Showing posts with label jurisdictional error. Show all posts
Showing posts with label jurisdictional error. Show all posts

Saturday, 18 April 2026

What is difference between error within jurisdiction and error outside jurisdiction?

In law, every erroneous decision is not necessarily a jurisdictional defect. The real issue is whether the court, tribunal, or authority had the legal power to decide the matter, and whether the mistake occurred while exercising that power or by going beyond it.

Jurisdiction means the legal authority to hear and decide a case. When a court or tribunal is competent to entertain a matter, any mistake committed while deciding that matter is generally described as an error within jurisdiction. Such an error may make the decision incorrect, but it does not automatically make the decision void.
Print Page

Thursday, 7 May 2015

Whether civil suit is tenable when jurisdiction of civil court is expressly barred?

The scope of the exclusionary clauses contained in the statutes has been considered in great detail with reference to the decisions of the superior courts in England and also the decisions of the Supreme Court of India by Justice G.P. Singh (former Chief Justice, M.P. High Court) in "Principles of Statutory Interpretation", 6th edition (1996) at page 475. The law is stated thus:
A review of the relevant authorities on the point leads to the following conclusions:
(1) An Exclusionary Clause using the formula 'an order of the tribunal under this Act shall not be called in question in any Court' is ineffective to prevent the calling in question of an order of the tribunal if the order is really not an order under the Act but a nullity.
(2) Cases of nullity may arise when there is lack of jurisdiction at the stage of commencement of enquiry e.g., when (a) authority is assumed under an ultra vires statute; (b) the tribunal is not properly constituted, or is disqualified to act; (c) the subject-matter or the parties are such over which the tribunal has no authority to inquire; and (d) there is want of essential preliminaries prescribed by the law for commencement of the inquiry.
(3) Cases of nullity may also arise during the course or at the conclusion of the inquiry, These cases are also cases of want of jurisdiction if the word 'jurisdiction' is understood in a wide sense. Some examples of these cases are (a) when the tribunal has wrongly determined a jurisdictional question of fact or law; (b) when it has failed to follow the fundamental principles of judicial procedure, e.g. has passed the order without giving an opportunity of hearing to the party affected; (c) when it has violated the fundamental provisions of the Act, e.g., when it fails to take into account matters which it is required to take into account or when it takes into account extraneous and irrelevant matters; (d) when it has acted in bad faith; and (e) when it grants a relief or makes an order which it has no authority to grant or make; "as also (f) when by misapplication of the law it has asked itself the wrong question.
With great respect to the learned author, I would adopt the above statement of law, as my own.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition Nos. 2243, 1947, 2071, 2172, 2242, 2255, 2278, 2576 of 2013,

 Mr. Yogesh Megaji Gada Vs.  The Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai & Ors. etc. etc.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N.M. Jamdar, J.
Print Page

Saturday, 4 April 2015

Distinction between error within jurisdiction and jurisdictional error of arbitrator


In McDermott International Inc. v. Burn Standard Co. Ltd., (2006)
11 SCC 181, this Court held as under:

“112. It is trite that the terms of the contract can be express or
implied. The conduct of the parties would also be a relevant
factor in the matter of construction of a contract. The
construction of the contract agreement is within the jurisdiction of
the arbitrators having regard to the wide nature, scope and ambit
of the arbitration agreement and they cannot be said to have
misdirected themselves in passing the award by taking into
consideration the conduct of the parties. It is also trite that
correspondences exchanged by the parties are required to be
taken into consideration for the purpose of construction of a
contract. Interpretation of a contract is a matter for the arbitrator
to determine, even if it gives rise to determination of a question of
law. (See Pure Helium India (P) Ltd. v. ONGC [(2003) 8 SCC
593] and D.D. Sharma v. Union of India [(2004) 5 SCC 325]).
113. Once, thus, it is held that the arbitrator had the jurisdiction,
no further question shall be raised and the court will not exercise
its jurisdiction unless it is found that there exists any bar on the
face of the award.”
In MSK Projects (I) (JV) Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan, (2011) 10 SCC
573, the Court held:
“17. If the arbitrator commits an error in the construction of the
contract, that is an error within his jurisdiction. But if he wanders
outside the contract and deals with matters not allotted to him, he
commits a jurisdictional error. Extrinsic evidence is admissible in
such cases because the dispute is not something which arises
under or in relation to the contract or dependent on the
construction of the contract or to be determined within the award.
The ambiguity of the award can, in such cases, be resolved by
admitting extrinsic evidence. The rationale of this rule is that the
nature of the dispute is something which has to be determined
outside and independent of what appears in the award. Such a
jurisdictional error needs to be proved by evidence extrinsic to the
award. 

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 10531
OF 2014
(ARISING OUT OF SLP (CIVIL) NO.14767 OF 2012)

Associate Builders Vs Delhi Development Authority

Dated;November 25, 2014
Citation;(2015) 3 SCC 49.
Print Page