In a summary suit under Order CPC, the defendant has no right to defend as of course; he must first obtain leave to defend, and leave is refused only when the defence is sham, illusory, frivolous, or vexatious.student.
Monday, 27 April 2026
What is Summary suit, grounds of defence and refusal of leave?
Sunday, 28 July 2024
Supreme Court: If the transaction is contained in more than one document between the same parties they must be read and interpreted together and they have the same legal effect for all purposes as if they are one document
The defence so raised itself being the question of law, as the interpretation of documents itself goes to the root of the transactions/contract and the claim based upon it. In the present case, B.O.I. Finance Ltd. (Supra), as relied is not applicable on facts and the laws. That was a case of ready forward contract. In the case in hand, three documents and the transactions, of which two views of the learned Judges unless decided finally in due trial, it is difficult to accept the case that the view taken by the one learned Judge that transactions are sham and bogus and unseverable and other Judge hold it to be severable, without trial and by overlooking the earlier opinion, this itself is a triable issue. The Appellate Bench also may not decide such issue on such question of law, considering the scope and purpose of law on order XXXVII of the CPC, at this stage of the Summary Suit. It should be after final Judgment. In the present case, the same documents are interlinked and interconnected as observed by the earlier learned Judge, therefore, unless these findings are set aside, the findings in the impugned order that those are severable just cannot be accepted, without the trial. The case of misconstruction or interpretation of all connected documents itself made out a case of good defence. It cannot be treated as sham or bogus defence. The misinterpretation itself affects the rights and the transaction/claim. Therefore, the construction of documents is always question of law so is the position in case in hand. The distinction, therefore, at this stage, in summary proceedings like this, itself will not sufficient to deny the order of unconditional leave as granted by one Judge on the basis of same documents. (Sir Chunilal V. Mehta and sons Ltd. v. Century Spinning and Manufacturing Co. Ltd.11 and Hero Vinoth (Minor) v. Seshammal12) {Para 56}
Interpretation of documents and the nature of transactions-triable issue-
57. We have to consider the legal position in view of the contentions so raised by the learned counsel appearing for the parties. The Apex Court in Smt. Krishnabai Bhritar Ganpatrao Deshmukh v. Appasaheb Tuljaramarao Nimbalkar13, while dealing with the aspects of interpretation of any deed or documents, has held as under:-
“27. Secondly, there is ample authority for the proposition that when there is a dispute in regard to the true character of a writing, evidence de hors the document can be led to show that the writing was not the real nature of the transaction, but was only an illusory, fictitious and colourable device which cloaked something else, and that the apparent state of affairs was not the real state of affairs. [See Chandi Prasad Singh v. Piari Bidi C.A. No. 75 of 1964, decided on 16-3-1966, and Bhagwan Dayal v. Mst. Reoti Devi (supra)].
58. While dealing with the effect of various transactions, based upon the various documents, the Court required to deal with and take into consideration every connected transactions and the documents, to give total effect to the transactions by treating them all as one document. The Apex Court in (S. Chattanatha Karayalar v. The Central Bank of India Ltd.)14 has observed as under:-
3. ………. “The principle is well established that if the transaction is contained in more than one document between the same parties they must be read and interpreted together and they have the same legal effect for all purposes as if they are one document. In Manks v. Whiteley 1912-1 Ch. 735 at p. 754, Moulton, L.J. Stated:
“Where several deeds form part of one transaction and are contemporaneously executed they have the same effect for all purposes such as are relevant to this case as if they were one deed. Each is executed on the faith of all the others being executed also and is intended to speak only as part of the one transaction, and if one is seeking to make equities apply to the parties they must be equities arising out of the transaction as a whole.”
In the High Court of Bombay
(Before Anoop V. Mohta and G.S. Kulkarni, JJ.)
