Showing posts with label amendment of pleading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label amendment of pleading. Show all posts

Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Supreme Court: Whether defendant whose defence is struck off is entitled to get copy of amended plaint?

There is something further which must be noted. As can be seen from the record, the Plaintiffs moved an application on 2nd August, 2002 to amend the description of the suit property. The endorsement on the application records that 'the case is proceeding ex parte against the Defendants'. Therefore, a copy of the said application was not served upon the Defendants. As seen from the proceedings, the application was allowed on 2nd August, 2002. Thereafter, the suit was decreed on 24th August, 2002. It is true that before the application for amendment of the plaint was allowed, the Defendants' defence was already struck out. Even if the Defendants' defence was struck out, the Defendants were entitled to a copy of the amended plaint. What was struck out was the right to defend the suit as unamended. Whether the subsequent plaint will affect the earlier order of striking out the defence will depend upon the nature of the amendment. However, even a copy of the amended plaint was not served on the Defendants. {Para 6}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 2394/2023, 

Decided On: 12.09.2024

Ranjit Singh and Ors. Vs. State of Uttarakhand and Ors. 

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Shreeniwas Oka, Ahsanuddin Amanullah and Augustine George Masih, JJ.

Author: Abhay Shreeniwas Oka, J.

Citation: 2024 INSC 724,MANU/SC/1052/2024
Print Page

Delhi HC: Whether judgment is vitiated if defendant who was proceeded exparte was not served copy of material amendment to plaint?

 In the following decision, it is held that even if a party is ex parte, and thereafter, if an amendment application is made, then that must be served to the party concerned and if the party remains absent despite notice, then the Court applying its discretion may pass an appropriate order. Reliance is placed on the following judgment:-


M/s. Jharkhand Mines and Industries Ltd. & Anr. vs. Nand Kishore Prasad & Ors., reported in MANU/BH/0058/1969 : AIR 1969 Pat 228


The High Court of Patna while dealing with the effect of passing of an ex-parte decree without service of notice at the time of the amendment of the suit, held as follows:


It was incumbent on the Court to see to it that the notice of the amended plaint was served on the defendants of that suit. The Code of Civil Procedure, in my opinion, casts a duty on the court to see that the defendants are made aware of any amendment in the plaint, whether the amendment be in regard to the addition of parties or in regard to the contents thereof. Unfortunately, the learned Subordinate Judge, who passed the ex parte decree, did not direct any notices to be issued to the defendants with a view to make them aware about the amendment of the plaint. He should have issued such notices and awaited the service report, and, if the defendants so desired, granted them an opportunity to file a written statement before putting up the suit for hearing and disposal, whether ex parte or otherwise. On this ground alone, I am of the opinion that the ex parte decree is vitiated and must be set aside. {Para 28}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

I.A. No. 9047/2011, 

Decided On: 25.05.2012

Flight Centre Travels P. Ltd. Vs. Rahul Nath and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Hon'ble Mr. Justice Manmohan Singh

 Citation: 2012:DHC:3618,MANU/DE/2202/2012.
Print Page

Tuesday, 8 September 2026

Bombay HC: Outsider's Alienation Of Joint Family Property Cannot Be Challenged In Partition Suit Between Coparceners

Here, the alienation is not done by a coparcener, but the same is done by an outsider i.e. Khot family. Therefore, the issue of alienation by Khot family to BCT cannot be a subject matter of suit for partition between Patil family members. Whether Khots had title to pass on to BCT is something which cannot be decided in suit for partition of joint family properties of Patils. Knowing this well, the alienation by Khots to BCT is consciously kept out of the scope of the suit by the Plaintiffs. The alienation made by Khot family in favour of BCT is questioned independently by a suit filed by Defendant No. 1. Knowing this difficulty, Plaintiffs have consciously kept the challenge to alienation not only outside the purview of the main suit, but have consciously not included the prayer for challenging the Indentures dated 14 January 1971 and 28 October 2009 even in the proposed amended prayers. Since the issue of permissibility to challenge alienation by a coparcener of joint family property in a partition suit is irrelevant in the facts and circumstances of the present case, it is not necessary to discuss the ratio of the judgment of Calcutta High Court in Ganeshmull Surana and of Madras High Court in Chinnasamy Naidu (supra). {Para 27}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION NO.1918 OF 2016

Arun Narayan Patil and Ors. Vs  Jayshree Jaywant Patil and Ors. 

