Showing posts with label false statement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label false statement. Show all posts

Sunday, 1 January 2017

How to ascertain territorial jurisdiction of court for filing complaint for making false statements in income tax search proceeding?

As hereinbefore stated, the appellants as
assesses, had residences both at Bhopal and Aurangabad and had been
submitting their income tax returns at Bhopal. The search operations
were conducted simultaneously both at Bhopal and Aurangabad in
course whereof allegedly the appellants, in spite of queries made, did not
disclose that they in fact did hold a locker located at Aurangabad. They
in fact denied to hold any locker, either individually or jointly. The locker,
eventually located, though at Aurangabad, has a perceptible co-relation
or nexus with the subject matter of assessment and thus the returns filed
by the appellants at Bhopal which in turn were within the purview of the
search operations. The search conducted simultaneously at Bhopal and
Aurangabad has to be construed as a single composite expedition with a
common mission. Having regard to the overall facts and the accusation
of false statement made about the existence of the locker in such a joint
drill, it cannot be deduced that in the singular facts and circumstances,
no part of the offence alleged had been committed within the
jurisdictional limits of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bhopal.
72. Chapter XIII of the Code sanctions the jurisdiction of the
criminal courts in inquries and trials. Whereas Section 177 of the Code
stipulates the ordinary place of inquiry and trial, Section 178 enumerates
the places of inquiry or trial. In terms of Section 179, when an act is an
offence by reason of anything which has been done and of a
consequence which has ensued, the offence may be inquired into or
tried by a court within whose local jurisdiction such thing has been done
or such consequence has ensued. For immediate reference, Sections 177
and 178 are extracted hereinbelow.
“177: Ordinary place of inquiry and trial – Every
offence shall ordinarily be inquired into and tried
by a court within whose local jurisdiction it was
committed.
178: Place of inquiry or trial – (a) When it is
uncertain in which of several local areas an
offence was committed, or
(b) where an offence is committed partly in one
local area and partly in another, or
(c) where an offence is continuing one, and
continues to be committed in more local areas
than one, or
(d) where it consists of several acts done in
different local areas, it may be inquired into or
tried by a court having jurisdiction over any of
such local areas.
73. As would be evident from hereinabove, ordinarily every
offence ought to be inquired into and tried by a court within whose local
jurisdiction it had been committed as is mandated by Section 177 of the
Code. Section 178, however marks a departure contingent on the
eventualities as listed in clauses (a),(b), (c) and (d) of Section 178 to
identify the court that would have the jurisdiction to try the offences as
contemplated therein. 
74. Though the concept of “cause of action“ identifiable with a
civil action is not routinely relevant for the determination of
territoriality of criminal courts as had been ruled by this Court in
Dashrath Rupsingh Rathod vs. State of Maharashtra and
Another, (2014) 9 SCC 129, their Lordships however were cognizant of
the word “ordinarily” used in Section 177 of the Code to acknowledge the
exceptions contained in Section 178 thereof. Section 179 also did not
elude notice .
75. Be that as it may, on a cumulative reading of Sections 177,
178 and 179 of the Code in particular and the inbuilt flexibility
discernible in the latter two provisions, we are of the comprehension that
in the attendant facts and circumstances of the case where to repeat, a
single and combine search operation had been undertaken
simultaneously both at Bhopal and Aurangabad for the same purpose,
the alleged offence can be tried by courts otherwise competent at both
the aforementioned places. To confine the jurisdiction within the
territorial limits to the court at Aurangabad would amount, in our view,
to impermissible and illogical truncation of the ambit of Sections 178
and 179 of the Code. The objection with regard to the competence of the
Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bhopal is hereby rejected.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.824 OF 2016
[ARISING OUT OF S.L.P. (CRL) NO. 1474 OF 2012]
BABITA LILA & ANOTHER 
V
UNION OF INDIA 
Citation:(2016) 9 SCC647
Print Page

Sunday, 6 November 2016

Whether filing of false affidavit, false document and making false statement on oath amounts to contempt of court?