Hubtown Limited Vs IDBI Trusteeship Service Limited,
Commercial Appeal No. 7 of 2016
Decided on October 24, 2016
Citation: 2016 SCC OnLine Bom 9019. Read full Judgment here: Click here. |
Bombay HC: summary suit as originally filed, prior to the commencement of the and as now transferred, being commercial dispute matter, the original procedure as provided under Order XXXVII shall be applicable to such summary suits
“Summary Suit” and “Summary Judgment”-
34. The conceptual position of “summary suit” as contemplated under Order XXXVII of CPC and its specific provisions are governed as per the original provisions of CPC. The amended CPC, in view of Section 16 of the Commercial Courts Act inserted the provision for a “summary judgment”, through Order XIII-A which is made applicable to the classes of Suits (commercial suits) which required to be decided by the Commercial Division/Court. It prescribes the procedure and stages for application for summary judgment. This also includes and provides the powers of a Commercial Judge to pass conditional order including for evidence for hearing of summary judgment. We are concerned with Order XIII-A, Rule 1(3) of CPC, whereby it is specifically provided “notwithstanding anything to the contrary, “an application” for summary judgment under this Order shall not be made in a Suit in respect of any commercial disputes that is originally filed as a summary suit under Order XXXVII.”. Therefore, once the summary suit as originally filed, prior to the commencement of the and as now transferred, being commercial dispute matter, the original procedure as provided under Order XXXVII shall be applicable to such summary suits. The parties are not entitled to prayer for summary judgment under XIII-A in view of the specific provision so referred above. This also means that the judgments and the issues so decided in summary suit shall for all purposes be governed by the CPC, even after such suits are transferred as commercial suits. The Commercial Division Judge is required to follow the original C.P.C. and is required to keep in mind the position in law revolving around all the facets of summary suits. The provisions of Section 13, therefore, is required to be interpreted and/or considered accordingly, when any decision is given by the Commercial Division/Court in such summary suit.
In the High Court of Bombay
(Before Anoop V. Mohta and G.S. Kulkarni, JJ.)
Hubtown Limited Vs IDBI Trusteeship Service Limited,
Commercial Appeal No. 7 of 2016
Decided on October 24, 2016
Citation: 2016 SCC OnLine Bom 9019. |
Bombay HC: The Commercial court Act is not applicable to the transaction of advancing the amount as a friendly loan
In the wake of the above, the impugned order which take a view that the transaction of advancing the amount as a friendly loan is commercial in nature, is an erroneous finding as a solitary transaction of advancing loan, on friendly terms, unlike a commercial lending with the prevailing market rate, would fall short or ordinary transaction of a financer, banker. Moreso, even the plaintiff is conscious of this position and in her response to the Application filed for return of plaint for presentation of appropriate court, she admit so. {Para 17}
In the High Court of Bombay
(Before Bharati Dangre, J.)
Glasswood Realty Pvt. Ltd. and Others Vs Chandravilas Kailashkumar Kothari
Writ Petition No. 8393 of 2021
Decided on December 6, 2021
Citation: 2021 SCC OnLine Bom 5032 : (2022) 1 Bom CR 527.
Print PageUnder which circumstances the loan transaction between businessman relating to mercantile documents will not be treated as Commercial dispute?
The plaintiff is a businessman. The 1st defendant is a partnership firm; the 2nd and 3rd defendants are its partners. And the 2nd defendant is said to be the plaintiffs friend. Therefore, acting beyond the call of his business, the plaintiff has given “a friendly loan” to the defendants. The defendants executed a promissory note and issued cheques as well. But the cheques were dishonoured. So, the plaintiff has sued the defendants for recovery.
16. It is trite to observe that, for the Court to determine the nature of the suit, what matters at this stage is the plaint allegations and nothing else. Both the learned counsel agree of section 2, what applies is clause (c) (i) of sub-section (1), the lexical provision of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The transaction may be ‘ordinary’ but must have occurred between “merchants, bankers, financiers and [or] traders”. And that ordinary transaction may relate to “mercantile documents, including enforcement and interpretation of such documents”. A merchant or a trader need not be as such-always and invariably. That merchant or trader is an individual, at first. And he may transact with another only as an individual. An individual may help another individual and that help may take the shape of lending. Not every instance of lending must reek of business or trade; not every trader must always act as a trader.
17. Here, the plaintiff pleads that he lent a friendly loan to another needy friend. It is not a transaction between them in the course of their ordinary business; much less can it be treated as money lending perse.