CORAM : SANDEEP V. MARNE, J.

Dated : 27 August 2026.

Citation:2026:BHC-AS:35171
Print Page

Wednesday, 15 April 2026

Amendment of Memorandum of Appeal in First Appeal: When It May Be Allowed, and Why It Does Not Amend the Trial Court Pleadings

 A first appellate court may permit amendment of the memorandum of appeal, or grant leave to urge an additional ground, where the amendment is necessary for effective adjudication of the real controversy and does not introduce a wholly new case causing irremediable prejudice to the respondent. However, such permission does not by itself amend the plaint, written statement, claim petition, or any other pleading before the trial court; the amendment must ordinarily be carried out in the appellate record itself.

Introduction

In appellate practice, applications are often made for amendment of the memorandum of appeal after filing, and sometimes even at an advanced stage of hearing. The real difficulty for courts is not whether such power exists, but how far that power extends and what exactly changes when the amendment is allowed.

Print Page

Supreme Court: Memo of appeal if permitted to be amended would not amount to amendment of original pleading

Mr. Salve submitted that the bar under Section 25 of the Act must be considered having regard to Section 53 thereof which provides for applicability of the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure. The learned counsel urged that the Respondents had already filed an application for amendment of Memo of Appeal in terms of Order 41, Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which having been allowed, would amount to amendment of the claim application in the reference case itself. Strong reliance in this behalf has been placed on Harcharan v. State of Haryana   MANU/SC/0166/1982 : AIR1983SC43 Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Anoop Singh and Anr.   MANU/SC/0041/2003 : [2003]1SCR522 . {Para 73}

We do not agree. The pleadings before the Trial Court are the basis for adduction of evidence either before the Trial Court or before the Appellate Court. By amending the memo of appeal the original pleadings cannot be amended.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 6825-26 and 6827-6832/2003, 

Decided On: 07.09.2005

Union of India (UOI) Vs. Pramod Gupta (D) by L.Rs. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Ashok Bhan and S.B. Sinha, JJ.

Author: S.B. Sinha, J.

Citation: 2005 INSC 409,MANU/SC/0549/2005.

Print Page

Supreme Court: New grounds containing new material/facts could not have been introduced for the first time in an appeal when admittedly these grounds were not originally raised in the arbitration petition for setting aside the award

The question then arises, whether in the facts and circumstances of the present case, the High Court committed any error in rejecting the appellant's application for addition of new grounds in the memorandum of arbitration appeal. As noticed above, in the application for setting aside the award, appellant set up only five grounds viz., waiver, acquiescence, delay, laches and res judicata. The grounds sought to be added in the memorandum of arbitration appeal by way of amendment are absolutely new grounds for which there is no foundation in the application for setting aside the award. Obviously, such new grounds containing new material/facts could not have been introduced for the first time in an appeal when admittedly these grounds were not originally raised in the arbitration petition for setting aside the award. {Para 28}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 2928 of 2010 

Decided On: 01.04.2010

State of Maharashtra Vs. Hindustan Construction Company Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

R.V. Raveendran and R.M. Lodha, JJ.

Author: R.M. Lodha, J.

Citation: 2010 INSC 191, MANU/SC/0215/2010.

Read full judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Supreme court: Do the principles relating to amendment of pleadings in original proceedings apply to the amendment in the grounds of appeal?

 Do the principles relating to amendment of pleadings in original proceedings apply to the amendment in the grounds of appeal? Order XLI Rule 2 CPC makes a provision that the appellant shall not, except by leave of the Court, urge or be heard in support of any ground of objection not set forth in the memorandum of appeal; but the Appellate Court, in deciding the appeal, shall not be confined to the grounds of objections set forth in the memorandum of appeal or taken by leave of the Court. Order XLI Rule 3 CPC provides that where the memorandum of appeal is not drawn up as prescribed, it may be rejected, or be returned to the appellant for the purpose of being amended. {Para 20}


21. The aforesaid provisions in CPC leave no manner of doubt that the appellate court has power to grant leave to amend the memorandum of appeal. As a matter of fact, in Harcharan v. State of Haryana   MANU/SC/0166/1982 : (1982) 3 SCC 408 this Court observed that the memorandum of appeal has same position like the plaint in the suit. This Court said:


...When an appeal is preferred the memorandum of appeal has the same position like the plaint in a suit because plaintiff is held to the case pleaded in the plaint. In the case of memorandum of appeal same situation obtains in view of Order 41, Rule 3. The appellant is confined to and also would be held to the memorandum of appeal. To overcome any contention that such is not the pleading the appellant sought the amendment....

