature of the son and they show very clearly that no electricity charges were included except the meter charges of .50 p. per month in the said bills. On the reverse of the said counter-foils, the meter reading is also shown and that specifically mentions that consumption was nil. On the reverse of the said counter-foils there is also signature of the son and, therefore, it cannot be said that what was written on the reverse of the counter-foils was not known to the present petitioners. As a matter of fact, he could not have said so as the rent receipts have in fact been issued to them and if there was any variance in the same, they could have definitely produced the same in the Court as the receipts must be in possession of the petitioners. The said receipts therefore, conclusively establish that there was no electricity consumption in the suit premises from May, 1978 and it cannot be said to be a coincidence that it is only since May, 1978 that the son occupied the newly constructed premises. Putting all this evidence together, it cannot be said that the appellate Court was in error in concluding that the suit premises was proved to be not in use by the mother, i.e. the present petitioner No. 2 and as the said finding is based on evidence on record it cannot be interfered with by this Court.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 3037 of 1985

Decided On: 29.10.1990

Shankar Vishnu Vengurlekar Vs. Rajaram Pandurang Deshpande and Ors.
Print Page

Whether landlord has discretion to seek premises from any of tenant?

Once it is established that the landlord required the premises bonafide and reasonably, it is his choice as to which premises and from which tenant he should seek the same. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 3037 of 1985

Decided On: 29.10.1990

Shankar Vishnu Vengurlekar Vs. Rajaram Pandurang Deshpande and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
I.G. Shah, J.

Citation: 1992 (1)  Rent Control Reporter 511
Print Page

Wednesday, 8 August 2018

Whether eviction decree will be passed against legal heirs of deceased tenant if they are not using tenanted premises?

As regards the hardship, it may be noted that no hardship is likely to be caused to the tenant. The original tenant was Mr. Manek who is dead and gone long ago. His wife Mehroo has also died in the year 1993. Their daughter Praised who was defendant No. 2 in the suit, is not using the suit premises. She has stated in her deposition that she works in a hospital and does not use the suit premises. She has a sister. The sister is also not using the suit premises. It is alleged that husband of the sister is using the suit premises as an office for his business of event management. Revision petitioner has admitted in her deposition the use started after the marriage of her sister which took place on 14th February, 1994. The mother of the revision petitioner died on 26th March, 1993. Thus admittedly from March, 1993 to February, 1994 the suit premises were not used at all. Even today the premises are not being used by any of the heirs of the original tenant Manek or even the heirs of his wife Mehroo. Thus the persons who could have inherited the tenancy under Section 5(11)(c) of the Bombay Rent Act are not using the suit premises nor do they require it. In the circumstances no hardship would be caused to the revision petitioner, by passing a decree of eviction.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Civil Revision Application No. 370 of 2003, Appeal No. 737 of 2001 and R.A.E. Suit No. 924 of 1990

Decided On: 09.10.2006

Praised Darius Gandhi Vs. B.A. Rane and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
D.G. Karnik, J.

Citation: 2007 (2) MHLJ 590
Print Page

Whether eviction decree will be denied to landlord if tenant casually visits tenanted premises?

 Chagla, C.J. Has further observed that - "Now, a mere casual occupation of premises does not constitute residence in those premises. In construing sub-clause (k), one must also bear in mind the object of the Legislature in passing this legislation. The Rent Restriction Act is passed because there was a scarcity of premises and therefore it was necessary to protect bonafide tenants and also to see that premises were not left unoccupied so that people in need of premises should not be deprived of them and also a tenant should not have one set of premises of one place and go about residing in some other premises. Therefore, the purpose within the meaning of sub-clause (k) for which premises are let is the purpose of permanent residence; not a mere casual occupation, not a mere spasmodic stay in the premises." So this decision of Chagla, C.J. interprets the words 'use' in a way connecting it with 'residence' importing that word in sub-clause (k) also and quite justifiably. As considered by me earlier, the purpose of the Rent Control Act is that the people in need of premises should not be deprived of them and also a tenant should not have one set of premises at one place and go about residing in some other premises. This is what exactly done in the instant case. The petitioner wants to continue her premises in Baroda and she states that her parents stay in the said premises. Her very parents have their own premises in Bombay where the petitioner herself stays. So it is not a case where person is without a shelter. But on the contrary, the person is trying to have shelter at both the places depriving some needy tenant of shelter in Baroda. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

Civil Revision Application No. 713 of 1979

Decided On: 03.04.1984

Mohini Bhiryomal Hingorani Vs. Bhanubhai Manilal Patel

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
V.V. Bedarkar, J.

Citation: 1985 Bom RC 27
Print Page

Whether eviction decree will be passed against tenant on ground of non user if he fails to produce documents regarding his business?

It is true that though he had maintained documents about his grocery business, the record has been eaten up by white-ants and cockroaches. This by itself would not dislodge the claim of the defendant that during the said period, he was carrying on with grocery business in the suit premises. The defendant has placed on record documents like payments made to the Telephone Department vide Exh. 11 colly., electricity bill (Exh. 10 colly.), payments made to the Corporation for weather frame (Exh. 9 colly.) and registration certificate of the establishment (Exh. 8) which covers the period in dispute. It is not disputed that the defendant obtained licence to sell, stock or exhibit for sale or distribute drugs by retail from 22-11-1972 to 31-12-1973 i.e. after filing of the suit. But this by itself would not show that the defendant was not doing any business in the premises prior to this.

