Showing posts with label eye witnesses. Show all posts
Showing posts with label eye witnesses. Show all posts

Saturday, 18 April 2026

When Eyes Speak and Science Checks: Ocular vs Medical Evidence in Criminal Trials

 In criminal trials, courts often face a recurring question: what should prevail when eyewitness testimony conflicts with medical evidence? The answer is not mechanical. Indian courts have consistently held that credible ocular evidence ordinarily carries primacy, while medical evidence generally plays a corroborative role. At the same time, when medical evidence completely rules out the prosecution’s eyewitness version and renders it impossible or wholly improbable, the court must approach the ocular version with great caution.

The basic rule

Print Page

Sunday, 18 May 2025

Bombay HC: How to appreciate evidence of eye witness of accident in motor accident claim petition when said witness was relative of claimant?

Second witness of the claimant is Balasaheb Bongane CW-3. He states that he was proceeding on his motorcycle and witnessed the offending jeep dashed against motor cycle of the deceased Dattarao. He states that, he noted jeep number and informed claimant no.3-Shailesh regarding the incident. In cross-examination, he admitted that he is relative of the claimants. He states that he noted number of offending vehicle after getting a pen from the owner of sugar cane juice shop. He states that he did not felt necessary to accompany deceased to the Hospital or he never informed police chowki or doctor regarding the vehicle number or incident. He never visited the police or gave his statement to the police. The Certified copy of his statement recorded in S.C.C. No.457 of 2018 is also placed on record of the Tribunal at Exhibit 15, wherein he states that he came to know about vehicle number from the mob gathered at the spot of accident. If the aforesaid evidence is taken into account, it is difficult to believe that accident occurred in presence of CW-3. Pertinently, CW-1 admits in his cross-examination that vehicle owner bears surname Karhale as claimants and he is resident of the village which is at a distance of 30 kilometers from village of the claimants. He admits that he had received information as to owner of the vehicle, but never disclosed it to any one prior to filing of the complaint. {Para 10}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

First Appeal No. 1631 of 2024 and Civil Application No. 7984 of 2024 in FA No. 1631 of 2024

Decided On: 21.02.2025

The New India Assurance Company Ltd. Vs. Sangita and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S.G. Chapalgaonkar, J.

 Citation: 2025:BHC-AUG:4911, MANU/MH/0999/2025.

Read full judgment here: Click here. 

Print Page

Bombay HC: Whether motor accident claim tribunal should rely on evidence of witness who is declared hostile in criminal court relating to same accident?

Mr. Choudhary, submits that evidence of eye witness is absolutely unreliable. They are got up witnesses. Perusal of evidence of CW 2 Santosh shows that he runs sugarcane juice shop nearby the place of accident and claims himself to be an eye witness. However, during his cross- examination he admitted that he cannot read and write. There is no provision of electric light at the spot of accident. He did not disclose offending vehicle number to any one till police approached him. He cannot tell as to whether it was head on collision between two vehicles as he was at the distance. All these admissions coupled with fact that he turned hostile before the criminal court makes his statement unreliable.

{Para 9}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

First Appeal No. 1631 of 2024 and Civil Application No. 7984 of 2024 in FA No. 1631 of 2024

Decided On: 21.02.2025

The New India Assurance Company Ltd. Vs. Sangita and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S.G. Chapalgaonkar, J.

 Citation: 2025:BHC-AUG:4911, MANU/MH/0999/2025.

Print Page

Monday, 14 April 2025

Supreme Court: Chargesheet Sufficient To Prove Negligence, Eyewitness Testimony Not Mandatory in motor accident claim petition

It is settled in law that once a charge sheet has been filed and the driver has been held negligent, no further evidence is required to prove that the bus was being negligently driven by the bus driver. Even if the eyewitnesses are not examined, that will not be fatal to prove the death of the deceased due to negligence of the bus driver. {Para 4}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2025

RANJEET & ANR. Vs  ABDUL KAYAM NEB & ANR.

Dated: FEBRUARY 25, 2025.
Print Page

Tuesday, 31 December 2024

Supreme Court: Whether Motor accident claim tribunal can disbelieve evidence of a eye witness on the ground that police has not recorded his statement?

