At this stage it would not be inapposite to read Order XXII, CPC with particular emphasis on the object sought to be achieved by introduction of sub-rule (4) in Rule 4 thereof. The provision reads as follows:
"4. Procedure in case of death of one of several defendants or of sole defendant.- (1) Where one of two or more defendants dies and the right to sue does not survive against the surviving defendant or defendants alone, or a sole defendant or sole surviving defendant dies and the right to sue survives, the Court, on an application made in that behalf, shall cause the legal representative of the deceased defendant to be made a party and shall proceed with the suit.
(2) Any person so made a party may make any defence appropriate to his character as legal representative of the deceased defendant.
(3) Where within the time limited by law no application is made under sub-rule (1), the suit shall abate as against the deceased defendant.
(4) The Court whenever it thinks fit, may exempt the plaintiff from the necessity of substituting the legal representatives of any such defendant who has failed to file a written statement or who, having filed it, has failed to appear and contest the suit at the hearing; and judgment may, in such case, be pronounced against the said defendant notwithstanding the death of such defendant and shall have the same force and effect as if it has been pronounced before death took place.
(5) Where-
(a) the plaintiff was ignorant of the death of a defendant, and could not, for that reason, make an application for the substitution of the legal representative of the defendant under this rule within the period specified in the Limitation Act, 1963 (36 of 1963), and the suit has, in consequence, abated, and
(b) the plaintiff applies after the expiry of the period specified therefor in the Limitation Act, 1963 (36 of 1963), for setting aside the abatement and also for the admission of that application under Section 5 of that Act on the ground that he had, by reason of such ignorance, sufficient cause for not making the application within the period specified in the said Act,
the Court shall, in considering the application under the said Section 5, have due regard to the fact of such ignorance, if proved."
18. What Order XXII Rule 4 postulates, in the contextual facts, is that when one of two or more defendants in a suit dies and the right to sue survives, the Court, on an application made in that behalf, shall cause the legal representative of the deceased defendant to be made a party and shall proceed with the suit. The object of bringing the legal representative of the deceased defendant on record under Order XXII Rule 4 is to have the estate of the deceased represented in the suit. If despite being seized of information of death of one of several defendants the plaintiff omits to bring his legal representative on record in the manner prescribed by law, the suit would abate as against the deceased defendant. This is what sub-rule (3) of Rule 4 ordains.
19. Sub-rule (4) was inserted in Rule 4 by the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1976 and conferred discretionary power on the Court to exempt a plaintiff from bringing the legal representative of a deceased defendant on record, who has either not filed written statement or having filed it, has abstained from contesting the suit by his non-appearance. Once exemption is granted, the judgment in the suit may be pronounced against all the defendants including the deceased defendant, and notwithstanding his death, such judgment shall have the same force and effect as if the judgment has been pronounced before the death of the deceased defendant. Therefore, sub-rule (4) is in the nature of an exception to the general rule laid down in sub-rule (3).
20. In Mata Prasad Mathur (supra), one of the defendants (Virendra Singh) was not contesting the suit. He died whereupon the plaintiff approached the trial court for deletion of his name from the array of defendants and for setting aside abatement. The matter having reached the Supreme Court, it was held that "substitution of the legal representatives of such a defendant could be legitimately dispensed with by the trial court in view of the provisions of Order 22 Rule 4 sub-rule 4" (see paragraph 3). In paragraph 9 once again, the Court observed that "in the absence of any compelling reason to the contrary the courts below could and indeed ought to have exercised the power vested in them to avoid abatement of the suit by exempting the plaintiff from the necessity of substituting the legal representative of the deceased defendant".
21. As has been observed by the Supreme Court in Mata Prasad Mathur (supra) upon noticing the several reports of the Law Commission leading to insertion of sub-rule (4) in Rule 4 of Order XXII, expedition in disposal of a suit which is not being contested by a defendant and the plaintiff not being required to bring on record the legal representatives of such non-contesting deceased defendant was the primary reason for insertion of sub-rule (4) in Rule 4 of Order XXII, CPC. The relevant observation reads as follows:
"9. It would appear from the above that the legislature incorporated the provision of Order 22 Rule 4(4) with a specific view to expedite the process of substitution of the LRs of non-contesting defendants.***"
22. There cannot be any quarrel of any nature with regard to the power that is conferred by sub-rule (4) in Rule 4 of Order XXII, CPC. But, can the power conferred by sub-rule (4) be exercised at any stage of the suit? There does not appear to be any express restriction in the statute. The statute, as read and interpreted in the decisions cited by Mr. Sen, seems to make the position clear that the power could be exercised any time prior to pronouncement of the judgment in the suit. The only check to the exercise of the power is that an order under sub-rule (4) can be passed when the judge thinks it fit. It cannot be gainsaid that grant of exemption being a matter in the discretion of the trial judge, in dealing with an application for exemption the judge ought to exercise discretion judiciously. Care must obviously be exercised to ensure that on the one hand, the object of the rule to assist the expeditious disposal of a suit is not defeated and on the other hand real and genuine defences are not shut out by passing unduly severe orders.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA
R.V.W.O. No. 44 of 2016, G.A. No. 2924 of 2016 arising out of GA 1950 of 2016 in APO 212 of 2016 arising out of GA No. 932 of 2016 in CS No. 136 of 2006
Decided On: 17.05.2017
A.K.R. Consultants (P) Ltd. and Ors.
Vs.
Asha Keshri and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dipankar Datta and Arijit Banerjee, JJ.
Citation: AIR 2017 Cal 176