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 2928 of 2010 

Decided On: 01.04.2010

State of Maharashtra Vs. Hindustan Construction Company Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

R.V. Raveendran and R.M. Lodha, JJ.

Author: R.M. Lodha, J.

Citation: 2010 INSC 191, MANU/SC/0215/2010

Print Page

Supreme Court: When an appeal is preferred the memorandum of appeal has the same position like the plaint in a suit and appellate Court can permit amendment of Memo of appeal

To effectively and finally adjudicate this controversy necessary pleadings ought to be available. To highlight this real controversy it may become necessary to amend the pleadings. When an appeal is preferred the memorandum of appeal has the same position like the plaint in a suit because plaintiff is held to the case pleaded in the plaint. In the case of memorandum of appeal same situation obtains in view of Order XLI, Rule 3. The appellant is confined to and also would be held to the memorandum of appeal. To overcome any contention that such is not the pleading the appellant sought the amendment. It was declined on the sole ground that it was delayed by six years because the High Court does not refer to any other ground for rejecting this application. The High Court has not held the averments in the application about the various decisions rendered by the same High Court as being untrue or otherwise. Therefore, the foundation for the amendment is neither shaken nor knocked out. We are, therefore, left to the only question whether the appellant should be denied an opportunity to agitate what is the market value of the land and what would be justly due to him on the ground of delay in moving the application for amendment of pleadings. 

8. Accordingly, interest of justice demands that we allow the appeal, set aside the order of the High Court rejecting the application and grant the amendment application and remit the matter to the High Court. The High Court will permit the respondent to raise any contention permissible in law and dispose of the appeal on merits.

  IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3620 of 1982 

Decided On: 16.11.1982

Harcharan Vs. State of Haryana

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

D.A. Desai and R.B. Misra, JJ.

Citation: AIR 1983 SC 43, MANU/SC/0166/1982.
Print Page

Tuesday, 14 April 2026

Can a Court Allow a Time-Barred Amendment of Pleadings? Scope of Trial Court and First Appellate Court Powers Under Order VI Rule 17 CPC

Order VI Rule 17 CPC confers a wide discretionary power on civil courts to permit amendment of pleadings at any stage if the amendment is necessary for determining the real question in controversy between the parties. But this power is not unstructured: the court must weigh necessity, prejudice, limitation, due diligence, and the effect of the proposed amendment on the nature of the case.

A frequent question is whether a court can permit an amendment when the plea or relief sought to be introduced appears to be barred by limitation. The correct answer is: yes, in some cases; no, in others. There is no absolute prohibition against allowing a time-barred amendment, but a court should ordinarily decline such amendment when it introduces a fresh cause of action or a fresh relief that had already become barred on the date of the amendment application, because that would deprive the opposite party of a valuable accrued defence.

Print Page

Supreme Court: Amendments necessary for determining the real controversy should ordinarily be permitted

(i) By way of the amendment, what was sought to be done was, to question the validity of the Will, on the basis of which, the Defendant sought to have the suit dismissed, while also expanding the scope of adjudication of the suit to include movable property. It had to be then, demonstrated that determination of the genuineness of the Will was the necessary course of action in determining the issues inter se the parties and given the finding of the court below that the application was presented post the commencement of the trial, it could not have been, despite due diligence, presented prior to such commencement.[13]


(ii) Any and all delays in judicial processes should be avoided and minimised to the largest extent possible, and should generally be, and are rightly frowned upon. However, not in all cases can delay determine the fate of a Suit. The Defendant submit that the time gap between submitting the written statement to the Suit and the presentation of the application seeking leave to amend is unexplained. If this argument of the Defendant was accepted, the question of Will shall remain undecided or at best would be decided with great delay. The trial which had admittedly already commenced, would be stalled by way of a challenge to the framing of issues which, in turn, would not be in consonance with the object of Order 6 Rule 17 of Code of Civil Procedure which was aimed at preventing multiplicity or multiple avenues of litigation, subsumed under the umbrella of one dispute.[17]


(iii) Keeping in view the above, along with the fact that without determination of the question of Will and its genuineness, the partition of the Suit property would not be possible, thus there was no infirmity in the order of the High Court, allowing the amendment setting aside refusal of the Trial Court to grant such amendment.[18]

Ratio: Amendments necessary for determining the real controversy should ordinarily be permitted and should not be defeated by an unduly technical approach where complete adjudication requires the plea to be considered.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 10812 of 2024 

Decided On: 24.09.2024

Dinesh Goyal Vs. Suman Agarwal (Bindal) and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

C.T. Ravikumar and Sanjay Karol, JJ.

