Showing posts with label benefit of doubt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label benefit of doubt. Show all posts

Saturday, 18 April 2026

When Eyes Speak and Science Checks: Ocular vs Medical Evidence in Criminal Trials

 In criminal trials, courts often face a recurring question: what should prevail when eyewitness testimony conflicts with medical evidence? The answer is not mechanical. Indian courts have consistently held that credible ocular evidence ordinarily carries primacy, while medical evidence generally plays a corroborative role. At the same time, when medical evidence completely rules out the prosecution’s eyewitness version and renders it impossible or wholly improbable, the court must approach the ocular version with great caution.

The basic rule

Print Page

Tuesday, 24 June 2025

How to appreciate evidence if in criminal case accused has received injuries and if prosecution fails to explain how accused has sustained injury?

 In Indian criminal law, the failure of prosecution to explain injuries sustained by the accused is a significant circumstance that courts must carefully consider while appreciating evidence. The legal position has evolved through various Supreme Court judgments that have established different theories and approaches.

General Principle

Print Page

Saturday, 24 June 2023

Does the Mention of the Expression 'Benefit of Doubt' in a Judgment of Acquittal Indicate that the Acquittal Was Not Honourable?


 However, the fact remains that mere use of the expression ‘benefit of doubt’ in the judgment of criminal court, by itself, would not deprive the employee from claiming that the acquittal was ‘honourable’ or ‘clean’. If in the totality of the circumstances, the court comes to the conclusion that the acquittal of an employee is after consideration of the entire material and recording categorical finding that the guilt is not proved, the fact that the criminal court had also used an expression ‘benefit of doubt’ in the judgment would not constitute an impediment in inferring ‘honourable acquittal’.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION NO.12326 OF 2017

Eknath Shankar Kamble Vs  Chief Executive Officer,

CORAM: N.J.JAMADAR, J.

PRONOUNCED ON : 8 JUNE 2023

Print Page

Sunday, 6 October 2019

Whether accused can be given benefit of doubt in offence U/S 307 of IPC if there is single blow of blunt part of weapon?

 It is in view of all these circumstances, in my considered view
when only a single blow of blunt part of a weapon has been used in
inflicting injury, there is reasonable doubt as to if really accused
Vikram was intending or had knowledge to kill Kashinath. In exactly
similar fact situation in the case of Hari Singh (supra), the Supreme
Court had upheld acquittal of the accused under Section 307 of the
I.P.C. It is in this fact situation and the evidence, it is quite apparent
that the two Courts below have not appreciated the aforementioned
circumstances in their proper perspective and by overlooking them
have convicted accused Vikram for the offence punishable under
Section 307 of the I.P.C. Had they borne in mind these circumstances
and the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Hari Singh
(supra), they would not have reached the conclusion which they
have.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION NO.145 OF 2004

Vikram Waman Bachake  Vs The State of Maharashtra


CORAM
: MANGESH S. PATIL,J.

PRONOUNCED ON : 04/06/2019.

Print Page

Monday, 29 July 2019

Whether accused is entitled to get benefit of doubt if dead body is not recovered?

 Sevaka Perumal and another vs. State of Tamil Nadu,
(1991) 3 SCC 471, was also a case where the corpus delicti was not
found yet conviction was upheld observing:
“5….In a trial for murder it is not an absolute
necessity or an essential ingredient to establish
corpus delicti. The fact of death of the deceased must
be established like any other fact. Corpus delicti in

some cases may not be possible to be traced or
recovered. Take for instance that a murder was
committed and the dead body was thrown into
flowing tidal river or stream or burnt out. It is
unlikely that the dead body may be recovered. If
recovery of the dead body, therefore, is an absolute
necessity to convict an accused, in many a case the
accused would manage to see that the dead body is
destroyed etc. and would afford a complete immunity
to the guilty from being punished and would escape
even when the offence of murder is proved. What,
therefore, is required to base a conviction for an
offence of murder is that there should be reliable and
acceptable evidence that the offence of murder, like
any other factum of death was committed and it
must be proved by direct or circumstantial evidence,
although the dead body may not be traced…”

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO(s).1070 OF 2017

SANJAY RAJAK Vs  THE STATE OF BIHAR 

NAVIN SINHA, J.
Dated:July 22, 2019.
Print Page

Sunday, 14 May 2017

Whether a person is entitled to get compensation if he is acquitted in Rape case?

