Showing posts with label exparte decree. Show all posts
Showing posts with label exparte decree. Show all posts

Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Delhi HC: Whether judgment is vitiated if defendant who was proceeded exparte was not served copy of material amendment to plaint?

 In the following decision, it is held that even if a party is ex parte, and thereafter, if an amendment application is made, then that must be served to the party concerned and if the party remains absent despite notice, then the Court applying its discretion may pass an appropriate order. Reliance is placed on the following judgment:-


M/s. Jharkhand Mines and Industries Ltd. & Anr. vs. Nand Kishore Prasad & Ors., reported in MANU/BH/0058/1969 : AIR 1969 Pat 228


The High Court of Patna while dealing with the effect of passing of an ex-parte decree without service of notice at the time of the amendment of the suit, held as follows:


It was incumbent on the Court to see to it that the notice of the amended plaint was served on the defendants of that suit. The Code of Civil Procedure, in my opinion, casts a duty on the court to see that the defendants are made aware of any amendment in the plaint, whether the amendment be in regard to the addition of parties or in regard to the contents thereof. Unfortunately, the learned Subordinate Judge, who passed the ex parte decree, did not direct any notices to be issued to the defendants with a view to make them aware about the amendment of the plaint. He should have issued such notices and awaited the service report, and, if the defendants so desired, granted them an opportunity to file a written statement before putting up the suit for hearing and disposal, whether ex parte or otherwise. On this ground alone, I am of the opinion that the ex parte decree is vitiated and must be set aside. {Para 28}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

I.A. No. 9047/2011, 

Decided On: 25.05.2012

Flight Centre Travels P. Ltd. Vs. Rahul Nath and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Hon'ble Mr. Justice Manmohan Singh

 Citation: 2012:DHC:3618,MANU/DE/2202/2012.
Print Page

Sunday, 29 March 2026

Ex Parte at Trial, New Defence in Appeal? The Real Limits of the First Appellate Court Under the CPC

A first appeal under Section 96 CPC is not a mere formality. It is a rehearing on facts and law, and the first appellate court has a duty to independently test the correctness of the decree on the basis of the pleadings, issues, and evidence already on record. But that wide appellate jurisdiction does not mean that a defendant who remained ex parte before the trial court can use the appeal as a fresh opportunity to construct an altogether new defence.

The governing principle is simple: appeal is a continuation of the suit, not a reconstruction of it. The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that in a first appeal the entire case is open for rehearing on facts and law, and the appellate court may reverse or affirm the trial court after reappreciating the evidence. At the same time, the appellate court remains confined to adjudicating the controversy as framed by the pleadings of the parties and proved through the trial record.

Print Page

Sunday, 26 September 2021

Questions and answers on law Part 40

 Q 1:- Whether report under section 156 sub section 3 CR PC is binding on the Court?

 Ans: Report filed by police U/S 156 of CRPC is not binding on magistrate. He can disagree with police report and take cognizance against accused or drop prosecution against accused.
Supreme Court of India
Abhinandan Jha & Ors vs Dinesh Mishra on 17 April, 1967

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
C.A. Vaidialingam and M. Hidayatullah, JJ

Print Page

Sunday, 20 December 2020

What remedies are available to the defendant if court passes an exparte decree against him?

 The proviso appended to Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure postulates that when an ex parte decree has been passed against some of the defendants and it is necessary to set aside the entire decree, the Court is not powerless to do so. If an application for setting aside the ex parte decree was maintainable at the instance of the appellants, we fail to understand as to why a separate suit was required to be filed. When an ex parte decree is passed, the defendant may have more than one remedies. He may file a suit contending that the decree was obtained fraudulently. He may file an application under Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure for setting aside the ex parte decree. He may prefer an appeal from the ex parte judgment and decree. In a given case, he may also file a review application.


13. In Bhanu Kumar Jain v. Arcbana Kumar and Anr. MANU/SC/1079/2004 : AIR2005SC626 , this Court held:


26. When an ex parte decree is passed, the defendant (apart from filing a review petition and a suit for setting aside the ex parte decree on the ground of fraud) has two clear options, one, to file an appeal and another to file an application for setting aside the order in terms of Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code. He can take recourse to both the proceedings simultaneously but in the event the appeal is dismissed as a result whereof the ex parte decree passed by the trial court merges with the order passed by the appellate court, having regard to Explanation appended to Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code a petition under Order 9 Rule 13 would not be maintainable. However, Explanation I appended to the said provision does not suggest that the converse is also true.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 7316 of 2008 

Decided On: 16.12.2008


 Mahesh Yadav and Ors. Vs.  Rajeshwar Singh and Ors.