18. First, the definition is exhaustive because section 2 (1) (c) (i) employs the expression “means”. Second, though it may be an ordinary transaction, it is not between or among merchants, bankers, financiers, or traders. So, it cannot be treated as a transaction, ordinary or otherwise, between merchants, bankers, financiers, or traders. It is indeed a private transaction sans any commercial or business trappings.
19. At any rate, the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 has not obliterated Order 37 of CPC. If I indulge in some generalisation, Order 37 is a genus and the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 a species.
20. Under these circumstances, I hold that the Suit ought to be treated as a Summary Suit rather than a Commercial Summary Suit. After re-numbering the suit thus, the Registry will place it before the Court the next week.
In the High Court of Bombay
(Before Dama Seshadri Naidu, J.)
Bharat Huddanna Shetty Vs Ahuja Properties & Developers and Others
Summons for Judgment No. 9 of 2021,
Decided on July 13, 2021
Citation: 2021 SCC OnLine Bom 13984.
Print PageWhat precautions the court should take while granting leave to defend in a summary suit based dishonoured cheque?
A Summary Suit based on dishonoured cheques stands on a higher pedestal. In addition to the proof of underlying consideration, evidenced by the documents and material on record, in a given case, the plaintiff can bank upon the presumptions contained in Section 118 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and Section 114 illustration (c) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
32. A slightly distinct position of a Summary Suit based on a dishonoured cheque has been expounded by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Rajesh Laxmichand Udeshi @ Bhatia v. Pravin Hiralal Shah8 wherein the Court adverted to the effect of the statutory presumptions under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, while considering the prayer for leave to defend the suit based on a negotiable instrument.
33. The observations of the Division Bench in paragraph 14 and 15 of the said judgment are material and, hence, extracted below.-
14] When a summary suit instituted is based on a cheque which is dishonoured, effect of Sections 138 and 139 of Negotiable Instruments Act raising statutory presumption that the cheque was issued in discharge of a liability, is a relevant consideration to be kept in mind. The said Sections cast a burden upon the defendant to rebut the presumption. Summary suits instituted on cheques which are dishonoured will, therefore, stand on a higher footing than summary suits instituted on the basis of other documents. In such cases, the Court will have to take into consideration the statutory presumption which is raised when the cheques are dishonoured. The object behind providing a statutory presumption under the N egotiable Instruments Act has to be kept in mind while judging the credibility of a defence raised by the defendant in summary suit. Thus, the test of more than “shadowy” and less than “probable” as adverted to by the Apex Court cannot apply in cases where the law requires a person to explain certain state of affairs. The judgments which are relied upon by the learned counsel do not consider the effect of the statutory presumptions raised under the Negotiable Instruments Act when a cheque is dishonoured. In our opinion, when a cheque is dishonoured, the Court is enjoined with the duty to scrutinize the defence put up by the defendant with a much higher degree of care and circumspection. Such summary suits cannot be treated as on par with the cases instituted on contracts or invoices etc. where such statutory presumptions do not operate.
15] The legislative intent behind enactment of Sections 138 and 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is to prevent abuse of the banking system. Thus, one who issues a cheque extends a solemn promise to pay. Based on this promise and action, the recipients arrange their affairs and quite often enter into further transactions. Unless extra ordinary circumstances are made out, one who issues cheque is deemed to have undertaken to pay. Negotiable Instruments Act enforces the promise strictly by raising statutory presumption and treating it as an offence. This provision elevates a cheque to a higher status than the other instruments, such as written contract etc. to which no such statutory presumption is attached. What needs to be emphasized is that presumption in respect of a dishonoured cheque places a higher burden on the defendant to elucidate the defence than the burden which is cast on a defendant where the suit is filed on the basis of ordinary instruments. In the cases based on dishonour of cheques, the defendant must satisfy the conscience of the Court and cannot take shelter behind the rules formulated primarily in respect of suits based on ordinary instruments. The Court while exercising the discretion to grant leave or otherwise to the defendant in such cases cannot be oblivious of the legislative intent to place the promise made through a cheque on a higher pedestal than the promise made through an ordinary instrument. This is not to state that moment a Summary Suit is lodged based on a dishonoured cheque, it must be decreed without anything more. What needs to be emphasised is that the fact that there is a statutory presumption attached to the dishonoured cheque will constitute an important ingredient while considering the question whether leave to defend should be granted in cases of dishonoured cheques and the Court must scrutinise the defence strictly. The object of the summary procedure is ultimately to see that the defendant does not needlessly prolong the litigation by creating untenable, frivolous and casual defences so as to deprive the plaintiff of the monies due to him.
