Showing posts with label exhibition of documents. Show all posts
Showing posts with label exhibition of documents. Show all posts

Friday, 25 September 2026

P & H High court: The presence of doctors or the chemists for proving medicine bills must be confined only to extraordinary situations where the documents themselves are seriously in doubt.

 The practice of merely marking them but not exhibiting them in evidence and looking for proof by examination of a chemist is quite a needless exercise. The Tribunals must be more pragmatic in their approach while dealing with the cases for motor accident victims and invoke the power which is vested in them under Sections 168 and 169 in such a fashion that they do not shackle themselves by unrealistic procedures to meet the ends of justice/Unless the bills seem fabricated or there is something very peculiar elicited at the trial to doubt genuineness of the bills, the Tribunal dealing with the motor accident cases ought not to be looking for evidence through a chemist who had issued the bills. The production of the bills relating to the purchase of medicines during the period of hospitalization and oral evidence given by the party about purchasing of medicines ought to be taken as sufficient proof of authentication and admissibility of these documents. {Para 2}

3. Similarly, the practice of summoning doctors even for merely marking the MLR reports must be stopped. It must be remembered that the procedure under the M.V. Act is summary in character and documents which are maintained in the Government hospitals in the regular course of business require no more proof and a mere copy produced at the trial shall be received as public documents satisfying the requirements under Section 76 of the Indian Evidence Act. The summoning of the documents from lawful custody or copy of the document duly authenticated by the seal of the hospital which has issued the MLR must themselves be taken as sufficient proof for the same and the procedures that go to prolong the proceedings or delay them must be immediately curtailed by the Tribunals.

4. Even as regards the examination of doctors, it should be confined only to securing appropriate proof of disability and in special circumstances where there is a prolonged treatment or a requirement for a continuous treatment even beyond the period of trial, the attempt of the Tribunal must be to elicit from the doctors the prognosis for cure and the likely expenses that may have to be incurred in future. With a view to devise a procedure adopted in the manner of assigning dates for doctors and the need to save time for professionals like doctors, they must stay confined to what are most essential features to assist the Court to understand the nature of injuries and assess disability, if any to the claimant. They shall not be merely called to Courts for exhibiting some documents like MLR, period of treatment, etc. A hospital document produced by a party which is duly authenticated must be taken as sufficient as proof of the documents themselves and the requirement to produce the doctor for mere production of hospital documents must be immediately given up.

5. Some directions as regards the procedure become necessary only because it is a recurrent theme in our Tribunals that they reject the medical bills or keep out of reckoning the hospital records only because either the chemist is not examined or the doctor is not before the Court to speak about the hospital records. The presence of doctors or the chemists must be confined only to extraordinary situations where the documents themselves are seriously in doubt.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

F.A.O. No. 12 of 1994 (O&M)

Decided On: 09.02.2012

Parsanni Vs. Sube Singh and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

K. Kannan, J.

Citation: 2011 SCC ONLINE P&H 2510,MANU/PH/4065/2012
Print Page

Saturday, 5 September 2026

Supreme Court: The contents of the documents which have been marked/exhibited will have to be proved in accordance with law

Therefore, in the instant case, the contents of the documents which have been marked/exhibited will have to be proved in accordance with law. We find no reason to eschew them, at this stage. {Para 12} 

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 10200 of 2026.

Decided On: 07.08.2026

S. Sangeetha and Ors. Vs. P. Ponni

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sanjay Karol and N. Kotiswar Singh, JJ.

Author: Sanjay Karol, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0825/2026.

Print Page

Sunday, 9 August 2026

Supreme Court: Mere Marking Of Document As Exhibit Is Not Proof Of Contents

 It is also settled law that mere marking of a document as an exhibit, is not a proof of the contents thereof. A Division Bench of this Court in LIC v. Ram Pal Singh Bisen2 had observed:{Para 11}

“25. We are of the firm opinion that mere admission of a document in evidence does not amount to its proof. In other words, mere marking of exhibit on a document does not dispense with its proof, which is requiredto be done in accordance with law.