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S.B. Sinha and Cyriac Joseph, JJ.

Author: S.B. Sinha, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/8463/2008,AIR 2009 SC 1064

Print Page

Monday, 4 February 2019

Whether Decree Passed On Plaintiff's Evidence Without Defendant's Appearance At Trial Is Ex-Parte Decree?

 In this case, the party, who was absent and
was proceeded ex parte was the "defendants" and
they had not led any evidence whereas it was the
plaintiff, who was present and had led his evidence.

26. In other words, if the plaintiff had remained
absent and was found to have led evidence, the
Court could have invoked its powers under
Explanation to Order 17 Rule 2 of the Code treating
the plaintiff as "present" for passing appropriate
orders. Such is, however, not the case here.
27. Similarly, in converse situation, if the
defendants had remained absent (as has happened
in this case) on that date and if it would have
noticed that they had adduced the evidence either
fully or substantially prior to the date on which they
were proceeded ex parte, the Court could have
invoked its powers under Explanation to Order 17
Rule 2 of the Code treating the defendants as
"present" on that day for passing appropriate orders
in the suit. Such is, however, again not the case
here.

28. We are, therefore, of the view that since the
defendants were proceeded ex parte and were found
not to have led any evidence in the suit, the Court
could only proceed under Order 17 Rule 3 (b) read
with Order 17 Rule 2 of the Code for disposal of the
suit by taking recourse to one of the modes directed
in that behalf by Order 9 of the Code or could have
made any other order as it thinks fit.
29. As mentioned above, the Trial Court did
proceed to hear the suit ex parte by taking recourse
to the Order 9 Rule 6 (a) in terms of Order 17 Rule 2
of the Code because on that day, the plaintiff was
present when the suit was called on for hearing
whereas the defendants were absent despite service
of summons and accordingly the Trial Court passed

the preliminary decree. Such decree, in our opinion,
was an "ex parte decree" within the meaning of
Order 9 Rule 6 (a) read with Order 9 Rule 13 of the
Code and, therefore, could be set aside under Order
9 Rule 13 on making out a sufficient ground by the
defendants.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL Nos.25822583
OF 2011

G. Ratna Raj Vs Sri Muthukumarasamy Permanent
Fund Ltd. 
Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.
Dated:February 01, 2019.
Print Page

Sunday, 11 November 2018

Whether evidence of witnesses recorded prior to passing of exparte decree can be used to confront them?

 In my view, where an order setting aside the ex parte decree with permission to file written statement attains the finality, it has the effect of wiping out the entire evidence recorded prior to setting aside the ex parte decree and the Court will have to re-record such evidence. The evidence of the witnesses of the plaintiff recorded earlier can be used to confront it to the said witnesses, as is permissible under Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, being the previous statement of the witnesses.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 2177 of 2016

Decided On: 03.04.2018

 Chandraprakash Dayaramji Lanjewar Vs.  Ratnakala Wamanrao Khatkhede and Ors.
Print Page

Sunday, 13 May 2018

Basic concepts of CPC 4 -definitions

Commission

Commission refers to an authority which is appointed to exercise a power or direction issued by court,when for instance a witness is unable to attend court on account of his illness or other similar reasons, the court can order such a witness to be examined on commission.
Under S 75 of CPC, commission can be issued by court for several purposes, as for instance to examine witnesses, to make a local investigation, to adjust accounts, to make a partition and so on.

Letter of request/Rogatory letter

A letter of request or rogatory letter is a letter issued by a court of one country to a court in a foreign country requesting for some judicial assistance from Judiciary of that country. Such assistance may be in the form of request to serve a summons or to take evidence of specified person.
Print Page

Friday, 20 April 2018

Whether parties are relegated to position existing prior to date of exparte order after setting aside of exparte decree?

