Showing posts with label minute book. Show all posts
Showing posts with label minute book. Show all posts

Saturday, 24 February 2018

Whether certified copy of resolution or extract of minutes book is admissible without proof of original?

Next comes the document No. 1 -the certified true copy of the resolution dated 16.2.2009, whereby the complainant company had allegedly resolved to give consent of the Board of Directors to execute power of attorney in favour of Ashwin Sheth, Managing Director and/or Sharad Doshi, Executive Assistant to the Managing Director to institute or defend any suit or criminal proceedings. The learned trial Court observed in the impugned order that there is no clear-cut provision about issuance of certified copy of extract of minutes book but if Sub-section (2) of Section 196 of the Companies Act is read, it may be stated that certified copy of the minutes can be given. The learned trial Court observed that the witness Sharad Doshi in his affidavit had deposed about the said document and thereby he has proved the genuineness of the document. Under Section 195 of the Companies Act, where minutes of the proceedings of any general meeting of the company have been kept in accordance with the provisions of Section 193, then, until the contrary is proved, the meeting shall be deemed to have been duly called and held, and all proceedings thereat to have duly taken place. Section 194 of the Companies Act provides that the minutes of meetings kept in accordance with the provisions of Section 193 shall be evidence of the proceedings recorded therein. However, no provision in the Companies Act is brought to my notice which provides that the certified copy or extract of the minutes would be admissible in evidence without proof of the original. Section 65(f) of the Evidence Act provides that secondary evidence may be given of the existence, condition and contents of the document when the original is the document of which a certified copy is permitted by the Evidence Act or by any other law in force in India to be given in evidence. As no provision from the Companies Act is brought to my notice under which the certified copy of the minutes of the meetings of the board of directors is admissible in evidence without proof of the original, it must be said that the copy of the minutes cannot be admitted in evidence directly unless the original is proved or the copy is admitted by opposite party. Therefore, even though that document is given exhibit number, it cannot be treated to have been proved, unless the complainant leads appropriate evidence to prove the minutes.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Writ Petition No. 40 of 2011

Decided On: 16.03.2011

Ashish C. Shah Vs. Sheth Developers Pvt. Ltd., 

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
J.H. Bhatia, J.
Citation: 2011(4) MHLJ 288
Print Page

Sunday, 17 September 2017

How to prove resolution passed by board of directors of company?

Sec. 193(1A)(a) of Company Act makes it clear that each page of the minute book is to be initialed or signed and the last page of the record of proceedings of each meeting in such book is to be dated and signed in case of minutes or proceedings of a meeting of Board or of a committee thereof, by the chairman of the said meeting or the chairman of the next succeeding meeting. Ld. counsel for the plaintiff has tried to make mountain out of a mole hill in view of the photostat copy Ex. DW 1/1 (mark A) of the resolution dated 9.3.1999 i.e. the 83rd resolution. In this document (mark A) Ex. DW 1/1 Ajay Chaudhary was mentioned as the chairman. Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff wanted to take this particular fact to be sufficient to conclude that this resolution was fabricated as Shiv Nadar was not present on 9.3.99 and he had later on signed the same. It is not in dispute that Shiv Nadar was the chairman of the company. Therefore in view of Sec. 193(1A)(a) Companies Act he had signed the 83rd resolution at the time of the meeting dated 20.4.99 on which date 84th meeting of the board of director had been convened. The photostat copy of the 84th meeting of Board of Directors shows that it was attended by Shiv Nadar. Therefore, in view of Sec. 193(1A)(a) of Companies Act, he was entitled to sign the minutes of the 83rd meeting. Thus, there is no material to hold that the minute book had been fabricated later on. The original minute book had been produced at the time of recording of statement of G.P. Kalra DW 1. The evidence had been recorded by my ld. predecessor. When the defendants were directed to produce the photostat copy of the minute book containing the entries of 83rd and 84th meeting, the same had been produced before on 13.12.2003. I had also perused the original minute book containing the minutes of 83rd and 84th meeting. The minute book appeared to be properly maintained in accordance with Sec. 193 of Companies Act and there did not appear anything to raise suspicion.
The judgment relied upon in the case of Amal Kumar Mukherjee (supra) with respect to the argument that the minute book of a company ought to be bound and written in hand, is to be read in the context of the facts of the said case wherein there were disputes inter se shareholders of a company and in such circumstances, the issue had arisen with respect to manipulation of the minute book of the company. In the present case, there is no dispute inter se shareholders or inter se Directors of the Board of the company and therefore the judgment in the case of Amal Kumar Mukherjee (supra) will have no application to the facts of the present case, especially for the reasons stated above that there is no subsequent resolution of the Board of Directors or any resolution in the General Body meeting of defendant No. 1/respondent No. 1-company questioning or rescinding the termination of services of the appellant - Sh. Pawan Kumar Dalmia.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

RFA Nos. 180/2004 and 235/2004

Decided On: 13.03.2012

Pawan Kumar Dalmia Vs. M/s. HCL Infosystems Ltd. & Ors.


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Valmiki J. Mehta
Print Page

Thursday, 14 November 2013

Bombay HC: At what stage of proceeding, Waiver of objection regarding admissibility of copy of document becomes irreversible


The judgment of Full Bench of this Court in the case of Mr. Hemendra Rasiklal Ghia .vrs. Subodh Mody (supra), has considered the judgment in case of Dayamanthibai .vrs. K.M. Shafi (2007 (4) SCC 107). In subsequent judgment reported at 2009 [10] SCC 239 (P.C. Thomas .vrs. P.M. Ismail and others) the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that once no objection to such document on plea either of inadmissibility or mode of proof, is raised at the time of exhibiting that document, or then during trial, such objection cannot be raised belatedly. It is therefore, obvious that opportunity to make amends or to rectify the procedural error was available to plaintiff [respondent no.1 herein] during trial. Had petitioner raised present objection then, plaintiff could have proved the resolution by producing the original proceeding book & tendering appropriate evidence. That opportunity is now lost to plaintiff and hence such 
an objection cannot be allowed to be raised thereafter. Waiver of that objection has now become irreversible.

Bombay High Court
M/S. Mohanlal Kisanlal Agrawal vs Shri Ajitnath Jain Shetambar ... on 5 January, 2011
Bench: B. P. Dharmadhikari
Citation; 2011 (2)MH L J 512

Print Page