Showing posts with label interlocutory mandatory injunction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label interlocutory mandatory injunction. Show all posts

Friday, 31 May 2019

Whether court should reject prayer for interim injunction if relief sought in injunction application and suit is same?

 In Dorab Cawasji Warden vs. Coomi Sorab Warden and others reported in MANU/SC/0161/1990 : (1990) 1 SCR 332, the Supreme Court held that the relief of interlocutory mandatory injunctions are granted generally to preserve or restore the status quo of the last known uncontested status which preceded the pending controversy until the final hearing when full relief may be granted or to compel the undoing of those acts that have been illegally done or the restoration of that which was wrongfully taken from the party complaining. But since the granting of such an injunction to a party who fails or would fail to establish his right at the trial may cause great injustice or irreparable harm to the party against whom it was granted or alternatively not granting of it to a party who succeeds or would succeed may equally cause great injustice or irreparable loss. Courts have evolved certain guidelines. Generally stated these guidelines are:

a) The plaintiff has a strong case for trial. That is, it shall be of a higher standard than a prima facie case that is normally required for a prohibitory injunction.

b) It is necessary to prevent irreparable or serious injury which normally cannot be compensated in terms of money.

c) The balance of convenience is in favour of one seeking such relief.

20. There is no law that in case the relief sought through the suit and relief prayed for in a application for temporary mandatory injunction under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 of the CPC are the same, in that eventuality the ad interim injunction cannot be granted.

21. However, it is true that the court would be very slow in granting such relief and would grant the same only when it comes to the conclusion that great injustice has been done to the petitioner who has been thrown away from a property in which he was in lawful occupation and a person who has got no right or title to the said property has occupied the same. In Indian Cable Company Limited (supra), this court held that if a court is called upon to grant any relief on an interlocutory application which when granted would mean granting substantially the relief claimed in the suit, the court will be very slow and circumspect in the matter of granting such prayer. It is indeed true that such a relief is granted only in exceptional cases, still at the same time no court should think that in law there is any absolute bar to the court granting such a relief. In deserving cases, the court should not hesitate to come in aid of a litigant and upheld the cause of justice by granting such a relief. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA

CO No. 359 of 2017

Decided On: 17.01.2019

Amita Sarbadhikary  Vs. Bandana Shome and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Bibek Chaudhuri, J.


Citation: AIR 2019 Cal 123
Print Page

Wednesday, 22 August 2018

Whether Principle Of Moulding Of Relief Can Be Invoked At Interlocutory Stage?

That apart, the learned Single Judge as well as the Division Bench have committed fundamental error in applying the principle of moulding of relief which could at best be resorted to at the time of consideration of final relief in the main suit and not at an interlocutory stage. The nature of order passed against the appellant is undeniably a mandatory order at an interlocutory stage. There is marked distinction

between moulding of relief and granting mandatory relief at an interlocutory stage. As regards the latter, that can be granted only to restore the status quo and not to establish a new set of things differing from the state which existed at the date when the suit was instituted. This Court in Dorab Cawasji Warden Versus Coomi Sorab Warden and Others,2 has had occasion to consider the circumstances warranting grant of interlocutory mandatory injunction. In paragraphs 16 & 17, after analysing the legal precedents on the point as noticed in paragraphs 11-15, the Court went on to observe as follows:
“16. The relief of interlocutory mandatory injunctions are thus granted generally to preserve or restore the status quo of the last non-contested status which preceded the pending controversy until the final hearing when full relief may be granted or to compel the undoing of those acts that have been illegally done or the restoration of that which was wrongfully taken from the party complaining. But since the granting of such an injunction to a party who fails or would fail to establish his right at the trial may cause great injustice or irreparable harm to the party against whom it was granted or alternatively not granting of it to a party who succeeds or would succeed may equally cause great injustice or irreparable harm, courts have evolved certain guidelines. Generally stated these guidelines are: (1) The plaintiff has a strong case for trial. That is, it shall be of a higher standard than a prima facie case that is normally required for a prohibitory injunction.
2 (1990) 2 SCC 117