In the High Court of Bombay
(Before N.J. Jamadar, J.)
Shailesh Bhagoobhai Bhoolabhai Vs Deepak Raheja.
Summons for Judgment No. 36 of 2021,
Decided on December 15, 2022,
Citation: 2022 SCCONLINE Bom 11643.
Read full Judgment here: Click here.
Print PageUnder which circumstances defendant is not entitled to get leave to defend the Summary suit qua the interest component?
Even the endeavor of Mr. Momaya to seek leave to defend by canvassing a submission that plaintiff has charged interest at an exorbitant and unconscionable rate does not advance the cause of the defendant. The plaintiff is seeking pre-suit, pendent lite, and future interest at the agreed rate of 12% per annum. In a business transaction in a commercial city like Mumbai, interest at the rate of 12% per annum can not be said to be exorbitant and unreasonable. Moreover, in the case at hand, there is an unequivocal undertaking to pay interest. In any event the award of interest on the amount covered by dishonoured cheques would be governed by the provisions contained in Section 80 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, which stipulates rate of 18 % per annum. Therefore, I am not persuaded to accede to the submission on behalf of the defendant to grant leave to defend the suit qua the interest component. {Para 35}
In the High Court of Bombay
(Before N.J. Jamadar, J.)
Shailesh Bhagoobhai Bhoolabhai Vs Deepak Raheja.
Summons for Judgment No. 36 of 2021,
Decided on December 15, 2022,
Citation: 2022 SCCONLINE Bom 11643.
Read full Judgment here: Click here.
Print PageSunday, 21 July 2024
What is difference between summary procedure as provided under Civil procedure code and The commercial courts Act?
Summary procedure is a legal process designed to expedite the resolution of certain types of cases, typically by allowing for a faster and simpler resolution than the regular court process. In the context of Indian law, both the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) and the Commercial Courts Act provide mechanisms for summary procedures, but they differ in scope, application, and specific procedures.
Summary Procedure under Civil Procedure Code (CPC)
The summary procedure under the CPC is governed by Order XXXVII. Here are the key aspects:
Thursday, 8 February 2024
Whether Summary suit based on settled account or Account stated is maintainable?
In so far as the 'settled account is concerned,' it is no doubt true as noticed by the learned single Judge, that the various judgments adverted to, for holding that the summary suit would lie on a settled account, either of the Privy Council or of the Supreme Court did not arise from suits filed as summary suits. However, after the judgment of the Privy Council (Elvira L. Rodrigues) Sequeira (supra) which has been considered by the Supreme Court in Hiralal & Ors. (supra), a summary suit on a settled account, duly confirmed by the Defendant is maintainable as it is an acknowledgement by the Defendant in the ledger in which mutual accounts have been entered and the accounts settled between them. Such settling of accounts gives rise to a written contract on a fresh cause of action, with an implied promise to pay the amount settled. A summary suit would therefore lie on 'Settled accounts duly confirmed by the defendants. Issue (1) is answered accordingly.{Para 29}
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Summons for Judgment No. 1117 of 2003 in Summary Suit No. 1551 of 2003
Jyotsna K. Valia and Ors. Vs. T.S. Parekh and Co. and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
F.I. Rebello, V.K. Tahilramani and Abhay Shreeniwas Oka, JJ.
Author: F.I. Rebello, J.
Decided On: 26.04.2007
Citation: citations: 2007 (3) BomCR 772, 2007 (4) CTC 257, 2007 (4) MhLj 517,MANU/MH/0252/2007.
Read full Judgment here: Click here.