The petitioner has invoked the writ jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and the inherent powers of this Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The principal prayer of the petitioner is to direct the respondent no.1 to pay an amount of Rs.200 crores towards compensation for ruining the life of the petitioner in the matter of his illegal arrest, detention and wrongful confinement for a long period of seven years though he is not responsible for the commission of offence of which he was charged. 2 The petitioner had also preferred criminal application no.92 of 2016 and seeking interim compensation in the sum of Rs.100 crores during the pendency of the petition before this Court.
We have already made observations hereinabove that the petitioner has not succeeded in attributing any malafides or malice to the investigating machinery or to the victim who had impleaded him as an accused in the said proceedings. The attributes of malafides or malice are not reflected either in the cross-examination of the prosecution witnesses at the instance of the defence, nor in the statement of the accused which was recorded under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code. Nor there were any arguments in that regard before the trial Court or before the Appellate Court. It is reiterated hereinabove. We have already observed that the petitioner was entitled for the benefit of doubt as observed by the Appellate Court on account of infirmities in the evidence or the doubt expressed by the Court with regard to the identification of the petitioner - accused. It is well settled that relief in exercise of powers under Article 226 of Constitution of India can be granted only when it is established  that there was or has been infringement of fundamental right of the citizen and no other form of appropriate redressal by the Court in the facts and circumstances of the case is possible. It is well settled that the Courts are empowered to award the compensation where it is a established fact that infringement was patent and incontrovertible and the violation was gross. The petitioner was subjected to trial by following procedure established by law. For all the reasons mentioned hereinabove, we are not inclined to award compensation as prayed by the petitioner and, we are, therefore, of the opinion that the petitioner is not entitled to any relief as prayed in the petition. The grant of compensation or the relief sought by the petitioner seeking investigation is also not warranted in the present proceeding.
Bombay High Court
Gopal S/O. Ramdas Shetye vs The State Of Maharashtra on 5 May, 2017
Print Page

Thursday, 4 May 2017

Whether accused can be acquitted on ground that prosecution witnesses gave contradictory evidence?

 A mere statement that the accused-appellant Jhuma was involved in illicit act of prostitution and that she insisted Ashalata to involve in the illicit activity and Ashalata denied to do so and therefore, she was tortured, in the particular facts and circumstances of this case where the other allegation of the prosecution is that the accused Sanjib used to suspect the character of his wife Ashalata and therefore, killed her in the night taking her out of the dwelling hut on some pretext are quite contradictory with each other and, therefore, I think the accused-appellant should get the benefit of doubt. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
Crl. Appeal No. 24 of 2013
Decided On: 08.12.2016
 Jhuma Das

Vs.
 State of Tripura

Coram:

S.C. Das, J.

Citation: 2017 CRLJ 1204
Print Page

Tuesday, 11 October 2016

Whether accused is entitled to get benefit of doubt if prosecution suppresses genesis and origin of occurrence?

 The High Court has also noted that both the sides had taken a
plea that the land in question where the occurrence had taken place
is in their possession. One of the injured Malli Devi-PW6 also

deposed, as noted by the High Court, that the parties were having
dispute with the accused over land. The High Court has also noted
the Judgment of this Court in the case of Lakshmi Singh and others
v. State of Bihar  1976 (4) SCC 394
 which was relied upon by the counsel for the
accused persons in support of private defence and for acquittal on the
ground of non-explanation of death and injuries on the side of the
accused. The High Court drew correct inferences from the aforesaid
judgment but proceeded to convict the appellants on the misconceived
ground that since both the parties had withheld the origin and genesis
of the occurrence and since it cannot be determined as to which party
was the aggressor, the case had to be decided against the accused
persons treating it as a case of free fight between the parties.
The aforesaid view of the High Court is devoid of legal merits.
Once the Court came to a finding that the prosecution has suppressed
the genesis and origin of the occurrence and also failed to explain the
injuries on the person of the accused including death of father of the
appellants, the only possible and probable course left open was to
grant benefit of doubt to the appellants. The appellants can
legitimately claim right to use force once they saw their parents being
assaulted and when actually it has been shown that due to such
assault and injury their father subsequently died. In the given facts,


adverse inference must be drawn against the prosecution for not
offering any explanation much less a plausible one. 
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.416 OF 2016
(Arising out of SLP(Crl.) No. 2301 of 2016)
Bhagwan Sahai and Anr. V State of Rajasthan 
Dated:June 03, 2016.

Citation: 2016 CRLJ3154 SC

Print Page

Tuesday, 7 January 2014

Supreme Court: Any discrepancy between inquest report or post-mortem report cannot be termed as fatal or suspicious circumstance which would warrant benefit of doubt to the accused.

 It has been canvassed on behalf of the appellants that the provisions of Sections 174 and 176(3) Cr.P.C. had not been complied with and the body had been exhumed by the IO without the permission of the Executive Magistrate and therefore, the investigation had not been conducted in accordance with law. Sub-section (1) of Section 174 Cr.P.C. only puts an obligation on the part of the IO to intimate the Executive Magistrate empowered to hold inquest but there is nothing in law which provides that investigation cannot be carried out without his permission in writing or in his absence. Even otherwise, the provision stands qualified “unless otherwise directed by any rule prescribed by the State Government, or by any general or special order of the District or Sub-divisional Magistrate.” The object of the inquest proceeding is merely to ascertain whether a person has died under unnatural circumstances or an unnatural death and if so, what is the cause of death. More so, the inquest report is not a piece of substantive evidence and can be utilised only for contradicting the witnesses to the inquest examined during the trial. Neither the inquest report nor the post-mortem report can be termed as basic or substantive evidence and thus, any discrepancy occurring therein cannot be termed as fatal or suspicious circumstance which would warrant benefit of doubt to the accused.

Supreme Court of India
Madhu @ Madhuranatha & Anr. vs State Of Karnataka on 28 November, 2013
Citation; 2013 (4) Crimes 571 SC
Print Page