 An ex parte decree is passed when the court believes that the Defendant has been served but is not appearing in court despite service of summons. In the present case, the appellate court while setting aside the ex parte decree, has come to the conclusion that the Defendant Shanti Devi (Respondent No. 1 herein) was not served and, therefore, the court had wrongly proceeded against her ex parte. That finding has been upheld till this Court. In our view, the effect of this would be that the ex parte decree, on its being set aside, would cease to exist and become non-est. After the ex parte decree is set aside, it is no decree in the eyes of law. The decree passed by the trial court on merits should be treated as the decree of the first court. We may make it clear that we are not dealing with those cases where a case has been decided on merits and the decree is set aside by the appellate court on any other ground and the matter remanded to the trial court for decision afresh. We leave that question open.

20. Here, we are dealing with a case where the Defendant was proceeded against ex parte and that order has been set aside on the ground that she has not been served and, therefore, she has been relegated to the position existing on the date she was proceeded against ex-parte, i.e., 6th April, 1990. After the amendment was introduced on 17th May, 1995, there was no right existing in the Plaintiff to file a suit for pre-emption. Since the decree on contest was passed on 27th November, 1999 the Plaintiff had no existing right of pre-emption on that date and the suit was rightly dismissed. This decree is the only subsisting decree of the first court.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 2062 of 2009

Decided On: 08.09.2017

Vijay Singh Vs. Shanti Devi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Madan B. Lokur and Deepak Gupta, JJ.
Citation: (2017) 8 SCC 837,2018(2) MHLJ 7
Print Page

Sunday, 15 April 2018

Whether exparte decree can be set aside without notice to some of defendants?

 Be that as it may, in our considered opinion, after the suit was restored at the instance of Defendant Nos. 3 and 4, the Trial Court committed another error inasmuch as it again did not issue fresh notice of the suit to Defendant Nos. 1 and 2. In other words, Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 were entitled for a fresh notice of the suit once restored despite their non-appearance in the first round of trial in the suit and in Order 9 Rule 13 proceedings.

19. The Trial Court, however, again decreed the suit by judgment/decree dated 20.02.2007 ex parte against Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 but after hearing only Defendant Nos. 3 and 4. It is against this judgment and decree which was impugned in appeal by Defendant Nos. 3 and 4, which was again set aside by the High Court by impugned judgment resulting in remand of the case to the Trial Court for fresh trial on merits giving rise to filing of this appeal by the Plaintiffs.

20. As mentioned above, though we are inclined to uphold the remand order, but that we do so on the basis of aforementioned two grounds noticed by us in the proceedings in the suit and in Order 9 Rule 13 proceedings. The two legal infirmities noticed by us in the proceedings call for remand of the case to the Trial Court for fresh adjudication of the civil suit on merits in accordance with law.

21. In the light of the foregoing discussion, the appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed.

22. The Trial Court will now issue fresh notice to Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 in the suit by usual mode of service and then by substituted service, if need arises. It is only after the service of the suit is held complete on Defendant Nos. 1 and 2, the Trial Court will proceed with the trial in the suit on merits.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 883 of 2018 (Arising out of S.L.P. (C) No. 14306 of 2015)

Decided On: 25.01.2018

 Jayaprakash and Ors. Vs.  T.S. David and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.K. Agrawal and Abhay Manohar Sapre, JJ.

Citation: (2018) 2 SCC 294
Print Page

Thursday, 29 March 2018

Whether decree passed by court without recording evidence of defendant is exparte decree?

No doubt, the plaintiff's suit was contested by defendant at its earlier stages and till the plaintiff's evidence was recorded, but he failed to appear on the subsequent dates of. hearing and remained absent, of course for valid reason, when the sail was set down for his evidence. Then the suit was decreed by the trial court on the basis of plaintiff's evidence only. It is not the case that defendant remained absent in the suit after any portion of his evidence was recorded in which event alone the trial court could have disposed of the suit treating him as present as envisaged by Explanation to Rule 2 of Order 17, C.P.C. Read in the context of this Explanation, sub-clause (b) of Rule 3 of Order 17, C.P.C. makes the legal position clear that when a party to the suit remains absent without leading any evidence, the trial court is enjoined by Rule 2. Order 17 to proceed to dispose of the suit in one of the modes stipulated in Order 9, C.P.C. As a necessary legal corollary it follows that any decree passed by the trial Court disposing of the suit on the basis of plaintiff's evidence only due to non-appearance of contesting defendant at subsequent stages in the suit and on his failure to lead his evidence, is an ex parte decree against him and not a decree on merits. In view of this emerging legal position the decree in the instant case has to be treated as an ex parte decree and not as decree passed on merits. Therefore, the application under Order 9, Rule 13, C.P.C. made by the petitioner before the trial court in Mis. Case No. 4/89 seeking to seaside the decree inquest ion was maintainable in law; and the trial court as well as the lower appellate court have clearly erred in taking the contrary view and passing the impugned orders dismissing the said application. As such, the revision is entitled to succeed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

