Showing posts with label obscene words. Show all posts
Showing posts with label obscene words. Show all posts

Sunday, 15 March 2020

Whether sending the personal messages on WhatsApp will amount to the utterance of obscene words in a public place?

Thus, the literature published on Website clearly indicates
that the WhatsApp messages sent by one person to another are end-toend
encrypted which means, only the sender of the message and the
recipient of the message can read the messages. It also claims that
nobody in between, not even WhatsApp, can read these messages.
These messages are secured with lock and only the recipient and
sender have special key needed to unlock and read them. It further

claims that every message sent has its own unique lock and key. It
also claims that the WhatsApp does not store the messages on server,
once they are delivered. Thus, this literature available on the Website
of the WhatsApp, makes it abundantly clearly that such types of
messages are strictly personal messages and nobody even the
WhatsApp can have access to these messages which means nobody
except the sender and the recipient can read the messages. Thus,
when these messages cannot be read by others, it ipso-facto goes to
show that no third person nor even WhatsApp can have access to those
messages. Therefore, WhatsApp cannot be a public place if messages
are exchanged on personal accounts of two persons. If these messages
had been posted on WhatsApp Group, in that case the same could
have been called as public place because all the members of the
group, will have access to those messages. It is not the prosecution
case that the alleged obscene messages were posted on WhatsApp
Group of which the petitioner and the respondent No. 2 and others are
the members. Therefore, sending the personal messages on WhatsApp
will not amount to utterance of obscene words in public place.
Therefore, Section 294 of the I.P.C. cannot be invoked.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 557 OF 2018

Nivrutti  Hariram Gaikwad, Vs The State of Maharashtra,

CORAM : T.V. NALAWADE &
M.G. SEWLIKAR, JJ.

Dated : 11.03.2020

JUDGMENT : [PER : M.G. SEWLIKAR, J.]
Print Page

Thursday, 6 April 2017

Whether offence U/S 509 of IPC is made out against accused even if obscene words are not heard by victim?

Learned   counsel   for   the   appellant   was   at   pains   to
argue that, as PW2 Priyanka Raorane had not heard the obscene
remark hurled at her by the accused, the accused is not liable for
conviction for the offence punishable under Section 509 of the
IPC,   and   at   the   most,   he   can   be   convicted   for   the   offence

punishable under Section 294 of the IPC.  Section 509 of the IPC
reads thus :
509. Word, gesture or act intended to insult
the   modesty   of   a   woman  —   Whoever,
intending to insult the modesty of any woman,
utters any word, makes any sound or gesture,
or   exhibits   any   object,   intending   that   such
word  or sound  shall  be  heard,  or that  such
gesture or object shall be seen, by such woman,
or intrudes upon the privacy of such woman,
shall   be   punished   with   simple   imprisonment
for a term which may extend to one year, or
with fine, or with both.
Evidence of PW1 Akshay establishes what were utterances of the
accused addressed to PW2 Priyanka Raorane, though she might
not have heard the same.  At the cost of repetition, it needs to be
put   on   record   that,   the   accused,   upon   seeing   PW2   Priyanka
Raorane, uttered  “kya ball hai.”   These utterances are obscene
remarks on breast of PW2 Priyanka Raorane.   Therefore, such
utterances are undoubtedly intending to insulting the modesty of
PW2 Priyanka Raorane.   Section 509 of the IPC provides that

utterances intending to insult the modesty of woman should be
with   an   intention   that   such   words   or   sound   shall   be   heard.
Section  509  of the IPC  does not  provide that such  utterances
should   be   heard   by   the   subject.     Hearing   such   utterances   by
anybody would amount to the offence punishable under Section
509 of the IPC.  Hence, no infirmity can be found in the order of
conviction of the accused for the offence punishable under Section
509 of the IPC.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.791 OF 2012

DIVAKAR BHAIRAVNATH YADAV @ ROCKY  V/s. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA 

CORAM : A. M. BADAR
DATE : 17th NOVEMBER 2016 &
18th NOVEMBER 2016.
Citation: 2017 ALLMR(CRI)941
Print Page