Showing posts with label infructuous. Show all posts
Showing posts with label infructuous. Show all posts

Sunday, 21 May 2017

Whether interim order can be treated as precedent?

In Kapila Hingorani (I) v. State of Bihar, MANU/SC/0403/2003 : (2003) 6 SCC 1, the apex Court while dealing with meaning of "precedent" has held as follows:
"A precedent is a judicial decision containing a principle, which forms an authoritative element termed as ratio decidendi. An interim order which does not finally and conclusively decide an issue cannot be a precedent. Any reasons assigned in support of such non-final interim order containing prima facie findings, are only tentative. Any interim directions issued on the basis of such prima facie findings are temporary arrangements to preserve the status quo till the matter is finally decided, to ensure that the matter does not become either in-fructuous or a fait accompli before the final hearing."
Similar view has also been taken by the apex court in State of Assam v. Barak Upatyaka D.U. Karmachari Sanstha, MANU/SC/0387/2009 : (2009) 5 SCC 694 wherein, it is further clarified that an interim order cannot be said to be a precedent. The interim directions issued on the basis of prima facie findings, are temporary arrangements to preserve the status quo, to ensure that the matter does not become either infructuous or a fait accompli before final hearing. This being the position, while vacating the interim order, no decision has been rendered by the Larger Bench of this Court, thereby the order so passed cannot be taken into consideration as no ratio decidendi to characterise as precedent for the present case.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) Nos. 11817 and 12427 of 2016
Decided On: 13.01.2017
 Mohapatra Binders and Ors. Vs. State of Odisha and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vineet Saran, C.J., Dr. Akshaya Kumar Rath and Dr. B.R. Sarangi, JJ.

Citation: AIR 2017(NOC) 205 Orissa
Print Page

Sunday, 7 August 2016

Whether election petition can be decided on merit if it has become infructuous?