31. Under the law of evidence also, it is necessary that contents of documents are required to be proved either by primary or by secondary evidence. At the most, admission of documents may amount to admission of contents but not its truth. Documents having not been produced and marked as required under the Evidence Act cannot be relied upon by the court. Contents of the document cannot be proved by merely filing in a court.”

NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026

S. SANGEETHA & ORS Vs  TMT. P. PONNI 

Author: SANJAY KAROL, J.

Dated: August 07, 2026

Citation: 2026 INSC 813

Print Page

Wednesday, 27 May 2026

Supreme Court: Whether accused Can ask the court to Exhibit Documents as per S.294 CrPC already Part Of Chargesheet Without Formal Proof Of Signature?

6) In the facts of the present case, it is clear

that the documents as sought to be marked as

exhibits by the appellant are part of the

chargesheet and of documents produced by the

prosecution. The appellant, through averments made

in the application, contends that these documents

were included in the list of documents of

prosecution. Learned Additional Solicitor General,

appearing for the CBI, disputes this fact, but on

prima facie examination of the record, it suggests

that the documents sought by accused formed part of

the list of documents produced by CBI. Nevertheless,

we reserve the CBI’s liberty to raise this objection

at the appropriate stage before court.

7) We have further perused the findings as

recorded by the High Court relying upon the judgment

in State of Punjab Vs Naib Din (2001) 8 SCC 578. The said judgment deals with the provisions of Section 296 Cr.P.C.

which relates to the evidence of formal character on

affidavit; it has nothing to do with the case

wherein no formal proof of certain documents are

required. It is needless to express that Section 294

Cr.P.C. deals with documentary evidence while

Section 296 Cr.P.C. deals with the formal character

of some evidence which is on affidavit. Therefore,

the ratio of the judgment in the case of Naib Din

(supra) is, in fact, not applicable, in particular,

while rejecting the application under Section 294

Cr.P.C. it is the duty of the Court to uphold the

spirit of the provision, particularly with regard to

the documents for which the application has been

filed. The order has to be passed after ascertaining

the genuineness of such document by admission or

denial or by proof, if any required.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. OF 2026

R. GANESH Vsv THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU 

Dated: April 27, 2026.

Print Page

Sunday, 10 May 2026

Supreme Court: Whether the court can permit Accused to Exhibit Documents as per S.294 CrPC, Already Part Of Chargesheet Without Formal Proof Of Signature?

 In order to duly appreciate the provisions of

Section 294 Cr.P.C., it is necessary to refer to the

provision which is reproduced as under:

“294. No formal proof of certain

documents.—(1) Where any document is

filed before any Court by the

prosecution or the accused, the

particulars of every such document

shall be included in a list and the

prosecution or the accused, as the case

may be, or the pleader for the

prosecution or the accused, if any,

shall be called upon to admit or deny

the genuineness of each such document.

(2) The list of documents shall be in

such form as be prescribed by the State

Government.

(3) Where the genuineness of any

document is not disputed, such document

may be read in evidence in inquiry,

trial or other proceeding under this

Code without proof of the signature of

the person to whom it purports to be

signed:

Provided that the Court may, in its

discretion, require such signature to

be proved.”{Para 4}

5) After perusal thereof, it cannot be doubted

that in case any document has been filed by the

prosecution or the accused in any Court, such

document is required to be included in a list. The

genuineness of the documents included in the list

can be ascertained by the Court by calling upon the

prosecution or the accused, as the case may be. If

such document is not disputed, it can be read in

inquiry, trial or other proceedings under Cr.P.C.

without proving the signature of the person to whom

it purports to be. As per proviso thereto, if

necessary, it is on the discretion of the Court to

require such signature to be proved, while applying

the provision of Section 294 (3) Cr.P.C.