The swearing of false affidavits in judicial proceedings nor only has the tendency of causing obstruction in the due course of judicial proceedings but has also the tendency to impede, obstruct and interfere with the administration of justice. The filing of false affidavits in judicial proceedings in any Court of law exposes the intention of the concerned party in perverting the course of justice. The due process of law cannot be permitted to be slighted not the majesty of law be made a mockery by such acts or conduct on the part of the parties to the litigation or even while appearing as witnesses. Anyone who makes an attempt to impede or undermine or obstruct the free flow of the unsoiled stream of justice by resorting to the filing of false evidence commits criminal contempt of the Court and renders himself liable to be dealt with in accordance with the Act. Filing of false affidavits or making false statement on oath in courts aims at striking a blow at the Rule of Law and no Court can ignore such conduct which has the tendency to shake public confidence in the judicial institutions because the very structure of an ordered life is put at stake. It would be a great public disaster if the fountain of justice is allowed to be poisoned by anyone resorting to filing of false affidavits or giving of false statements and fabricating false evidence in a Court of law. The stream of justice has to be kept clean and pure and anyone soiling its purity must be dealt with sternly so that the message percolates loud and clear that no one can be permitted to undermine the dignity of the Court and interfere with the due course of judicial proceedings or the administration of justice in Chandra Shashi v. Anil Kumar Verma MANU/SC/0558/1995 : 1994ECR636(SC) the respondents produced a false and fabricated certificate to defeat the claim of the respondent for transfer of a case. This action was found to be an act amounting to interfere with the administration of justice. Brother Hansaria, J. speaking for the Bench observed: (At P. 4995, of AIR)
"The stream of administration of justice has to remain unpolluted so that purity of Court's atmosphere may give vitality to all the organs of the State. Polluters of judicial firmament are, therefore, required to be well taken care of to maintain the sublimity of Court's environment; so also to enable it to administer justice fairly and to the satisfaction of all concerned. Anyone who takes recourse to fraud deflects the course of judicial proceedings; or if any thing is done with oblique motive, the same interferes with the administration of justice. Such persons are required to be property dealt with, not only to punish them for the wrong done, but also to deter others from indulging in similar acts which shake the faith of people in the system of administration of justice."
Thus, if any person tries to either file any false affidavit, forged document or even makes false statement on oath, the conduct of such person has a tendency to interfere with the administration of justice or the due course of judicial proceedings. This conduct is having tendency of impeding, obstructing or interference striking a blow on the role of law and no Court can ignore such conduct which has the tendency to shake the confidence of the public and in the judicial institution. It would be in our view a great public disaster if the fountain of justice is allowed to be poisoned by anyone resorting to file false affidavits by giving false statements or fabricating false evidence even by impersonation in a Court of law and as such, this type of acts clearly fall within the definition of criminal contempt as defined under Section 2(C) of the Contempt of Courts Act.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
Cr. C.C.C. No. 26/2000
Decided On: 30.07.2003
Advocate General, High Court of Karnataka
Vs.
 Chidambara and Anr.
Coram:
A.M. Farooq and S.R. Bannurmath, JJ.

Citation: 2004 CRLJ493

Print Page

Sunday, 14 February 2016

When consumer dispute should be referred to civil court?

Learned counsel for the respondent on the other hand submitted that no interference is called with the decision of the Commission. He also stated that no such proposal form as claimed by the appellant was submitted.
The Commission noted that the specific stand of the appellant was that there was mis-declaration in the proposal form and the false claim that the respondent's wife was a teacher which as now appears is not the correct position. It also accepted that she was really not a teacher.
Proceedings before the Commission are essentially summary in nature and adjudication of issues which involve disputed factual questions should not be adjudicated. It is to be noted that Commission accepted that insured was not a teacher. Complainant raised dispute about genuineness of the documents (i.e. proposal forms) produced by the appellant.
The Commission having accepted that there was wrong declaration of the nature of occupation of the person insured, should not have granted the relief in the manner done.
The nature of the proceedings before the Commission as noted above, are essentially in summary nature. The factual position was required to be established by documents. Commission was required to examine whether in view of the disputed facts it would exercise the jurisdiction. The State Commission was right in its view that the complex factual position requires that the matter should be examined by an appropriate Court of Law and not by the Commission.
Supreme Court of India
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd vs Munimahesh Patel on 12 September, 2006

Bench: Arijit Pasayat, Lokeshwar Singh Panta
           CASE NO.:Appeal (civil)  4091 of 2006
Print Page