Showing posts with label manufacturer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label manufacturer. Show all posts

Sunday, 29 March 2026

Delay, Denial, and Direct Cognizance: Why the Bombay High Court Quashed the Prosecution in C.B. Healthcare v. Union of India

 

The Bombay High Court’s decision in Ms. C.B. Healthcare and Ors. v. Union of India is a significant reminder that prosecutions under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 must satisfy not only public health objectives but also the statutory safeguards built into the Act and the Rules. In a judgment delivered on 24 March 2026, Justice N.J. Jamadar quashed the criminal prosecution against the manufacturer and its partners, holding that the cumulative procedural lapses had destroyed the accused’s valuable right to challenge the analyst’s report and had rendered the continuation of prosecution an abuse of the process of court.

Facts and procedural history

Print Page

Friday, 14 April 2023

Is the Central Drugs Laboratory report conclusive against a manufacturer if they did not have the opportunity to get the sample re-analyzed?

 From the foregoing analysis of law on the subject, it is clear that while a manufacturer has a valuable right of getting the sample re-tested/re-analyzed by the Central Drugs Laboratory so as to adduce evidence in controversion of the report of the Government Analyst but once the sample has been tested by the Central Drugs Laboratory, there is no occasion for sending the sample again for testing to the same laboratory. It has been further laid down by the Supreme Court in the aforequoted judgment, that the conclusiveness meant in Section 25(3) of the Act has reference to the person referred to in the said subsection, meaning thereby that the facts stated in the report of the Government Analyst would become conclusive only against the person who despite having been provided a copy of the report, has failed to notify his intention to adduce evidence regarding facts stated therein within a period of 28 days. This conclusiveness of the facts stated in the report would not come into play in a case where the manufacturer or any other person has either not been provided the copy of the report or where such manufacturer or person had no occasion to notify his intention to adduce evidence in controversion of the report. In view of the above, the question whether in a particular case, conclusiveness is to be attached to the report of the Central Drugs Laboratory and whether valuable right of a manufacturer to adduce evidence in controversion of the report would get violated in a particular case depends upon the facts and circumstances peculiar to that case. {Para 16}

17. In case, like the present one, the manufacturers/petitioners were not provided the copy of the report of the CDL, Kolkata, or if at all the same was provided, the petitioners/manufacturers could not ask for reanalysis of the sample as the same had already been tested by Central Drugs Laboratory. Therefore, the report would not be conclusive against the petitioners. The petitioners would be at liberty to adduce evidence in controversion of the said report before the trial court. In these circumstances no prejudice has been caused to the petitioners even if the complaint has been filed when the shelf life of the drug in question was due to expire or because in the circumstances explained hereinbefore, they could not seek reanalysis of the sample of the drug in question. The report of the CDL, Kolkata, as already stated, in the facts and circumstances of the case is not conclusive against the petitioners and they have a right to controvert the same by leading evidence before the trial court. 

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT SRINAGAR

CRMC No. 169/2016

Decided On: 01.11.2022

Swiss Garnier Life Sciences and Ors.  Vs. Union of India

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sanjay Dhar, J.

Citation: MANU/JK/1186/2022

Print Page

Whether Drug Manufacturer Can Be Held Liable For Not Meeting Standards Prescribed After Date Of Manufacture?

The undisputed facts are that the alleged drug was manufactured on 01.10.2004. On that date no standard was prescribed. On 06.10.2005 a notification came to be issued wherein for the first time a standard was prescribed by the Food and Drug Administration, Maharashtra State. The sample was collected on 03.06.2005. It was sent for analysis on 04.06.2005. The analyst prepared report on 08.09.2005. The complaint was filed on 04.01.2006 and order of issuance of process was passed on 16.01.2006. {Para 8}

13. Next question that would fall for consideration is that in this case it is admitted fact that the drug was manufactured on 01.10.2004 having expiry period of three years. On the date of manufacture, there was no standard prescribed by Food and Drugs Administration, Maharashtra State. Vide notification dated 06.10.2005 the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare issued notification prescribing standard for the sterile devices intended for external or internal use in human beings as drugs with immediate effect, in which at Sr. No. (viii) present drug is mentioned. Thus, at least when the drug was manufactured, there was no standard prescribed by the State of Maharashtra for the said drug and certainly therefore manufacturer cannot be held responsible. This Court, therefore finds that prosecuting manufacturer would be clearly an abuse of process of law as a person cannot be held guilty for the act done prior to notification prescribing standard.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Criminal Writ Petition No. 912 of 2022

Decided On: 31.03.2023

Kirti Kumar Jayantilal Patel and Ors.  Vs. State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Kishore C. Sant, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/1218/2023,2023 Lawweb (Bom HC ) 17.

Print Page

Saturday, 10 October 2015

Whether manufacturer can be prosecuted at the place where the drug is sold?