6) In the facts of the present case, it is clear

that the documents as sought to be marked as

exhibits by the appellant are part of the

chargesheet and of documents produced by the

prosecution. The appellant, through averments made

in the application, contends that these documents

were included in the list of documents of

prosecution. Learned Additional Solicitor General,

appearing for the CBI, disputes this fact, but on

prima facie examination of the record, it suggests

that the documents sought by accused formed part of

the list of documents produced by CBI. Nevertheless,

we reserve the CBI’s liberty to raise this objection

at the appropriate stage before court.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. OF 2026

(Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 1383 of 2026)

R. GANESH Vs THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU 

Dated: April 27, 2026.

Print Page

Sunday, 30 March 2025

Bombay HC: Whether the court can decree suit for Specific performance of contract even if there are procedural irregularities regarding admissibility of documents

  • The Bombay High Court upheld a decree for specific performance despite procedural irregularities in evidence admission at the trial court level. The court concluded that even if certain documents were excluded, sufficient evidence supported granting specific performance based on the agreement's existence and fulfillment of obligations by the plaintiff.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

First Appeal No. 1841 of 2024

Decided On: 21.02.2025

Yasin Khan and Ors. Vs. Ajit Developers Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sharmila U. Deshmukh, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/1001/2025,2025:BHC-AS:8423

Print Page

Sunday, 15 September 2024

Supreme Court grants Compensation rupees 3,00,000/- for Loss of marriage prospects in motor accident claim petition

 Loss of marriage prospects

28. The Tribunal has awarded Rs. 3,00,000/- for loss of marriage prospects. We see no reason to interfere with this finding.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 735 of 2020.

Decided On: 05.02.2020

Kajal Vs. Jagdish Chand and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

L. Nageswara Rao and Deepak Gupta, JJ.

Author: Deepak Gupta, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0126/2020,(2020) 4 SCC 413.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Saturday, 14 September 2024

Supreme Court: The strict compliance applicable to the suits and other proceedings not required in motor accident claim petition

 At the outset, we may reiterate as has been consistently said by this Court in a series of cases that the Act is a beneficial piece of legislation enacted to give solace to the victims of the motor accident who suffer bodily injury or die untimely. The Act is designed in a manner, which relieves the victims from ensuring strict compliance provided in law, which are otherwise applicable to the suits and other proceedings while prosecuting the claim petition filed under the Act for claiming compensation for the loss sustained by them in the accident. {Para 16}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 11042 of 2018.

Decided On: 16.11.2018

Vimla Devi and Ors. Vs. National Insurance Company Limited and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Manohar Sapre and Indu Malhotra, JJ.

Author: Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/1290/2018,(2019) 2 SCC 186.
Read full Judgment here: Click here.
Print Page

Supreme Court: Motor accident claim tribunal can not dismiss a claim petition if claimant has produced all relevant documents even though those were not exhibited

The Appellants along with their claim petition filed all those documents, which were filed by the State in the criminal proceedings against the driver, such as FIR, charge sheet, site plan, post mortem report of the deceased, registration of Truck No. HR-A-7729, insurance coverage, mechanical inspection report, copy of notice issued to the owner Under Section 133 of the Act etc. {Para 8}

10. The claimants examined three witnesses in support of their case. The Insurance Company did not examine any witness. By award dated 05.12.2005, the Tribunal dismissed the Appellants' claim petition. It was held that the claimants failed to prove the accident including involvement of offending Truck, which caused death of Rajendra Prasad. It was held that though the claimants filed the documents but since those documents were not exhibited, the Insurance Company could not cross-examine the claimants' witnesses on the documents. In short, the Tribunal held that the claimants failed to prove the accident for want of evidence and the one adduced was not exhibited and hence was of no use. These were basically the two findings on which the claim petition was dismissed.

33. Seventh, if the Court did not exhibit the documents despite the Appellants referring them at the time of recording evidence then in such event, the Appellants cannot be denied of their right to claim the compensation on such ground. In our opinion, it was nothing but a procedural lapse, which could not be made basis to reject the claim petition. It was more so when the Appellants adduced oral and documentary evidence to prove their case and the Respondents did nothing to counter them.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 11042 of 2018.

Decided On: 16.11.2018

Vimla Devi and Ors. Vs. National Insurance Company Limited and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Manohar Sapre and Indu Malhotra, JJ.

