In a separate concurring judgment R.M. Sahai, J. after
going into the case law in paragraph 3 of his judgment, made
an extremely perceptive observation. He stated that where the
filing of the suit within limitation is made dependent on any
condition precedent, then such condition precedent not
curtailing the limitation period within which a suit could be filed,
would be valid and not hit by Section 28. In paragraph 8 of the
judgment, the learned Judge put it thus:-
“It does not directly or indirectly curtail the period of
limitation nor does it anywhere provide that the
Corporation shall be precluded from filing suit after
expiry of six months. It can utmost be construed as
a condition precedent for filing of the suit that the
appellant should have exercised the right within the
period agreed to between the parties. The right was
enforced under the agreement when notice was
issued and the company was required to pay the
amount. Assertion of right is one thing than
enforcing it in a court of law. The agreement does
not anywhere deal with enforcement of right in a
court of law. It only deals with assertion of right. The
assertion of right, therefore, was governed by the
agreement and it is imperative as well that the party
concerned must put the other side on notice by
asserting the right within a particular time as
provided in the agreement to enable the other side
not only to comply with the demand but also to put
on guard that in case it is not complied it may have
to face proceedings in the court of law. Since
admittedly the Corporation did issue notice prior to
expiry of six months from the termination of
contract, it was in accordance with the Fidelity
Insurance clause and, therefore, the suit filed by the
appellant was within time.” [para 8]
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NOS.9087-9089 of 2016
UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
V
M/S INDUSIND BANK LTD. & ANR
Dated:September 15, 2016
Print Page
going into the case law in paragraph 3 of his judgment, made
an extremely perceptive observation. He stated that where the
filing of the suit within limitation is made dependent on any
condition precedent, then such condition precedent not
curtailing the limitation period within which a suit could be filed,
would be valid and not hit by Section 28. In paragraph 8 of the
judgment, the learned Judge put it thus:-
“It does not directly or indirectly curtail the period of
limitation nor does it anywhere provide that the
Corporation shall be precluded from filing suit after
expiry of six months. It can utmost be construed as
a condition precedent for filing of the suit that the
appellant should have exercised the right within the
period agreed to between the parties. The right was
enforced under the agreement when notice was
issued and the company was required to pay the
amount. Assertion of right is one thing than
enforcing it in a court of law. The agreement does
not anywhere deal with enforcement of right in a
court of law. It only deals with assertion of right. The
assertion of right, therefore, was governed by the
agreement and it is imperative as well that the party
concerned must put the other side on notice by
asserting the right within a particular time as
provided in the agreement to enable the other side
not only to comply with the demand but also to put
on guard that in case it is not complied it may have
to face proceedings in the court of law. Since
admittedly the Corporation did issue notice prior to
expiry of six months from the termination of
contract, it was in accordance with the Fidelity
Insurance clause and, therefore, the suit filed by the
appellant was within time.” [para 8]
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NOS.9087-9089 of 2016
UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
V
M/S INDUSIND BANK LTD. & ANR
Dated:September 15, 2016
Citation:(2016) 9 SCC720