Civil Revision Petition No. 115/1994

Decided On: 13.02.1997

 Smt. Ansari Sakeenabi Vs. Maligi Moideensab and others

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Mohammad Anwar, J.

Citation: AIR 1997 Karat 339
Print Page

Saturday, 27 January 2018

Whether decree will be deemed to be exparte decree if defendant has filed his written statement?

 Looking to the law as laid down by the Supreme Court and thereafter followed by our Court, what becomes clear is that where the Defendant has filed his Written Statement but remains absent on the date when the suit is called out for hearing and where the Defendant has not led any evidence, the suit can be disposed of (as per Order XVII Rule 2) only in any of the modes as prescribed under Order IX. Once the suit is disposed of under Order IX and the Defendant had not appeared at the hearing of the suit and a decree is passed in his absence, then, an application to set aside that decree is certainly maintainable under Order IX Rule 13. This being the clear enunciation of the law, I find that the Courts below were totally in error in coming to the conclusion that merely because the Defendant was served with the writ of summons and filed his Written Statement and thereafter did not appear, the decree passed could not be said to be one as being ex-parte.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition (L) No. 17138 of 2017

Decided On: 28.06.2017

 R.P. Bros Vs. Fakhruddin Siraj Topiwala

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B.P. Colabawalla, J.

Citation: 2017(6) MHLJ 845
Print Page

Saturday, 15 July 2017

Whether exparte decree in former suit will operate as res judicata in subsequent suit?

The judgment cited by the learned Counsel for the appellant is not applicable to the facts of the case. From the judgment in O.S.No.170 of 1998, it is seen that the present appellant is the plaintiff. The suit was dismissed for default. However, a counter claim filed by the second defendant/second respondent herein was allowed and hence, the appellant suffered a decree for recovery of possession. The decree for recovery of possession in the previous suit is only on the assumption that the second respondent herein is the lawful owner of the suit property. It is well settled now that even an ex-parte decree in the former suit could be taken as final and it would operate an res judicata in the subsequent suit. It is not disputed that the matters directly and substantially in issue in the present suit and in the previous suit are constructively the same.
13. In such circumstances, it cannot be said that the decree passed in the counter claim preferred by the second defendant herein will not operate as res judicata as against the appellant and the appellant is estopped from disputing the title of the second defendant herein. 
Madras High Court
Sivasubiramaniyampillai : vs Jothimani : 1St on 22 September, 2016
CORAM   
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE  S.S.SUNDAR           

Citation: AIR 2017(NOC)429 Mad
Print Page

Saturday, 25 March 2017

Whether one spouse can get exparte divorce decree set aside after death of other spouse?