 In Mundrika Singh Yadav vs. Shiv Bachan Yadav and others ((2005) 12 SCC 211), an election petition under Sections 80 and 80-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 filed by the appellant was dismissed by the High Court. In the above said election petition, the appellant had sought for the relief of recount of ballot papers. The High Court on trial found a case in that regard having not been made out. The election to the Bihar State Assembly forming subject-matter of the election petition was held in the year 2000. The term of the Legislative Assembly was over. Fresh elections were being held. Under these circumstances, the Apex Court has held that no relief could be allowed to the appellant in this appeal even if this appeal is allowed. The appeal was rendered infructuous and was dismissed accordingly. 51. In P.H. Pandian vs. P. Veldurai and another ((2013) 14 SCC 685), an appeal under Section 116-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 was filed questioning the judgment and order made by this Court in the election petition in ELP.No.1 of 1996 on 29.12.1999. 52. In this case, the Apex Court has observed that though fresh elections have since been held to Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly and to an extent this appeal has been rendered infructuous, the manner in which the election petition was dealt with by the High Court causes us concern and that necessitates our making reference to some salient facts. 53. Ultimately, the Apex Court has observed that it is a settled practice of Supreme Court not to pronounce upon matters which are only of an academic interest. Once the charge of corrupt practice fails, rest of the appeal would be rendered infructuous because fresh elections have already taken place and the old Assembly is no longer in existence. Even if the appellant was to succeed on the issue that the returned candidate had a subsisting contract with the Panchayat Union and the State Government and was, therefore, disqualified to be chosen for the seat under Section 9-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, it would only be of an academic interest. 54. In Shankar Pendaam vs. Smt. Jyoti Dhurve (Judgment delivered on 18.7.2014 by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Jabalpur Bench in the Election Petition No.45 of 2009). 55. In this case, the election petition was filed by the petitioner therein under Section 80 read with Section 81 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 for declaring the election of the respondent to be void. 56. This case is an identical one to that of the present case on hand. During the course of arguments of the learned Senior Counsel, who was appearing on behalf of the respondent before the Jabalpur Bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court had submitted that the said election petition had become infructuous because the term of the respondent had come to an end by efflux of time on 16th May, 2014 and thereafter, general elections had also taken place in May, 2014 and the respondent had already been elected from the same constituency of Loksabha. Thus, the grounds taken in this election petition have been rendered of academic importance and the academic questions should not ordinarily be decided by the Courts. 57. It was further submitted that this election petition had not been filed by the petitioner on the ground of corrupt practice. Therefore, it was urged that the election petition might be dismissed as infructuous. 58. The learned Senior Counsel had made reference to the following decisions of the Apex Court:- a. Dhartipakar Madan Lal Agarwal Vs. Rajiv Gandhi (1987 (Supp) SCC 93). b. Sushma Swaraj vs. Raj Kumar Patel in SLP (Civil) No.2951 of 2014 decided on 5.5.2014. 59. Having taken into consideration of the related facts and circumstances, the learned Single Judge of the Jabalpur Bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court has observed as under:- Considering the fact that the tenure of the respondent has already come to an end by the efflux of time and the matter has been rendered of academic importance. In view of the aforesaid discussion and in the light of the aforesaid decision of Apex Court in Dhartipakar Madan Lal Agarwal vs. Rajiv Gandhi (supra) and Sushma Swaraj vs. Rajkumar Patel (supra), I am of the considered view that nothing further survives in this matter. This petition has become infructuous, same is hereby dismissed as having been rendered infructuous. 60. In a case between Chandra Mohan Shukla and Anil Dhirubhai Ambani and 11 others in the Election Petition No.6 of 2004 decided by the Lucknow Bench of High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Mr. Anupam Mehrotra, learned counsel for the respondents had raised a preliminary objection with submission that keeping in view of the fact that election petition challenging the same election has been dismissed by this Court and also since the term of elected representation of the Rajya Sabha has expired, petition should be dismissed as infructuous. 61. It was also submitted that the court should not adjudicate an academic issue and in any case the petitioner shall not be entitled for any benefit. 62. The learned Single Judge of the said High Court, has observed as under:- 22. Keeping in view the submission made by learned counsel for the parties it appears that whenever in a petition, which includes election petition, the relief claimed with regard to main issue involved becomes redundant or infructuous then for other relief courts may exercise its discretion and may not proceed further in case right of the plaintiff or dependent satisfied or no grievance remained pending against defendant or respondents because of the change of circumstances. Court may use its discretion to drop the proceeding and may not proceed further in a matter even if, some relief of academic nature stand survive. In the present case, admittedly the term of respondent no. 1 to 4 expired and vacancy has been filled up by fresh election accordingly even if the impugned provision is struck down or the case of Kuldip Nayar (supra) is distinguished because of larger bench neither the petitioner will have any gain nor respondent no. 1 to 4 will suffer from any loss like loss of office as the member of Rajya Sabha. The things remain for adjudication would be the validity of impugned provision after taking into account the judgement of Kuldip Nayar(supra). Observation made by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Rajeev Gandhi that time of the court is precious one and academic exercise is not warranted unless still some relief may be granted to petitioner or the appellant may be followed.
In view of above, there appears to be no good ground to proceed further in the matter to make academic exercise with regard to impugned provision.
Madras High Court
V. Anbazhagan vs A. Laser on 27 April, 2016
CORAM : THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE T.MATHIVANAN

ELP.No.7 of 2011

Print Page

Sunday, 30 August 2015

Whether high court can issue directions in infructuous writ petition?

Equivalent Citation: 2015(3)RCR(Criminal)67, 2015(6)SCALE590, (2015)6SCC716
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Appeal No. 789 of 2015 (Arising out of S.L.P. (Crl.) No. 6054 of 2013)
Decided On: 14.05.2015
State of U.P. and Ors.Vs. Anil Kumar Sharma and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:Dipak Misra, R.K. Agrawal and Prafulla C. Pant, JJ.


Criminal - Validity of directions - Sections 207 and 209 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 - Present appeal filed against directions issued by High court pertaining to dispensation of requirement of committal of cases by Magistrate to Court of Sessions, supply of copies to accused and not to accept final report unless accused were produced - Whether impugned directions issued by High court was liable to be set aside - Held, manner in which sweeping directions issued by High Court, could not be appreciated - High Court erred in treating writ petition filed for quashing of FIR, as Public Interest Litigation, and issued sweeping directions - No requirement under Section 173 of Code for Investigating Officer to produce accused along with charge-sheet - No mandate in Section 207 of Code which requires police to prepare copies of all papers before chargesheet was filed - High Court had exceeded its jurisdiction in asking State Authorities to file compliance report, in matter of dispensing with requirement of committal of cases as per Section 209 of Code - Therefore, impugned order by which sweeping directions were given by High Court, was liable to be set aside - Appeal allowed. 

Print Page