Author: Sanjay Karol, J.

Citation: 2024 INSC 726, MANU/SC/1053/2024
Print Page

Supreme Court: Subsequent events can be brought on record by amendment where they are linked to the original controversy and form part of a continuous cause of action

Challenging the Impugned Order, the Appellants submit that subsequent events of debarment give rise to a fresh cause of action for which a fresh suit is to be filed, regardless of the parties being the same. Accordingly, it is their case that the Underlying Debarment Order dated 31.10.2017 gave rise to a fresh cause of action for which the Respondent did not take any steps for initiating action, resulting in now being time-barred. Therefore, the proposed amendment changes the character and the nature of the suit. {Para 10}

22. We have carefully perused the Underlying Application preferred by the Respondent before the High Court. The facts sought to be brought on record relate to the subsequent debarment orders and their respective challenges. Adjudication in the Civil Suit will be incomplete and ineffective if the consequent facts are not brought on record. This is due to the fact that the subsequent debarment orders and related events form a continuous chain finding its genesis in the memo dated 08.03.2016. For instance, the Respondent has made a claim for an amount to be paid to it by penalising the Appellants for wrongfully issuing the First Debarment Order. The subsequent debarment orders all arise as a part of the same event and hence, its effect on the claim of the Respondent, if any, must be adjudicated together. Accordingly, we hold that the subsequent events form a continuous cause of action for which a fresh suit is not to be filed, as it does not change the nature and character of the Civil Suit.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 300 of 2025 

Decided On: 09.01.2025

The State of West Bengal and Ors. Vs. Pam Developments Private Limited and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Bela M. Trivedi and S.C. Sharma, JJ.

Author: S.C. Sharma, J.

Citation: 2025 INSC 69,MANU/SC/0057/2025.

Print Page

Supreme Court: What are leading principles for deciding application for amendment of pleading?

70. Our final conclusions may be summed up thus:


(i) Order II Rule 2 Code of Civil Procedure operates as a bar against a subsequent suit if the requisite conditions for application thereof are satisfied and the field of amendment of pleadings falls far beyond its purview. The plea of amendment being barred Under Order II Rule 2 Code of Civil Procedure is, thus, misconceived and hence negatived.


(ii) All amendments are to be allowed which are necessary for determining the real question in controversy provided it does not cause injustice or prejudice to the other side. This is mandatory, as is apparent from the use of the word "shall", in the latter part of Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure.


(iii) The prayer for amendment is to be allowed.

(i) if the amendment is required for effective and proper adjudication of the controversy between the parties, and


(ii) to avoid multiplicity of proceedings, provided


(a) the amendment does not result in injustice to the other side,


(b) by the amendment, the parties seeking amendment does not seek to withdraw any clear admission made by the party which confers a right on the other side and


(c) the amendment does not raise a time barred claim, resulting in divesting of the other side of a valuable accrued right (in certain situations).


(iv) A prayer for amendment is generally required to be allowed unless


(i) by the amendment, a time barred claim is sought to be introduced, in which case the fact that the claim would be time barred becomes a relevant factor for consideration,


(ii) the amendment changes the nature of the suit,


(iii) the prayer for amendment is malafide, or


(iv) by the amendment, the other side loses a valid defence.


(v) In dealing with a prayer for amendment of pleadings, the court should avoid a hypertechnical approach, and is ordinarily required to be liberal especially where the opposite party can be compensated by costs.


(vi) Where the amendment would enable the court to pin-pointedly consider the dispute and would aid in rendering a more satisfactory decision, the prayer for amendment should be allowed.


(vii) Where the amendment merely sought to introduce an additional or a new approach without introducing a time barred cause of action, the amendment is liable to be allowed even after expiry of limitation.


(viii) Amendment may be justifiably allowed where it is intended to rectify the absence of material particulars in the plaint.