(2) It is necessary to prevent irreparable or serious injury which normally cannot be compensated in terms of money.
(3) The balance of convenience is in favour of the one seeking such relief.
17. Being essentially an equitable relief the grant or refusal of an interlocutory mandatory injunction shall ultimately rest in the sound judicial discretion of the court to be exercised in the light of the facts and circumstances in each case. Though the above guidelines are neither exhaustive nor complete or absolute rules, and there may be exceptional circumstances needing action, applying them as prerequisite for the grant or refusal of such injunctions would be a sound exercise of a judicial discretion.”
(emphasis supplied)
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 7079 OF 2018
(Arising out of SLP (Civil) No.18465/2018)

Samir Narain Bhojwani Vs M/s. Aurora Properties and Investments
and Anr.
Dated:August 21, 2018.
A.M. Khanwilkar J,
Citation:  2018 (5) Bom.C.R. 731 : 2018 (5) RAJ 243 : 2018 (10) Scale 33 
Print Page

Wednesday, 20 July 2016

Whether court should grant interlocutory mandatory injunction if prima facie case is not made out?

The principles relating to grant of interim ex parte orders by the High Court in writ jurisdiction are well settled. Courts should not grant interim orders in a mechanical manner, on the assumption that the aggrieved party can always seek vacation. Grant of ex parte interim orders, that too mandatory orders, routinely or merely for the asking, on ground of sympathy or otherwise, will interfere with justice leading to administrative chaos, rather than serving the interests of justice. Where the writ petition does not make out a prima facie case or where there is any doubt about the maintainability of the writ petition or the jurisdiction of the court or the tenability of the claim, the High Court will not issue any interim order, that too when there is no irreparable loss or injury. At all events, the High Court will desist from issuing an ex parte mandatory injunction or direction which virtually has the effect of allowing the petition ex parte without hearing the respondents. Mandatory interim orders are issued in exceptional cases, only where failure to do so will lead to an irreversible or irretrievable situation. In service matters relating to retirement, there is no such need to issue ex parte mandatory directions. When the writ petition disclosed that the respondent was retired after 30 years of service in accordance with the Bank's regulations, there was no question of any irreparable injury or urgency.
Supreme Court of India
State Bank Of Patiala & Ors vs Vinesh Kumar Bhasin on 22 January, 2010
Bench: R.V. Raveendran, K.S. Radhakrishnan
(Civil Appeal No. 1718 of 2010)
Citation:2010(3) ALL MR 981(SC).                          
Print Page

Principles to be considered for grant of interlocutory mandatory injunction

 It is necessary to notice at this stage that in an original suit of this nature, it was not appropriate for the Additional District Judge to pass an order directing the parties to maintain status quo, without indicating what the status quo was. If he was satisfied that the appellant before him had made out a prima facie case for an ad interim ex parte injunction and the balance of convenience justified the grant of such an injunction, it was for him to have passed such an order of injunction. But simply directing the parties to maintain status quo without indicating what the status quo was, is not an order that should be passed at the initial stage of a litigation, especially when one court had found no reason to grant an ex parte order of injunction and the appellate court was dealing with only the limited question whether an ad interim order of injunction should or should not have been granted by the trial court, since the appeal was only against the refusal of an ad interim ex parte order of injunction and the main application for injunction pending suit, was still pending before the trial court itself. Therefore, we are prima facie of the view that the Additional District Judge ought not to have passed an equivocal order like the one passed in the circumstances of the case. But of course, that aspect has relevance only to the extent that before ordering an interim mandatory injunction or refusing it, the court has first to consider whether the plaintiff has proved that he was in possession on the date of suit and on the date of the order and he had been dispossessed the next day. Unless a clear prima facie finding that the plaintiff was in possession on those dates is entered, an order for interim mandatory injunction could not have been passed and any such order passed would be one without jurisdiction.
5. An interim mandatory injunction is not a remedy that is easily granted. It is an order that is passed only in circumstances which are clear and the prima facie materials clearly justify a finding that the status quo has been altered by one of the parties to the litigation and the interests of justice demanded that the status quo ante be restored by way of an interim mandatory injunction.
Supreme Court of India
Kishore Kumar Khaitan & Anr vs Praveen Kumar Singh on 13 February, 2006

Bench: S.B. Sinha, P.K. Balasubramanyan
           CASE NO.:
Appeal (civil)  1101 of 2006

Citation:AIR 2006 SC 1474
Print Page

What are basic principles for grant interlocutory mandatory injunction?