In Medisearch Laboratories and others v. State of Goa (supra) as also in Smt. Sunder Ben and another v. State of Maharashtra (supra) even though.the firm falling in the jurisdiction of the Court from where the samples had been taken had not been party yet one of the purchasers who did not fail within the jurisdiction of the Court had been a party along with the manufacturer. In my opinion, taking into account the purpose sought to be achieved by the said Act, the principle has to be expanded and wherever an adulterated drug is manufactured, the manufacturer can be prosecuted at the place where the drug is sold irrespective of whether the seller has been made party or not since the consequences ensue at the place where the goods are sold and purchased. The goods are manufactured for the purpose of distribution throughout the country and the manufacturers cannot be permitted to escape their liability on technical grounds. At any rate, the consequences of manufacturer of adulterated drug ensue wherever the drug is sold and as such manufacturer can be sued at any place of sale of adulterated drug. Of course, the sale within the jurisdiction of the Court taking cognizance against the manufacturer will have to be established.
Bombay High Court
Ashok Sureshchand Bal And Ors. vs State Of Maharashtra on 26 September, 2001
Equivalent citations: (2002) 1 BOMLR 483, 2002 (1) MhLj 211
Bench: R Batta
Print Page

Wednesday, 7 October 2015

Whether dealer, manufacturer or distributor can be prosecuted alongwith vendor in case of prevention of food adulteration Act?

The other ground namely that the dealer, manufacturer or distributor cannot be prosecuted alongwith the vendor by impleading all of them initially as the accused in a prosecution under the Act is unsustainable in view of the decision of this Court in Bhagwan Dass Jagdish Chander v. Delhi Administration MANU/SC/0092/1975 : [1975] Supp. S.C.R. 30. In that case after considering the effect of Section 19(2), Section 20 and Section 20-A of the Act, Court observed at pages 36-37 thus:
We are also unable to accept as correct a line of reasoning found in V.N. Chokra v. The State MANU/PH/0283/1965 and Food Inspector, Palghat Municipality v. Setharam Rice and Oil Mills MANU/KE/0114/1974 : (1974) F.A.C.P 534 and P.B. Kurup v. Food Inspector, Malappuram Panchayat (1969) K L T 845 that in every case under the Act, there has to be initially a prosecution of a particular seller only, but those who may have passed on or sold the adulterated article of food the vendor, who is being prosecuted, could only be brought in subsequently after a warranty set up under Section 19(2) has been pleaded and shown to be substantiated. Support was sought for such a view by referring to the special provisions of Section 20A and Section 19(2) and Section 20 of the Act. A reason for Section 20A seems to be that the prosecution of a person impleaded as an accused under Section 20A in the course of a trial does not require a separate sanction. Section 20A itself lays down that, where the Court trying the offence is itself satisfied that a "manufacturer, distributor or dealer is also concerned with an offence", for which an accused is being tried, the necessary sanction to prosecute will be deemed to have been given. Another reason seems to be that such a power enables speedy trial of the really guilty parties. We are in agreement with the view of the Delhi High Court that these special provisions do not take away or derogate from the effect of the ordinary provisions of the law which enable separate as well as joint trials of accused persons in accordance with the provisions of the old. Sections 233 to 239 of Criminal Procedure Code. On the other hand, there seems no logically sound reason why, if a distributor or a manufacturer can be subsequently impleaded under Section 20A of the Act, he cannot be joined as a co-accused initially in a joint trial if the allegations made justify such a course.
(emphasis added)
Equivalent Citation: 1983(7)ACR337(SC), AIR1983SC545, 1983 AWC 668 SC, 1983CriLJ980, 1983KLJ301, (1983)85PLR496, 1983(1)SCALE365, (1983)2SCC384, [1983]2SCR714
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Appeal Nos. 286-292 of 1981
Decided On: 07.04.1983
Appellants: State of Punjab
Vs.
Respondent: Devinder Kumar and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.N. Sen and E.S. Venkataramiah, JJ.


Print Page

Sunday, 6 September 2015

When dealer,manufacturer or distributor can be impleaded in food adulteration case?

 In this connection, the learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in M/s. Omprakash Shivaprakash v. Kuriakose (1999(3) KLT
861) that:
"The essential conditions for invoking the power under section 20A are that: (1) the trial should have begun already;
(2) the trial must be of any offence under the Act allegedly committed by a person other than the manufacturer or distributor or dealer of the food article;
(3) the Court must have been satisfied that such manufacturer or dealer or distributor is also concerned with the offence;
(4) such satisfaction must have been formed "on the evidence adduced before the Court"."
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Court can proceed against the manufacturer, distributor or dealer only if the Court is satisfied from the "evidence adduced before it during the trial".
843) this court has held:
"A reading of section 20A would make it clear that the power given to the Court under that Section can be exercised only after taking evidence in the case. The section says that only when the Court is satisfied on the evidence adduced before it that manufacturer, distributor or dealer is also concerned with that offence, the Court may proceed against him as though prosecution had been instituted against him under section
20. Then the Court has the power to implead the manufacturer, distributor or dealer under section 20A of the Act. Court's power to implead a dealer, manufacturer or distributor under section 20A can neither be invoked before the stage of adducing evidence in the trial nor after the conclusion of trial."
Kerala High Court
M/S.RADHAKRISHNA TRADERS  vs C.V.Saseedharan on  27th day of September, 2012 
Citation: 2013CriLJ937, 2013(3)Crimes220, 2012 (4) KHC 647, 2012(4)KLJ670
Print Page