Learned Counsel for the appellant submitted one objection in connection with such proceedings. He submitted that if such an action survives and the challenge to a decree ex parte or bipartite for divorce is found to be maintainable at the instance of the aggrieved spouse against whom the decree has been passed then persons who are non-spouses will have to be joined in the litigation and this would go counter to Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act. This difficulty is more imaginary than real. Once a divorce decree is passed, the stage of launching any petition under Section 13(1) does not survive. It is true that Section 13 of the Hindu marriage Act lays down that marriage whether solemnised before or after the commencement of the Act may be dissolved by a decree of divorce on the grounds mentioned therein on a petition presented by either the husband or the wife, thus, initially when such petition is to be presented. The person who presents such petition must be either wife or husband and the other party would be the other spouse. But once these proceedings are initiated by the concerned aggrieved spouse, the trial then proceeds further. It is of course true that pending such trial if either of the spouses expires then, as seen earlier, the personal cause of action against the husband or the wife, as the case may be, dies with the departing spouse. As no rights are still crystallized by then against or in favour of either spouse, no proprietary effect or any adverse effect on the status of the parties would get generated by mere filing of such petition and the status quo ante would continue to operate during the trial of such petition. However the situation gets changed once a decree of divorce follows in favour of either of the spouses whether such decree is bipartite or ex parte. Thereafter, as noted earlier, direct legal consequences affecting the status of parties as well as proprietary rights of either of them, as noted earlier, would flow from such a decree. Under these circumstances, if the aggrieved spouse who suffers from such legal effects of the adverse decree against him or her is told off the gates of the appellate proceedings or proceedings for setting aside such ex parte decree, the concerned spouse would suffer serious legal damage and injury without getting any opportunity to get such a decree set aside on legally permissible grounds. Consequently, it may be held that once the petition under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act results into any decree of divorce either ex parte or bipartite then the concerned aggrieved spouse who suffers from such pernicious legal effects can legitimately try to get them reversed through the assistance of the court. In such an exercise, all other legal heirs of deceased spouse who are interested in getting such a decree maintained can be joined as necessary parties. Section 13(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act can obviously come in the way of such proceedings being maintained against the legal heirs of the decree-holder spouse. A mere look at the ground of Section 13(1) will show that a Hindu marriage can be dissolved on the proof of matrimonial misconduct of very serious nature as mentioned in the concerned grounds, namely, that the offending spouse, after the solemnization of the marriage, has voluntary sexual intercourse with any person other than his or her spouse; or has treated the petitioner with cruelty; or has deserted the petitioner for a continuous period of not less than two years immediately preceding the presentation of the petition; or has ceased to be Hindu by conversion to another religion; or has been incurably of unsound mind, or has been suffering continuously or intermittently from mental disorder; or has been suffering from a virulent and incurable form of leprosy; or has been suffering from venereal disease in a communicable from; or has renounced the world by entering any religious order or has not been heard of as being alive for a period of seven years or more. These grounds of say the least, if found established, against the offending spouse would be serious matrimonial misconducts or incapability's and such a spouse will go with a stigma for the rest of his or her life which will have serious pernicious consequences only special but also legal, as we have noted earlier. If a decree of divorce on these grounds whether ex parte or bipartite is not permitted to be challenged by the aggrieved spouse, it would deprive the aggrieved spouse of an opportunity of getting such grounds re-examined by the competent court. It cannot, therefore, be said that after a decree of divorce is passed against a spouse whether ex parte or bipartite such aggrieved spouse cannot pi safer an appeal against such a decree or cannot move for getting ex parte divorce decree set aside under Order IX Rule 13 C.P.C. Such proceedings would not abate only because the petitioner who has obtained such decree dies after obtaining such a decree. The cause of action in such a case would survive qua the estate of the deceased spouse in the hands of his or her heirs or legal representatives. Consequently in such appellate proceedings or proceedings under Order IX Rule 13 C.P.C, other heirs of the deceased spouse could be joined as opposite parties as they would be interested in urging that the surviving spouse against whom such decree is passed remains a divorcee and is not treated to be a widow or widower of the deceased original petitioners so that she or he may not share with other heirs the property of deceased spouse. So far as the other heirs of the deceased spouse are concerned, they would certainly be interested in getting the decree of divorce confirmed by the appellate court or by the Trial Court by opposing application under Order IX Rule 13 C.P.C. if it is ex parte decree against the concerned spouse. It must, therefore, be held that when a divorce decree is challenged by the aggrieved spouse in proceedings whether by way of appeal or by way of application under Order IX Rule 13 C.P.C. for setting aside the ex prate decree of divorce, right to sue survives to the aggrieved surviving spouse if the other spouse having obtained such decree dies after the decree and before appeal is filed against the same by the aggrieved spouse or application is made under Order IX Rule 13 by the aggrieved spouse for getting such an ex parte decree of divorce set aside. Similarly, the right to sue would also survive even if the other spouse dies pending such appeal or application under Order IX Rule 13 C.P.C. In either case proceedings can be continued against the legal heirs of the deceased spouse who may be interested in supporting the decree of divorce passed against the aggrieved spouse.
 
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Civil Appeal No. 9852 of 1996.
Decided On: 08.10.1996

Smt. Yallawwa  Vs. Smt. Shantavva

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N.P. Singh and S.B. Majmudar, JJ.
Citation : AIR 1997 SC 35
Print Page

Saturday, 11 March 2017

Whether court should set aside exparte decree relying on affidavit without verifying factual position from record?