Print PageSaturday, 28 October 2023
Whether the court can infer that there was contract on the basis of exchange of Emails?
I agree with the Plaintiff's Counsel submission relying on the case of Jyotsna Valia (supra) that a written contract need not always be a contract signed by both parties and may consist of correspondence exchanged between the parties without signature. In the present case the authenticity or veracity or truth of its contents of the emails exchanged between the parties are not in dispute. Thus the contentions of the Defendant with regard to no agreement between the parties to extend time upto 31st March 2020 is repelled as misconceived.{Para 30}
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Interim Application No. 655 of 2023 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 75 of 2021 and Summons for Judgment No. 65 of 2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 75 of 2021
Decided On: 20.09.2023
Play Games 24X7 Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Loran Leasing And Infotech Pvt. Ltd.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Kamal Khata, J.
Citation: MANU/MH/3838/2023.
Read full Judgment here: Click here.
Whether the court should grant unconditional leave to defend in Summary suit on the ground that defendant has raised a counter claim?
I am in respectful agreement with the judgement of this Court in the case of First Rand Services Pvt. Ltd vs. Pantheon Infrastructure Ltd.2 which held that
"I find substance in the submission of Mr. Engineer. If the contention on behalf of the defendant that the defendant is entitled to an unconditional leave to defend the suit since the defendant has raised a counterclaim is accepted, the very object of providing summary procedure under Order XXXVII of the Code would be rendered otiose. It is one thing to contend that while seeking leave to defend the suit, the Defendant has raised a counterclaim which raises a substantive defence or at any rate triable issues. It is a completely different thing to assert that since the Defendant has raised a counter claim, irrespective of the nature and quality of the defence and/or counterclaim the Defendant is entitled to an unconditional leave to defend the suit. It all turns upon the quality of defence raised by the Defendant. The tests enunciated by a catena of decisions and reformulated in the case of Hubtown (supra) are required to be applied even in a case where the Defendant raises a counterclaim. An unconditional leave cannot be granted on the sole premise that the Defendant has raised a counterclaim."{Para 36}
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Interim Application No. 655 of 2023 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 75 of 2021 and Summons for Judgment No. 65 of 2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 75 of 2021
Decided On: 20.09.2023
Play Games 24X7 Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Loran Leasing And Infotech Pvt. Ltd.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Kamal Khata, J.
Citation: MANU/MH/3838/2023.
Print PageSaturday, 18 February 2023
Whether application for Summary Judgment is maintainable if Summary suit is converted into Commercial suit?
Assuming that plaintiffs' suit is initially filed as a summary suit under Order XXXVII of the Code, thereby taking it out of ambit of provisions of Order XIII-A of the Code, would it's subsequent conversion as commercial suit entail loss of both the rights viz. (i) to seek summary judgment under Order XIII-A as well as (ii) pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII, Rule 3 of the Code?. To paraphrase, would conversion of summary suit into a commercial suit would put a Plaintiff in a disadvantageous position where he loses right to seek pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII, Rule 3 of the Code as well as attracts the bar for seeking summary judgment under sub rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order XIII A of the Code?
15. Through Mr. Dawar strenuously pressed his objection about non-applicability of provisions of Order XIII-A to Plaintiff's application, upon being confronted with the above conundrum, he fairly concedes to the position that a Plaintiff in summary suit cannot be put to a disadvantageous position merely because his summary suit is converted into a commercial suit. The objective behind incorporating provision of sub-rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order XIII A of the Code is to prevent Plaintiff who once attempts pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII Rule 3 of the Code and upon conversion of his summary suit into commercial one, seeks to have another bite at the cherry by seeking pronouncement of judgment under Order XIII-A of the Code. The provisions of sub-rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order XIII A cannot be interpreted to mean that Plaintiff in a summary suit which is converted into commercial suit would loose both rights of pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII Rule 3 of the Code as well as seeking summary judgment under Order XIII A of the Code. Thus, the objection about non-maintainability of application for Summary Judgment filed by the Petitioners is repelled.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Writ Petition No. 10573 of 2022
Decided On: 31.01.2023
Ashok Commercial Enterprises and Ors. Vs. Rajesh Jugraj Madhani
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Sandeep V. Marne, J.