12. If the evidence of the parties is weighed, it cannot be said that the plaintiffs by merely stating on oath that the defendant was not doing any business in the premises during the said period except for running a matka den would entitle them to evict the defendant from the premises. The evidence of the defendant as well as the documents placed before the Court would show that the premises were not kept idle and in all probability it was used for business. In this background, it cannot be said that the two Courts below committed any error or illegality in dismissing the suit of the plaintiffs on the ground of Section 13(1)(k) of the Bombay Rent Act. Therefore, I find no merit in the petition and the same is dismissed with no order as to costs. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petn. No. 1779 of 1988

Decided On: 03.08.2000

Laxmibai Ramji and Ors. Vs. Khimji Palan

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
J.N. Patel, J.

Citation: 2000(4) ALLMR 314
Print Page

Sunday, 7 January 2018

Whether non user of tenanted premises can be inferred on basis of electricity meter reading?

 Now if coming to the case in hand, learned Appellate Authority has formed an opinion on the basis of evidence available on record that the consumption of electricity for the period May, 2003 till December, 2003 was nil, whereas, till February, 2004, 40 units. Also that during the period from April, 2004 to February, 2006, again the consumption of electricity in the demised premises was nil. After taking note of the law laid down by this Court in Gurbachan Singh V. Ravinder Nath Bhalla and others Latest HLJ 2006 (HP) 177 and in Joginder Nath Sood V. Jagat Ram Sood MANU/HP/0015/1990 : 1989(1) Sim.L.C. 179 has held that the nil consumption of electricity during the period April, 2004 to February, 2006 i.e. preceding the institution of Rent Petition, which was instituted on 23.12.2005 extends a ground in favour of the landlord to seek eviction of the tenant on the ground of ceased to occupy. In order to meet out the claim of the petitioner-tenant that he had been visiting the demised premises occasionally, learned Appellate Authority, while taking note of the law laid down by this Court in Joginder Nath Sood V. Jagat Ram Sood MANU/HP/0015/1990 : 1989(1) Sim.L.C. 179 and in Sohan Lal Khanna V. Amar Singh MANU/HP/0185/2000 : 2000(2) Latest HLJ 1008, has held that occasional and casual visits of the tenant would not clothe him with the status of in occupation of the demised premises so as to frustrate the right of the landlord to seek his eviction on the ground of ceased to occupy. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA

Civil Revision No. 42 of 2009

Decided On: 04.05.2017

Sanjay Kumar Vs. Dinesh Chand

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dharam Chand Chaudhary, J.
Citation: AIR 2017(NOC) 920.
Print Page

Friday, 1 December 2017

How to appreciate evidence in case of non user of tenanted premise in eviction suit?

As far as the issue of non-user is concerned, the same has been dealt with by the Trial Court from paragraphs 9 to 15 of its order. It has referred to the evidence in considerable detail and after examining it in its entire perspective has come to the conclusion that the Defendant was not using the suit premises for a continuous period of six months prior to the filing of the suit. What is important to note is that the Trial Court has taken into consideration the electricity consumption for the suit premises and has clearly stated that on most of the times electricity consumption was 'Zero' units for the period from June 2005 to January 2009. The learned Trial Court correctly surmises that if the Defendant was actually using and living in the suit premises as contended by him, there ought to be a regular consumption of electricity. Merely because the Defendant has produced the ration-card, election identity card and other documents showing the address of the suit premises would not by itself with nothing more, establish that the suit premises were used by the Defendant. Another factor that the Trial Court took into consideration was the fact that the wife of the Defendant admittedly used the alternate premises in Thane. It is not the case of the Defendant that he is estranged from his wife and living separately. This is coupled with the fact that the Defendant was 71 years old and was certainly unlikely to live alone all by himself. Another factor which indicates that the suit premises were not being used by the Defendant, are the service reports of the Bailiff. These reports clearly shows that the Defendant was not available at the suit premises on three occasions when the writ of summons was sought to be served at the said address. When inquiries were made with the neighbour, it was revealed that most of the times the premises remained locked. Looking to all these facts and considering all the evidence, the Trial Court disbelieved the story of the Defendant that he was in use and occupation of the suit premises as alleged by him. Even the appellate Court has considered all these aspects and confirmed the findings and conclusions reached by the Trial Court on this issue. On going through these findings and conclusions, I am clearly of the opinion that the Courts below have correctly applied their mind to the evidence led before them and come to the correct conclusions. It certainly cannot be said that the analysis of the evidence done by the Courts below suffers from any perversity as sought to be contended before me.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Civil Revision Application No. 746 of 2015

Decided On: 15.06.2017

Shridhar Dattatraya Karadkar Vs. Narayan Laxman Soparkar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B.P. Colabawalla, J.

Citation: 2017(4) MHLJ 713

Print Page

How to prove non user of tenanted premises in suit for eviction?

Having considered the rival submissions in the light of the evidence on record, it is not possible to accept the contentions of Shri Dalvi. A perusal of the evidence clearly shows that in October, 1974 the petitioner left Pune for good and he shifted his entire family viz. his wife, two children and his mother to Nagpur in May, 1975. Apart from the fact the petitioner was provided with Service Quarters at the Pench Project, near Nagpur, the petitioner acquired tenanted premises in Dhantoli at Nagpur and got his ration card and gas connection transferred from Pune to Nagpur. Merely because the petitioner kept some of his belongings in the suit premises at Pune, it would not be possible to hold that the petitioner continued to use the suit premises for the purpose for which they were let.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 3059 of 1980

Decided On: 07.01.1993

Govind Ramchandra Deo Vs. Smt. Ramabai Vasudeo Pandit and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.V. Savant, J.
Citation: 1993(1) MHLJ 437
Print Page