Showing posts with label merging of decree. Show all posts
Showing posts with label merging of decree. Show all posts

Monday, 7 March 2016

When decree of trial court will not merge with decree of appellate court?

It is well settled that when a decree of the Trial
Court  is  either confirmed, modified or  reversed  but  the
Appellate  decree, except when the decree is passed  without
notice to the parties, the Trial Court decree gets merged in
the appellate decree. But when the decree is passed  without
notice to a party, that decree will not, in law, be a decree
to which he is a party. Equally so in the case of an  appel-
late decree. In this case these two persons were not  served
in  the  suit. A decree was passed  ex-parte  against them
without  giving them notice of the suit. In law,  therefore,
there  is  no decree against them. In the appeal  also they
were  not  served. If they had been served  in the  appeal,
things would have been different. They could have put for-
ward their case in appeal and got appropriate orders passed.
But  that is not the case here. That being so, there  is  no
bar for an application by them before the Trial Court  under
Order IX, Rule 13, to set aside the ex-parte decree  against
them. 
    There  is no error of law in allowing a joint decree  to
stand  against the person who contested  throughout  while
setting  aside the ex-parte decree  passed  against  others
without serving them personally on admitting the application
under Order IX Rule 13 C .P.C. [690C]

Supreme Court of India

Kewal Ram vs Smt. Ram Lubhai & Ors. And Vice ... on 26 March, 1987
Equivalent citations: 1987 AIR 1304, 1987 SCR (2) 685,(1987)2SCC344, 

BENCH:
KHALID, V. (J)
OZA, G.L. (J)
Print Page