Citation: MANU/MH/0251/2023,2023 Lawweb (Bom HC ) 10.
Print PageSaturday, 10 December 2022
What is basic concept of Account stated?
With that, let us consider what constitutes a "settled account" or "account stated". Before further discussing the issue, it would be relevant to refer to some judgments which, in our opinion, shed light on the issue and can be said to have conclusively decided that aspect of the matter. In Tulsiram Shrikisan Marwadi v. Zaboo Bhima Shankar MANU/NA/0041/1947, learned Division Bench was considering as to what would be an account stated. After relying on various judgments, the Court observed as under:
that a real account stated is a very different thing from an acknowledgment. In a real account stated there is consideration in the shape of an agreement that items on one side of the account be taken as paid by items on the other side. In an account stated it does not matter if some of the items are time-barred. It would be different thing if all the items are time-barred, and we see no reason to depart from the view expressed on this point in Ganesh prasad v. Rambati Bai I.L.R. (1942) Nag.369 : MANU/NA/0022/1941 .
The Privy Council had an occasion to deal with the issue in the case of (Elvira Rodrigues) Siqueira v. (Godnicalo Hypolito Construction) Noronha A.I.R. 1934 P C 144. The Privy Council was considering Section 25(3) of the Contract Act, 1872 and Article 64 of the Limitation Act, 1908 whether - a suit could be maintained on a settled account. It is in that context, that Lord Atkin, speaking for the Privy Council, held as under:
Their Lordships think that what has been forgotten is that there are two forms of account stated. An account stated may only take the form of a mere acknowledgment of a debt, and in those circumstances, though it is quite true it amounts to a promise and the existence of a debt may be inferred, that can be rebutted, and it may very well turn out that there is no real debt at all, and in those circumstances there would be no consideration and no binding promise.
But on the other hand, there is another form of account stated which is a very usual form as between merchants in business in which the account stated is an account which contains entries on both sides, and in which the parties who have stated the account between them have agreed that the items on one side should be set against the items upon the other side and the balance only should be paid; the items on the smaller side are set off and deemed to be paid by the items on the larger side, and there is a promise for good consideration to pay the balance arising from the fact that the items have been so set off and paid in the way described.
This judgment was considered by the Supreme Court, in Gordon Woodroffe & Co. (Madras) Ltd. v. Shaikh M.A. Majid & Co. A.I.R. 1976 Sup Cou 181. The second question in issue before the Supreme Court was whether there was a settled account between the parties and whether it was open for the Plaintiff to reopen it. It was an admitted fact that to the statement of accounts, no objections were raised by the Plaintiff any time nor was a single document produced to show that the Plaintiff ever wrote to the Defendant raising an objection to the statements of account. At one stage, the Plaintiff sent a memorandum to the Defendant, accepting the accuracy of the accounts. It is in that context that the Court was considering the concept of "account settled" or "stated" We may gainfully refer to a portion of paragraph 14:
(14) The legal position is that the accounts are settled or stated if they are submitted and accepted as correct by the other side to whom the accounts have been rendered. Such a statement of accounts need not be in writing, nor is it necessary that before the accounts are settled, they should be gone into by the parties and scrutinised and supported by vouchers. It is sufficient if the accounts are accepted and such acceptance may be inferred by conduct of the parties. As observed in Daniell's Chancery Practice, eighth edition, Vol. I, p. 419:
The mere delivery of an account will not constitute a stated account without some evidence of acquiescence which may afford sufficient legal presumption of a settlement.
There is also the following passage in Bullenn and Leake's Precedents of Pleadings ninth edition, p. 584:
It is not enough for the accounting party merely to deliver his account; there must be some evidence that the other party has accepted it as correct. But such acceptance need not be express, contemporaneous or subsequent conduct may amount to a sufficient acquiescence.
