It is essential to give full opportunity to both the parties to put their respective case in the Suit, If case is made out even at the appellate stage or until the suit/litigation attains finality. The amendment which is based upon the events/facts which are available or well within the knowledge of the concerned parties before filing of the suit and the subsequent events and/or the materials cropped up after filing of the suit and which are necessary to decide the controversy and/or relevant for the proper adjudication of the issue and/or for passing executable final decree/judgment, the Court needs to consider the same differently, based upon the facts and material available on the record. The Court also to consider, that even if the facts/materials are taken on record as it is, whether the Court will be in a position to pass the executable order/decree. There is no point in passing any Judgment or order which is inexecutable. The Court cannot overlook the subsequent events or the material which are necessary for passing final order/decree in the interest of justice for or against the parties and or even to consider whether it is likely to frustrate the basic claim or the case.
15. The Apex Court a Three-Judge Bench decision in Shikharchand Jain v. Digamber Jain Praband Karini Sabha and Ors. MANU/SC/0349/1974 : [1974]3SCR101 , has observed as under:
10. ...Ordinarily, a suit is tried in all its stages on the cause of action as it existed on the date of its institution. But it is open to a Court (including a court of appeal) to take notice of events which have happened after the institution of the suit and afford relief to the parties in the changed circumstances where it is shown that the relief claimed originally has (1) by reason of subsequent change of circumstances become inappropriate; or (2) where it is necessary to take notice of the changed circumstances in order to shorten the litigation; or (3) to do complete justice between the parties.
16. In Pasupuleti Venkateswarlu v. The Motor & General Traders MANU/SC/0415/1975 : [1975]3SCR958 , a three-Judge Bench has further observed as under:
4. ...If a fact, arising after the lis has come to court and has a fundamental impact on the right to relief or the manner of moulding it, is brought diligently to the notice of the tribunal, it cannot blink as it or be blind to events which stultify or render inept the decretal remedy. Equity justifies bending the rules of procedure, where no specific provision or fair play is violated, with a view to promote substantial justice - subject, of course, to the absence of other disentitling factors or just circumstances. Nor can we contemplate any limitation on this power to take note of updated facts to confine it to the trial Court. ...We affirm the proposition that for making the right or remedy claimed by the party just and meaningful as also legally and factually in accord with the current realities, the Court can, and in many cases must, take cautious cognisance of events and developments subsequent to the institution of the proceeding provided the rules of fairness to both sides are scrupulously obeyed.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Chamber Summons No. 218 of 2009 in Suit No. 95 of 2006
Decided On: 22.04.2009
NTPC Limited Vs. Reliance Industries Limited
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Anoop V. Mohta, J.
Citation: 2009(4) ALLMR 24
Print Page