Author: Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/1290/2018,(2019) 2 SCC 186.
Print Page

Tuesday, 3 September 2024

Supreme Court: Motor accident claim tribunal can exhibit medicine bill even if name of the patient was not written on the bill

One must remember that amongst people who were not Government employees and belong to the poorer strata of society, bills were not retained. Some of the bills had been excluded by the courts below only on the ground that the name of the patient was not written on the bill. There was no dispute with regard to the long period of treatment and hospitalisation of this young girl. Immediately after the accident, she was admitted at a hospital. From there, she was referred to the other hospital, where she remained admitted and, thereafter, she was again admitted in the hospital. She was in the hospital for almost fifty one days, and both doctor had supported this. Limiting the amount only to the bills which have been paid in the name of the claimant only, would not be reasonable.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 735 of 2020.

Decided On: 05.02.2020

Kajal Vs. Jagdish Chand and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

L. Nageswara Rao and Deepak Gupta, JJ.

Author: Deepak Gupta, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0126/2020,(2020) 4 SCC 413.

Print Page

Bombay HC: Motor accident claim tribunal can exhibit medicine bills and vouchers in absence of the specific case made out that the documents were fabricated.

Lot of expenditure must have been incurred on travelling and residence of the relatives and friends of the appellant. The bills evidencing expenditure on medicines, medical treatment, special diet, travelling expenses and residence of the relatives and friends of the appellant have been produced on record. There are four lists of documents marked as 85/1 to 85/4. Along with the said four lists, voluminous original documents such as bills, vouchers etc. have been produced on record. As expected, none of the documents were admitted by the respondent No. 3. Perhaps the respondent No. 3 wanted that large number of witnesses should be examined to prove the documents. In the examination-in-chief, the appellant has made a reference to all the bills and vouchers. The Tribunal constituted under the said Act is not bound by strict rules of evidence. Therefore, the said bills and vouchers ought to have been taken into consideration by the Tribunal in absence of the specific case made out that the documents were fabricated.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

F.A. No. 717 of 1999

Decided On: 08.08.2011

Dattatraya Laxman Shinde Vs. Nana Raghunath Hire and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Shreeniwas Oka, J.

Citation: 2011 (4) TAC 367 (Bom), MANU/MH/1265/2011.

Print Page

Bombay HC: In Motor accident claim petition it is not necessary to summon the owners of the medical shops to prove the bills

However, the Appellant is relying upon a large number of bills of medicines and other items which are produced on record. The Learned Member of the Tribunal has taken a technical view of the matter by holding that the Appellant has not proved the said bills. Considering the nature of injuries sustained by the Appellant, it was not expected of the Appellant to maintain account in minute details of the amounts spent on the purchase of medicines and other equipments. It is impossible to expect the Appellant to summon the owners of the medical shops to prove the bills. According to the case of the Appellant, the bills produced on record show that total amount spent by him in that behalf is Rs. 44,483.32 ps. Hence, a sum of Rs. 45,000/- can be straightway granted on the said count.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

First Appeal No. 169 of 2009

Decided On: 07.03.2013

Farooq Mohammad Gaouse Vs. The Transport Manager

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Shreeniwas Oka and A.P. Bhangale, JJ.

Citation: 2013(2) TAC 404 Bom, MANU/MH/0217/2013.

Print Page

Sunday, 26 February 2023

Whether certified copy of sale deed is deemed to be proved if it is exhibited without objection from other side?

 But, here, the question is, whether the plaintiffs have been able to prove the contents and execution of the sale deed they adduced as evidence. The scribe of the sale deed was produced by the plaintiffs who deposed as PW.3. During his cross-examination, PW.3 admitted that he did not know Asrab Ali, the vendor of the sale deed in question or his hand writing or signature and he also could not say whether original Asrab Ali executed the sale deed before the Sub-Registrar. Furthermore, the case of the defendant/respondents is total denial of the facts and circumstances of execution of the sale deed.  {Para 13}

14. Clause (b) of Section 65 of the Evidence Act contemplates that secondary evidence may be given of the existence, condition or contents of a document when the existence, conditions or contents of the original have been proved to be admitted in writing by the person against whom it is proved or by his representative.