The courts below have recorded the finding of non-involvement of the car in the accident by disbelieving the eyewitness, PW-6 only on the ground that in the police investigation, he was not examined as an eyewitness. In our considered view, a witness who is otherwise found trustworthy cannot be disbelieved, in a motor accident case, only on the ground that the police have not recorded his statement during investigation. There is abundance of evidence pointing to the fact that the car was involved in the accident and the courts below have not considered the evidence in true perspective and have misguided themselves to record perverse finding regarding non-involvement of the car in the accident. In claim cases, arising out of motor accident, the court has to apply the principles of preponderance of probability and cannot apply the test of proof beyond reasonable doubt. The evidence available in the present case tested on the principles of preponderance of probability can record only one finding that the car was involved in the accident, otherwise, the damage found to the car in the Mahazar (Annexure P-2) was not possible. The Mahazar clearly records that the front bumper right side of the car is broken, front right parking light is broken, the grill fitted above the front bumper is curved. With such damages to the front side of the body of the car, it is impossible to record a finding that the car was not involved in the accident. {Para 16}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 7881 of 2024.

Decided On: 17.10.2024

Sajeena Ikhbal and Ors. Vs. Mini Babu George and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

C.T. Ravikumar and Prashant Kumar Mishra, JJ.

Author: Prashant Kumar Mishra, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/1120/2024,2024 INSC 787.

Print Page

Sunday, 27 February 2022

Should the court disbelieve the evidence of eye witness if he did Not Intervene When the accused attacked the Deceased?

Even otherwise, we do not find the present one to

be a case of manifest illegality so as to call for

interference. The evidence of PW-1, being the eye-witness

to the incident, remains unimpeachable and has been

believed by the two Courts. His evidence cannot be

discarded only for the reason that he allegedly did not

raise any alarm or did not try to intervene when the

deceased was being ferociously assaulted and stabbed.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1349 OF 2013

SURESH YADAV @ GUDDU  Vs. THE STATE OF CHHATTISGARH 

Author: DINESH MAHESHWARI J,

Dated: February 25, 2022.

Print Page

Saturday, 11 April 2020

Supreme Court judgment on appreciation of evidence of eye witness

While appreciating the evidence of a witness, the approach must be to assess whether the evidence of a witness read as a whole appears to be truthful. Once the impression is formed, it is necessary for the court to evaluate the evidence and the alleged discrepancies and then, to find out whether it is against the general tenor of the prosecution case. If the evidence of eye witness is found to be credible and trustworthy, minor discrepancies which do not affect the core of the prosecution case, cannot be made a ground to doubt the trustworthiness of the witness.

30. While appreciating the evidence, the court has to take into consideration whether the contradictions/omissions had been of such magnitude that they may materially affect the trial. Minor contradictions, inconsistencies, embellishments or improvements on trivial matters without effecting the core of the prosecution case should not be made a ground to reject the evidence in its entirety. The trial court, after going through the entire evidence, must form an opinion about the credibility of the witnesses and the appellate court in normal course would not be justified in reviewing the same again without justifiable reasons. 
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1066 of 2009

Decided On: 08.08.2019

 Mallikarjun  Vs.  State of Karnataka
Print Page

Friday, 27 December 2019

Leading Supreme court judgment on appreciation of medical evidence and ocular evidence

Coming to the plea that the medical evidence is at variance with ocular evidence, it has to be noted that it would be erroneous to accord undue primacy to the hypothetical answers of medical witnesses to exclude the eye-witnesses' account which had to be tested independently and not treated as the "variable" keeping the medical evidence as the "constant".

9. It is trite that where the eye-witnesses' account is found credible and trustworthy, medical opinion pointing to alternative possibilities is not accepted as conclusive. Witnesses, as Bentham said, are the eyes and ears of justice. Hence the importance and primacy of the quality of the trial process. Eye witnesses' account would require a careful independent assessment and evaluation for their credibility which should not be adversely prejudged making any other evidence, including medical evidence, as the sole touchstone for the test of such credibility. The evidence must be tested for its inherent consistency and the inherent probability of the story; consistency with the account of other witnesses held to be credit-worthy; consistency with the undisputed facts; the 'credit' of the witnesses; their performance in the witness-box; their power of observation etc. Then the probative value of such evidence becomes eligible to be put into the s for a cumulative evaluation.