 Adverting to the impugned order, it would be noticed that the
learned Court has simply chosen to rely upon the contents of the application
only because the same was supported by the affidavit of the respondents.
Despite the factual aspects being disputed, it did not care to verify the factual
position from the records and proceeded to allow the application by
observing that expression sufficient cause should be construed to advance
substantial justice and the Court should not take strict and pedantic approach
and that the petitioner could conveniently be compensated by imposing cost
and then proceeded to award Rs.1,500/- as cost.
15. Obviously, learned trial Court has fallen in error in relying upon
the contents of the averment which were clearly belied by the documents
placed on record more particularly the summons that have been received
back after the service of respondents No.1 and 4. Therefore, the ultimate
award of costs would be no panacea in such cases, since the mischief
cannot be repaired. The order passed by the learned Court below is clearly
unsustainable and is therefore set aside.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA.
CMPMO No. 308 of 2016.

Date of decision : November 8th, 2016

Dinesh Kumar 
 V
Jyoti Prakash and others 
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Tarlok Singh Chauhan, Judge.
Citation:AIR 2017 HP26
Print Page

Thursday, 1 December 2016

Whether order of setting aside exparte decree is appealable?


Similarly, suppose the Trial Judge passes an
Order setting aside an exparte decree against the
defendant, which is not appealable under any of the
clauses of O. 43 R.1 though an order rejecting an
application to set aside the decree passed exparte falls6
within O. 43 R.l cl. (d) and is appealable, the serious
question that arises is whether or not the order first
mentioned is a judgment within the meaning of Letters
Patent. The fact, however, remains that the order
setting aside the ex-parte decree puts the defendant to
a great advantage and works serious injustice to the
plaintiff because as a consequence of the order, the
plaintiff has now to contest the suit and is deprived of
the fruits of the decree passed in his favour. In these
circumstances, therefore, the order passed by the Trial
Judge setting aside the ex parte decree vitally affects
the valuable rights of the plaintiff and hence amounts
to an interlocutory judgment and is therefore,
appealable to a larger Bench.”
 HIGH COURT OF ORISSA: CUTTACK.
 MATA NO.72 OF 2015


Gyanasis Jena V Smt.Rekha Swain 
 Date of Order : 08.09.2016

P R E S E N T:
 THE HONOURABLE SHRI JUSTICE B.K.NAYAK
A N D
 THE HONOURABLE SHRI JUSTICE K.R. MOHAPATRA
Citation:AIR 2016 Orissa 163
Print Page

Sunday, 16 October 2016

What are basic principles for setting aside exparte decree?

 In Vijay Kumar Madan and others v. R. N. Gupta

Technical Education Society and others, (2002 (5) SCC 30)

interpreting the provisions in Order IX Rule 7 of the CPC, the Apex Court

held that terms imposed by the court on the defendant assigning good



cause for previous non-appearance should not be too onerous or vague

nor should they have the effect of prejudging the controversy involved

and automatically decreeing the suit even though the ex parte order is set

aside. The Apex Court held further that, costs should be so assessed as

would reasonably compensate the plaintiff for the loss of time and

inconvenience caused by relegating back the proceedings to an earlier

stage. Paragraphs 7 and 8 of the judgment in Vijay Kumar Madan's

case (supra) read thus:

        "7. Power in the Court to impose costs and to put the

            defendant-applicant on terms is spelled out from the

            expression "Upon such terms as the Court directs as to

            costs or otherwise". It is settled with the decision of this

            Court in Arjun Singh vs. Mohinder Kumar and Ors., AIR

            1964 SC 993, that on an adjourned hearing, in spite of

            the Court having proceeded, ex parte earlier the

            defendant is entitled to appear and participate in the

            subsequent proceedings as of right. An application under

            Rule 7 is required to be made only if the defendant wishes

            the proceedings to be relegated back and re-open the

            proceedings from the date wherefrom they became ex

            parte so as to convert the ex parte hearings into bi-parte.