(ix) Delay in applying for amendment alone is not a ground to disallow the prayer. Where the aspect of delay is arguable, the prayer for amendment could be allowed and the issue of limitation framed separately for decision.


(x) Where the amendment changes the nature of the suit or the cause of action, so as to set up an entirely new case, foreign to the case set up in the plaint, the amendment must be disallowed. Where, however, the amendment sought is only with respect to the relief in the plaint, and is predicated on facts which are already pleaded in the plaint, ordinarily the amendment is required to be allowed.


(xi) Where the amendment is sought before commencement of trial, the court is required to be liberal in its approach. The court is required to bear in mind the fact that the opposite party would have a chance to meet the case set up in amendment. As such, where the amendment does not result in irreparable prejudice to the opposite party, or divest the opposite party of an advantage which it had secured as a result of an admission by the party seeking amendment, the amendment is required to be allowed. Equally, where the amendment is necessary for the court to effectively adjudicate on the main issues in controversy between the parties, the amendment should be allowed. (See Vijay Gupta v. Gagninder Kr. Gandhi and Ors.,   MANU/DE/2236/2022)

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 5909 of 2022 

Decided On: 01.09.2022

Life Insurance Corporation of India Vs. Sanjeev Builders Private Limited and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Aniruddha Bose and J.B. Pardiwala, JJ.

Author: J.B. Pardiwala, J.

Citation: 2022 INSC 896, MANU/SC/1093/2022

Print Page

Sunday, 17 September 2023

Whether the appellate court can permit parties to adduce additional evidence if they have amended memo of appeal not original proceeding?

 We have noticed hereinbefore that the amendments have not been carried out in the pleadings in terms of Order VI, Rule 18 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The said provision being mandatory, if not complied with the consequences flowing therefrom shall ensue.The purported amendments of the Memo of Appeal and the Reference applications, therefore, could not have been the basis for allowing adduction of additional evidence as has been done by the High Court. {Para 76}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 6825-26 and 6827-6832/2003, 

Decided On: 07.09.2005

Union of India (UOI)  Vs. Pramod Gupta (D) by L.Rs. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Ashok Bhan and S.B. Sinha, JJ.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0549/2005.

Read full Judgment here: Click here

Print Page

Whether the court can determine rights of parties on the basis of other reported judgments?

 The High Court in its judgment has referred to various decisions showing that the rates specified in the notification issued by the Union of India would be admissible in evidence. There is nothing to show that the said judgments were brought on record in accordance with law. There is also nothing to show that any application under Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC was filed and allowed by the High Court permitting the Respondents to bring the said judgment on records. In fact, several reported judgments have been referred to by the High Court not for the purpose of applying the ratio therein as precedent that such notifications are admissible in evidence but for the purpose of computing the amount of compensation on the basis of the rates at which the market price was fixed therein. The High Court had referred to the judgments whereby the market value of the land had been calculated on the basis of the rates specified in such notification in respect of Vasant Vihar, Defence Enclave and several other areas, without arriving at any finding that the said judgments are admissible in evidence or otherwise have relevance for determination of the market value of the land in question. The rights of the parties, it is well- settled, must be determined on the basis of the case pleaded and proved by leading proper evidence and just not on the basis of other reported judgments [See Surendra Kumar Vakil and Ors. v. Chief Executive Officer, M.P. and Ors., MANU/SC/0227/2004 : (2004)10SCC126 and Sanjay Gera v. Haryana Urban Development Authority and Anr. MANU/SC/0127/2005 : (2005)3SCC207 ].

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 6825-26 and 6827-6832/2003, 

Decided On: 07.09.2005

Union of India (UOI)  Vs. Pramod Gupta (D) by L.Rs. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Ashok Bhan and S.B. Sinha, JJ.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0549/2005.

Read full Judgment here: Click here


Print Page

Whether pleading before trial court is deemed to be amended if said amendment in incorporated in Memo of appeal?

 The learned counsel urged that the Respondents had already filed an application for amendment of Memo of Appeal in terms of Order 41, Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which having been allowed, would amount to amendment of the claim application in the reference case itself. Strong reliance in this behalf has been placed on Harcharan v. State of Haryana MANU/SC/0166/1982 : AIR1983SC43 Ghaziabad Development Authority v. Anoop Singh and Anr. MANU/SC/0041/2003 : [2003]1SCR522 .We do not agree. The pleadings before the Trial Court are the basis for adduction of evidence either before the Trial Court or before the Appellate Court. By amending the memo of appeal the original pleadings cannot be amended. {Para 73}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 6825-26 and 6827-6832/2003, 

Decided On: 07.09.2005

Union of India (UOI)  Vs. Pramod Gupta (D) by L.Rs. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Ashok Bhan and S.B. Sinha, JJ.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0549/2005

Print Page

Friday, 28 April 2023

Can the court permit the substitution of one distinct cause of action for another by amendment of plaint?

