Showing posts with label invoice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label invoice. Show all posts

Thursday, 19 March 2026

Suit on Account and Suit for Accounts: The Crucial Distinction

 A suit on account is generally a money recovery suit based on an existing account, account stated, or bills/invoices, where the amount claimed is already ascertained or can be claimed as a definite sum; by contrast, a suit for accounts is filed when the plaintiff does not know the exact amount due and asks the court to direct rendition and taking of accounts first, with the final amount to be determined later.

Core distinction

Print Page

Tuesday, 11 October 2022

Bombay HC: If Adjustment Is Made Towards A Particular Invoice, It Can't Extend Limitation For Other Outstanding Invoices

 The claimant though urged before this Court vehemently that the respondent having issued a cheque of Rs. 50 lakhs, which was dishonored, the entire outstanding claim under various invoices stood revived on the ground that there was fresh period of limitation under section 18 of the Limitation Act, the claimant having exercised the option under section 60 of the Indian Contract Act, no such inconsistent plea can be permitted.


55. Under section 60 of the Indian Contract Act, where the debtor has omitted to intimate and there are no settled circumstances undertaking the debt to be applied, the creditor may apply at his discretion to any lawful debt actually due and payable to him from the creditor, whether is regular or is not barred by law in force for the time being as to the limits of the suit. In this case, admittedly the respondent did not intimate the claimant that the said sum of Rs. 50 lakhs was made towards any particular invoice or was by way of part payment towards all the outstanding invoices on the date of such part payment.


56. At this stage, it would be apposite to refer to section 61 of the Indian Contract Act which provides that where neither party makes any appropriation, the payment shall be applied in discharge of the debts in order of time, whether they are or are not barred by the law in force for the time being as to the limitation of suits. If the debts are of equal standing, the payment shall be applied in discharge of each proportionably. In our view, since the claimant in this case has invoked section 60 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, section 61 of the Indian Contract Act cannot be invoked.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Commercial Appeal No. 574 of 2019 in Commercial Arbitration Petition No. 987 of 2018

 Anmol Steel Processors Private Limited  Vs. Colour Roof (India) Limited

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

R.D. Dhanuka and R.N. Laddha, JJ.

Decided On: 19.01.2022

Author: R.D. Dhanuka, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/0167/2022.

Read full Judgment here: Click here

Print Page

Will limitation extend if part payment of debt or acknowledgement of liability is made after the expiry of the limitation period?

It is thus clear that even according to the claimant the cause of action arose for payment of interest as well as principle amount after expiry of 45 days from the date of each invoice. The last invoice is dated 2nd June, 2011, the alleged part payment of Rs. 16 lakhs on 28th July, 2015 thus would not extend the period of limitation. It is clear that the entire claim had already become barred by law of limitation prior to 28th July, 2015 and was not a legally enforceable debt as on 28th July, 2015.


51. Learned single Judge in the impugned judgment dated 5th September, 2019 considered the issue of limitation in detail and has rightly held that the supplies were payable respectively at the expiry of 45 days of each individual notice. The arbitration agreement was arrived at between the parties on 22nd November, 2016 and accordingly the terminus ad quem in respect of the claim in the arbitration was 22nd November, 2016. It is with reference to that date the bar of limitation has to be construed. Learned single Judge also held that there was no dispute that the last acknowledgment before 25th May, 2015 came on 5th January, 2012. It was thus not made before expiration of the prescribed limitation period for the suit or application, as the case may be.


52. Learned single Judge rightly held that if according to the claimant itself, adjustment was made towards a particular outstanding invoice, that payment cannot enure to the benefit of claimant so as to extend the period of limitation for other outstanding invoices. 


53. Under section 18 of the Limitation Act, 1963, a fresh period of limitation shall be computed from the time when the acknowledgment was so signed only where, before the expiration of the prescribed period for a suit of application in respect of any property or right, an acknowledgment of liability in respect of such property or right has been made in writing signed by the party against whom such property or right is claimed, or by any person through whom he derives his title or liability. It is thus clear that the acknowledgment, if any, has to be prior to the expiration of the prescribed period for filing the suit. In our view, since the limitation for filing a suit or arbitration proceedings for recovery of the outstanding invoices had already expired much prior to the period of three years prior to the date of commencement of the arbitral proceedings, limitation would not revive under section 18 of the Limitation Act even if there is any part payment or acknowledgment of liability after expiry of the period of limitation. Fresh limitation would arise only during subsistence of the claim i.e. within the period of limitation, if any part payment is made or liability is acknowledged and not after the claim already having become time barred.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Commercial Appeal No. 574 of 2019 in Commercial Arbitration Petition No. 987 of 2018

 Anmol Steel Processors Private Limited  Vs. Colour Roof (India) Limited

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

R.D. Dhanuka and R.N. Laddha, JJ.