            While exercising power of putting the defendant on terms

            under Rule 7 the Court cannot pass an order which would

            have the effect of placing the defendant in a situation

            more worse off than what he would have been if he had

            not applied under Rule 7. So also the conditions for taking



            benefit of the order should not be such as would have the

            effect of decreeing the suit itself. Similarly, the Court may

            not in the garb of exercising power of placing upon terms

            make an order which probably the Court may not have

            made in the suit itself. As pointed out in the case of Arjun

            Singh (supra), the purpose of Rule 7 in its essence is to

            ensure the orderly conduct of the proceedings by

            penalizing improper dilatoriness calculated merely to

            prolong the litigation.

         8. Costs should be so assessed as would reasonably

            compensate the plaintiff for the loss of time and

            inconvenience caused by relegating back the proceedings

            to an earlier stage. The terms which the Court may direct

            may take care of the time or mode of proceedings

            required to be taken pursuant to the order under Rule 7.

            For example, keeping in view the conduct of the

            defendant-applicant, the Court may direct that though the

            ex-parte proceedings are being set aside, the defendant

            must file the written statement within an appointed time

            or recall for cross-examination at his own cost and

            expenses the witnesses examined in his absence or that

            the defendant shall be allowed not more than one

            opportunity of adducing his evidence and so on. How the

            terms are to be devised and made a part of the order

            would depend on the facts and circumstances of a given

            case. In short, the Court cannot exercise its power to put

            the defendant/applicant on such terms as may have the

            effect of pre-judging the controversy involved in the suit

            and virtually decreeing the suit though ex-parte order has

            been set aside or to put the parties on such terms as may


            be too onerous. .......... ........"

      16. On an application filed under Order IX Rule 13 of the

Code, the court has to find out whether the erring party has made

out sufficient cause for setting aside the ex parte decree. When no

negligence or inaction is imputable to the erring party and the

absence was not malafide or intentional, the discretion has to be

exercised in his favour, especially when the application is within the

statutory time limit.    In appropriate cases, the plaintiff can be

compensated by adequate costs for the loss of time and the

inconvenience caused to him. But any such condition shall not be

too onerous.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALAAT ERNAKULAM

                                                      PRESENT:

                          MR.JUSTICE P.N.RAVINDRAN
                                                            &
                        MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN

                         20TH DAY OF MARCH 2015

                         FAO.No. 187 of 2014 ()
                                                 

         M/S. PEEVES ENTERPRISES, 
Vs

            MUHAMMED ASHRAF
Print Page

Friday, 9 September 2016

When exparte decree can be set aside as per O 9 R 13 of CPC even if defendant has appeared in the suit?

From the aforesaid it is, therefore, clear that if the plaintiff was
called upon to lead evidence and he thereafter filed various documents on
record which came to be exhibited and after considering the same a decree
came to be passed in absence of defendant, the same was an exparte decree.
In the present case, the record indicates that the Court did not pass any
judgment on account of failure of the defendants to file written statement.
The case was kept for no written statement evidence after which plaintiff
initially amended the plaint, led his evidence and an opportunity was given

to the defendants to cross examine the plaintiff.   Hence, judgment passed
thereafter cannot be termed as a judgment delivered either under Order 8
Rule 5 or Order 8 Rule 10 of the Code.   Merely because the Small Causes
Court  had   observed  that  the  judgment   had  been  passed   without   written
statement, that would not mean that said observation can prevail even when
it is evident from the record that the judgment as passed was not under
Order VIII Rule 5 or Rule 10 of the Code.  Though the judgment has been
passed without the written statement on record, it is after calling upon the
plaintiff to lead evidence and prove his case.  Hence, ratio of the decision in
Jugalkishore   Kothari  (supra)   cannot   apply   in   the   aforesaid   facts.     The
application therefore moved by the defendants under Order IX Rule 13 of the
Code was perfectly tenable.  

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY NAGPUR BENCH
NAGPUR.
WRIT   PETITION  NO.    3802    OF     2013

Ashok Kundalrai Mohekar,V The National Textile Corporation
Ltd. 

CORAM:   A. S. CHANDURKAR  J.
                         

DATED: MARCH  12, 2015.
Citation:2016(4) ALLMR1 04
Print Page

Thursday, 4 August 2016

When exparte decree can be set aside?