 Principles governing amendment of pleadings are well-settled. Order VI Rule 17 C.P.C. deals with the amendment of pleadings and provides that the Court may at any stage of the proceedings allow either party to alter or amend pleadings in such a manner and on such terms as may be just and all such amendments shall be made as may be necessary for the purpose of determining the real questions in controversy between the parties. It is trite that though an amendment cannot be claimed as a matter of right under all circumstances, yet the power to allow the amendment is wide and can be exercised at any stage of the proceedings in the interest of justice. It is equally well-settled that unless serious injustice or irreparable loss is likely to be caused to the other side, the Court should adopt liberal approach and not a hyper- technical approach particularly in a case where the other side can be compensated with costs. Dominant object to allow the amendment in the pleadings liberally is to avoid multiplicity of proceedings (See: L.J. Leach & Co. Ltd. and Anr. v. Jardine Skinner & Co. MANU/SC/0009/1957 : [1957]1SCR438 , Smt. Ganga Bai v. Vijay Kumar and Ors. MANU/SC/0020/1974 : [1974]3SCR882 and B.K. Narayana Pillai v. Parmeswaran Pillai and Anr. MANU/SC/0775/1999 : AIR2000SC614 Nevertheless, one distinct cause of action cannot be substituted for another nor the subject-matter of the suit can be changed by means of an amendment. The following passage from the decision of the Privy Council in Ma Shwe Mya v. Maung Mo Hnaung A.I.R. 1922 PC 249 succinctly summarises the principle which may be kept in mind while dealing with the prayer for amendment of the pleadings:


All rules of court are nothing but provisions intended to secure the proper administration of justice, and it is therefore essential that they should be made to serve and be subordinate to that purpose, so that full powers of amendment must be enjoyed and should always be liberally exercised, but nonetheless no power has yet been given to enable one distinct cause of action to be substituted for another, nor to change, by means of amendment, the subject-matter of the suit. {Para 19}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 6114 and 6115 of 1999 and 1005 and 1006/2000

Decided On: 25.09.2006

State of A.P. and Ors.  Vs. Pioneer Builders, A.P.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

H.K. Sema and Devinder Kumar Jain, JJ.

Author: Devinder Kumar Jain, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/8520/2006

Print Page

Monday, 23 January 2023

Whether the court can allow amendment of plaint to correct four boundaries of suit property after commencement of trial?

True it is that the plaintiffs have sought to

completely alter the boundaries of the suit property in

all four directions by amending the plaint. The

amendment was opposed on the ground that the

plaintiffs were trying to fill up serious lacuna in their

case. Be that as it may. Trial in the suit is yet to

progress. In such a case, plaintiffs would be at liberty

to correctly describe the suit property by removing any

error. The trial court has not committed any error while

allowing amendment application by imposing costs.

Petition is devoid of any merits. Petition stands

dismissed without any order as to costs. {Para 3}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

950 WRIT PETITION NO.7826 OF 2022

MUNICIPAL CORPORATION Vs SABIYA SULTANA MOHAMMAD HUSSAIN BABA MASTAN AND OTHERS

CORAM : SANDEEP V. MARNE, J.

Dated : November 25, 2022.

Citation: 2023 Lawweb (Bom HC ) 2.

Print Page

Saturday, 24 December 2022

Can the court allow an amendment of the plaint to set up a total new cause of action or incorporate new pleas that are inconsistent with the original plaint?

 In the original plaint, the plaintiff claims that he is  owner in possession of one half of the property left behind by his uncle, deceased Salam Bhat, whereas other half is owned and possessed by the defendants who also happen to be the successors-in-interest of other cousin brother of Salam Bhat. In the original plaint, it is claimed by the plaintiff that the deed of adoption in favour of defendant No.1 is null and void and, as such, the property of deceased Salam Bhat has to devolve upon his heirs as per Muslim Personal Law. However, by way of proposed amendment, the plaintiff claims that in the absence of deed of adoption, he would be the lone legal heir entitled to ownership and possession of the property left behind of deceased Salam Bhat, which is clearly in contradiction to his claim made in the original plaint.