10. A person has, no doubt, a profound right not to be convicted of an offence which is not established by the evidential standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt. Though this standard is a higher standard, there is, however, no absolute standard. What degree of probability amounts to 'proof' is an exercise particular to each case? Referring to probability amounts to 'proof' is an exercise the inter-dependence of evidence and the confirmation of one piece of evidence by another a learned author says: (See "The Mathematics of Proof II": Glanville Williams: Criminal Law Review, 1979, by Sweet and Maxwell, p.340 (342).

"The simple multiplication rule does not apply if the separate pieces of evidence are dependent. Two events are dependent when they tend to occur together, and the evidence of such events may also be said to be dependent. In a criminal case, different pieces of evidence directed to establishing that the defendant did the prohibited act with the specified state of mind are generally dependent. A junior may feel doubt whether to credit an alleged confession, and doubt whether to infer guilt from the fact that the defendant fled from justice. But since it is generally guilty rather than innocent people who make confessions and guilty rather than innocent people who run away, the two doubts are not to be multiplied together. The one piece of evidence may confirm the other."
11. Doubts would be called reasonable if they are free from a zest for abstract speculation. Law cannot afford any favourite other than truth. To constitute reasonable doubt, it must be free from an over emotional response. Doubts must be actual and substantial doubts as to the guilt of the accused persons arising from the evidence, or from the lack of it, as opposed to mere vague apprehensions. A reasonable doubt is not an imaginary, trivial or a merely possible doubt; but a fair doubt based upon reason and commonsense. It must grow out of the evidence in the case.

12. The concepts of probability, and the degrees of it, cannot obviously be expressed in terms of units to be mathematically enumerated as to how many of such units constitute proof beyond reasonable doubt. There is an unmistakable subjective element in the evaluation of the degrees of probability and the quantum of proof. Forensic probability must, in the last analysis, rest on a robust common sense and, ultimately, on the trained intuitions of the judge. While the protection given by the criminal process to the accused persons is not to be eroded, at the same time, uninformed legitimization of trivialities would make a mockery of administration of criminal justice. This position was illuminatingly stated by Venkatachaliah, J. (as His Lordship then was) in State of U.P. v. Krishna Gopal and Anr. MANU/SC/0506/1988 : 1989CriLJ288 .


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal Nos. 238-239 of 2004

Decided On: 29.10.2004

State of Madhya Pradesh Vs. Dharkole and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dr. Arijit Pasayat and C.K. Thakker, JJ.
Print Page

Friday, 2 March 2018

Guidelines of supreme court on examination of eye witnesses

 We are also of the view that it is necessary in the interest of justice that the eye-witnesses are examined by the prosecution at the earliest.

12. It is also necessary that the statements of eye-witnesses are got recorded during investigation itself Under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure In view of amendment to Section 164 Code of Criminal Procedure by the Act No. 5 of 2009, such statement of witnesses should be got recorded by audio-video electronic means.

13. To conclude:

(i) The trial courts must carry out the mandate of Section 309 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as reiterated in judgments of this Court, inter alia, in State of U.P. v. Shambhu Nath Singh and Ors. MANU/SC/0221/2001 : (2001) 4 SCC 667, Mohd. Khalid v. State of W.B. MANU/SC/0722/2002 : (2002)7 SCC 334 and Vinod Kumar v. State of Punjab MANU/SC/0068/2015 : (2015)3 SCC 220.

(ii) The eye-witnesses must be examined by the prosecution as soon as possible.

(iii) Statements of eye-witnesses should invariably be recorded Under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as per procedure prescribed thereunder.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal Nos. 2045-2046 of 2017 (Arising out of Special Leave Petition (Crl.) Nos. 8994-8995 of 2015) 

Decided On: 28.11.2017

Doongar Singh and Ors. Vs. The State of Rajasthan

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.K. Goel and U.U. Lalit, JJ.


Print Page

Monday, 25 December 2017

Whether testimony of eye witnesses can be disbelieved on basis of site plan?

Next, it has been contended by the learned Counsel for the Respondents that the site plan belies the prosecution claim in view of the height of agricultural crops, as PW 1, PW 2 and PW 5 could not have seen the incident and more precisely as to which accused was doing what. However, when we examine the deposition of PW 8, it appears that there was some disparity in the height of the agricultural crops. While some crops were waist high, others were only as high as the knees. Hence, there is not much force in this submission of the learned Counsel for the Respondents either. Besides, the judgment of this Court in Prithvi v. Mam Raj MANU/SC/0143/2004 : (2004) 13 SCC 279, is an authority for the proposition that site plan is not a ground to disbelieve the otherwise credible testimony of eye-witnesses.