It is well settled that when a decree of the Trial
Court  is  either confirmed, modified or  reversed  but  the
Appellate  decree, except when the decree is passed  without
notice to the parties, the Trial Court decree gets merged in
the appellate decree. But when the decree is passed  without
notice to a party, that decree will not, in law, be a decree
to which he is a party. Equally so in the case of an  appel-
late decree. In this case these two persons were not  served
in  the  suit. A decree was passed  ex-parte  against them
without  giving them notice of the suit. In law,  therefore,
there  is  no decree against them. In the appeal  also they
were  not  served. If they had been served  in the  appeal,
things would have been different. They could have put for-
ward their case in appeal and got appropriate orders passed.
But  that is not the case here. That being so, there  is  no
bar for an application by them before the Trial Court  under
Order IX, Rule 13, to set aside the ex-parte decree  against
them. [689G-H; 690A-B]
    There  is no error of law in allowing a joint decree  to
stand  against the person who contested  throughout  while
setting  aside the ex-parte decree  passed  against  others
without serving them personally on admitting the application
under Order IX Rule 13 C .P.C. [690C]

Supreme Court of India

Kewal Ram vs Smt. Ram Lubhai & Ors. And Vice ... on 26 March, 1987
Equivalent citations: 1987 AIR 1304, 1987 SCR (2) 685,(1987)2SCC344, 

BENCH:
KHALID, V. (J)
OZA, G.L. (J)

Print Page

Monday, 7 March 2016

When decree of trial court will not merge with decree of appellate court?

It is well settled that when a decree of the Trial
Court  is  either confirmed, modified or  reversed  but  the
Appellate  decree, except when the decree is passed  without
notice to the parties, the Trial Court decree gets merged in
the appellate decree. But when the decree is passed  without
notice to a party, that decree will not, in law, be a decree
to which he is a party. Equally so in the case of an  appel-
late decree. In this case these two persons were not  served
in  the  suit. A decree was passed  ex-parte  against them
without  giving them notice of the suit. In law,  therefore,
there  is  no decree against them. In the appeal  also they
were  not  served. If they had been served  in the  appeal,
things would have been different. They could have put for-
ward their case in appeal and got appropriate orders passed.
But  that is not the case here. That being so, there  is  no
bar for an application by them before the Trial Court  under
Order IX, Rule 13, to set aside the ex-parte decree  against
them. 
    There  is no error of law in allowing a joint decree  to
stand  against the person who contested  throughout  while
setting  aside the ex-parte decree  passed  against  others
without serving them personally on admitting the application
under Order IX Rule 13 C .P.C. [690C]

Supreme Court of India

Kewal Ram vs Smt. Ram Lubhai & Ors. And Vice ... on 26 March, 1987
Equivalent citations: 1987 AIR 1304, 1987 SCR (2) 685,(1987)2SCC344, 

BENCH:
KHALID, V. (J)
OZA, G.L. (J)
Print Page

Wednesday, 8 July 2015

Duty of court while deciding suit exparte or without written statement

 Even if the suit proceeds ex-parte and in the absence of a written statement, unless the applicability of Order VIII Rule 10 of the CPC is attracted and the Court acts thereunder, the necessity of proof by the plaintiff of his case to the satisfaction of the Court cannot be dispensed with. In the absence of denial of plaint averments the burden of proof on the plaintiff is not very heavy. A prima facie proof of the relevant facts constituting the cause of action would suffice and the Court would grant the plaintiff such relief as to which he may in law be found entitled. In a case which has proceeded ex-parte the Court is not bound to frame issues under Order XIV and deliver the judgment on every issue as required by Order XX Rule 5. Yet the Trial Court would scrutinize the available pleadings and documents, consider the evidence adduced, and would do well to frame the 'point for determination' and proceed to construct the ex-parte judgment dealing with the points at issue one by one. Merely because the defendant is absent the Court shall not admit evidence the admissibility whereof is excluded by law nor permit its decision being influenced by irrelevant or inadmissible evidence.
Supreme Court of India
Ramesh Chand Ardawatiya vs Anil Panjwani on 5 May, 2003
Equivalent citations: AIR 2003 SC 2508, 2003 (4) ALD 10 SC, 2003 (3) AWC 2511 SC, JT 2003 (4) SC 450, 2003 (4) MhLj 579, (2003) 3 MLJ 26 SC, (2003) 134 PLR 636, 2003 (4) SCALE 652, (2003) 7 SCC 350, 2003 3 SCR 1149, 2003 (2) UJ 1210 SC

Bench: R Lahoti, B Kumar

Read full judgment here; click here
Print Page