AS temporary mandatory injunction as was held by me in Baldev Raj. V. Savitri Bai, 1981 Rajdhani LR 367 : AIR 1982 NOC 49, can be issued only in case of extreme hardship and compelling circumstances and mostly in those cases when status quo existing on the date of the institution of the suit is to be restored."
The above observations relate only to the proper exercise of jurisdiction and not to its existence.
 Now about exercise of the jurisdiction. There are two essential pre-requisites. First is that such power is not to be exercised unless the Court feels a high degree of assurance that at the trial a similar injunction would in all probabilities be granted and secondly, irreparable injury will be caused if thing complained of is allowed to continue until the final decisions.
Bombay High Court
Baban Narayan Landge vs Mahadu Bhikaji Tonchar And Ors. on 30 September, 1988
Equivalent citations: AIR 1989 Bom 247, 1989 (1) BomCR 669
Bench: V Mohta
Print Page

Tuesday, 26 November 2013

Basic principle for grant of mandatory interim relief



Grant of mandatory interim relief requires the highest degree of satisfaction of the Court; much higher than a case involving grant of prohibitory injunction. It is, indeed, a rare power, the governing principles whereof would hardly require a reiteration inasmuch as the same which had been evolved by this Court in Dorab Cawasji Warden vs. Coomi Sorab Warden and Others[2] has come to be firmly embedded in our jurisprudence. Paras 16 and 17 of the judgment in Dorab Cawasji Warden (supra), extracted below, may be usefully remembered in this regard: “16. The relief of interlocutory mandatory injunctions are thus granted generally to preserve or restore the status quo of the last non-contested status which preceded the pending controversy until the final hearing when full relief may be granted or to compel the undoing of those acts that have been illegally done or the restoration of that which was wrongfully taken from the party complaining. But since the granting of such an injunction to a party who fails or would fail to establish his right at the trial may cause great injustice or irreparable harm to the party against whom it was granted or alternatively not granting of it to a party who succeeds or would succeed may equally cause great injustice or irreparable harm, courts have evolved certain guidelines. Generally stated these guidelines are:
(1) The plaintiff has a strong case for trial. That is, it shall be of a higher standard than a prima facie case that is normally required for a prohibitory injunction.
(2) It is necessary to prevent irreparable or serious injury which normally cannot be compensated in terms of money.
(3) The balance of convenience is in favour of the one seeking such relief.
17. Being essentially an equitable relief the grant or refusal of an interlocutory mandatory injunction shall ultimately rest in the sound judicial discretion of the court to be exercised in the light of the facts and circumstances in each case. Though the above guidelines are neither exhaustive nor complete or absolute rules, and there may be exceptional circumstances needing action, applying them as prerequisite for the grant or refusal of such injunctions would be a sound exercise of a judicial discretion.”

Supreme Court of India

Mohd Mehtab Khan & Ors. vs Khushnuma Ibrahim Khan
 & Ors. on 24 January, 2013

Bench: P. Sathasivam, Ranjan Gogoi
Print Page

Friday, 1 February 2013

Supreme Court Guidelines for grant of interlocutory mandatory injunction


"The relief of interlocutory mandatory injunction are thus granted generally to preserve or restore the status quo of the last non-contested status which preceded the pending controversy until the final hearing when full relief may be granted or to compel the undoing of those acts that have been illegally done or the restoration of that which was wrongfully taken from the party complaining. But since the granting of such an injunction to a party who fails or would fail to establish his right at the trial may cause great injustice or irreparable harm to the party against whom it was granted or alternatively not granting of it to a party who succeeds or would succeed may equally cause great injustice or irreparable harm, courts have evolved certain guidelines. Generally stated these guidelines are :
(1) The plaintiff has a strong case for trial. That is, it shall be of a higher standard than a prima facie case that is normally required for a prohibitory injunction.
(2) It is necessary to prevent irreparable or serious injury which normally cannot be compensated in terms of money.
(3) The balance of convenience is in favour of the one seeking such relief.

Supreme Court of India
Dorab Cawasji Warden vs Coomi Sorab Warden & Ors on 13 February, 1990
Equivalent citations: 1990 AIR 867, 1990 SCR (1) 332
Bench: Sharma, L.

Print Page