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1482 of 2013

Decided On: 20.10.2016

 Yogesh Singh Vs.  Mahabeer Singh and Ors.
Print Page

Sunday, 30 April 2017

Whether evidence of eye witnesses can be disbelieved on ground of discrepancy with site plan?

Next, it has been contended by the learned counsel for the respondents that the site plan belies the prosecution claim in view of the height of agricultural crops, as PW1, PW2 and PW5 could not have seen the incident and more precisely as to which accused was doing what. However, when we examine the deposition of PW8, it appears that there was some disparity in the height of the agricultural crops. While some crops were waist high, others were only as high as the knees. Hence, there is not much force in this submission of the learned counsel for the respondents either. Besides, the judgment of this Court in Prithvi Vs. Mam Raj, (2004) 13 SCC 279, is an authority for the proposition that site plan is not a ground to disbelieve the otherwise credible testimony of eye-witnesses.
Reportable
Supreme Court of India
Yogesh Singh vs Mahabeer Singh & Ors on 20 October, 2016
Bench: Pinaki Chandra Ghose, Amitava Roy
Citation: 2017 CRLJ 291 SC
Print Page

Saturday, 8 April 2017

Whether evidence on eye witness can be rejected on ground of minor inconsistency?

The next part of the episode is giving a fatal blow to deceased Firoz Nimbargi. Evidence of Dr. Rajendra Parmar (PW8) and report of postmortem examination (Exhibit 99) of dead body of Firoz Nimbargi shows that he had suffered only one blow of the knife which ultimately proved fatal. Except PW1 Abhijit Nikude, rest of the three witnesses viz., PW2 Anwar Nimbargi, PW3 Tanvir Qureshi and PW4 Noor Mohd., are attributing fatal blow on Firoz Nimbargi by appellant/accused No. 1 Kasam only. It appears that except this inconsistency in evidence of PW1 Abhijit Nikude, rest of the part of his version regarding the entire episode of murder of Firoz Nimbargi and assault on prosecution witnesses, is consistent with version of injured eye witnesses as well as PW4 Noor Mohd. The entire incident as stated in foregoing paragraphs took place in rapid succession in a short span of time as seen even from cross-examination of PW1 Abhijit Nikude. There was an element of shock and surprise to PW1 Abhijit Nikude because of this incident wherein one person of his acquaintance was murdered and atleast two persons suffered injuries. Even power of observation differs from person to person. Merely because informant PW1 Abhijit Nikude has stated that appellant/accused No. 2 Rahim had also given blows of chopper on deceased Firoz Nimbargi, his evidence cannot be jettisoned on this count by branding him as a liar. It is well settled that "falsus in uno falsus in omnibus" (false in one thing, false in everything) is neither a sound rule of law nor a sound rule of practice. It is inapplicable to criminal cases in India, as witnesses may be partly truthful and partly false in their evidence. Experience shows evidence of many witnesses contains a grain of untruth or some exaggeration or embellishment. This many a times happens perhaps due to fear in the mind of witnesses that their testimony may be rejected. The court should not disbelieve evidence of such witnesses altogether if they are otherwise trustworthy. Discrepancies in deposition of witnesses are always there however honest or truthful they may be. Discrepancies caused due to normal error of observation, normal error of memory due to lapse of the time, due to mental disposition, impaired mental faculty due to impact or shock caused due to incident needs to be ignored. The prosecution case would fall only where inconsistencies in it goes to the root of the case. Otherwise, it becomes the duty of the court to sift truth from falsehood by culling out nuggets of truth from evidence of witnesses examined by the prosecution. If such exercise is possible, their evidence cannot be discarded wholly.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Criminal Appeal Nos. 956, 1069, 1127 of 2005 and 624 of 2006
Decided On: 06.12.2016
Kasam Alisha Shaikh and Ors.

Vs.
The State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V.K. Tahilramani and A.M. Badar, JJ.
Print Page

Sunday, 13 November 2016

How to appreciate evidence if one eye witness did not see other witness during occurence of incident?