Decided On: 19.01.2022

Author: R.D. Dhanuka, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/0167/2022

Print Page

Tuesday, 14 July 2020

Whether the court can infer an arbitration agreement from invoices/bills, which contained an Arbitration clause?

In Shakti Bhog Food Limited v. Kola Shipping Limited (Supra), it was observed by Supreme Court;

We would want to reiterate that as far as the provision of Section 7 of the Act is concerned, an arbitration agreement may be in the form of an arbitration clause in a contract or in the form of a separate agreement and furthermore an arbitration is considered to be in writing if it is contained in a document signed by the parties or in a exchange of letters, telex, telegrams or other means of telecommunication which provide a record of the agreement or an exchange of statement of claim and defence in which the existence of an agreement is alleged by one party and not denied by the other. So from the provisions of Section 7, it is clear that a charter party agreement need not be in writing signed by both parties and this could as well be made out from the acts of the parties to the agreement by way of their exchange of letters and information through fax, e-mails, etc.
23. In the case in hand, admittedly there had been business transactions between the parties. Respondents have not placed any document with regard to these transactions, On the other hand, appellant has placed various invoices/bills before the Arbitrator, which contained the clause with regard to the arbitration.

24. Clause 5 mentioned on various invoices/bills is an arbitration agreement between the parties. As respondents have themselves admitted in their cross-objections that they had the business dealing with the appellant and have made various payments to the appellant by demand draft after purchasing the goods in question on credit basis. Since respondents admits the purchase of goods in question, it was their duty to have placed on record the invoices/bill through which they had purchased the goods from the appellant. In the absence of any document being placed by the respondents before the Arbitrator, it is apparently clear that respondents received the goods only through the invoices/bills which were filed by the appellant before the Arbitrator. Thus, there was an arbitration agreement between the parties as per Clause 5 of the invoice.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

FAO. No. 59/2002

Decided On: 17.11.2009

 Kailash Nath Agarwal  Vs.  Aaren Exports and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Vidya Bhushan Gupta, J.

Citation: MANU/DE/2916/2009
Print Page

Sunday, 5 February 2017

When summary suit is maintainable on basis of invoice?

 The first and foremost question that arises for determination is whether a suit under the provisions of Order 37 CPC could be filed on the basis of a invoice of the goods supplied to the defendant. The original invoice which is the basis of the suit had been placed on record by the plaintiff. The invoice which is dated 7.6.1994 has simply given the description of the goods. the quantity, the unit the price the rate and the price of the goods supplied. The value of the goods was Rs. 33.120/- plus sales tax of Rs. 828/- making the total to Rs. 33.948/- There is an endorsement recorded by Reghvender Singh regarding the acknowledgement of the receipt of the goods sold. There is no other terms and conditions printed over this invoice. The question is whether such an invoice amounted to was written contract within the meaning of Order 37 Rule (1) CPC. Sub Clause (2) of Rule 1 of Order 37 CPC provides that the provision of summary provision provided in this Order will apply to the classes of the suits mentioned in Sub-clauses (a) and (b). Sub-clause (1) of Clause (b) included the suit in which the plaintiff seeks to recover a debt or liquidated demand in money payable by the defendant with or without interest arising "on a written contact". The invoice which is the basis of the suit of he plaintiff does not contain any terms and conditions entered into between the parties regarding the supply of the goods and its payment. The invoice shows that certain quantity of goods at a total price of Rs. 33.948/- including sales tax was delivered to he defendant on 10.6.1994. It by no stretch of reasoning could be treated to be as written contract between the parties as envisaged under clause (b) of Sub-rule (2) or Order 37 CPC.
The court took note of the judgment in Punjab Pen House (supra) and made the following observations:
In the case cited a suit under Order xxxvII C.P.C. was held to be maintainable abased on an invoice since the invoice embodied all the terms and conditions of the contract. It was the admitted position between the parties that the supply of the goods had been under he terms and conditions as per invoice. In the case before us the invoice does not contain the terms and conditions of the contract and it cannot be said that all the terms and conditions of supply had been agreed to between the parties in the correspondence exchanged."
 I am in respectfully agreement with the observations of the learned Judge in that case.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI
C.R. No. 1168/1998
Decided On: 15.03.2002

A.R. Electronic Private Ltd. Vs.  R.K. Graphics Pvt. Ltd.

Coram:
Mahmood Ali Khan, J.


Print Page