After so observing, considering the contention of the Defendants that there has been a stated or settled account, the Court in paragraph 15 held as under:
In this connection it is necessary to state that the expression "account stated" has more than one meaning. It sometimes means a claim to payment made by one party and admitted by the other to be correct. An account stated in this sense is no more than an admission of a debt out of Court: while it is no doubt cogent evidence against the admitting party, and throws upon him the burden of proving that the debt is not due, it may, like any other admission, be shown to have been made in error. Where the transaction is of this character, it makes no difference whether the account is said to be "stated" or to be "stated and agreed": the so-called agreement is without consideration and amounts to no more than an admission. There is, however, a second kind of account stated where the account contains items both of credit and debit, and the figures on both sides are adjusted between the parties and a balance stuck.
Accounts stated which contains entries on both sides and parties who have stated the account between them have agreed that the items on one side should be set off against the items on the other side and the balance amount should be paid, would amount to a written contract for good consideration arising from the fact that the items have been so set off. Such an account stated gives cause to a contract in writing on a fresh cause of action, with an implied promise to pay. {Para 25}
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Summons for Judgment No. 1117 of 2003 in Summary Suit No. 1551 of 2003
Jyotsna K. Valia and Ors. Vs. T.S. Parekh and Co. and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
F.I. Rebello, V.K. Tahilramani and Abhay Shreeniwas Oka, JJ.
Author: F.I. Rebello, J.
Decided On: 26.04.2007
Citation: citations: 2007 (3) BomCR 772, 2007 (4) CTC 257, 2007 (4) MhLj 517,MANU/MH/0252/2007
Print PageMonday, 17 May 2021
What is basic concept of liquidated demand in Summary Suit?
Order XXXVII Rule 1 CPC applies to suits in which a debt or
liquidated demand is sought to be recovered. The term ‘liquidated demand’ has been defined by a ld. Single Judge of this Court in Rajinder Kumar Khanna v. Oriental Insurance Co., AIR 1990 Del 278 as follows:
“2. It was asserted by the plaintiff in the suit and
the petitioner before me, that the claim in the suit
was a “liquidated demand”. The petitioner seeks
to take advantage of the amendments made to the
Code of Civil Procedure, by which “liquidated
demand” became subject-matter of summary suits
for the first time.
3. The industry of counsel had not been able to
produce a single precedent of courts in India,
which explained what is “liquidated demand”.
However, reference has been made to Words and
Phrases Permanent Edition, in which reference is
made to Rifkin v. Safenovitz, 40 A 2d 188. It is
stated that “amount claimed to be due is a
“liquidated demand” within statute authorizing
summary judgments if it is susceptible of being
made certain in amount by mathematical
calculations from factors which are or ought to be
in possession or knowledge of party to be
charged”.”
It is therefore clear that any sum which can be ascertained from the documents on record would constitute a liquidated demand.{Para 11}
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 15th December, 2020
C.R.P. 57/2020 & CM APPL.20305/2020
SURENDER KUMAR Vs MANOJ KUMAR
Print PageWhether plaintiff can file a Summary suit based on the entry in the bank passbook about the transfer of money to the defendant?
The brief background is that the Plaintiff filed a summary suit under
Order XXXVII CPC for recovery of a sum of Rs.21 lakhs along with
interest. The case of the Plaintiff is that the Plaintiff gave a loan to the Defendant to the tune of Rs.21 lakhs, which was transferred from the bank account of the Plaintiff in Bank of Baroda to the bank account of the Defendant’s firm i.e., MK Clothing, in HDFC Bank, Priyadarshini Vihar, Delhi. The payment of Rs.21 lakhs and receipt thereof on 8th August, 2015 is not disputed by the Defendant.
14. Considering the fact that the amount, which was transferred by the Plaintiff to the Defendant was through proper banking channels for which clear evidence has been placed on record, the suit under Order XXXVII CPC would be maintainable as it is for a liquidated sum. The onus would be on the Defendant to show as to why the leave to defend should be granted.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 15th December, 2020
C.R.P. 57/2020 & CM APPL.20305/2020
SURENDER KUMAR Vs MANOJ KUMAR
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
Prathiba M. Singh, J. (Oral)
Tuesday, 29 October 2019
Whether summary suit is maintainable against legal representative of deceased defendant?
Whether trial court can look in to merits of dispute involved at the stage of filing of summary suit?
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR AT JAMMU