When we analyse the statements of PW1 and PW65, they are not contradictory to each other, rather they are complementary to each other. Merely because PW65 did not see PW1 until the accused had left, does not mean that she was not present at the place of occurrence and she did not witness the occurrence. She has already stated that she was afraid of her own life and so she was hiding to some extent, and thus, PW65 might not have seen her. PW65 made a call to the police but did not mention PW1’s presence to the police at that time. This fact is quite natural as in the commotion, he had made a police call only to inform the police about the incident and could not provide details for the same.
The fact that PW1 was not named in the inquest report is of no consequence as the inquest report relates to the cause of death and not the witnesses’ account of the incident. The first informant though had not named PW1 in the complaint such omission is not fatal in the face of otherwise cogent and convincing evidence of PW1, corroborated by PW65. 

Reportable

Sheikh Sintha Madhar @ Jaffer @ ... vs State Rep.By Inspector Of Police on 13 April, 2016

Bench: Pinaki Chandra Ghose, Amitava Roy
Citation:AIR 2016 SC 1844 ; 2016(3) Supreme 752
Print Page

Tuesday, 17 May 2016

Whether prosecution case can be disbelieved on the ground that independent witness is not examined?

 As far as the non-examination of any other independent witness
is concerned, there is no doubt that the prosecution has not been
able to produce any independent witness. But, the prosecution case
cannot be doubted on this ground alone. In these days, civilized
people are generally insensitive to come forward to give any
statement in respect of any criminal offence. Unless it is inevitable,
people normally keep away from the Court as they feel it distressing
and stressful. Though this kind of human behaviour is indeed
unfortunate, but it is a normal phenomena. We cannot ignore this
handicap of the investigating agency in discharging their duty. We
cannot derail the entire case on the mere ground of absence of
independent witness as long as the evidence of the eyewitness,
though interested, is trustworthy.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. 1467-1468 OF 2005
SADHU SARAN SINGH 
V
STATE OF U.P. AND ORS. 
Dated;FEBRUARY 26, 2016
N.V. RAMANA, J.
Citation;(2016) 4 SCC357
Print Page

Tuesday, 5 May 2015

Whether it is mandatory for prosecution to examine all eye witnesses?

We are also not impressed by the arguments of the learned counsel appearing for the appellants when he contended that one eye- witness, Kariya was not examined and hence it has weakened the case of the prosecution.
 The law does not say that the prosecution must examine all the eye-witnesses cited by the prosecution. When the evidence of two eye- witnesses, PWs 1 and 3 was found worthy of acceptance to prove the case then it was not necessary for the prosecution to examine any more eye-witnesses. It is for the prosecution to decide as to how many and who should be examined as their witnesses for proving their case. Therefore, we find no merit in this submission.
Supreme Court of India
Nand Kumar vs State Of Chhattisgarh on 31 October, 2014

Bench: Fakkir Mohamed Kalifulla, Abhay Manohar Sapre
Citation; 2015 ALLSCR 326
Print Page

Sunday, 17 August 2014

Whether testimony of eye witness identification expert is admissible in evidence?


 Principles proposed by psychologists in the field of eyewitness recognition:  
–exposure time (the amount of time available for viewing a perpetrator affects the witness’s ability to identify the perpetrator);
–cross-racial and cross-ethnic inaccuracy (non-Hispanic Caucasian eyewitnesses are generally less accurate in identifying Hispanic people than in identifying other non-Hispanic Caucasians);
–weapon focus (a victim’s focus on the weapon used in an assault can affect ability to observe and remember the attacker);
–lineup fairness (similarity of fillers to the suspect increases identification accuracy);
–lineup instructions (police instructions indicating that the police believe the perpetrator to be in the lineup increase the likelihood of false identification);
–forgetting curve (the rate of memory loss for an event is greatest right after the event and then levels off over time);
–postevent information (eyewitness testimony about an event often reflects not only what the witness actually saw but also information the witness obtained later);
–wording of questions (eyewitness testimony about an event can be affected by how questions put to the witness during investigation are worded);
–unconscious transference (eyewitnesses sometimes identify as the culprit an individual familiar to them from other situations or contexts);
–simultaneous versus sequential lineups(witnesses are more likely to make mistakes when they view simultaneous lineups than when they view sequential lineups);
–eyewitness confidence issues (an eyewitness’s confidence level is not a good predictor of eyewitness accuracy, but eyewitness confidence is the major determinant in whether an identification is believed by jurors), and
–confidence malleability(eyewitnesses’ confidence levels can be influenced by factors unrelated to identification accuracy).
People v. Santiago 
2011 NY Slip Op 07303
Decided New York Court of Appeals October 20, 2011

Print Page