15) Apart from the above, in the original plaint, the plaintiff claims a decree of partition in respect of the suit property against the defendants whereas by way of proposed amendment, he has sought substitution of relief of partition by a decree of possession of whole of the property left behind by deceased Salam Bhat. Thus, the plaintiff seeks to change the very nature of the suit. Even the cause of action is sought to be changed by the plaintiff by amending the para of the plaint which relates to the cause of action. In the original suit, the plaintiff has claimed that he had sought partition of the property from defendant No.1 and when he refused, he filed the suit but by way of proposed amendment, the plaintiff has pleaded that he had sought possession of the property from defendant No.1 which he refused.


16) Inconsistent pleas can be taken and even subsequent events can be allowed to be incorporated by way of amendment but not when the total cause of action is going to be changed. There is no doubt that liberal approach has to be adopted while considering an application for amendment of the pleadings in order to avoid multiplicity of litigation but it does not mean that the plaintiff should be permitted to set up a total new cause of action or incorporate new pleas which are inconsistent with the pleadings of the original plaint.

17) The amendment sought by the plaintiff by way of application which he had filed before the learned trial court, if allowed would have amounted to not only the change of cause of action but also to change of nature of the suit. Therefore, the same did not deserve to be allowed and the learned trial court has rightly rejected the same. The impugned order passed by the learned trial court, therefore, does not call for any interference by this Court. The petition lacks merit and is dismissed accordingly.

Jammu & Kashmir High Court - Srinagar Bench

Abdul Aziz Bhat vs Mohammad Iqbal Bhat And Ors on 16 December, 2022
OWP No.1353/2011
Read full Judgment here: Click here
Print Page

Thursday, 15 December 2022

Whether the court can allow an amendment of plaint if it is pertaining to suit property if it introduces a new case?

 Thus, the Supreme Court has held that whether amendment changes the nature of the suit or the cause of action, so as to set up an entirely new case, foreign to the case earlier set up in the plaint, the amendment must be disallowed. In the present case there was complete absence of pleadings with regard to alleged right of pre-emption in favour of plaintiffs and therefore it cannot be stated by any stretch of imagination that the amended prayer is premised on the pleadings which already existed in the plaint. {Para 13}


15. Perusal of the impugned order passed by the trial Court

would indicate that it has completely lost sight of the fact that the

amendment would change the nature of the suit entirely. In fact,

though specific objection was raised by defendant no.5 about changeof nature of suit, the trial Court has not recorded any finding on that aspect. However the trial Court did observe that “Given thoughtful consideration to the contentions in the plaint it notices that, it is crystal clear that plaintiffs are coming with a new case in respect of their right to pre-emption.”

16. Despite arriving at a finding that plaintiffs were introducing an altogether new case by amending the plaint, the trial Court has still proceeded to allow the application for amendment on

the ground that since the amendment is also in respect of the same property, the plaintiffs are at liberty to seek a prayer as to how they are entitled to the suit property. This reasoning in my view is completely erroenous.

17. In the result, I find that the order passed by the trial

Court is indefensible and the same is liable to be set aside.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

WRIT PETITION NO.6971 OF 2022

Damodhardas Govindprasad Sangi  Vs  Fatehsinh s/o. Kalyanji Thakkar

CORAM : SANDEEP V. MARNE, J.

PRONOUNCED ON : 12-12-2022

Print Page

Saturday, 19 November 2022

Can the court allow an amendment of the written statement if the defendant takes the additional ground of defence by said amendment?

From a perusal of the amendment application we find that the appellant in their prayer for amendment has only taken an additional defence that in view of Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act, the suit itself is not maintainable. It is well settled, as noted herein earlier, that at the time of considering the prayer for amendment of the written statement it would not be open to the Court to go into the fact whether in fact the suit in view of Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act was or is not maintainable.

6. That apart it is permissible in law to amend a written statement of the defendant by which only an additional ground of defence has been taken.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 2946 of 2007 

Decided On: 10.07.2007

 Andhra Bank  Vs.  ABN Amro Bank N.V. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Tarun Chatterjee and Markandey Katju, JJ.

Author : Tarun Chatterjee, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/2907/2007, AIR 2007 SC 2511.
Print Page