15. In the instant case, the existence, conditions or contents of the original sale deed have not been admitted in writing by the defendants against whom the plaintiffs wanted to prove it. However, considering the law that certified copy of a registered deed may be the proof of the contents of the original deed, the contents of the sale deed (Ext.3 series) may be admissible in evidence since objection to the contents was not raised by the defendants. Applying the principle as laid down in Dayamathi Bai (supra), in the opinion of this Court, there cannot be any disagreement in the said proposition of law that admissibility of a document in the form of secondary evidence cannot be questioned if objection is not raised by the opposite party when the document is introduced and taken into evidence and marked as exhibit. 16. Here, however, the principal question hinges upon whether the execution of the sale deed (Ext.3 series) is proved or not, keeping in view the findings of the Courts below as regards admissibility of sale deed in evidence.

17. According to this Court, a certified copy is secondary evidence under Section 63 of the Evidence Act which acknowledges/recognizes the existence, conditions and contents of the deed, but not of its execution. This Court does not find any mention that secondary evidence itself is the proof of the execution of the deed. Added to it, execution of document means the last act or series of acts which complete the document. It does not mean merely signing it. In other words, execution means all acts necessary to make the parties to the contract bound thereby. In furtherance thereof, it should be accompanied by the intention to give effect to the document in question. 

18. In the context of the present case, it is re-iterated at the cost of repetition that execution of the sale deed by Asrab Ali i.e. vendor of the sale deed (Ext.3 series) has not been proved since PW.3 admitted that he did not know Asrab Ali or his handwriting or signature and he also could not say whether original Asrab Ali executed the sale deed before the Sub-Registrar.

19. In this situation, according to this Court, in the present case, it is apparent that execution of the sale deed (Ext.3 series) has not been proved being not accompanied by the intention of the executant (Asrab Ali, the vendor) to give effect to the said sale deed, Ext.3 series in question, when it is the specific pleaded case of the defendants/respondents that Late Asrab Ali had never intended to sell the suit land and the alleged sale deed (Ext.3 series) was simultaneously accompanied by a deed of re-conveyance, which, in reality was a deed of mortgage. Therefore, in the context of the case, the attending circumstances of the execution of sale deed (Ext.3 series) ought to have been necessarily proved by the plaintiffs, which they failed to discharge by leading other evidence recognized by law of evidence.

HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA AGARTALA

 RSA No.52 of 2022

Smti. Rubia Bibi  W/o Alfat Ali, Vs Md. Mati Miah

 Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH 

Dated : 08.02.2023 

Print Page

Friday, 1 May 2020

Whether the court should exhibit gift deed (Hiba ) executed by muslim person even if it is not registered?

Under the provisions of Section 149 of the Mullas Principles of Mohammedan Law, there are only three essential conditions of a valid gift and those are 1] declaration of gift by the donor, 2] an acceptance of the gift, express or implied, by or on behalf of the donee and 3] delivery of possession of the subject of the gift by the donor to the donee. . It is stated in Section 150 that if these conditions are complied with, the gift is complete. In fact, Sub-section 3 of the Section 150 provides that if it is proved by oral evidence that gift was complete as required by law, it is immaterial that the donor has also executed the deed of gift, but the deed had not been registered as required by the Registration Act, Section 17(a). Thus in view of the provisions of Section 150(3) of the Mullas Principles of Mohamedan Law, it is clear that a gift made by the Mohamedan donor in writing is not compulsorily registrable. The trial court ought to have exhibited the document dated 11.4.1966 in the facts and circumstances of the case.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 1843/2009

Decided On: 10.11.2009

 Abdul Rahim Vs. Qayyum and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
V.A. Naik, J.

Citation: 2010(1) ALLMR 328,2010(1) MHLJ 343,
Print Page

Thursday, 26 March 2020

Whether a party can take objection to the admissibility of a document in the appeal if said document was exhibited without objection in the trial court?

