Showing posts with label written contract. Show all posts
Showing posts with label written contract. Show all posts

Sunday, 5 February 2017

When summary suit is maintainable on basis of invoice?

 The first and foremost question that arises for determination is whether a suit under the provisions of Order 37 CPC could be filed on the basis of a invoice of the goods supplied to the defendant. The original invoice which is the basis of the suit had been placed on record by the plaintiff. The invoice which is dated 7.6.1994 has simply given the description of the goods. the quantity, the unit the price the rate and the price of the goods supplied. The value of the goods was Rs. 33.120/- plus sales tax of Rs. 828/- making the total to Rs. 33.948/- There is an endorsement recorded by Reghvender Singh regarding the acknowledgement of the receipt of the goods sold. There is no other terms and conditions printed over this invoice. The question is whether such an invoice amounted to was written contract within the meaning of Order 37 Rule (1) CPC. Sub Clause (2) of Rule 1 of Order 37 CPC provides that the provision of summary provision provided in this Order will apply to the classes of the suits mentioned in Sub-clauses (a) and (b). Sub-clause (1) of Clause (b) included the suit in which the plaintiff seeks to recover a debt or liquidated demand in money payable by the defendant with or without interest arising "on a written contact". The invoice which is the basis of the suit of he plaintiff does not contain any terms and conditions entered into between the parties regarding the supply of the goods and its payment. The invoice shows that certain quantity of goods at a total price of Rs. 33.948/- including sales tax was delivered to he defendant on 10.6.1994. It by no stretch of reasoning could be treated to be as written contract between the parties as envisaged under clause (b) of Sub-rule (2) or Order 37 CPC.
The court took note of the judgment in Punjab Pen House (supra) and made the following observations:
In the case cited a suit under Order xxxvII C.P.C. was held to be maintainable abased on an invoice since the invoice embodied all the terms and conditions of the contract. It was the admitted position between the parties that the supply of the goods had been under he terms and conditions as per invoice. In the case before us the invoice does not contain the terms and conditions of the contract and it cannot be said that all the terms and conditions of supply had been agreed to between the parties in the correspondence exchanged."
 I am in respectfully agreement with the observations of the learned Judge in that case.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI
C.R. No. 1168/1998
Decided On: 15.03.2002

A.R. Electronic Private Ltd. Vs.  R.K. Graphics Pvt. Ltd.

Coram:
Mahmood Ali Khan, J.


Print Page

Saturday, 9 April 2016

Whether oral evidence will prevail over written contract in suit for specific performance of contract?

The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the Courts below have not considered circumstances that there is only oral evidence of plaintiff and there is nothing in rebuttal in respect of the oral evidence. He submitted that when evidence is given that plaintiff had approached Smt. Mathurabai and Mathurabai had given assurance to execute the sale deed, this unrebutted evidence ought to have been considered by the Courts below and it ought to have been held that the remedy was still in existence. This submission is not at all acceptable.
When the terms and conditions of the contract were embodied in the document and there was condition like fixing of time of performance, not much importance can be given to the oral evidence of plaintiff though it is unrebutted.
Bombay High Court
Dr. Kunda Khemraj Choudhary vs Mathurabai Mahadu Jadhav Lrs ... on 1 September, 2015
Bench: T.V. Nalawade
SA No. 183/15
                                         
Citation;2016(2) ALLMR203
Print Page