Showing posts with label irrevocable licence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label irrevocable licence. Show all posts

Monday, 27 April 2026

Explain Irrevocable licence with illustrations

 An irrevocable licence is a licence which, once validly created, cannot be revoked at the mere will of the grantor in certain recognized situations. Under Section 60 of the Indian Easements Act, a licence is generally revocable, but it becomes irrevocable mainly when it is coupled with a transfer of property and such transfer is in force, or when the licensee, acting upon the licence, has executed a work of permanent character and incurred expenses in doing so.

Print Page

Sunday, 19 August 2018

Whether a person can acquire easementary right over property which is owned by him?

 With regard to the nature of occupation of the defendant and the finding that the license in his favour was irrevocable under Section 60 of the said Act, it is necessary to refer to the respective pleadings of the parties. While the plaintiff came up with a specific case that he was the owner of the suit property by virtue of the sale-deed dated 16th August, 1983, according to the defendant this document was nominal in nature and executed by way of security for the amount borrowed. It was pleaded that the ownership of the defendant continued and the defendant did not lose his title by virtue of the sale-deed. In alternate, it was pleaded that the occupation of the defendant was by way of a license and a permanent structure had been constructed. As noted above, the relief with regard to declaration of title was rightly granted in favour of the plaintiff by the trial Court.

10. The Full Bench of this Court in Raychand Vanmalidas [supra] has held that though a party may raise inconsistent pleas of ownership and easement in the alternative in the same suit, such party has to elect one of the pleas through the course of the proceedings. Even if a party does not choose one of the alternate pleas, he can lead evidence on both and it is for the Court to decide whether he is entitled to succeed on one of his pleas. This judgment of the Full Bench was considered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court on Chapsibhai Dhanjibhai Dand [supra] and the same came to be affirmed. It was observed that after taking the plea of ownership and failing in the same, a party cannot subsequently turn around and claim that right as an easement by prescription. For establishing the right based on easement, such right has to be exercised on the property owned by somebody else and not as an incident of his own ownership of that property. In the light of this legal position, it is clear that the defendant having failed to prove his ownership cannot now be permitted to turn around and claim that by virtue of easementary right, he had undertaken a permanent construction and, therefore, was not liable to be evicted. In Shankar Gopinath Apte [supra], this position has been reiterated by emphasizing that the party undertaking the work of a permanent character should do so while "acting upon the license" under Section 60(b) of the said Act.



11. In view of this legal position, it is found that both the Courts committed an error in refusing the relief of possession to the plaintiff by relying upon the provisions of Section 60(b) of the said Act. Having failed to prove his title, it was not open for the defendant to fall back upon his other plea that he had easementary right in the suit property. Both the Courts refused the relief of possession by wrongly applying the law. Substantial question of law No. 2 is answered by holding that the defendant is not entitled to claim that on account of permanent construction being made, the license was irrevocable.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Second Appeal No. 384 of 2003

Decided On: 09.02.2018

 Tulshidas  Vs. Madhukar
Print Page

Sunday, 23 April 2017

Whether irrevocable licence is created even if construction is made without consent of landlord?

The contention of the appellant that, in view of construction erected by the defendant and permitted on the suit plot, the defendant became irrevocable licensee in view of Section 60(b) of the Easement Act. This contention has been strongly opposed on the ground that the construction in question is neither permanent nor pucca nor such intention was expressed by the appellant (defendant) at any time. No permission was obtained from the landlord for erecting the construction on the suit plot. The Courts below have rightly rejected this contention of the defendant. Section 60(b) of the Indian Easement Act is not attracted in the facts and circumstances of the case because there is no evidence of a licence coupled with transfer of property in operation nor there is evidence to establish that the appellant had, acting upon licence, executed a work of permanent character and incurred expenses in execution of the construction of permanent character. In the absence of such evidence, no irrevocable licence was created in favour of the defendant. Substantial question of law at No. (iii) is thus answered in the negative against the appellant.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)
Second Appeal No. 79 of 1999
Decided On: 21.07.2010
 Haribhau  Rajaramji Rewasekar, 
Vs.
 Shri Swami Narayan Mandir.

Coram:
A.P. Bhangale, J.



Print Page