 To the same effect is the judgment of the Privy Council in the case of Gopal Das & Anr. v. Sri Thakurji & Ors. reported in MANU/PR/0002/1943 in which it has been held that when the objection to the mode of proof is not taken, the party cannot lie by until the case comes before a Court of appeal and then complain for the first time of the mode of proof. That when the objection to be taken is not that the document is in itself inadmissible but that the mode of proof was irregular, it is essential that the objection should be taken at the trial before the document is marked as an exhibit and admitted to the record. Similarly, in Sarkar on Evidence, 15th Edition, page 1084, it has been stated that where copies of the documents are admitted without objection in the trial Court, no objection to their admissibility can be taken afterwards in the court of appeal. When a party gives in evidence a certified copy, without proving the circumstances entitling him to give secondary evidence, objection must be taken at the time of admission and such objection will not be allowed at a later stage.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 2434 of 2000

Decided On: 04.08.2004

Dayamathi Bai Vs. K.M. Shaffi

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Ashok Bhan and S.H. Kapadia, JJ.

Citation: (2004) 7 SCC 107:AIR 2004 SC 4082
Print Page

Wednesday, 30 October 2019

Whether insufficiently stamped document can be impounded even after it is exhibited?

A reference to sections 35 and 58 of the Stamp Act shows that section 35 only gives finality to the decision in regard to the admissibility of the document in evidence. It does not operate as a bar to impounding of the same. Order impounding document confirmed."

24. It appears to me that the same course was liable to be adopted in the present matter also. It appears that the Trial Court failed in appreciating and understanding the object of Section 33 of the Stamp Act. The object of this Section is to safeguard the revenue. As has been held by this Court in the aforesaid Judgment, Section 35 of the Stamp Act only gives finality to the decision in regard to the admissibility of the said document in evidence, it however does not operate as a bar for impounding of the said document. The Trial Court in the impugned order has observed that filing of an application by the present petitioner for impounding of document in question was only with the intention to protract the trial. If that be so, the Trial Court could have taken appropriate care in that regard also. There was no impediment to forward the original document to the Collector to impound the same by keeping on record the attested or certified copy of the document in question. It need not be stated that the Trial Court may not be required to wait for the decision of the Collector on the issue of impounding and can very well proceed further with the trial of the Suit. Since the agreement of sale dated 04.05.2009 has been admitted in the evidence, it would not be open for the present petitioner to call in question such admission at any stage of the Suit or proceeding on the ground that it has not been duly stamped.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 2810 of 2019

Decided On: 29.04.2019

 Priya  Vs.  Parushuram Printers and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
P.R. Bora, J.

Citation: 2019(5) MHLJ 678
Print Page

Thursday, 10 October 2019

Mere production of police papers and exhibiting those documents does not dispense the proof of contents of those documents

As regards the evidence in the form of police papers is concerned, in Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Sangita Dattatraya Jamdade & others null [MANU/MH/1406/2004 : 2006 ACJ 971], this Court has held that the certified copies of FIR, panchanama and medical papers prepared by public servants in discharge of their public duty are admissible in evidence. However, the Division Bench of this Court at Goa Bench in Pukh Raj Bumb Vs. Jagannath Achut Naik & others [First Appeal No. 32 of 2013, decided on 11-07-2013] has held that mere production of police papers and exhibiting those documents does not dispense the proof of contents of those documents. The Division Bench of this Court went further and observed that merely on the basis of certified copies of FIR, spot panchanama and other documents, the claimants cannot prove their case. Therefore, it can be concluded that though police papers are required to be exhibited and the provisions of Evidence Act are not strictly applicable, yet, that does not dispenses the claimants from proving the manner in which the accident had taken place and the point of negligence. If the claimants want to agitate negligence and rashness in respect of a particular party, then mere production of those documents will not absolve them, unless the situation on the basis of spot panchanama allows the Tribunal to draw the principles of res ipsa loquitur.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

First Appeal No. 02757 of 2017 and Cross Objection Stamp No. 10801 of 2019 in First Appeal No. 02757 of 2017

Decided On: 26.09.2019

Shriram General Insurance Company Limited  Vs.   Chandrakala Atmaram Mohite 

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Vibha Kankanwadi, J.

