From the aforesaid it is graphically clear that an Insurance
Company is not protected under the 1999 Act. Once it is held
that defendant No. 1, the New India Assurance Company, the
original tenant, is not protected, the question would be whether a
subtenant can be protected under the Act. In the case of Bhatia
Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. (supra), it has been clearly
laid down that Section 4(1) of the 1947 Act applies to premises
and not to parties or their relationship. Section 3 uses the term
‘premises’. The provision commences with the non-obstante
clause that the Act does not apply to any premises belonging to
the Government or a local authority. Sub-section 3(1)(b) makes
it clear that the Act does not apply to any bank, public sector
undertaking or certain other categories of tenants. The
Insurance Company is covered under Section 3(1)(b). Thus, as a
logical corollary, the Act does not apply to the premises held by
the Insurance Company who is a tenant.
23. The learned Single Judge has allowed protection to the
Government Department on the foundation that it has become a
tenant. We are disposed to think that the analysis is
fundamentally erroneous. When the Act does not cover the
tenant, namely, the Insurance Company as basically the
exemption applies only to premises and not to any relationship,
the subtenant who becomes a deemed tenant cannot enjoy a
better protection or privilege by ostracizing the concept of
premises which is the spine of the provision.
N THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL Nos . 3356-3357/2012
Kesri Commissariat Vs Ministry of Food and Civil Supplies,
Dipak Misra , J
Dated:April 03, 2012.
Citation: AIR 2012 SC 1271:2012(5) MHLJ 212 SC
Citation: AIR 2012 SC 1271:2012(5) MHLJ 212 SC