Print Page

Sunday, 28 July 2019

Whether court can direct impounding of document even though it is exhibited?

It appears to me that the same course was liable to be adopted in the present matter also. It appears that the Trial Court failed in appreciating and understanding the object of Section 33 of the Stamp Act. The object of this Section is to safeguard the revenue. As has been held by this Court in the aforesaid Judgment, Section 35 of the Stamp Act only gives finality to the decision in regard to the admissibility of the said document in evidence, it however does not operate as a bar for impounding of the said document. The Trial Court in the impugned order has observed that filing of an application by the present petitioner for impounding of document in question was only with the intention to protract the trial. If that be so, the Trial Court could have taken appropriate care in that regard also. There was no impediment to forward the original document to the Collector to impound the same by keeping on record the attested or certified copy of the document in question. It need not be stated that the Trial Court may not be required to wait for the decision of the Collector on the issue of impounding and can very well proceed further with the trial of the Suit. Since the agreement of sale dated 04.05.2009 has been admitted in the evidence, it would not be open for the present petitioner to call in question such admission at any stage of the Suit or proceeding on the ground that it has not been duly stamped.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 2810 of 2019

Decided On: 29.04.2019

 Priya Vs. Parushuram Printers and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
P.R. Bora, J.

Print Page

Thursday, 4 July 2019

Whether any document can be exhibited if its maker has admitted his signature even if contents of document is not proved?

In the case of Mrs. Cynthia Martin Wd/o A.V. Martin v/s. Prembehari s/o. Makhanlal Yadu & Another reported in MANU/MH/0074/1998 : 1998 (1) Bom. C.R. 631, it is observed in paragraph 12 that:-

By the said letter, it was informed by the competent authority that the house was not situated in the slum area. Shri De submitted that the only witness, who has been examined, has not been able to give any details regarding the said letter and mere proof of the signature would not amount to the proof of the contents of the letter. It is true that mere proof of the signature could not prove the contents of the letter. However, that is not a case here. The letter is clear enough, and once the letter is proved by proving the signature of the maker thereof, there would hardly be any reason to doubt the same regarding the veracity of the contents therein.
24. In the case of Grasim Industries Limited (supra), following observation made in paragraph 6:-

In our opinion, when a person signs a document, there is a presumption, unless there is proof of force or fraud, that he has read the document properly and understood it and only then he has affixed his signatures thereon, otherwise no signature on a document can ever be accepted.

... Hence, it is difficult to accept the contention of the respondent while admitting that the document, Ext. D-8 bears his signatures that it was signed under some mistake.

25. In the case of Byramjee Jeejeebhoy Private Limited (supra), the following observation was made:-

The learned trial Judge curiously declined to exhibit the document and marked it for identification s Ex. X/6 on the ground that even if the signature of the vendor on the document is proved, unless the contents are proved, the document cannot be admitted. We are afraid we cannot share the view of the learned trial Judge. The document stands proved as soon as the fact of execution is proved and it is wholly irrelevant whether the contents are proved.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 3190 of 2011 with Civil Application No. 956 of 2011

Decided On: 14.11.2011

Dinesh Vasantrai Bhuta  Vs.  Vasantben Harvilas Jani

Print Page

Tuesday, 18 June 2019

Whether any document can be challenged after it is exhibited?

On a document being exhibited, the party against it is being brought on record, is entitled to question it on the ground of it being inadmissible. What is not open to question is the mode of proof put forward that it was irregular or insufficient. I find support from the decision of a Privy Council judgment reported in Gopal Das v. Sri Thakurji, AIR (30) 1943 PC 83.

Rajasthan High Court
Prabhu Dayal vs Suwa Lal And Anr. on 20 August, 1993
Equivalent citations: AIR 1994 Raj 149, 1994 (1) WLC 620

Bench: K Agrawal

Print Page